What Would You Do With $205?

Lancid

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
404
I am willing to spend $205, and no more, for a video card. I am contemplating two options, which follow.

1. Buy a cheap card now, and wait until new cards are released.
The benefit to this is that all current cards will be cheaper, and new cards may be affordable. (An acceptable increase would be $10/month to the $205. E.g., spending no more than $215 on Feb 23rd.) The only disadvantage I can think of, is that I'll be spending money now, all of which I won't be able to recover. Buying used would lessen depreciation, but I still estimate I would lose more than $20.

2. Buy a card now with the $205.
With this, I'd have a card now and wouldn't upgrade for at least a year unless my situation dramatically changed, which is unlikely. The downside is that, even with price drops, I'd likely spend the same as I would if I were to wait, and lose the opportunity to get a better card then is currently available.

So, what would you do?
 
Because you arent going to find an 8800 for 205. You can on the other hand get a 3870 from ncix for around 225.
 
Because you arent going to find an 8800 for 205. You can on the other hand get a 3870 from ncix for around 225.

$225 is still $20 over $205. You can also get a 8800GT 512MB for $236 ....

http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=A9670542


I am willing to spend $205, and no more, for a video card. I am contemplating two options, which follow.


Lancid, if I were you I would just wait one month to see how the new cards being released are going to effect pricing. Nothing wrong in waiting just a month.

If you want a card now, I think the HD3850 512MB would be an excellent choice within your $205 budget. If you could swing a few dollars more see above link for the 8800GT.

http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=A9630954
 
I got my 8800gt for 229 after taxes but I wish I would have gotten a 3870 for xfire reason. that way you could own the shit out of 8800gt's :)
 
All the new cards soon to be released will make the price of the older ones drop.

For your curent budget, a HD3850 512Mb is your best bet. But if I were you, I would ski all day for a month and buy a videcard when all the new stuff will be out.

Don't make the same mistake as the people who got the 8800 GTS 320/640 a month before the gt/gts were out. Beside, ski is good for you.
 
$225 is still $20 over $205. You can also get a 8800GT 512MB for $236 ....

http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=A9670542





Lancid, if I were you I would just wait one month to see how the new cards being released are going to effect pricing. Nothing wrong in waiting just a month.

If you want a card now, I think the HD3850 512MB would be an excellent choice within your $205 budget. If you could swing a few dollars more see above link for the 8800GT.

http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=A9630954

+1 thats what I would do.
 
Buy a card now that fits your needs and be happy with it. Possibly the 3850 512? Waiting is pointless.
 
Buy a card now that fits your needs and be happy with it. Possibly the 3850 512? Waiting is pointless.

If he waits 1 month, that's not pointless in my opinion. With all the new cards coming out, within one month's time he could see the prices fall for the HD3870 and 8800GT 512MB cards into his price range rather than settling for an HD3850 or 8800GT 256MB now. If you were saying, waiting 6 months to a year would be pointless, then I would agree.
 
If he waits 1 month, that's not pointless in my opinion. With all the new cards coming out, within one month's time he could see the prices fall for the HD3870 and 8800GT 512MB cards into his price range rather than settling for an HD3850 or 8800GT 256MB now. If you were saying, waiting 6 months to a year would be pointless, then I would agree.


Why would prices for those cards fall? There are no cards coming out in the performance segment of the 3870 or 8800 GT, the release of a $450+ 3870x2 or 9800gx2 wouldn't drop the price of mid-range cards.

waiting is pointless.
 
Why would prices for those cards fall?
Reverse that though, why would the prices go up? The release of the X2's may do nothing but cause a minor price drop in the line of mid-range parts and worse case, it will have absoulutely no effect at all as you said. So what has lancid got to lose waiting for a month? besides 30 days of course. Also, as time goes by, the cards recommended to Lancid are also slowly becoming "slightly" less expensive than they were on release and deals and rebates are becoming more frequent. So a month? What's the big deal? I didn't guarantee anything would be lower in price, but waiting 30 days? It certainly isn't going to get any worse.
 
Wait a month! Better to have 4 good choices later (3850, 9600, 3870, 8800gs) rather than 2 overpriced ones now. Long term regret sucks, waiting pain can be eazed wtih tv, flogging, pron, and solitaire.
 
I went with a gecube 512mb 3850 because it has unreal performance for its price and i have a xfire mobo :) so ill grab another in a few months. cod4 1680x1050 maxed settings max af, fps locked at 65 and never dip.
 
