How much artifacting is too much?

firebush

n00b
Joined
Dec 16, 2007
Messages
5
I just flashed my 8800GT's BIOS to give it a voltage increase. In ATITool, I can get the core up to 725.5mhz with zero detected artifacts. At 740mhz I get a detected artifact every 3 or 4 seconds on average. The thing is, these artifacts aren't noticeable in games. Am I doing damage to the card running it with minor artifacting?

Something else I noticed, I can run my card up to 750mhz on the core with 0 artifacts until it reaches 56C! Anyone else notice this phenomenon? If this is happening with other cards, then heat plays a huge factor in achievable 8800GT overclocks. Then again, I didn't realize this until after the voltage increase.
 
Any artifacts is too much for me. Artifacts means the card isn't processing the images correctly which isn't good. Whether or not it damages the card I don't know but to much voltage will damage a card.
 
Any artifacts is too much imo. It means you are pushing the card too far.
 
Any artifacts is too much imo. It means you are pushing the card too far.

Thing is, the artifacts aren't at all noticeable. ATITool detects them, but I can't see anything in game. These are pixel sized blips every 3 to five second. Because image quality isn't affected, the biggest concern I have is with damage. I wouldn't allow RAM induced artifacting because it seems that RAM is a little easier to kill, but I don't know about the core.

Temps are under 70C.
 
Thing is, the artifacts aren't at all noticeable. ATITool detects them, but I can't see anything in game. These are pixel sized blips every 3 to five second. Because image quality isn't affected, the biggest concern I have is with damage. I wouldn't allow RAM induced artifacting because it seems that RAM is a little easier to kill, but I don't know about the core.

Temps are under 70C.

Doesn't matter if you can see them or not. If it reports there are artifacts that is bad.
 
Any artifacts is too much for me. Artifacts means the card isn't processing the images correctly which isn't good. Whether or not it damages the card I don't know but to much voltage will damage a card.

Any artifacts is too much imo. It means you are pushing the card too far.

Exactly. any artifacts is too much. It's not good for the card. It is possible that you have already done permanent damage all ready, and voided the warranty. Congratulations!

Fortunately it seems to be working in games. Was the performance gain worth the BIOS flash? Is it possible to revert back to the original BIOS?

When it comes to hacking hardware, I have not attempted modifying a BIOS on my graphics card. I have flashed several motherboards before, but only if it helps with stability. (I have even seen mother boards go tits-up with a BIOS flash.)
When I over clock, just because Windows boots up ok, and games don't crash, I don't consider it a good stable over clock until I run several hours of ORTHOS with out errors.

Not sure what I'd do in your situation. If possible, I'd go back to the original BIOS, and leave it alone. that's just my opinion.
 
Pushing your card right to its limits usually hurts performance more than it helps anyway. Back off a bit and settle on a stable OC which seems to be around 725mhz for you.
 
how do u get ATItools working
I just tried to install it with Vista 64 and it didnt work.
 
If temps are okay, it's not a problem. I just don't see how graphical corruption, with normal temperatures is hurtful to the card.
 
If temps are okay, it's not a problem. I just don't see how graphical corruption, with normal temperatures is hurtful to the card.

Then you're not seeing the obvious. Just because you don't see/hear that anything is wrong when the engine light comes on doesn't mean harm isn't being done.
 
Exactly. any artifacts is too much. It's not good for the card. It is possible that you have already done permanent damage all ready, and voided the warranty. Congratulations!

Fortunately it seems to be working in games. Was the performance gain worth the BIOS flash? Is it possible to revert back to the original BIOS?

Yes you can revert back to your previous bios if you took a dump of it.
17,500 3D marks on a 8800GT with a modified BIOS

to the OP what were your Max clocks (without artifacting) before the BIOS uodate
Atm mine sit at 725/1800/1045 on Stock Cooling.
 
I run the artifact tester in ATITool for no less than 6 hours in order to consider my video card stable.

I'll just run it overnight while im sleeping.

Basically, ANY artifact is too much.
 
man those seem like a low score my 8800GT I got a 19,125 in 3dmark05
and 11,765 in 06

my GPU is set at 690/1620/1950
I see alot are with C2Q also..i only have a C2D E6750 at 3ghz as well
 
I run the artifact tester in ATITool for no less than 6 hours in order to consider my video card stable.

I'll just run it overnight while im sleeping.

