New Dell 3008WFP Coming?

the gamer

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
1,426
I've been hearing about this monitor on and off and I wanted to know if anyone else here know more about it?
 
I just want it to have a S-IPS panel and I'll be happy. Unless it's outrageously expensive because of the new scaler to enable non-native resolutions on it.
 
Nice set of inputs, but the design...

It's just the ugly cheapass design they use for the TN crap monitors. Equal to the design of the SP2008W.

I also want to know what panel it uses and whether is has inputlag or not. If it uses PVA, TN or a IPS with inputlag I will buy a 3007WFP-HC, if it's uses a little better IPS panel, maybe I will buy it. But overall, I like the design of the 3007WFP-HC much more. Combine that with the fact that I already own two 2007FP monitor, and you can say that a 3007WFP-HC will look much better then a 3008WFP between them.
 
Maybe I'll get a wicked deal on a 3007-hc because of this.

I suspect all the connectivity + scaler is going to driver the price up on this one and all I really want it for is a computer monitor.

Besides knowing Dell they will be switching to a PVA screen on this one.
 
What improvements are there compared to the other 30" model in regards to the scaler?
I have the older model and it scales fine...??:confused:
 
the older model doesnt scale at all, guy.


$20 says this one doesnt have all the necessary scaling options to handle all the different inputs properly, and doesnt properly handle the ones it is designed to work with either.

needs: 1:1, aspect, fullscreen, 4:3 scale, 16:9 scale options.

if it is missing any one of those its a failure in my eyes
 
Maybe I'll get a wicked deal on a 3007-hc because of this.

I suspect all the connectivity + scaler is going to driver the price up on this one and all I really want it for is a computer monitor.

Besides knowing Dell they will be switching to a PVA screen on this one.

You have a source about that switching to PVA? It would really be a downgrade..
 
Response time, I need response time!!!!!!!!

Ghosting on my 2407 drives me nuts on hardforum... well, not so much... I can ignore it.

My 3007WFP though is niceeeeeeeee
 
needs: 1:1, aspect, fullscreen, 4:3 scale, 16:9 scale options.

if it is missing any one of those its a failure in my eyes

Nah. 1:1 and aspect are all it needs. Do you really enjoy watching stretched/squished aspect ratios? I'd much rather have the black bars than have the 70's kungfu movie effect going on. Or the everybody-is-a-short-stubby-dwarf effect, for that matter.
 
How could this be a bad monitor? With all those inuts and an S-IPS panel with a resolution to match the panel's size, how could this be bad? Now all we need is a release date and a price.
 
Who says it will be S-IPS?

I've got a 3007WFP-HC that I can return up until the beginning of December. If any more substantial info comes out regarding the new one, I might consider returning it. Don't like the buzz, lack of scaling, and lack of inputs much. Otherwise it is a fantastic monitor. I'm still skeptical that I would actually want to buy the first of something - Dell doesn't exactly have a great track record when it comes to Rev1 of their monitors....
 
Seeing as Displayport is a major feature of this monitor and there are no Displayport graphics cards out any time soon... I doubt this monitor is coming out in 2007. Also the only LCD company who announced Displayport support is Samsung. So this is likely using a S-PVA panel, not S-IPS. Hope I'm proven wrong.

There is also the 2408wfp which may have similar features at a lower cost.
 
Of course 2408 will be lower cost... it's smaller.

I'm ready to swap my 2407 for that 2408 anytime =P
 
Nah. 1:1 and aspect are all it needs. Do you really enjoy watching stretched/squished aspect ratios?

No. Do you? Because if you watch anything over s-video or composite (VCR, older game consoles, etc etc) you need 16:9 and 4:3 scaling options.

because the signal is sent in 3:2, but the image is created to be displayed on a 4:3 or 16:9 display, neither of which this is.

or did you think some of the samsung monitors just had those options in there for fun

Not to mention other scenarios like SD channels coming in over a digital connection from an HD box. they'll still be 4:3 content over a non 4:3 signal, so you need that option to scale them up to the largest 4:3 box possible


granted, it shouldnt need the fullscreen option, but i suppose its good its there (never seen it done wrong!)
 
