AMD X2 4400+ vs Phenom

other than hardware virtualization, from which I've seen no tangible benefit yet, all of your preferences were virtually meaningless. There is no honest reason, other than possibly having the best AM2 mobo out already, to get Phenom. Especially since the new boards (790) suck.


Other then the fact the 790 boards run the SB600, which in all honesty perfectly fine for people not running raids, the boards are very solid and will only continue getting better with a few bios updates. I am not sure what you are basing your opinion off of other then Dan's hatred of the SB600. The 790FX motherboards nearly give you every feature of the X38 boards for about 100 dollars less.

As for the snappyness most poeople reinstall their OS each time the upgrade their CPU/Mobo which could atribute to the more snappy feeling having a clean OS install.

That still being said a Phenom 9500 will walk all over a 4400+, there really isnt any real comptition between them, other then price.
 
other than hardware virtualization, from which I've seen no tangible benefit yet, all of your preferences were virtually meaningless. There is no honest reason, other than possibly having the best AM2 mobo out already, to get Phenom. Especially since the new boards (790) suck.

Do you own a 790? Otherwise on what do you base your comments? And virtualization might be meanless to you, but I use it every day. I plan on getting not only a 790FX, but a Phenom. Maybe my preferences will change when Nehalem is released, since all those goodies are included. Until then, I'm sticking with the platform that I like most. Do what you like as well.
 
Other then the fact the 790 boards run the SB600, which in all honesty perfectly fine for people not running raids, the boards are very solid and will only continue getting better with a few bios updates. I am not sure what you are basing your opinion off of other then Dan's hatred of the SB600. The 790FX motherboards nearly give you every feature of the X38 boards for about 100 dollars less.

As for the snappyness most poeople reinstall their OS each time the upgrade their CPU/Mobo which could atribute to the more snappy feeling having a clean OS install.

That still being said a Phenom 9500 will walk all over a 4400+, there really isnt any real comptition between them, other then price.

Actually the SB600 does ok performance wise now. The largest problem with it is the lack of features more than anything.

Sure the Phenom can out perform an X2 4400+ but that's not exactly an impressive feat.

Do you own a 790? Otherwise on what do you base your comments? And virtualization might be meanless to you, but I use it every day. I plan on getting not only a 790FX, but a Phenom. Maybe my preferences will change when Nehalem is released, since all those goodies are included. Until then, I'm sticking with the platform that I like most. Do what you like as well.

I can agree with you on the 790i SLI. Until we see some reviews and they are released into the wild it is all speculation. You can't say that the 700 sucks yet. As for virtualization, it is highly useful, but not for most desktop users. Virtualization is much more important for businesses. The importance of virtualization should not be ignored. It really is the best way to leverage technology and meat the needs of growing businesses.
 
other than hardware virtualization, from which I've seen no tangible benefit yet, all of your preferences were virtually meaningless. There is no honest reason, other than possibly having the best AM2 mobo out already, to get Phenom. Especially since the new boards (790) suck.

Am I missing something? Intel's C2Ds and the X2s both have hardware virtualization too, how is that a selling point for Phenom? I'm using Intel's VT on my ThinkPad laptop right now, works great...
 
Am I missing something? Intel's C2Ds and the X2s both have hardware virtualization too, how is that a selling point for Phenom? I'm using Intel's VT on my ThinkPad laptop right now, works great...

My Core 2 Duo T7200 in my laptop has it too. It works VERY well. I've used it on some of my desktops as well, but I don't do it too often anymore.
 
Am I missing something? Intel's C2Ds and the X2s both have hardware virtualization too, how is that a selling point for Phenom? I'm using Intel's VT on my ThinkPad laptop right now, works great...

it's not a selling point, it's actually a sales detractor now because virtualization is what is hit the hardest performance-wise after the "fix" is applied, but i guess it is basically broken if you dont apply the fix.....
 
I think that's truly a placebo effect. Back in the day when the Athlon 64's were all the rage and even when the X2's came out everyone said the P4's were snappier and more responsive.

(sorry to drag this out from a few pages back, but well late catching up)

Hey Dan,

I'm going to disagree with you on the "placebo effect" in the example you cited. During the P4 Northwood vs 64(Not the X2's) days I would argue the P4 was "snappier" for only one very specific reason, Hyper threading on a SMP aware OS. The "feeling" was like running my BP6 with BeOS for the first time.

Fast forward to today my dual core Intel laptop (Yonah) was as "snappy" as my dual core AMD(Brisbane). It's a load of crock that any "platform" can deliver any tangible "feeling" on any modern multi core system.
 
