Dell 3008WFP review @ ExtremeTech

enyceexdanny

2[H]4U
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
2,618
3008WFP Review

If you're looking for a large desktop display well suited for a variety of source material, including standard definition video, then the Gateway XHD3000 may be a better bet. However, the Dell UltraSharp 3008WFP-HD should excel in professional graphics applications and most PC source materials. It's not a bad high def display, either....
 
Well it doesn't appear to be a glossy display panel after all in those images. That sure makes it more appealing to me.
 
Well it doesn't appear to be a glossy display panel after all in those images. That sure makes it more appealing to me.

That was already made clear in the last thread from several eye-witness accounts.
 
That was already made clear in the last thread from several eye-witness accounts.

I hadn't been keeping up with that thread for some time. Either that or I blanked on that piece of information. I've slept since then. :)
 
I hadn't been keeping up with that thread for some time. Either that or I blanked on that piece of information. I've slept since then. :)

Blanked. You posted after someone already said it was non-glossy. :p


I'm disappointed the reviews speaks nil about scaling and aspects, save for one resolution it apparently can't do
 
That review seems rather pitiful in comparison to HotHardwares review. Would be nice to have a second review source to compare but thie review just seems to amatuerish to be taken seriously :( It is so lacking in actual information in fact that it leads me to wonder wether or not they really even had the monitor in their possesion? Perhaps if they at least posted a picture other than the generic picture we have all seen forever now this would seem a bit more credible?
 
Blanked. You posted after someone already said it was non-glossy. :p


I'm disappointed the reviews speaks nil about scaling and aspects, save for one resolution it apparently can't do

I guess I must have. In any case I am glad it isn't glossy.
 
That review seems rather pitiful in comparison to HotHardwares review. Would be nice to have a second review source to compare but thie review just seems to amatuerish to be taken seriously :( It is so lacking in actual information in fact that it leads me to wonder wether or not they really even had the monitor in their possesion? Perhaps if they at least posted a picture other than the generic picture we have all seen forever now this would seem a bit more credible?

What!? I thought the complete opposite. HotHardware gave it a very positive review with lackluster testing methodology. ExtremeTech gave it a mixed review using actual lab equipment. Are you sure your not letting your lust for this monitor cloud your judgement? I really wanted this monitor to be excellent in all situations (PC, TiVO, XBOX 360) but it looks like I'm going to have to put the 3008 and XHD3000 side by side and make a decision.
 
I gotta agree with Strafe here, They gave my 275T a 10/10 and it's exactly that. It's better than any monitor i've ever had. At the time they tested it the con was that it was expensive and some other things that are true, I think for monitor reviews hothardware is unparalleled.
 
I gotta agree with Strafe here, They gave my 275T a 10/10 and it's exactly that. It's better than any monitor i've ever had. At the time they tested it the con was that it was expensive and some other things that are true, I think for monitor reviews hothardware is unparalleled.

I would agree with that(hothardware reviews), they usually use the product for a few weeks at least i.e. real world testing.

Im not a fan of the 275T, my rule and advice to people is no PVA monitors ever.
 
That review seems rather pitiful in comparison to HotHardwares review. Would be nice to have a second review source to compare but thie review just seems to amatuerish to be taken seriously :( It is so lacking in actual information in fact that it leads me to wonder wether or not they really even had the monitor in their possesion? Perhaps if they at least posted a picture other than the generic picture we have all seen forever now this would seem a bit more credible?

Here is a direct quote from the ExtremeTech review.

"Subjective Testing
We plopped the 3008WFP-HC on our desktop for several weeks, using it extensively on our production system, which is equipped with a single GeForce 8800 Ultra"

Did you actually READ the review or are you saying they are lieing?
 
That review seems rather pitiful in comparison to HotHardwares review. Would be nice to have a second review source to compare but thie review just seems to amatuerish to be taken seriously :( It is so lacking in actual information

You mean unlike all the actual lab test data that ExtremeTech did? Come on now, ExtremeTech had the more thorough review, they used hard data and real world experince.
 
Extreme Tech didn't cover the monitor nearly as well IMO, they didn't even mention the scaler which is the most important part for me, having problems in one eye my eyesight is poor at times and being able to use the scaler to run the monitor at 1900x1200 with near pixel perfect rendition is HUGE and yet Extremetech doesn't even mention this? Theres no pictures or anything in the Extremetech review...

I care more about real world performance than I do about some calibration machine telling me that this monitor is better than that monitor LOL And HotHardwares review definitely leaves you with the impression that they were actually using the monitor rather than hooking up a bunch of machines to tell them how good it is.

