Should I recommend the Q6600?

deadman_uk

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 30, 2003
Messages
2,036
My friend is looking to replace his whole computer with a new one and I am selecting the parts for him.

First of all the processor, what processor would you recommend? He wants to play demanding games, do a little bit of video/photo editing and use demanding applications. Would the Q6600 be a good choice of CPU? Price range for the CPU is around £200.

Please help me select a CPU for him. Thanks!
 
i say go with Q6600. if you wanna o/c it's a very easy chip to o/c to 3.0/1333 on stock voltage
 
My friend is looking to replace his whole computer with a new one and I am selecting the parts for him.

First of all the processor, what processor would you recommend? He wants to play demanding games, do a little bit of video/photo editing and use demanding applications. Would the Q6600 be a good choice of CPU? Price range for the CPU is around £200.

Please help me select a CPU for him. Thanks!

Q6600 is an EXCELLENT cpu!
Its plenty fast at stock speeds, and most of them overclock quite well. I have mine at 3.4Ghz on air with no issues after 5 months.
In games this thing screems. The newest games even take advantage of all 4 cores.
Video and photo editing is a dream. Apps like this are what really make quad shine.

I guarantee that if your buddy is really going to use it, he will not be disapointed. I know i'll never look back to a dual core. For the price range, this is the best thing you could do. If you really want to save some cash, get an e6550, but the quad is definately worth the money.
 
Just my 2 cents here.

I just bought the E6750 for $170. The Q6600 costs $100 bucks more. I chose to not go quad core because I really doubt I'll get $100 worth of performance out of a Quad for some time to come. Games like Crysis are getting better at using 2+ cores, but I have yet to see where the quad is really boosting game performance enough to make it worth the added price.

I think this link shows a good example of why I think this: http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQxMSw2LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA== As you can see, when you crank the resolution up to real-world gaming levels, the Extra 2 cores wont really gain you much. In crisis the difference was 0.2 FPS. That equates to $500 per FPS gained.

EDIT: However, If you have a Fry's nearby, the Q6600 is a total bargain when they package it for < $200 with a shitty ECS mobo. Toss the mobo and keep the proc.

The last thing I should mention is OC ability. While no should sneeze at how well most Q6600's clock; from what I read, the Quad puts a lot more strain on the p35 & x38 motherboards with 4-phase PWM circuits. This in turn leads to lower clocks. Supposedly some the gaudy x48 8-phase mobos are going to help this out. I think a lot of people are thinking "let's wait and see" before 8-phase is given the credit that is being hyped up to.
 
Yeah I don't think Quad Core will give much benefits in games but it's still fairly new and for the price, I would recommend this to my friend.

Thanks all!

Now what motherboard should I combo this Q6600 with? Any recommendations?
 
Yeah I don't think Quad Core will give much benefits in games but it's still fairly new and for the price, I would recommend this to my friend.

Thanks all!

Now what motherboard should I combo this Q6600 with? Any recommendations?
Abit IP35 Pro or IP35-E
Gigabyte P35-DS3R
 
One that doesn't get much talk is the DFI blood iron P35 which many have found to up among the best of the cheaper P35's. Abit IP35 is also good.

Because of the voltage damping of the P5K-E Wifi, I chose it. But it's about $50 more.
 
i have been using an EVGA 680i SLI. its been great for me, but it seems i'm one of the lucky ones. Theres a thread started by Dan_D in the mobo forums. He said he's gone through 11 in the last year. Lots of other people have been having problems too. Seems like they are all with quads. I'm not sure if those were the newest revision or not, but i still can't really recomend this. With that many people reporting problems, its to risky.
 
Due to availability, It seems it's either of these..

Abit IP35 Pro
Abit IP35-E
Gigabyte P35-DS3R

What are the differences? The prices do differ.
 
The Intel motherboard structure is a little crazy cause they release a new chip set every week.