AMD supported virtualization on a broad scale, from K8 (F) and beyond. There were quite a few Intel processors that didn't/don't support virtualization. I know for certain the E4300 doesn't, and probably the whole series. I also seem to remember a problem of it being unsupported under certain firmware.
 
Do you own a 790? Otherwise on what do you base your comments? And virtualization might be meanless to you, but I use it every day. I plan on getting not only a 790FX, but a Phenom. Maybe my preferences will change when Nehalem is released, since all those goodies are included. Until then, I'm sticking with the platform that I like most. Do what you like as well.

buddy, I know more about virtualization that you could ever dream of, or will ever know. I'm an engineer for VMWare, albeit in the storage and OS groups instead of the hardware group.

I base my comments on the reviews I've read. The SB600 is lacking in features, and the bios for the boards in question are often buggy, not to mention the whole errata issue on top of that. And at the price asked, often over 250, there is little to no justification for getting a phenom at all, unless you already have a good AM2 board and only want a proc upgrade.

http://techreport.com/articles.x/13628/2

AMD supported virtualization on a broad scale, from K8 (F) and beyond. There were quite a few Intel processors that didn't/don't support virtualization. I know for certain the E4300 doesn't, and probably the whole series. I also seem to remember a problem of it being unsupported under certain firmware.

Every processor that the Phenom competes with has hardware virtualization. Any processor you'd want to be running any significant environment on has it.
 
(sorry to drag this out from a few pages back, but well late catching up)

Hey Dan,

I'm going to disagree with you on the "placebo effect" in the example you cited. During the P4 Northwood vs 64(Not the X2's) days I would argue the P4 was "snappier" for only one very specific reason, Hyper threading on a SMP aware OS. The "feeling" was like running my BP6 with BeOS for the first time.

Fast forward to today my dual core Intel laptop (Yonah) was as "snappy" as my dual core AMD(Brisbane). It's a load of crock that any "platform" can deliver any tangible "feeling" on any modern multi core system.

I never meant to state that the P4 wasn't actually snappier than the A64. I felt it myself as I am an avid multitasker. In fact that's the reason why I went from a single Athlon 64 to a dual Opteron 254 setup. The X2's weren't out when I built that thing. I got to have my multitasking performance, encoding performance, general workstation performance and best of all, a fantastic gaming experience.
 
Interesting article (and conclusion) over at Digit-Life, explaining the subtle memory nuances of the X10, and the benefits of an integrated memory controller... for anyone curious about how the new AMD stuff works. I'm sure we'll see improvements as the platform matures.

AMD Phenom X4 Intel X48 and Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 Dual-Channel DDR2-800/1066 Memory

"We have never seen such a big step to revealing the full potential of DDR2-800 and DDR2-1066 memory. And we can now say that the memory controller integrated into AMD processors has finally managed to demonstrate its indisputable advantage over the traditional bus architecture of Intel platforms."
 
Interesting article (and conclusion) over at Digit-Life, explaining the subtle memory nuances of the X10, and the benefits of an integrated memory controller... for anyone curious about how the new AMD stuff works. I'm sure we'll see improvements as the platform matures.

AMD Phenom X4 Intel X48 and Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 Dual-Channel DDR2-800/1066 Memory

"We have never seen such a big step to revealing the full potential of DDR2-800 and DDR2-1066 memory. And we can now say that the memory controller integrated into AMD processors has finally managed to demonstrate its indisputable advantage over the traditional bus architecture of Intel platforms."

and it's still slower. The original Netburst P4 had more memory bandwidth than the AXP: RDRAM combined with the quad-pumped bus meant you had a crapton of speed to work with, and the processor was still an abysmal failure in terms of performance.

Design concepts are only worthwhile if you can leverage them into a benefit of some kind. Right now, Phenom is unable to leverage it's memory bandwidth into any form of usable performance benefit. Sure, in time it may, see the Northwood-C P4's for proof, but right now it's not worth buying except for certain backgrounds: If you have a great AM2 board and just want a new proc, for instance.
 
and it's still slower. The original Netburst P4 had more memory bandwidth than the AXP: RDRAM combined with the quad-pumped bus meant you had a crapton of speed to work with, and the processor was still an abysmal failure in terms of performance.

Design concepts are only worthwhile if you can leverage them into a benefit of some kind. Right now, Phenom is unable to leverage it's memory bandwidth into any form of usable performance benefit. Sure, in time it may, see the Northwood-C P4's for proof, but right now it's not worth buying except for certain backgrounds: If you have a great AM2 board and just want a new proc, for instance.