No. Do you? Because if you watch anything over s-video or composite (VCR, older game consoles, etc etc) you need 16:9 and 4:3 scaling options.

because the signal is sent in 3:2, but the image is created to be displayed on a 4:3 or 16:9 display, neither of which this is.

or did you think some of the samsung monitors just had those options in there for fun

Not to mention other scenarios like SD channels coming in over a digital connection from an HD box. they'll still be 4:3 content over a non 4:3 signal, so you need that option to scale them up to the largest 4:3 box possible


granted, it shouldnt need the fullscreen option, but i suppose its good its there (never seen it done wrong!)

3:2? I've never seen a common video device that outputs that ratio.

Are we just not communicating here? Isn't "aspect" mode a scaling mode that resizes the image to fill as much of the screen as possible while maintaining the proper aspect ratio? If so, that's all you need for non-16:10 ratios. I'm not familiar with Samsung's scaling terminology, so I might be misunderstanding "16:9" and "4:3". To me those terms mean that they'd scale the signal to a 16:9 or 4:3 ratio respectively regardless of the ratio of the source material/device, but like I said I don't know how Samsung names their scaling options and could be completely off the mark.
 
3:2? I've never seen a common video device that outputs that ratio.

Are we just not communicating here? Isn't "aspect" mode a scaling mode that resizes the image to fill as much of the screen as possible while maintaining the proper aspect ratio? If so, that's all you need for non-16:10 ratios. I'm not familiar with Samsung's scaling terminology, so I might be misunderstanding "16:9" and "4:3". To me those terms mean that they'd scale the signal to a 16:9 or 4:3 ratio respectively regardless of the ratio of the source material/device, but like I said I don't know how Samsung names their scaling options and could be completely off the mark.

But those all ARE spitting out that ratio. NTSC is a 3:2 signal, dude. That's why when you take one through a display and set it to 1:1 mode, the outputted image measures 3mm across for ever 2 in height

You never noticed because the devices you've used them on in the past most likely have always been TV's - with decent enough scalers to bring the image to fullscreen. And since TV's are 4:3 and 16:9, the image was being pulled or squished to that ratio.

The reason it WORKS and you don't notice is that the CONTENT of the image is designed for those other 2 ratios. the SIGNAL might be 3:2, but it's sent already squished one way or another, and when it gets squished the other way to 4:3 or 16:9, it looks proper, and as intended.

Currently monitors like the BenQ or Dell dont have 4:3 or 16:9 scaling options, so there is no way to watch NTSC (composite/s-video) signals without distortion. You can either set the outputting device to 4:3 and watch it on a scaled up (via aspect mode) 3:2 box, or you can set it to 16:9 and watch it on a fullscreen (via fullscreen) 16:10 box, but neither is a proper match and there will be wide or narrow faces.

This is probably shocking, but its absolutely all true. It just comes down to image vs signal ratio.



Oh and I totally forgot to mention this is a problem with pretty much any kind of 480p as well. So now you realise how much it affects you. 720x480. (thats a 3:2 signal! but the image isn't in 3:2!)
 
Seeing as Displayport is a major feature of this monitor and there are no Displayport graphics cards out any time soon... I doubt this monitor is coming out in 2007. Also the only LCD company who announced Displayport support is Samsung. So this is likely using a S-PVA panel, not S-IPS. Hope I'm proven wrong.

There is also the 2408wfp which may have similar features at a lower cost.

this has nothing to do with the LCD module, all input/output/scaling is controlled externally. The LCD is connected via LVDS to the controller, Dell is only future-proofing.
 
But those all ARE spitting out that ratio. NTSC is a 3:2 signal, dude. That's why when you take one through a display and set it to 1:1 mode, the outputted image measures 3mm across for ever 2 in height

You never noticed because the devices you've used them on in the past most likely have always been TV's - with decent enough scalers to bring the image to fullscreen. And since TV's are 4:3 and 16:9, the image was being pulled or squished to that ratio.