I think the whole color calibration is overblown anyway as regardless how perfectly your monitor renders colors the person who's looking at your rendtions on their own monitors is not going to see the same rendition anyway so it's pointless, might as well make the monitor pleasing to your own eye. To me the only place color calibration really matters is with printing.


Different strokes for different folks I spose.
 
I think the whole color calibration is overblown anyway as regardless how perfectly your monitor renders colors the person who's looking at your rendtions on their own monitors is not going to see the same rendition anyway so it's pointless, might as well make the monitor pleasing to your own eye. To me the only place color calibration really matters is with printing.


Different strokes for different folks I spose.

The whole point of a color managed workflow is that what you scan/capture, what you see on the display, and what you print match (within the gamut capabilities of the devices in question). Photographers and video folks need a display that takes calibration/profiling well and displays as large a color gamut as possible. Typically the display is the most limiting part of a photographic workflow in terms of color gamut and resolution.

You don't profile your display to make photos "look" better on the screen (although they might). You profile so that the colors are "correct" and standardized when shown on screen, and can be accurately manipulated and sent to an output device with the desired results. Otherwise you spend hours correcting a photo only to have greenish skin tones when you send it to a printer. Companies like LaCie and Eizo make their living producing expensive wide gamut displays for these markets. Amateurs and pros with shallower pockets are anxiously watching the HC wide-gamut displays trickling downmarket and into the mainstream.
 
I still would like to know if the panel uses 10 or 12-bit LUT. If the LUT is still 8-bit the wide gamut is going to be just a gimmick for the most part :(
 
Extreme Tech didn't cover the monitor nearly as well IMO, they didn't even mention the scaler which is the most important part for me, having problems in one eye my eyesight is poor at times and being able to use the scaler to run the monitor at 1900x1200 with near pixel perfect rendition is HUGE and yet Extremetech doesn't even mention this? Theres no pictures or anything in the Extremetech review...

I care more about real world performance than I do about some calibration machine telling me that this monitor is better than that monitor LOL And HotHardwares review definitely leaves you with the impression that they were actually using the monitor rather than hooking up a bunch of machines to tell them how good it is.

I think the whole color calibration is overblown anyway as regardless how perfectly your monitor renders colors the person who's looking at your rendtions on their own monitors is not going to see the same rendition anyway so it's pointless, might as well make the monitor pleasing to your own eye. To me the only place color calibration really matters is with printing.


Different strokes for different folks I spose.

Actually they mention the scaler here
"The story with video—specifically DVD video—isn't so robust. If you're playing DVD video or high def video on your PC, the Dell looks great. You'll get good image quality, and the display handles scaling fairly well.

However, if you pipe in a source from a consumer electronics source device—say, a DVD player—the results are less than optimal. We attached an Oppo DVD player through the HDMI port, and set the Oppo to 480i input. Then we ran the HQV DVD image quality test. The result was a fairly poor score of 50. In particular, the Dell had problems with 3:2 inverse telecine and other cadence detection. However, aliasing was also visible. On the other hand, noise reduction was quite robust.

When we pipe in source material at a full 1080p, the result is much more pleasing.

Overall, the Dell excels as a PC display, but is less useful as a display for standard definition CE devices such as set top boxes and DVD players. If you attach high def devices, though, you'll get better results"

They did not like the scaler as much as the Gateway scaler. Gateway upscaled lowres content better.

"If you're looking for a large desktop display well suited for a variety of source material, including standard definition video, then the Gateway XHD3000 may be a better bet. "

You have to READ reviews not just skim thm.
 
What a bummer. I might as well just go with the 3007HC and save $800 since dell decided to go cheap on the scaler for the 3008
 
chances are the scaler is subpar to par. Noticed we have not heard from Dell boasting the scaler capabilities. The only marketing I've read is the DisplayPort and 117% color gamut.
 
Actually they mention the scaler here
"The story with video—specifically DVD video—isn't so robust. If you're playing DVD video or high def video on your PC, the Dell looks great. You'll get good image quality, and the display handles scaling fairly well.

However, if you pipe in a source from a consumer electronics source device—say, a DVD player—the results are less than optimal. We attached an Oppo DVD player through the HDMI port, and set the Oppo to 480i input. Then we ran the HQV DVD image quality test. The result was a fairly poor score of 50. In particular, the Dell had problems with 3:2 inverse telecine and other cadence detection. However, aliasing was also visible. On the other hand, noise reduction was quite robust.