Agreed. There isn't much reason to buy a Phenom right now.
 
Interesting article (and conclusion) over at Digit-Life, explaining the subtle memory nuances of the X10, and the benefits of an integrated memory controller... for anyone curious about how the new AMD stuff works. I'm sure we'll see improvements as the platform matures.

AMD Phenom X4 Intel X48 and Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 Dual-Channel DDR2-800/1066 Memory

"We have never seen such a big step to revealing the full potential of DDR2-800 and DDR2-1066 memory. And we can now say that the memory controller integrated into AMD processors has finally managed to demonstrate its indisputable advantage over the traditional bus architecture of Intel platforms."

I'm not a graph expert, but it seems to me that AMD took a step backwards and managed to not only have less memory bandwidth than the competition, but also less bandwidth than their own "last-gen" part... http://hardocp.com/image.html?image=MTE5NTQzNTAzNzN1Q25HQmZCSWxfNl8xX2wuZ2lm
 
I'm not a graph expert, but it seems to me that AMD took a step backwards and managed to not only have less memory bandwidth than the competition, but also less bandwidth than their own "last-gen" part... http://hardocp.com/image.html?image=MTE5NTQzNTAzNzN1Q25HQmZCSWxfNl8xX2wuZ2lm

It's hard to say. For one thing that is a synthetic test and should already be taken with a grain of salt. Secondly there may be something wrong with the program in regard to Phenom benchmarking.
 
anyone who buys one now is simply "taking one for the team" or hasnt done any research, they are really worthless now after "fixing" the errata hang...i bet they wont be able to give away the 9500 and 9600.....nobody in their right mind would buy now when 9550 and 9650 will be much better, but that brings a whole dilemma again where intels chips will be even further ahead...not good, i expect intels prices to remain constant or could even go higher

http://techreport.com/articles.x/13741/1
 
I'm waiting for the other shoe to drop,so to speak with Phenom.Given the deep discounts Scott mentioned in the latest errata article,how long will it be before AMD cuts prices at retail ?

Anand spoke of the chip being effected by some cuts in early Q1,but my thinking is they need to do it now.My friend Stephan @ Ingram Micro,says they are not moving well at all,and that already purchase orders,from the Mom and Pops,have dropped off for the Phenom even more.Many of the Mom and Pop owners read sites like this,and the Tech Report.Of course these things could be totally unrelated,but he seems to think no.Whats in the channel now,has a 'stigma attached to them now'.These were his words.
 
anyone who buys one now is simply "taking one for the team" or hasnt done any research, they are really worthless now after "fixing" the errata hang...i bet they wont be able to give away the 9500 and 9600.....nobody in their right mind would buy now when 9550 and 9650 will be much better, but that brings a whole dilemma again where intels chips will be even further ahead...not good, i expect intels prices to remain constant or could even go higher

http://techreport.com/articles.x/13741/1

I'll take one for test purposes, but I wouldn't put one in my own machines, nor would I pay for one of these things.
 
Anand spoke of the chip being effected by some cuts in early Q1,but my thinking is they need to do it now.My friend Stephan @ Ingram Micro,says they are not moving well at all,and that already purchase orders,from the Mom and Pops,have dropped off for the Phenom even more.Many of the Mom and Pop owners read sites like this,and the Tech Report.Of course these things could be totally unrelated,but he seems to think no.Whats in the channel now,has a 'stigma attached to them now'.These were his words.
Troubling news. I guess this also has impacted purchases from the intermediary-level retailers like local small computer chains?
 
You know what I'd really like to see?

A Crossfire Spider platform system versus an similarily priced Nvidia chipset mobo, SLI and Intel processor.
 
Troubling news. I guess this also has impacted purchases from the intermediary-level retailers like local small computer chains?



I would think yes,as this will have a chain like reaction effect to sales at retail (in fact it already is).Its not even that todays retail mom and pop buyer,are more tech savvy,its that bad news travels fast.AMD today,are already saying sales are way down,and that Q4 rev will drop off by hundreds of millions,far off and below Wallstreet analysts estimtes,or AMD's own projections.

People are stupid ! If they hear that a product is damaged or 'broken' they will stay away in droves.No matter that they will likely never,ever,ever run into the issue. :(
 
You know what I'd really like to see?

A Crossfire Spider platform system versus an similarily priced Nvidia chipset mobo, SLI and Intel processor.