Basically, ANY artifact is too much.

when doing atitool do you put the artifact dectaion bar all the way to the left or leave it stock? cause i can get 700/1725/1000 on mine if i leave it stock or if its all the way to the left I can only get 675/1675/1000
 
man those seem like a low score my 8800GT I got a 19,125 in 3dmark05
and 11,765 in 06

my GPU is set at 690/1620/1950
I see alot are with C2Q also..i only have a C2D E6750 at 3ghz as well


Are you talking about the link to XtreamSystems??
Because thats 17.5K in 3Dmark 06
 
when doing atitool do you put the artifact dectaion bar all the way to the left or leave it stock? cause i can get 700/1725/1000 on mine if i leave it stock or if its all the way to the left I can only get 675/1675/1000

I dont use Atitool to change my overclock - I ONLY use atitool to check for stability after setting the overclock in Rivatuner.

If ATITool complains even once in 6 hours - it's unstable (for me).
 
Can someone explain how artifacts are harmful for the gpu, using facts? The way I see it, the card isn't making the correct calculations because the temperature is too high/clocks too high/not enough voltage. What does this do on a physical level?
 
I laughed when I saw the question, any artifacting is too much!
Without considering any damage that could occur to the card, you risk crashing windows and hosing your install if you make a component run out of spec.
Your choice I suppose.
 
I laughed when I saw the question, any artifacting is too much!
Without considering any damage that could occur to the card, you risk crashing windows and hosing your install if you make a component run out of spec.
Your choice I suppose.

But isn't that the whole point of overclocking in the first place? :D
 
But isn't that the whole point of overclocking in the first place? :D

hehe yeah I overclock to get artifacts!
By out of spec I meant that components within the device are being pushed beyond their operational limits.
 
Can someone explain how artifacts are harmful for the gpu, using facts? The way I see it, the card isn't making the correct calculations because the temperature is too high/clocks too high/not enough voltage. What does this do on a physical level?

If you're getting artifacts, then something is causing a 0 to become a 1 or vice versa. That means that electrons are getting to somewhere they are not wanted by way of a path not designed in to the silicon or they're simply not getting where they are intended. To get where they weren't meant to go, they have to "punch through walls" so to speak. Punching through walls means irreparable damage.

To not get where they're meant to go, they have to be being stopped somewhere (maybe a single transistor can't switch fast enough to operate at the speed all the others are), a.k.a resistance. Resistance = heat. It may not be enough heat to raise the OVERALL die temp up, but it could enough to eventually destroy the single (or multiple) transistor(s) that aren't performing as they should.
 
when doing atitool do you put the artifact dectaion bar all the way to the left or leave it stock? cause i can get 700/1725/1000 on mine if i leave it stock or if its all the way to the left I can only get 675/1675/1000

Very good question. I was just thinking of asking this until I came across you asking. If left auto I can go all day. If I go one to the left I get no visible artifacts but I get a 1 pixel error after a few hours. I talked to W1zzard about this and he said don't worry about 1 pixel errors, just ignore them. They could be caused from anything and as long as you don't get actual rendering errors and yellow marks on the cube you are fine. 1 pixel errors do not show up on the cube.

So for you guys running ATItool artifact scanner, are you leaving the artifact sensitivity slider on default being one over from the left or ultra sensitive with the slider being at the far left?
 
If you're getting artifacts, then something is causing a 0 to become a 1 or vice versa. That means that electrons are getting to somewhere they are not wanted by way of a path not designed in to the silicone or they're simply not getting where they are intended. To get where they weren't meant to go, they have to "punch through walls" so to speak. Punching through walls means irreparable damage.

To not get where they're meant to go, they have to be being stopped somewhere (maybe a single transistor can't switch fast enough to operate at the speed all the others are), a.k.a resistance. Resistance = heat. It may not be enough heat to raise the OVERALL die temp up, but it could enough to eventually destroy the single (or multiple) transistor(s) that aren't performing as they should.

Essentially correct.
At low enough speeds and temps, artifacting wont necessarily cause damage but might start a wrong path for electrons to flow and subsequent use of the device in this condition can make this path a better route for electrons to flow down.
This will increase heat and potentially reduce an overclock or even make the card unstable at rated clocks if it progresses far enough.
Its best to keep the card operating as intended.
 
Very good question. I was just thinking of asking this until I came across you asking. If left auto I can go all day. If I go one to the left I get no visible artifacts but I get a 1 pixel error after a few hours. I talked to W1zzard about this and he said don't worry about 1 pixel errors, just ignore them. They could be caused from anything and as long as you don't get actual rendering errors and yellow marks on the cube you are fine. 1 pixel errors do not show up on the cube.

