Q6600 vs. Xeon X3220?

Joined
Jun 20, 2005
Messages
982
Hey guys, I'm curious of something. I'm looking into buying a Quad-Core processor for the new rig I'm currently building. I've looked into both the Intel Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz quad-core processor and I've found the Intel Xeon X3220 Kentsfield 2.4GHz quad-core processor. My questions are these;

- What is the difference between the two, exactly??

- Is one better than the other, and if so, why??

- Does one have more overclocking ability? Does one provide more stability?

To my research, the only difference is support for SSE4 and a higher voltage on the part of the Xeon. Besides of course being labeled a "server" based processor and carrying a slightly higher pricetag (Xeon).

Sorry if this has been posted before, but without search it's impossible to find anything without manually surfing through several dozen pages of information.

Thanks,
- Joey
 
from what little research I've done about the differences...

They are both based on the kentsfeild... so I don't really think the Xeon has SSE4 since penryn was supposed to be the first to have it...


The only difference which made me choose a Xeon was it has a higher threshold for heat... I think Q6600 is 70C and the Xeon is 85C which would help in OCing and whatnot...
 
If it's the same socket and same core, I wonder if a Xeon would work in a non-server based ("normal") motherboard such as an X38/ X48 or 680i/780i??

- Joey
 
Yes, most xeons are 775 socket.

2nd, stop double signing your posts.
 
I don't see anything in reference to his name in his signature, thus its not a double signing.

Anyhow, any S775 Xeon runs fine in 'normal' board. I run an X3210 in my BadAxe2.
 
If it's the same socket and same core, I wonder if a Xeon would work in a non-server based ("normal") motherboard such as an X38/ X48 or 680i/780i??

- Joey

If it is an LGA775 Xeon then yes. If it is a LGA771 Xeon then no it won't work as it isn't pin compatible with the LGA775 socket.

Yes, most xeons are 775 socket.

2nd, stop double signing your posts.

No they aren't. Most Xeons are LGA771. (At least there are more LGA771 models than LGA775 models.)

All the dual processor Xeons are LGA771 and all the LGA775 Xeons are incapable of SMP.

I don't see anything in reference to his name in his signature, thus its not a double signing.

Anyhow, any S775 Xeon runs fine in 'normal' board. I run an X3210 in my BadAxe2.

Of course it does. The LGA775 Xeons are identical to their Core 2 Quad counterparts.
 
@ Dan_D: Thank you. That answered those questions.

Now, I just need to get back on track and answer my original questions;

- What is the difference between the two, exactly??

- Is one better than the other, and if so, why??

- Does one have more overclocking ability? Does one provide more stability?

(note: @ Down8; Thanks for the defense. But I do apologize, it's just become a habit as I've signed just about every forum message I've sent (on any forum), not to mention e-mails and countless other forms of "electronic text", but if it does piss people off or violate a stated rule, I apologize and I will try to put an end to my habit...)


Thanks,
- Joey
 
Hey guys, I'm curious of something. I'm looking into buying a Quad-Core processor for the new rig I'm currently building. I've looked into both the Intel Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz quad-core processor and I've found the Intel Xeon X3220 Kentsfield 2.4GHz quad-core processor. My questions are these;

- What is the difference between the two, exactly??

- Is one better than the other, and if so, why??

- Does one have more overclocking ability? Does one provide more stability?

To my research, the only difference is support for SSE4 and a higher voltage on the part of the Xeon. Besides of course being labeled a "server" based processor and carrying a slightly higher pricetag (Xeon).

Sorry if this has been posted before, but without search it's impossible to find anything without manually surfing through several dozen pages of information.

Thanks,
- Joey

If you look at the Intel Processor Spec Finder, you will see that the Q6600 has a maximum thermal limit of 71C (G0), and the X3220 (G0) has a thermal limit of 85C. So if you plan on overclocking, you will have more headroom.

Other than the thermal specifications, and the possibility of needing an updated BIOS, there really is no difference (other than price) between the two of them. However, the X3220 is "server grade", so in theory it will stand more abuse and higher temps longer than its desktop counterpart.
 
@ Dan_D: Thank you. That answered those questions.

Now, I just need to get back on track and answer my original questions;



(note: @ Down8; Thanks for the defense. But I do apologize, it's just become a habit as I've signed just about every forum message I've sent (on any forum), not to mention e-mails and countless other forms of "electronic text", but if it does piss people off or violate a stated rule, I apologize and I will try to put an end to my habit...)


Thanks,
- Joey

The LGA775 Xeons are identical to their normal Core 2 Quad counterparts. They do not overclock better. Stability is also the same as their Core 2 Quad counterparts.

The 45nm desktop parts haven't been released yet. Well not the quad cores. The only 45nm parts out are the QX9650's and the 45nm Xeon processors. The rest were all delayed. Those are the parts with SSE4 support. The regular Xeon 3000 series hasn't gone to 45nm just yet as far as I know. So again the LGA775 Xeons are identical to their LGA775 Core 2 Quad processors. The difference is just the name. The LGA775 Xeons are marketed to the singe processor server and workstation market. The LGA771 variety are typically marketed to the higher end workstation and server markets.
 