I think the Intel/NVIDIA combination would be the better performer (especially overclocked), although it would likely end up being slightly more expensive. Even so there are plenty of good inexpensive SLI compatible motherboards that would be nearly comparable to the 790FX boards.

All prices taken from Newegg.com. I won't bother including the PSU, and everything else, just the parts that are different between the two theoretical setups.

Intel Q6600 2.4GHz (G0 stepping) =$279.99
eVGA 680i SLI =$259.99
eVGA 8800GT Superclocked 512MB =$289.99
eVGA 8800GT Superclocked 512MB =$289.99

Total= $1119.96

AMD Phenom 9600 $269.99
Gigabyte GA-MA790FX-DQ6=$267.51
ASUS Radeon 3870 512MB =$269.99
ASUS Radeon 3870 512MB =$269.99

Total= $1077.48

They seem to be about the same price when totalled up and video cards aside, the Intel processor will overclock better and provide much better performance than the Phenom can ever provide. Seems clear to me.
 
Quick question, since I don't really follow CrossFire/SLi goings-on, is dual 3870 superior to dual 8800GT? Even close?
 
I think the Intel/NVIDIA combination would be the better performer (especially overclocked), although it would likely end up being slightly more expensive. Even so there are plenty of good inexpensive SLI compatible motherboards that would be nearly comparable to the 790FX boards.

All prices taken from Newegg.com. I won't bother including the PSU, and everything else, just the parts that are different between the two theoretical setups.

Intel Q6600 2.4GHz (G0 stepping) =$279.99
eVGA 680i SLI =$259.99
eVGA 8800GT Superclocked 512MB =$289.99
eVGA 8800GT Superclocked 512MB =$289.99

Total= $1119.96

AMD Phenom 9600 $269.99
Gigabyte GA-MA790FX-DQ6=$267.51
ASUS Radeon 3870 512MB =$269.99
ASUS Radeon 3870 512MB =$269.99

Total= $1077.48

They seem to be about the same price when totalled up and video cards aside, the Intel processor will overclock better and provide much better performance than the Phenom can ever provide. Seems clear to me.


would be interested, only thing I'd say since we're not comparing quad gpu setups, should go with the DS-5, which would make AMD solution $50 cheaper than above, or about $100 less overall.

The Nvidia solution should be faster, but still, would really be a good read.
 
Quick question, since I don't really follow CrossFire/SLi goings-on, is dual 3870 superior to dual 8800GT? Even close?

http://forums.firingsquad.com/firingsquad/board/message?board.id=hardware&thread.id=112611

According to the test results there, 3870's in Crossfire are faster than 8800GT's in SLI when no AA or AF is used. When AA and AF are used, Crossfire takes a sharp nose dive in performance. As far as scaling between the two, it seems that there is a lot of give and take but Crossfire generally seems to scale a little better. Obviously Crossfire has had some major improvements since the dongle days. Even so in terms of absolute performance SLI still has the lead if for no other reason than the NVIDIA cards themselves are faster than their ATI counterparts.

It used to be that SLI always scaled better and the NVIDIA cards were faster individually when AA and AF were disabled. It seems that these days the tables have turned.
 
is it just me, or does anyone else think tests on SLI/CF systems with AA is kind of pointless? I mean, if you have an SLI/CF setup, you're probably playing at a resolution that it doesn't really matter?
 
would be interested, only thing I'd say since we're not comparing quad gpu setups, should go with the DS-5, which would make AMD solution $50 cheaper than above, or about $100 less overall.

The Nvidia solution should be faster, but still, would really be a good read.

I went with the highest end models of each board. I could have picked $100 NVIDIA board if I wanted to, but it didn't make sense to me. As for Quad GPU setups that would only put the ATI/AMD system in a more expensive price bracket.

is it just me, or does anyone else think tests on SLI/CF systems with AA is kind of pointless? I mean, if you have an SLI/CF setup, you're probably playing at a resolution that it doesn't really matter?

I couldn't disagree more. I'd wager that many people running SLI/CF systems are doing so with 22" monitors and at 1680x1050 AA and AF are still needed very much. Beyond that even at 2560x1600 AA and AF are still noticable depending on the game. 4xAA looks much better than 2xAA in COD4 even at 2560x1600.
 
and it's still slower. The original Netburst P4 had more memory bandwidth than the AXP: RDRAM combined with the quad-pumped bus meant you had a crapton of speed to work with, and the processor was still an abysmal failure in terms of performance.

Yea and? I'm not really sure where you were trying to go with this statement:confused: AXP's didnt have an IMC, they had a fsb just like the p4's. axp's had a 400 fsb and p4's had a 800 fsb. Not really hard to figure out which one would have a higher memory bandwidth.

