Cheap tape drive solution for home? Or other data storage methods...

danyal711

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 9, 2004
Messages
205
I am planning on setting up a NAS server with 3-4TB. RAID doesn't help when it comes to disaster recovery (viruses, user error, fire etc) so I am looking for more of a static backup solution. + My data is mostly files that will only need to be read (media) so a tape drive seems to be the best logical option. Are there any other solutions that would be useful to backup that much data?

From the little I have read / shopped around, I am thinking about getting an LTO or LTO2 tape drive. Am I on the right track / would this be a cost effective solution?

I briefly looked into blueray burners but the media is so expensive and 50GB max is a major limitation.

Also, what is the deal with tape drive 2:1 compression? Is that reliable / ok or is it generally not used?
 
it would depend what you classify as cheap, in order to backup ~4tb of data you would need tape setup thats around $2k-3k
 
well, I looked on ebay and lto 1 drives are going for as low as $120 and lto 2 drives are going for ~$400. Then tapes come out to around $100 per TB. Is it risky buying these kind of drives off ebay etc?
 
lto 1 has write speed of 15mb/s it would take days to write 4tb, not to mention with tape size of 200gb, it would be 20 tapes for full backup set :p

with lto 2 it would be a bit better you could do a full backup in about day and a half and it would take ~10 tapes

As for buying stuff from ebay it would depend on how honest the seller is about the condition of the item, you might think $400 is a bargain but if the heads are shot or the loading mechanism is busted you will quickly change your mind.

Personally I would go with lto 3 drive but that's about $1200 for the drive and $40 per 400/800gb tape but with write speed of ~70+ mb/s the backup would take about 16 hours
 
also forgot to ask but what kind of data are you backing up? if it's something that is already compressed like zips,rars,jpeg, mp3 and most movies you can forget about the compression on the drive. Your backups will be aprox 2x as slow, take 2x tapes and take 2x as long.
 
I recently installed this in an Ear/Nose/Throat Doctors office for under $2000 roughly 3.5TB

5 disk Enclosure

5 harddrives

This way you get insane backup speeds, tons of storage, and not a bunch of crap to deal with. Although there is a failure rate of harddrives you have to account for. :( But backup is 100%

That enclosure I used though is pricey.. Here's a cheaper one Get that, and maybe 1TB drives.. Should stay under 2k..


I work with tapes... Lots of tapes. They're mainly used in corporate world as a backup for backups. I don't see to many people being able to adequately use tape backup
 
The stuff I will be storing is mainly media so yes it will be already compressed. The reason I am not worried about the write speeds is because in theory I will only need to do a full backup once. After that point, my data will be on an incoming drive which is redundant and as soon as I hit X GB (where X is the size of a tape), I will back it up and transfer the data to my NAS.

So yes, with LTO 1 it may take 40 tapes for 4TB but I will only have to do that once, after which it will just be incremental. Then worst case if a drive dies... I will be able to restore it from the tapes.

I am hoping to spend wayyyy less than 2K but we'll see... i havent calculated everything out yet.
 
lto 1 tape drive will take ~ 80 hours to backup 4tb and you will have to swap 40+ tapes roughly 1 tape every 2 hours, it's not a very good solution but if you willing to put up with that then by all means go for it
 
This thread really belong in optical and backup drives but aside from that see these two older threads below. Takes patience and you need to be sure of the seller, condition of the unit, and internal drive type but you can occasionally pick up a very nice used autoloader on eBay for some great prices. Then just get a SCSI card, tapes, and a older copy of Backup Exec (or any other backup software that will fully control a robotic library and automate incremental backups). You should be able to get going for under a grand.

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1099228
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1162715
 
IMO you might as well buy a B-ray burner for backups since most of what you have is media and only has to be backed up once.
 
Stuff 4 1TB drives in a esata enclosure and call it a day.
 
I am hoping to spend wayyyy less than 2K but we'll see... i havent calculated everything out yet.

Tape drives (and the tapes) aren't cheap. I would consider hard drives in external enclosures or hard drive racks.
 