Here's how you can break it up:

P35 (roughly a year old or so)
- Midrange around $100 to $150 (Down and dirty but surprisingly sturdy)
- High-mid range around $150 to $250 (For the SLi users, will have a crap load of heatpites, RAID, etc)
- Uber high end diamond encrusted $300 (The motherboard company will pay someone to come OC your rig for you, however they will have to install a Chinese version of windows on your system)

AFAIK, it's pretty hard to get a bad P35 board. The only strike against them is Vcore voltage droop, but the PK5 is supposed to offset this and has been shown to do well at not lotting the voltage get way out of whack under load with a high OC. That being said, I've not read a bad word about the IP35, or the Blood Iron, the Gigabyte or otherwise. Buying a P35 must be like fishing in a bucket, because even the $100 boards can get some serious FSB clocks, so long as your CPU has high FSB barrier.

If you want to get into the x38 or x48, you can follow the above structure, just increase the prices substantially. Some things about the x38 and x48 are great. I just didn't see enough benefit all around to warrant the price. And DDR3 is ungodly expensive
 
I forgot to mention, my friend does not want to overclock any hardware of his. I will probably get one of the abits, I will look at the specs of both and pick one that sounds the best.
 
If your friend has no intentions whatsoever of ever overclocking and wants a solid stable and always reliable box, tell him to buy an actual Intel motherboard and not just some other brand with an Intel chipset on it. There are some nice solid Intel boards at Newegg for $100-150 these days, P35 based, ready for a Q6600 and you simply cannot buy a more stable motherboard for an Intel processor than one actually manufactured by Intel itself.

</The_above_opinion_comes_from_30+_years_of_experience_with_building_PCs_of_all_shapes_brands_and_sizes>

And Intel rules. :D

If he can't or won't buy an actual Intel board, stick with Gigabyte. Their reputation stomps on Abit's like Godzilla coming to Tokyo for a late night snack.
 
I would suggest the E6850 together with the best available mobo right now

GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6

Fudzilla 2200 MHz on Gigabyte P35T-DQ6
TweakTown GIGABYTE Push More Out Of their P35T-DQ6 Motherboard With Micron DDR3 Modules
TweakTown GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6 (DDR3)
[H]ardOCP GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6
AnandTech Gigabyte GA-P35T-DQ6: (DDR3)

Remeber this Gigabyte Mobo is also available in the (only) DDR2 version.

Most of the time you won't be able to fully utilize your Quad depending on what your core thing is on your comp. If you are heavely involved into mov en-decoding I would go for the Quad certainly but otherwise, ...no.

The Intel Mobo's get very hot which the Gigabyte P35T-DQ6 does not!
 
I would suggest the E6850 together with the best available mobo right now

GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6

Fudzilla 2200 MHz on Gigabyte P35T-DQ6
TweakTown GIGABYTE Push More Out Of their P35T-DQ6 Motherboard With Micron DDR3 Modules
TweakTown GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6 (DDR3)
[H]ardOCP GIGABYTE P35T-DQ6
AnandTech Gigabyte GA-P35T-DQ6: (DDR3)

Remeber this Gigabyte Mobo is also available in the (only) DDR2 version.

Most of the time you won't be able to fully utilize your Quad depending on what your core thing is on your comp. If you are heavely involved into mov en-decoding I would go for the Quad certainly but otherwise, ...no.

The Intel Mobo's get very hot which the Gigabyte P35T-DQ6 does not!

Well DDR3 ram is too expensive so my friend will get fast DDR2 ram. The reason I selected Quad Core was because of the price.. it's so cheap and could be useful in the future when more applications demand it. About the Intel motherboard.. does it really get so hot? The Gigabyte DQ6 is almost double the price of the Gigabyte GA P35C-DS3R I was recommended on here... what's the difference?
 
Well can't go realy wrong on the Q6600 either but I just think the E6850 does his OC much easier than the Q_bottumline_

If you only have a brief look on the design of the two Mobo's you problably find out yourself.

ga-p35-dq6-1b.jpg


ga946gm1.jpg


And all highest quality components there, this mobo stays extreemly :cool:
 
Like I said my friend doesn't want to overclock so I think the Q6600 is the best for the price and performance @ stock levels :cool:
 
Back
Top