$150 Budget Video Card

BTJustice

n00b
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
44
I need a PCI-E video card for my new rig. I was going to go with a 512 MB ATI 2600 Pro but I have seen the light after reading several bad reviews about it and the 2600 XT. I am not sure what AMD is doing but it is bad currently.

So I will go with a 512 MB nVidia. I am on a budget and the limit is $150 (after any rebates). That being said, I was looking at this 8600 GTS...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127309 (MSI NX8600GTS-T2D512EZ HD)

It sounds pretty good feature-wise.

I then saw this 8600 GT...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814134036 (ECS N8600GT-512MX HS)

It is a really great deal after the mail-in rebate.

Now the spin part...

http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=513&card2=512

If I understand the above website correctly, you simply move the sliders for the Core Clock and Memory Clock to figure out what you are getting. If that is the case...

8600 GTS
Manufacturer: nVidia
Series: GeForce 8
GPU: G84
Release Date: 2007-04-17
Interface: PCI-E x16
Core Clock: 675 MHz
Shader Clock: 1450 MHz
Memory Clock: 2000 MHz (4000 DDR)
Memory Bandwidth: 64 GB/sec
FLOPS: 92.8 GFLOPS
Pixel Fill Rate: 5400 MPixels/sec
Texture Fill Rate: 10800 MTexels/sec

8600 GT
Manufacturer: nVidia
Series: GeForce 8
GPU: G84
Release Date: 2007-04-17
Interface: PCI-E x16
Core Clock: 800 MHz
Shader Clock: 1440 MHz
Memory Clock: 1600 MHz (3200 DDR)
Memory Bandwidth: 51.2 GB/sec
FLOPS: 46080 GFLOPS
Pixel Fill Rate: 6400 MPixels/sec
Texture Fill Rate: 12800 MTexels/sec


So it seems that this ECS 8600 GT model beats the MSI 8600 GTS. Is that correct?

There is also this MSI 8800 GTS

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127328 (MSI NX8800GTS 320M OC)

It's a little more than I want to spend and has a slower core clock than the 8600 GT mentioned above.

8800 GTS
Manufacturer: nVidia
Series: GeForce 8
GPU: G92
Release Date: 2007-12-11
Interface: PCI-E 2.0 x16
Core Clock: 575 MHz
Shader Clock: 1550 MHz
Memory Clock: 1700 MHz (3400 DDR)
Memory Bandwidth: 108.8 GB/sec
FLOPS: 198400 GFLOPS
Pixel Fill Rate: 9200 MPixels/sec
Texture Fill Rate: 36800 MTexels/sec


I guess 64 more stream processors and the higher bit rate make a huge difference.

Yet the ATi HD 2600XT cards all generally have 800 MHz core clock, 1400 MHz memory clock, and 120 stream processors.

Here is a MSI HD 2600XT that is overclocked...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127303 (MSI RX2600XT Diamond Plus Radeon HD 2600XT)

ATi HD 2600XT
Manufacturer: ATi
Series: Radeon HD 2k
GPU: RV630
Release Date: 2007-06-28
Interface: PCI-E x16
Core Clock: 850 MHz
Shader Clock: 850 MHz
Memory Clock: 2300 MHz (4600 DDR)
Memory Bandwidth: 73.6 GB/sec
FLOPS: 102000 GFLOPS
Pixel Fill Rate: 3400 MPixels/sec
Texture Fill Rate: 6800 MTexels/sec

I am not an ATi or NVIDIA fanboy. I like them both. I just want the most bang for my budget.
 
All of those are outdated, and was never really that great to begin with.

An HD3850 should be right on the mark at $150. Twice the performance of any of the gpu's listed there.

edit- sorry.. I thought I saw $150AR earlier on newegg.. guess not. You might have to stretch a little for the 3850, or there are used ones on ebay for like 120-130+shipping.
 
I've gotta be real honest with you. I would not buy a new card right now. What I would do with $150 is keep it until I get $200 or so. Then, I'd buy a used 8800GTS. You'll get way better performance/dollar spent.
 
I've gotta be real honest with you. I would not buy a new card right now. What I would do with $150 is keep it until I get $200 or so. Then, I'd buy a used 8800GTS. You'll get way better performance/dollar spent.

or you could get a used 8800gt around $180ish
 
well I have to say that $150 is an inbetween budget. Its not quite enough to cover the cost of what you "should" get and anything under that 150 mark doesnt back up the price with good performance for now and any future proofing. Here are 3 worth spending some money on.

1) ASUS EAH3850/G/HTDI/512M Radeon HD 3850 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 $184.99 after mir
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814121219

2) MSI NX8800GTS 320M OC GeForce 8800GTS 320MB 320-bit GDDR3 $179 after mir
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127328

3) VisionTek 900203 Radeon HD 3850 256MB 256-bit GDDR3 $169
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814129101

I would take anyone of these over an 8600 gt or gts.
 
Thank you all for the recommendations.

I am pretty much at a toss up between a HD 3950XT with 512 MBs of RAM or an 8800GTS with 320 MBs of RAM. I could have swore I read a review somewhere about the 8800GTS comparing 320 to 640 and there was negligible differences between them.

EDIT: Here is that review... http://www.nvnews.net/reviews/msi_geforce_nx8800gts_320mb/index.shtml

What's a HD 3950XT? Haven't seen this one yet?