@ Dan_D & sawm;

Thank you. That is what my own research has shown, but I wasn't sure if there was something I was missing.

- Joey
 
My X3075 works great in my p35-DS4 board, also worked in my older 965p board.

I plan to grab a X3220 over a Q6600 myself
 
My X3075 works great in my p35-DS4 board, also worked in my older 965p board.

I plan to grab a X3220 over a Q6600 myself

Why? Based on Dan_D's information what motivation could there be to get the xeon? :confused:
 
I've been doing some research on the Xeon processor in modern motherboards and I've found that though the Q6600 and the Xeon X3220 are essentially the same (or so it seems), unless the motherboard explicitly labels support for the Xeon processor, it may present problems if used in place of (or instead of) a Q6600.

Any truth to this? There has to be some form of logical explanation for the seemingly "partial incompatibility" on the part of the Xeon processor. Or maybe I'm just confused beyond my own good.

What happened to the days of the Skt. 478? I used to know everything there was to know, in-depth, about modern chipsets, processors and motherboards. I feel like such a "newb" with all this new technology. I've been out of the "geek scene" for awhile.

- Joey
 
I've been doing some research on the Xeon processor in modern motherboards and I've found that though the Q6600 and the Xeon X3220 are essentially the same (or so it seems), unless the motherboard explicitly labels support for the Xeon processor, it may present problems if used in place of (or instead of) a Q6600.

Any truth to this? There has to be some form of logical explanation for the seemingly "partial incompatibility" on the part of the Xeon processor. Or maybe I'm just confused beyond my own good.

What happened to the days of the Skt. 478? I used to know everything there was to know, in-depth, about modern chipsets, processors and motherboards. I feel like such a "newb" with all this new technology. I've been out of the "geek scene" for awhile.

- Joey

The only thing that gets screwy with the Xeon 3220 concerns a motherboard not being able to identify it. That by itself doesn't necessarily mean you'll have problems. I think you are ok though with most high quality name brand boards. Hell even the 680i SLI boards support the Xeon LGA775 processors. The chips are identical except for some micro-code.
 
The only thing that gets screwy with the Xeon 3220 concerns a motherboard not being able to identify it. That by itself doesn't necessarily mean you'll have problems. I think you are ok though with most high quality name brand boards. Hell even the 680i SLI boards support the Xeon LGA775 processors. The chips are identical except for some micro-code.

What about the Intel P35 chipset Asus P5K Deluxe (WiFi-AP) or the Intel X38 Asus Maximum Formula?

Do you think either of those motherboards would present any fore-see-able problems if using a Xeon X3220 in place of a Q6600?

I'm building a new rig, my first in years, and I have everything I need except for a motherboard, processor and video card. I've already pretty much ruled out SLI and all SLI motherboards. I'm trying to explore all of my options when it comes to the motherboard and its chipset (P35 or X38), and of course the processor.

Thanks,
- Joey
 
What about the Intel P35 chipset Asus P5K Deluxe (WiFi-AP) or the Intel X38 Asus Maximum Formula?

Do you think either of those motherboards would present any fore-see-able problems if using a Xeon X3220 in place of a Q6600?

I'm building a new rig, my first in years, and I have everything I need except for a motherboard, processor and video card. I've already pretty much ruled out SLI and all SLI motherboards. I'm trying to explore all of my options when it comes to the motherboard and its chipset (P35 or X38), and of course the processor.

Thanks,
- Joey

Both boards are probably ok. ASUS is generally good about processor support. So I wouldn't worry about it. Though I'd check around. Maybe try to find some Xeon 3220 users and see what they are using.
 
Why? Based on Dan_D's information what motivation could there be to get the xeon? :confused:

Because as said Above, it is just cooler.

And as Dan D said a little bit more headroom temp wise. They are normally only 10$ more anyway so why not is what I say.

Xeon=Makes girls heads spin :p
 
Because as said Above, it is just cooler.

And as Dan D said a little bit more headroom temp wise. They are normally only 10$ more anyway so why not is what I say.

Xeon=Makes girls heads spin :p

I didn't say they ran cooler. I said it had a cooler sounding name.
 
Ahh, yeah sorry. It was sawm who posted about the slightly higher thermal limits, that is what I was refering to.

My Tjunction max is 100C
 
I got my X3210 b/c it sounded cooler. And b/c they don't make a Q6400. Also, it sounds like a countdown... X...3...2...1...0!
 
I got my X3210 b/c it sounded cooler. And b/c they don't make a Q6400. Also, it sounds like a countdown... X...3...2...1...0!

That's true. There are fewer Core 2 Quad models than there are LGA775 Xeon models. Specifically the lowest end Core 2 Quad is the Q6600. While the lowest end LGA775 Xeon is the X3210 I believe. So comparatively we have a 2.4GHz or a 2.0GHz model as the lowest echelon of each family.
 
Judging from my experience with AMD athlon vs AMD opterons, the xeon or server class chips should run cooler and overclock better.
 
Judging from my experience with AMD athlon vs AMD opterons, the xeon or server class chips should run cooler and overclock better.

That's not the case with the Intel processors. The LGA775 Xeons and Core 2 Quads are identical except for some micro-code.
 
Back
Top