The reason it WORKS and you don't notice is that the CONTENT of the image is designed for those other 2 ratios. the SIGNAL might be 3:2, but it's sent already squished one way or another, and when it gets squished the other way to 4:3 or 16:9, it looks proper, and as intended.

Currently monitors like the BenQ or Dell dont have 4:3 or 16:9 scaling options, so there is no way to watch NTSC (composite/s-video) signals without distortion. You can either set the outputting device to 4:3 and watch it on a scaled up (via aspect mode) 3:2 box, or you can set it to 16:9 and watch it on a fullscreen (via fullscreen) 16:10 box, but neither is a proper match and there will be wide or narrow faces.

This is probably shocking, but its absolutely all true. It just comes down to image vs signal ratio.

Oh and I totally forgot to mention this is a problem with pretty much any kind of 480p as well. So now you realise how much it affects you. 720x480. (thats a 3:2 signal! but the image isn't in 3:2!)

Wow, fascinating. You learn something new every day! So you're saying that for source material that is targeted at 4:3 displays, the native NTSC signal is actually at 3:2, which means that viewed in its native unscaled state the content would look stretched horizontally (people look short and stubby). Am I understanding that correctly? I never knew. I knew about anamorphic DVDs and how the source material looks distorted if viewed in native format, but had no idea this was also the case with regular over-the-air broadcasts.
 
Wow, fascinating. You learn something new every day! So you're saying that for source material that is targeted at 4:3 displays, the native NTSC signal is actually at 3:2, which means that viewed in its native unscaled state the content would look stretched horizontally (people look short and stubby). Am I understanding that correctly? I never knew. I knew about anamorphic DVDs and how the source material looks distorted if viewed in native format, but had no idea this was also the case with regular over-the-air broadcasts.

yes they would. because 3:2 is wider than 4:3 and the expectation is to squish it on the sides and narrow up their faces/bodies where you could see it.

but without squishing (1:1 or aspect) it remains too wide looking. of course (fullscreen) would just make it even worse.
 
wow I forgot about this thread :D,

Dell looks like they are going all out to make there 30" monitor great, I just hope the price is around the $1500-2000AUD mark.
 
OT -

Hey Mentat; just noticed your system is real similar to what I am using
you have
"Asus A8R32-MVP | AMD Athlon64 X2 4600+ | 2x 1GB OCZ PC-3200 3-4-4-8 | PNY 8800GTS | Creative Audigy 2 ZS | Hauppauge WinTV-PVR-150 | 2x Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 320GB SATA HDD | 1x Western Digital Caviar SE16 320GB SATA HDD | NEC 3540A CD/DVD burner | FSP AX500-A 500W | custom quiet 6A case by mnpctech | various external enclosures"

I'm using
Asus A8R-MVP (btw this board sucks; the a8r32 might be better thou)
x2 4800+, pny 8800gts, Audigy 2zs, nec 3540a, Using a mix match of HDs, 250 maxtor ide, 2 250 gig sata hitachis and a new 750 gig sata 2 WD, using a p150 case (love this case). Cept I have 5 hard drives in there so its cram packed with cables.

oh ya ...

Looking forward to a 30" monitor with xbox 360 support (give me a reason to get a 360 finally if they come out with one. May pick up the 27" thou till they come out with this one.

I dont see the gateway here in the UK; some so so reviews on it anyways
 
My concern is that we're all talking about the 3008WFP here, if I drop a wedge on buying one of these then what are the chances that the 3008WFP-HC will show up a couple of months later?
 
My concern is that we're all talking about the 3008WFP here, if I drop a wedge on buying one of these then what are the chances that the 3008WFP-HC will show up a couple of months later?

LED backlighting will be the only way to get better colours, as 100-102% NTSC is about the max you will get with a standard backlight. There MAY be a 3008WFP-LED (mega exprensive), but I doubt it. More than likely just revisions until the nex gen.
 
Back
Top