When we pipe in source material at a full 1080p, the result is much more pleasing.

Overall, the Dell excels as a PC display, but is less useful as a display for standard definition CE devices such as set top boxes and DVD players. If you attach high def devices, though, you'll get better results"

They did not like the scaler as much as the Gateway scaler. Gateway upscaled lowres content better.

"If you're looking for a large desktop display well suited for a variety of source material, including standard definition video, then the Gateway XHD3000 may be a better bet. "

You have to READ reviews not just skim thm.

I did read it, I just don't consider "the display handles scaling fairly well" and the Gateway might be a better choice if you want to hook up your SNES a credible account of the scaling, I could care less how the monitor functions as a TV LOL I want use it for my PC! Read the Hothardware review with regards to scaling at 1900x1220 etc... much more to gather from what they said.
 
chances are the scaler is subpar to par. Noticed we have not heard from Dell boasting the scaler capabilities. The only marketing I've read is the DisplayPort and 117% color gamut.

According to Hothardware review the scaler works great making 1900x1220 look nearly perfect. I just wish there was another review to confirm if it's true or not. I don't want to commit money to this monitor solely off of one review :(
 
What a bummer. I might as well just go with the 3007HC and save $800 since dell decided to go cheap on the scaler for the 3008

That's probably what I'd do but I've got to admit I like the inputs on the 3008WFP.
 
From article said:
On games, we did notice some smearing in fast action sequences, though for the most part, the Dell proved a capable gaming display—except for one quirk.
Is that caused by the scaler or something? Because I can't see that on the 3007 (it's surprisingly quick for a 30'').
 
I have been using my 3008 for nearly 3 weeks now (Australia), and I think scalling is very good. Obviously don't expect miracles, but with a little tweaking 1920x1200 is a very useable day-to-day resolution. Granted I spend the majority of the time using the native res, however when I do switch down to lower res (xbox, hd-dvd etc), the picture is just as pleasing.

My particular screen arrived with 0 dead/stuck pixels, and only a small amount of backlight bleed at the top left.
 
I have been using my 3008 for nearly 3 weeks now (Australia), and I think scalling is very good. Obviously don't expect miracles, but with a little tweaking 1920x1200 is a very useable day-to-day resolution. Granted I spend the majority of the time using the native res, however when I do switch down to lower res (xbox, hd-dvd etc), the picture is just as pleasing.

My particular screen arrived with 0 dead/stuck pixels, and only a small amount of backlight bleed at the top left.

Have you noticed any input lag while scaling or running at native resolution?
 
I have been using my 3008 for nearly 3 weeks now (Australia), and I think scalling is very good. Obviously don't expect miracles, but with a little tweaking 1920x1200 is a very useable day-to-day resolution. Granted I spend the majority of the time using the native res, however when I do switch down to lower res (xbox, hd-dvd etc), the picture is just as pleasing.

My particular screen arrived with 0 dead/stuck pixels, and only a small amount of backlight bleed at the top left.


Have you tried 1920x1200 for Web browsing? How is the text compared to that of native resolution?
 
Text scalling at 1920x1200 is actually rather good. You still get the 'softness' as expected with scalling, however for the most part it is better than expected.

As for input lag, i'm no expert, but for my part I haven't noticed any. Best wait for someone else to do the relavent tests.
 
I did read it, I just don't consider "the display handles scaling fairly well" and the Gateway might be a better choice if you want to hook up your SNES a credible account of the scaling, I could care less how the monitor functions as a TV LOL I want use it for my PC!
Then you don't need this monitor. All modern video cards scale PC input very well. The real test of the scaler is how it handles non PC inputs


Read the Hothardware review with regards to scaling at 1900x1220 etc... much more to gather from what they said.


Here is what HotHardware said of the scaler
"And once again, the 3008WFP performed admirably with respect to image scaling below it's native 2560X1600 resolution. The panel's built-in scaler processor allowed us to drop down to 1920X1200 and with a small bit of adjustment in the sharpness setting, we achieved what we would consider to be as close to perfect image quality as you could expect, short of turning back up to native resolution. Again, nothing looks as crisp as native resolution, no matter how much image processing and clean-up you apply, but the Dell 3008WFP definitely outshined our 30" HP LP3065 and its older 3007WFP sibling in this regard."

That isn't that much more info, they left out how it scales the non PC inputs.
 
With regards to extremetech's lack of detail. That is regular for them. I used frequent their forums but about a year ago they got far less detailed in their reviews and what not, and very lazy with the articles. Needless to say I don't go there anymore.
 
Back
Top