Anyway, as Jeff Rage mentioned, you can get a 8800GT 512MB with a very nice heatpipe cooler and 3 phase power system for only $188 after $40 rebate plus $12.00 shipping. I'd splurge for this one if I were you ....

http://www.ncixus.com/products/27328/88YFF6HUFEXX/Galaxy Technology/
 
If you need a card now at the ~150 pricepoint the 3850 is the sweetspot. Although if you can find a 8800GT for ~200 thats a much better card.

I personally do not like to play the waiting game. You never know how or when the new products will actually be released and there is no gaurantees about price or availability. IMHO enjoy yourself now.
 
I am pretty much at a toss up between a HD 3950XT with 512 MBs of RAM or an 8800GTS with 320 MBs of RAM. I could have swore I read a review somewhere about the 8800GTS comparing 320 to 640 and there was negligible differences between them.

8800 GTS 320 MB is old tech; 8800 GT for the same price or often cheaper is better. Heck, even the 3850 (which I assume you mean) is better than the 8800 GTS 320 MB. Only the 512MB version of the 8800 GTS is based on new tech; the 320MB and 640MB versions are not. Blame NVIDIA for the confusing naming scheme.
 
8800 GTS 320 MB is old tech; 8800 GT for the same price or often cheaper is better. Heck, even the 3850 (which I assume you mean) is better than the 8800 GTS 320 MB. Only the 512MB version of the 8800 GTS is based on new tech; the 320MB and 640MB versions are not. Blame NVIDIA for the confusing naming scheme.

Well. Your recommendations are good. But, GT/GTS 512 is not new tech. It's a die shrink, and it has less shaders. That's all. New tech won't be here until Mid to late summer.
 
Well. Your recommendations are good. But, GT/GTS 512 is not new tech. It's a die shrink, and it has less shaders. That's all. New tech won't be here until Mid to late summer.

...and more steam processors (as honestjohn said), and higher clock and memory speeds, and more optimizations, and PureVideo HD...

It's a nitpicky point, but I believe that a die shrink counts as new tech; look at how it turned the 2900 XT power-sucking and expensive monster into an inexpensive and wattage-friendly but zippy 3870. Anyway, as I said, that's just nitpicking and a matter of semantics. ;)

hossdaddy said:
the 3850 is not flat out better, its on par and in many cases the 8800gts 320mb still beats it while only needing a 400w psu and the 3850 needs 450 minimum. See below

http://www.neoseeker.com/Articles/Ha...hd3850/12.html

As for power requirements...the 3850 uses far less than the 8800 GTS 320/640, as shown in the very review you linked to. It uses just a little bit more under load than the 8800 GTS 320/640 does at idle. The 400W vs 450W quoted power supply requirements are arbitrary and misleading; what really matters is how much is on the 12V rails, and the 3850 assuredly needs less there.

Agreed about the 3850 not flat-out beating the 8800 GTS 320/640 though. Given that they're equal and the 3850 is generally around the same price or cheaper than the G80 GTS though, not to mention the lower power requirements, I'd take the 3850 any day. Of course, the 8800 GT or GTS 512MB is even better than that, other than the power requirements (which is a fair tradeoff for better performance).
 
hmm well once you get your new card you will run 1650x1050 minimum probably it depends on your preference after you see how secksy it looks.
 
the 3850 is not flat out better, its on par and in many cases the 8800gts 320mb still beats it while only needing a 400w psu and the 3850 needs 450 minimum. See below

http://www.neoseeker.com/Articles/Hardware/Reviews/powercolor_hd3850/12.html

yes, but overclocking the 3850 is simply amazing, i wonder why some people have become so lazy when it comes to oc'ing their cards, other than simply installing a software and tweaking the clocks. one simple bios flash and the 3850 flies, FLIES

860-900 core is no big deal. at those clocks, it beats a 3870 stock easily, provided you have the 512mb version

cheers
 
It kind of depends on the game. I have a 22" widescreen monitor. Some games I play at 1024x768. Some I might play in the 1920 resolution range.

playing at 1024x768 in a 22" widescreen monitor:confused::confused:

im sure with your newer card you wouldnt be looking at those resolutions, atleast not below the 16xx range.
 
9600 supposedly coming this week at the 179 and up range let that hit may drive a few things down a couple bucks.
 
Whether you get the HD 3850, 9600GT or 8800GT, the jump from that 5700LE AGP card will be HUGE.
 
Sorry about the XT part. My bad.

No worries mate. It really wasn't the "XT" product designation I was questioning, it was the more so the 3950 you mentioned. Just thought there may have been a new part I didn't know about.

At the moment, these are the video cards I am looking at...

http://www.ncixus.com/products/27328/88YFF6HUFEXX/Galaxy Technology/

I can't wait. I need one soon.

I am still running an AGP FX 5700LE with 256 MBs of RAM.

Still the best and fastest card in the group and within $15 (AR) of most of ones you selected. Good luck with which ever one you end-up with.
 
Does it matter that the 8800s and the upcoming 9xxx version only support DirectX 10 and not DirectX 10.1? Aren't the 2 versions essentially the same just that the 10.1 version is fixed?
 
Hmm what is the stats for the rest of your new rig that this videocard is gonna be used in?
 
3.2 GHz Pentium D Dual Core 935
450W PSU
4 GBs DDR2 800
2 TBs combined hard drives

Just wondering why your chose to go with a pentium D dualcore they are pretty horrible.. considering its a new build. Unless you didnt have a say in it.
 
Back
Top