Wal-Mart Ends Test of Linux in Stores

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to a Wal-Mart spokesperson, there wasn’t enough interest in PCs that run Linux so the retail giant will discontinue the sales of penguin powered PCs. Bummer.

"This really wasn't what our customers were looking for," said Wal-Mart Stores Inc. spokeswoman Melissa O'Brien. To test demand for systems with the open-source operating system, Wal-Mart stocked the $199 "Green gPC," made by Everex of Taiwan, in about 600 stores starting late in October.
 
Why is that a "bummer"? lol Linux has always been a PC enthusiast's domain and it's always been free. Seems to me like it was a bummer for Wal-Mart because it wasn't an idea that had success written on it from the get-go. O wait... maybe that's what you meant. :D
 
Walmart didn't even try this idea right. The distribution of the PC's in stores was sad, as the 10 stores in driving distance in this area didn't have them. There was shelf space for them, I might have got them just for the decent hardware at 200 bucks, but they never even came in. How can we buy them if you don't stock them?
 
Going by percentages, it's more widely used by scientists & network admins than hobbyists, I would think.
 
I think it is funny that Wal-Mart's primarily tech uneducated customer base refuse to use Linux.
 
Half the people in my Walmart don't even speak english (and many can't even read their native Spanish) so I didn't think Linux was going to fly there.
 
None of the walmarts near Tallahassee had any that I could see. If they did I probably would have bought one. I don't think most people even realize what "Linux" is. The OS needs more advertising.
 
I think that was their problem. In order to get Linux to the desktop, the first people to go for are not the kind of people who shop for a PC at WalMart. It was a good idea, and I believe Linux is ready for the desktop right now, but to expect the average WalMart shopper to know what it is and want to buy one, is a bit of a stretch.
Yeah, I think the kind of people who'd buy a $199 pre-built PC at WalMart aren't that tech savvy and would be afraid of Linux. Or maybe they're buying it for their kid or their mom and they wouldn't be able to help them with it if they only know Windows.

Don't know if it's true or not, but I read somewhere once that Bill Gates bought his mom an iMac. :p
 
I've heard it mentioned many times - people that have never used Windows have a much easier time using a Linux box (that's already been set up.) I thought this product was a good idea for the basic internet/email user.

I could see a version of Linux being marketed to the masses. Maybe something like Ubuntu, but where the command line stuff is done through more friendlier means.
 
gOS seems to have the right idea. Cheap cheap PCs that run a customized version of Ubuntu that is configured for easy email, open office, and web browsing right out of the box. This sort of thing should be able to catch on better as Ubuntu is very easy to use and as long as the fornt end is configured for that sort of usage, it should fit most peoples' needs just fine (and again cheap!).
 
And as far as being "too complex" for the masses, have you seen Vista? Compared to OS X and Ubuntu it is a headache and is only good for Windows gaming, IMHO.

This in a $200 box makes a lot more sense to me than an el cheapo box with Vista: http://www.thinkgos.com/
 
The reason that it didn't work probably had to do with the techknowledge, not of the customers, but of the employees.
What kind of person knows enough to sell this kind of PC would work at Wally world?
 
Have you seen the people walking around wal marts electronic section? Yeah, I'm stereotyping and you know what else? You know I don't need to say anything else. :)
 
The reason that it didn't work probably had to do with the techknowledge, not of the customers, but of the employees.
What kind of person knows enough to sell this kind of PC would work at Wally world?

Agreed. The only way it would work is for a dedicated employee to sell those things and answer questions, kind of like the specialists you see manning the cell phones at Costco.
 
I think it's silly to think that a typical Fry's customer would want a linux box, much less a Walmart customer. They need remember one acronymn: Linfy (Linux is not for you).
 
Agreed. The only way it would work is for a dedicated employee to sell those things and answer questions, kind of like the specialists you see manning the cell phones at Costco.

I think you'd have to have a call center for users as well. Never underestimate the lack of technical knowledge/ability of the typical computer user.