I went with a gecube 512mb 3850 because it has unreal performance for its price and i have a xfire mobo :) so ill grab another in a few months. cod4 1680x1050 maxed settings max af, fps locked at 65 and never dip.

Thanks for that info, I run at 1680x1050 and I will be recieving this tomorrow:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814129102

VisionTek 900206 Radeon HD 3850 OC edition 512MB - $189 (on sale $10 off now and w/free 3 day shipping)

It's got a sweet looking 2 slot (vent out the back slot!) cooler w/heatpipes and a nice big fan.

Good to know I can play COD4 at max settings for my monitor. I was also pleased to see that the 3850 is extremely fast at running Team Fortress 2 (which I haven't tried yet, but look forward to trying).

Then later, maybe once they really get Crysis optimized and working well on Crossfire I'll pickup a 2nd card in 6 mos. to a year. But, probably not, SLI never really seems to be a decent value, the prices of the 2nd card never drop low enough before they stop being available/newer card comes out with BETTER price / performance.
 
Then it looks like the HD 3850 512MB would be a good choice or scrape up $30 for a 8800GT 512MB.

My comment wasn't serious.

After reading the replies here, I'm leaning toward waiting, and not buying any card right now.
 
All the new cards soon to be released will make the price of the older ones drop.

For your curent budget, a HD3850 512Mb is your best bet. But if I were you, I would ski all day for a month and buy a videcard when all the new stuff will be out.

Don't make the same mistake as the people who got the 8800 GTS 320/640 a month before the gt/gts were out. Beside, ski is good for you.

I like this recommendation :) The few times that I HAVE waited out an impulse buy, it's usually worked out really well in the end.. there's a high probability 1 month of patience will get you a card w/higher performance & last you an extra 3-6 months in the end.

PS Kneissl skis FTW :D
 
Save $50 more and get a GT. You're wasting your money buying a cheap card now then having to upgrade because you were impatient/frugal in the first place!
 
I really cant believe how cheap 3850's are for the performance you get its a steal.
 
I'd put the money in a bank account and try to forget about it. While that money sits safely out of my reach, I'd work another $200 whatever.

Seriously though, if $200 (I forgot the exact number of chump change you had there) is all you've got to spend, you're better off waiting or getting more money.

Dont let it burn a hole in your pocket right now man.. It's just not worth it.
 
screw the video card

get two hookers an icecream sandwhich and some penicillin have a night of it lol


that or wait to see how new cards will effect prices of new cards
 
Wait a month! Better to have 4 good choices later (3850, 9600, 3870, 8800gs) rather than 2 overpriced ones now. Long term regret sucks, waiting pain can be eazed wtih tv, flogging, pron, and solitaire.

I see you point, but how much money are we really talking about here? I laugh when we read..I bought this VC for $209.99 & then I purchased the E8400 for $9.00 less the Newegg etc.

So, is it $20.00-$30.00? Why bother? Everyones prices are always up & down. Example GeCube X1950PRO on newegg.com was 3 weeks was $119.00 (free shipping) with rebate, then a week later it was $159.99 plus $7.00+ for shipping!

About 10 days ago, Clubit.com had the 3870 Gigabyte w/ Zalman Fan for exactly $205.00 with free shipping with a $20.00 rebate.

Link: http://clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA9630955

Now it's $211.99 plus $6.98. Pretty close to this $205.00 mark (off by $13.97)

I guess I'm 42 & when I want something, then I want it! Someone made a good point about those people buying the 320MB & 640MB Nvidia cards & then you "really" should have waited. But that's simply common sense.

My 2 cents? Buy when you're ready & don't look back! Were talking computer products here!
 
Waiting doesn't have much sense - there ALWAYS is something worth waiting for in next x months but seriously is it worth saving 20 bucks Instead of enjoying your new hardware for now?
 
Waiting doesn't have much sense - there ALWAYS is something worth waiting for in next x months but seriously is it worth saving 20 bucks Instead of enjoying your new hardware for now?

But obsessing over the parts to save $5 here, $10 there is part of the fun! Why indulge when you can obsessive almost forever! :)

BTW My store upped the price of the e6750 back to $210 (from $190). The GT is back to $279 (from $249), and the DS3R is back to $155.

I know that in 3 months though all of those parts will be like 1/2 price, but hey, for a few weeks in January I actually saved money :)
 
Back
Top