So for you guys running ATItool artifact scanner, are you leaving the artifact sensitivity slider on default being one over from the left or ultra sensitive with the slider being at the far left?

I'm really intrigued by mention of of an artifact sensitivity slider, I have never seen this.
I am running ATITool version 0.272b, which version are you using?
 
Same, though all versions have this. If you open ATItool and go under the detecting artifacts menu you will see the slider towards the bottom of the menu allowing you to choose how 'picky' ATItool will be at discovering artifacts while testing.
 
If you're getting artifacts, then something is causing a 0 to become a 1 or vice versa. That means that electrons are getting to somewhere they are not wanted by way of a path not designed in to the silicone or they're simply not getting where they are intended. To get where they weren't meant to go, they have to "punch through walls" so to speak. Punching through walls means irreparable damage.

To not get where they're meant to go, they have to be being stopped somewhere (maybe a single transistor can't switch fast enough to operate at the speed all the others are), a.k.a resistance. Resistance = heat. It may not be enough heat to raise the OVERALL die temp up, but it could enough to eventually destroy the single (or multiple) transistor(s) that aren't performing as they should.

Thanks for making an informative post. Makes sense.

Also, I keep the artifact sensor at ultra sensitive but it doesn't seem to make a difference. I guess I have a problem because the whole 3d display can go yellow but atitool doesn't report any errors. I might try an older version from when my x800xt was in production.
 
Same, though all versions have this. If you open ATItool and go under the detecting artifacts menu you will see the slider towards the bottom of the menu allowing you to choose how 'picky' ATItool will be at discovering artifacts while testing.

Brilliant, I cant believe I never spotted that before, thanks :)
 
ryan_975 said:
If you're getting artifacts, then something is causing a 0 to become a 1 or vice versa. That means that electrons are getting to somewhere they are not wanted by way of a path not designed in to the silicone or they're simply not getting where they are intended. To get where they weren't meant to go, they have to "punch through walls" so to speak. Punching through walls means irreparable damage.

To not get where they're meant to go, they have to be being stopped somewhere (maybe a single transistor can't switch fast enough to operate at the speed all the others are), a.k.a resistance. Resistance = heat. It may not be enough heat to raise the OVERALL die temp up, but it could enough to eventually destroy the single (or multiple) transistor(s) that aren't performing as they should.

Thanks! I was hoping for a more informed answer. I wasn't interested in running while artifacting for the longterm, and mainly just for a few benchmarks. Knowing this, I won't do it.

Something off topic... While in ATITool, accidentally hit the "find max core" button (right next to the damn "default" settings button that I tried to hit. The fuzzy dice picture went yellow. Once I figured out what happened, I went for the power switch, but it was too late. Upon reboot, the card showed signs of damage through major artifacting past 690mhz with and without the voltmod. It still runs fine at under 690, but it sucks knowing that the card was harmed.

Why the hell isn't that button hidden away somewhere in ATITool? Who thought it was a good idea to send the core speed to 785mhz right off the batt only to work down from there? I don't mean to get pissed with the maker of ATITool, but its so easy to hit a wrong button and literally fry your card within a second.

Just FYI about ATITool. Be careful.
 
Artifacts are created when the hardware is running too fast that it's no longer able to reliably calculate correctly, if you have any artifacting at all then you're pushing your hardware too hard and it's causing errors, it's a sure sign to not only stop but also underclock another 5-10mhz to make sure it doesn't happen again.

The extra few Mhz isn't worth killing the card, which is what will happen if you overclock too much.
 
Any artifacting is bad, but then again I've had atitool report artifacts for seemingly random reasons where the card is obviously not having issues. I would go with more than just atitool. I prefer to do stuff like run 3dmark in a loop for a while, or just play your games with it and after a week or so you should have a good feel as to the stability of your overclock.
 
Ok, so if you are running ram in your system and its unstable then your ram is destroying its self? I was just under the impression that it wasn't responding to the commands fast enough and sometimes messed up. Video ram isn't fundamentally different than system ram is it?

As for the gpu... They get damaged by making errors while cpus dont?
Ive "heard" CPUs make errors when the signal they send becomes irregular and some parts that are supposed to pass the threshold that define something as a 1 instead of a 0 dont make it high enough. So you feed them more juice to amplify it and essentially lower the bar so the weaker parts of the irregular signal can still register. After a certain point the voltage required is too much for the chip to handle without frying from temps or the signal is just to irregular to fix. Is something totally different with GPUs? Anyone care to educate us with more than common assumption? I dont know but I sure would like to.
 
Back
Top