As was pointed out to me in another thread ( and this did actually get me thinking ) a raid backup system is much better than a lone harddrive, but it really isn't a backup system. An electrical surge, bulding collapse, flood, theft, etc and everything is gone at once. Lose a hd and you're still in business. Losing a hd is my primary concern. I've recently been looking at building a much smaller 1tb raid 1 setup or possibly a raid 5 setup for the purposes of centralizing my data.

The comments about tape being for corporations, I can't comment on because I have little experience with them, but I do know that these companies go to extremes. For instance, a company my cousin worked for had their primary system (with onsite raid backup). Then they had 2 tapes. 1 at a location and another on a truck on the way to the location. The tapes would never be in the same spot for more than a few minutes while 1 was offloaded from the truck and 1 was loaded on the truck. Then the truck would turn around to drive back to the facility to get the new backup on those tapes and start the whole thing over. 3 copies of data in 3 locations. 1 in constant motion. They're dead serious about this stuff.

I think we can be a little easier on ourselves. Personally, I think a raid backup system hooked up to a good battery backup / conditioner with the REALLY critical stuff (the stuff you actually couldn't replace, pictures, acct numbers, etc ) backed up remotely or on dvd.
 
Good points and in a personal use situation if your house burned to the ground the last thing I'd be worried about is my archive of movies and music. Family photo collection thats only digital is different though - I have a fireproof file cabinet at home (3 hours rated) that a keep a backup copy of irreplaceable stuff like that in.
 
Well if you are looking for a remote backup solution, let me know. I can hook you up with something to your needs for more than reasonable.
 
hehe can you imagine uploading 4tb of data using standart home connection ? :p
 
hehe can you imagine uploading 4tb of data using standart home connection ? :p

It'd be blazing! Now that I just upgraded to 56kbps from 28.8, I'm surfing around the net at 10 to 12 pages per hour! Can you imagine? What's tb? Is that like a term for several kb?

:p I kid, I kid.

Yeah, I would think a remote backup solution would only be for a few gb of 'mission critical' info. Not movies, music and pr0....i mean *cough* 'downloads'.
 
haha yah, remote backup would be nice but I dont think I am going to upload 4TB of stuff... Someone mentioned that I should buy a blue-ray burner however that only provides max 50GB per disk... LTO1 is 100GB and LTO2 is 200GB so IMO a much better solution.

I could basically mirror my drives as proposed however this would still require you to replace drives and scale the mirror along with the primary drives. In the case of tapes, you can just keep popping in tapes and incrementally backing up stuff.

My thinking is, it may take 80 hours to do 4TB, but after that point, its all incremental, not to mention that if you keep the tapes safe etc, you shouldnt have to worry about them losing data.

Any other suggestions?
 
How are you going to do it incremental? By adding new stuff to new folders then backing that up? Wouldn't an incremental backup of the entire thing require running all the tapes through and pretty much rewriting everything.
 
every file has an archive bit, when you run full backup the bit gets set to 0, if the file is unchanged the bit remains a 0, incremental backup only backs up files with archive bit set to 1, so it will only grab new stuff since last backup
 
every file has an archive bit, when you run full backup the bit gets set to 0, if the file is unchanged the bit remains a 0, incremental backup only backs up files with archive bit set to 1, so it will only grab new stuff since last backup

Good to know. Thanks! *thumbs up*
 
How are you going to do it incremental? By adding new stuff to new folders then backing that up? Wouldn't an incremental backup of the entire thing require running all the tapes through and pretty much rewriting everything.

No. Full backup is one set of tapes. Incremental tapes are used on top of that. To do a restore, you restore the full backup, then all incrementals up to the most current.

I had a server that had a schedule of 1 full backup per week (started friday night), and incrementals every weekday (except friday). The full backup required 4 tapes, incrementals got one for each day. Every business day, the previous nights tapes were sent off site. To do a full restore, I needed the previous Friday's tapes, plus each daily tape used since until the most current day of the week.
 
Back
Top