Additionally rdram was superior to ddr in memory bandwidth. It just had the down fall of not being as dependable as other types of memory and being A LOT more expensive. Other than these downfalls rdram really wasnt all that bad.

As for your other comment in regards to phenoms. It's really to hard to say much of anything right now. With all of the issues that the phenom has among itself and possible software updates for benchmarking programs its really just to hard to make heads or tails of its real memory performance at the moment, imo.
 
is it just me, or does anyone else think tests on SLI/CF systems with AA is kind of pointless? I mean, if you have an SLI/CF setup, you're probably playing at a resolution that it doesn't really matter?



AA/AF still makes things look even better, i dont understand why anyone would NOT run AA/AF no matter what resolution

when i set up a program tp play i always enable the highest amount of AA/AF i can run at my default resolution and still get playable framerates, this would not change if i was running SLI
 
Yea and? I'm not really sure where you were trying to go with this statement:confused: AXP's didnt have an IMC, they had a fsb just like the p4's. axp's had a 400 fsb and p4's had a 800 fsb. Not really hard to figure out which one would have a higher memory bandwidth.

Additionally rdram was superior to ddr in memory bandwidth. It just had the down fall of not being as dependable as other types of memory and being A LOT more expensive. Other than these downfalls rdram really wasnt all that bad.

As for your other comment in regards to phenoms. It's really to hard to say much of anything right now. With all of the issues that the phenom has among itself and possible software updates for benchmarking programs its really just to hard to make heads or tails of its real memory performance at the moment, imo.

RDRAM was perfectly dependable. The problem was that RDRAM was a poor performer in non-sequential reads and writes. RDRAMs reputation was further soiled by the fact that the first single channel chipsets were poor performers due to the high latency and poor random read/write performance of RDRAM. You may be thinking RDRAM wasn't relaible due to the i820 MTH recall issue but that was a chipset level problem and not a memory problem. Beyond that due to the whole Rambus legal issues and required royalties only two companies actually produced RDRAM increasing the cost to outrageous levels. When RDRAM was properly implemented on the later chipsets it was a better performer than DDR was, but not to enough of a degree to justify the cost. Once DDR400 modules became the standard RDRAM was dead in the water.

While it is true that some applications and benchmarking tools need to be updated to work their best with Phenom we can see already in many real-world situations that Phenom is inferior to the Core 2 architecture based processors clock for clock. Lets not forget that current Phenom processors overclock like shit.
 
People are stupid ! If they hear that a product is damaged or 'broken' they will stay away in droves.No matter that they will likely never,ever,ever run into the issue. :(

Well, that, plus the fact that it's slower, plus the fact that it costs the same or more than an equally clocked Intel chip. I think those factors combined are a pretty good reason not to buy. I know I wouldn't want to pay more for a defective and slower CPU.
 
Yea and? I'm not really sure where you were trying to go with this statement:confused: AXP's didnt have an IMC, they had a fsb just like the p4's. axp's had a 400 fsb and p4's had a 800 fsb. Not really hard to figure out which one would have a higher memory bandwidth.

Additionally rdram was superior to ddr in memory bandwidth. It just had the down fall of not being as dependable as other types of memory and being A LOT more expensive. Other than these downfalls rdram really wasnt all that bad.

As for your other comment in regards to phenoms. It's really to hard to say much of anything right now. With all of the issues that the phenom has among itself and possible software updates for benchmarking programs its really just to hard to make heads or tails of its real memory performance at the moment, imo.

bandwidth != performance is where I was going. The P4 had more bandwidth, but was a crappy performer. Vista was claiming that Phenom having memory bandwidth would equal performance.

Memory performance is meaningless. It underperforms everywhere else.
 
bandwidth != performance is where I was going. The P4 had more bandwidth, but was a crappy performer. Vista was claiming that Phenom having memory bandwidth would equal performance.

Memory performance is meaningless. It underperforms everywhere else.

Oh ok gotcha now. Thanks for the clear up.

And oh yea no doubt Dan. I'm not arguing that phenom is going to be miserable against core clock for clock even with its much needed fixes. At best phonom will match up against penryn sometime down the road with some more mature chipset drivers and a few steppings. But even still as you pointed out Intel can just make higher clocked chips. Not to mention its cheaper for Intel to create chips than it is for AMD.

And yea there were other issues with the rdram issue but I didnt want to derail the thread to much after the whole turkey incident :/
 
Back
Top