Upgrade question, going to 8600gt

martinw79

n00b
Joined
Nov 16, 2007
Messages
19
So I currently have a 6800GT OC from BFG with a 3ghz pentium4. I'm long overdue for an upgrade. I have a very tight budget. My biggest question how much GPU improvement is the 6800GT going to an 8600GT 512Ram?

I only have budget for the e4500, but that would still be an increase compared to my pentium4 3.0 ht. single core.
 
Don't waste your money on 512MB versions, they general have DDR2 and not DDR3. You should goto HD 3850 card. Should be about more than double performance of the old video card.
 
it's ATI.

Er, so what? The 3850 is an amazing budget card, well worth the money. However, I hear the 9600GT (which should be a large jump over the 8600GT also) is due out in a couple of months, might make sense to wait for that.
 
You can get a 8600GT 512 OC GDDR3 from newegg for like $110 I think.

Also, if he was on a tight budget why would you suggest a 9800GT lol. He won't even be able to run an 8800GT (without a massive Bottleneck), let alone a card that spanks the 8800GT.
 
You can get a 8600GT 512 OC GDDR3 from newegg for like $110 I think.

The 512 is a waste. If he is getting an 8600GT it might as well be the 256mb

Also, if he was on a tight budget why would you suggest a 9800GT lol. He won't even be able to run an 8800GT (without a massive Bottleneck), let alone a card that spanks the 8800GT.

I didn't lol :rolleyes: (besides, the e4500 is certainly not going to be a massive bottleneck).
 
They have some XFX 8600XTs at NE for about $100, $80 AR. There are some 512 MB cards that do have GDDR3 RAM.

Last I heard the 9600XT should be out by the end of the month. It is a mid-range card that will replace the 8600XT and (hopefully) will run close to $150. It does not perform as well as a 8800GT.

Right now, I'm trying to decide which of these to get.
 
Yep I came across an XFX 8600GT with 512ram DDR2 for just under $100. What kind of a boost will I be in store for coming off a 6800GT....
 
I would go with a 256MB with DDR3 over a 512MB with DDR2. There are a few cards at NE that are 512MB with GDDR3. However, based on what I've been reading, there wouldn't be much difference in that card with the extra 256MB.
 
Your budget is simply way too unworkable for a sizeable boost in performance, if you absolutely must stick to a $100 and you can't wait, then go for the 8600 (GDDR3 256MB versions are fastest). Don't say we didn't warn you though, that card isn't exactly a screamer in performance. You would be much better off scrounging another $50 in the meantime while you wait for the 9600GT.
 
DO NOT GET THE GDDR2 CARD!!! :eek:

The memory bandwidth on the GDDR2 8600GT is only 10.8GB/s. :mad:
The memory bandwidth on the GDDR3 8600GT is 22.4GB/s. :cool:

Believe me when I say this, the 8600GT with GDDR2 is total fucking garbage. It is a decent GPU bottlenecked horribly by a tiny memory bandwidth.

If you are playing older games like DOOM 3 or Quake 4, then I might say go with the GDDR2 512MB model (@ Ultra settings). But on modern games, forget it! By the time the settings are up high enough to eat up 512MB the GPU will be far too bottlenecked (and overloaded with this card) to get decent frames.

If you want to get an 8600GT with 512MB GDDR3, I would recommend either the ASUS models: SILENT (I used this one) or fan for around $140 at newegg or the EVGA or BFGTech models (which will cost considerably more).

Like I said, it comes down to what game is being played. An 8600GT 512MB GDDR2 can easily play DOOM 3 @ ultra settings (which requires 512MB on a graphics card) with good frame rates. However, having the extra memory bandwidth will come into play with more modern games.


EDIT: Honestly, you will see a small improvement over the 6800GT, but not a moderate or massive one. These cards are better for video editing/playback than for gaming. I have to agree with the people above, try to squeeze out the extra cash for a HD3850. You won't regret spending the extra $50-70. Even the 256MB HD3850 will run circles around the 8600GT GDDR3 512MB card.
 
You're a fool if you want to get the 8600 GT to replace your 6800 GT. The memory bandwidth is actually LOWER with the 8600 GT (22 GB/s versus 32GB/s for the 6800 GT). The raw performance the 8600 GT is capable of is slightly above a 7600 GT, which puts this card at about %20-30 faster than your current one.

The 3850 is the only card available that will provide an acceptable upgrade to your 6800 GT for low cost. Do what you will with your money; you're obviously unsure of this purchase, because you stopped in here first. But don't discount our advice.

Ask people around here, I usually hammer on others for suggesting overly-expensive upgrades, but this is for certain: if you game at all, you will surely appreciate the extra power you get with the 3850.
 
Agreed. Don't settle with a 8600GT, its really not a fast card meant for gaming.

Either stretch your budget for an HD 3850 or hold on the money until the 9600GT (hopefully its a good card).
 
EVGA just added a 8800gs to their product line, might be something to look into for a budget gamer as well
 
EVGA just added a 8800gs to their product line, might be something to look into for a budget gamer as well


naw, not really with the 9600GT around the corner. Its kinda a halfbake stopgap until then and does not even really compair to the HD3850 performance wise. Just stay away from the 8600GT, 128bit is not the way to go if you want an actual upgrade out of this generation... unless you play at 1024x768 -pukes-
 
+1 to 3850, substantially faster than 6800GT, twice as fast as the 8600GT, which, in some cases, is not even as fast as a 7600GT...
 
I made this exact swap by necessity rather than choice. I had already upgraded from AthlonXP to E4300 while keeping my 6800GT, saving up for an 8800GT. Then the 6800GT started artifacting on me like crazy over a weekend when I was up against a deadline. I went out and bought an 8600GT as a stopgap even though it pained me to pay full retail. As defaultluser said, it's about a 20% boost. But for me that was a 20% boost on top of the noticeable gain from the CPU upgrade earlier.

Think about it this way. 20% more performance from a smaller, quieter card that draws less power, generates less heat, and cost me a lot less than the 6800GT did. And I'm recouping the retail price gouge by doing a step-up since it's an eVGA card.

Mine is the 256MB DDR3 card, and as others have said you've got to stay away from the DDR2's.

Anyway, thoughts from one who's been there.
 
Thanks for the feedback, much appreciated. Never thought the 6800 gave the 8600 a run in terms of mem bandwidth. I may just pony up another $300 for the rig and buy an 8800 ddr3 card, who knows when my next upgrade will be.
 
I can't agree more. Some people feel the 512 video memory has a big advantage over 256mb video like how they view 512mb system memory over 256mb memory. But, that is not always true. An HD 3850 with 256mb is a great card and can easily outperform the 8600GT with 512mb and also the 8600GTS. For me personally, If I get an Nvidia card for gaming, I would get an 8800GT minimum. I would not bother with 8600 series or lower. As far as ATI, HD 3850 at least. For your current setup, an HD 3850 will do nicely at this time. No sense upgrading, if you don't see a noticeable difference.


Don't waste your money on 512MB versions, they general have DDR2 and not DDR3. You should goto HD 3850 card. Should be about more than double performance of the old video card.
 
Back
Top