Hell, I know programmers that can't get around *nix and fewer still that could actually do anything other than install it (maybe).

For most people, they should stick to Windows or buy a Mac.

*nix is not for newbies.
 
I think you'd have to have a call center for users as well. Never underestimate the lack of technical knowledge/ability of the typical computer user.

Hell, I know programmers that can't get around *nix and fewer still that could actually do anything other than install it (maybe).

For most people, they should stick to Windows or buy a Mac.

*nix is not for newbies.

I'd be surprised if both gOS and gPC didn't provide customer support. That would be ridiculous for any PC manufacturer.

Either way, I've played around with one of the gOS machines. They hide all the Unixy underpinnings and make it really newbie friendly. I'm assuming the gPC is the same way. So long as you have a call center or online help (which they must have right?) then it should be ok.
 
Wait, people weren't flocking into stores to buy underpowered computers with an alternative OS installed? Shocking!

Excluding the OS, low end computer hardware is pretty cheap. I wonder why those gPC/gPC2 systems aren't any cheaper than $200. Even in Qty 1 I could build (and have built) something much better for the same price.
 
I think that was their problem. In order to get Linux to the desktop, the first people to go for are not the kind of people who shop for a PC at WalMart. It was a good idea, and I believe Linux is ready for the desktop right now, but to expect the average WalMart shopper to know what it is and want to buy one, is a bit of a stretch.

Yeah, I think the kind of people who'd buy a $199 pre-built PC at WalMart aren't that tech savvy and would be afraid of Linux. Or maybe they're buying it for their kid or their mom and they wouldn't be able to help them with it if they only know Windows.

Don't know if it's true or not, but I read somewhere once that Bill Gates bought his mom an iMac. :p

I think you are missing the point Kyle is making. The common WallMart customer is not tech savvy enough to make a difference between Windows and Linux (assuming both of the machines are equipped with software and pre-set to some degree). The chances he has ever heard of a Computer OS (not to mention Windows and Linux alone) are so small that the pre-installed OS could not be a decision-maker here.

Do some of you know or care what software uses your DVD player? Or your PSP? Or cell phone?
The average WallMart customer wants a working computer, not specific OS. The buy a working black-box.

So Kyle is right. It IS strange that the main customer base of WallMart refused to use something which they cannot distinguish among the others... Was every computer-buyer coming with a consultant under his arm?? Or is WallMart to be blamed (the staff I mean) for recommending customers NOT to choose LINUX computers?
 
Most computer sales people in the retail big box stores (Walmart,Target, Best Buy, Circuit City, CompUSA) are only good salespeople and rarely are tech savvy to begin with. When I worked at CompUSA I could not believe half the shit they would tell the customer in order to sell a computer. They are usually trained to catch the customers eye with tech lingo that sounds good. I can imagine the responses a customer asking someone at Walmart what they think about the linux computer would get.
 
Most people in my experience have some idea of or have heard the name Bill Gates ,or Microsoft. While I am sure Linus Torwald would get blank stares from 95% of the population. Would you by product that features an operating system you never heard of ? Linux might as well be dos when it comes to brand recognition. The only people responsible for that are the Linux community.
 
Just because people don't buy an Everex PC and Walmart stops selling it, it doesn't mean that people doesn't buy Linux and Walmart stops selling Linux. I don't know whether they sell Eee PC or not, but people buy the Eee PC and it comes with a Linux OS.
 
LOL @ blaming everything else for this failure. Sorry, but Linux is simply still limited for the average user and aint ready for primetime.
 
sure in-store sales are poor BUT onlines walmart sales for such machines are very very good

nothing mentioned in the OP that online walmart sales of such gOS machines are strong and Walmart are going to continue to sell them online :rolleyes: very poor by the OP, I can only assume it was done as such to start a flamefest (which this section of the [H] seems to be prone to)

online sales of the gOS-based PC by walmart makes sense, it keeps the price down.
 
I'd guess that these desktops (and to a lesser extent, the Eee) appeal mostly TO techies, which is exactly not what walmart cares about in stores.
 
The AP report says "they sold out but decided not to restock". Initial news from linux sources mention "selling out in 1 day".

Its possible that either people already running linux stopped by to pick up yet annother box, or grandmas went ballistic when the thing didn't run family tree maker.

Personally, I'd assume that they never intended to restock, but simply were trying yet annother way to grind the price down on their suppliers (windows box OEMs) and never intended to try to sell the things.
 
Heh, is anyone surprised by this news?
 
Most computer sales people in the retail big box stores (Walmart,Target, Best Buy, Circuit City, CompUSA) are only good salespeople and rarely are tech savvy to begin with. When I worked at CompUSA I could not believe half the shit they would tell the customer in order to sell a computer. They are usually trained to catch the customers eye with tech lingo that sounds good. I can imagine the responses a customer asking someone at Walmart what they think about the linux computer would get.

I used to walk around the CompUsa by me and blow up the salesmen's spot all the time. I was there one day and this guy had the older couple buying just about every piece of software they sold.. It wasn't holiday time either, this couple has a basic Compaq computer with a 21 inch monitor and as he(the salesman) is walking them around the store he is just filling up thier shopping cart, their had to be over 40 titles of software this guy was telling them to buy.

Of course he is throwing out what sounded like TECH lingo.. I just kept coughing "BULL-S" until the customer got the hint and walked out of the store... The guy was pissed... I told him dude you were trying to sell those people 3 different types of Office software, 5 different burning programs, and games that wouldn't run on that system... You are the scumbag...
 
You know what? I never saw this in 2 of the local Walmarts, and one of them is the top Superstore in the country just about every other year. I don't think they really gave it a chance. If they were interested in making it work, they should have set up a demo unit to let people try out the interface, like Sam's, CC, et al.
 
I've never used linux very much.

However, 90% of the computers in the engineering labs at my school use linux.
I think they use gnome. Regardless of what the GUI is...its easier to use than windows.

I don't see how a basic user(internet,email,etc) could be upset with linux.
Guessing a lot of the people buying $200 PCs don't know how to use windows anyway.
 
Now that I think about it some more, the reason for not carrying those computers in store was probably due to returns. Fry's used to sell very low end systems (first VIA C3 "GigaPro", later Socket A) with Linspire installed for $100-$130 on sale and the return rate was pretty high. I picked up a clearance Geode 1.4GHz system for $60 recently at Fry's and unsurprisingly it was returned from the repair depot with "no problem found" (I haven't found any problems either).

I had bought a few more of those in past years and there was nothing really wrong with the hardware besides the VIA-based system running slowly. The system could run acceptably when a little more memory was added.

No longer selling in stores solves the problem of casual returns, returns for no reason other than not liking the OS.
 
I've never used linux very much.


I don't see how a basic user(internet,email,etc) could be upset with linux.
That's easy. you cannot go out a buy software for it. Name a national chain that carries Linux software. Parallels, VMware etc don't count because someone buying a $200 computer will not spend $80 plus another OS cost.
Wine doesn't count because it's far too complicated for this hypothetical basic user.

Guessing a lot of the people buying $200 PCs don't know how to use windows anyway.

Not true at all. Plus you can go out and buy software for windows. With GUI installers and CD's, not ephemeral downloads and tarballs...
The people who gets these systems are college kids with a budget and low income families. i see them all the time come in to my store looking at e-machines and compaqs
 
Half the people that I see shopping at Wal-mart probably barely know how to use Windows much less using command lines.
 
Half the people that I see shopping at Wal-mart probably barely know how to use Windows much less using command lines.

I think I agree. People that are in the market to buy the cheapest possible PC from Walmart are going to be completely out of their element, to put it mildly, in Linux. Linux is great. But I don't think it fits in well to this target.
 
Back
Top