Please rate/critique my potential new gaming rig

Joined
Oct 30, 2007
Messages
45
I haven't upgraded since my Athlon 2700+ which I'm now typing to you on. I'm a hardcore gamer and I somehow skipped an entire generation (the dual cores) and am going all out for my quad core system. I want high end parts but not bleeding edge or stupid extras just to waste money. So that being said for example I'm going with the smart buy of the 8800GT w/ SLI instead of 8800Ultra SLI. I've never overclocked before but considering I've played competitive FPS for a decade and am a game developer myself I feel embarassed that I've not become a part of the hardware side of the hardcore community ;) I'm hoping to achieve 3.4ghz on my OC, but would still be thrilled with 3.2 (newbs can't get greedy right?). There are sooooooo many new chipsets to choose from right now, and so many coming out around the corner. I thought the X38 was my sure choice until I found it out had no SLI :*( Anyways I'd love to hear any comments and thank you for your time! Cya in Crysis, UT3 and TF2 :D

My target budget is $2000-2300 for my PC, not including the monitor.

*Some notes on my needs for my system*
-I will definitely overclock
-Noise is a definite issue as this PC will sit in my bedroom, 6 feet from my bed. I already have my old machine there and I'm used to a soft hum perhaps, but I don't want an airplane in my house 24/7. If I picked any parts that you think are like this, please let me know!
-I will definitely use SLI 8800GT
-I will likely be using raid one day and upgrading to a Penryn sometime down the road
-I really don't know the difference between the vast variety of motherboards out there. I basically picked the one that was rated well on newegg after reading tons of peoples reviews for it on there. Also the one I picked has cool colours LOL. :p Really I want the best mobo for OC'ing so that it will make it easiest on me to OC to my goal of 3.4.
-I'm not sure whether I should be getting a 4gb kit or 2 2gb kits, if it is 4gb kit then do I get 2 x 2gb or 4 x 1gb?
-I need a mid tower case no taller than 21 inches, anything else goes.


So here's what I've come up with so far:

CPU - Intel Q6600 G0 stepping ($280)
Motherboard - EVGA 122-CK-NF68-T1 nForce 680i SLI Motherboard ($200)
Heatsink - Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme ($65)
Ram - 2 x G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 ($80 x 2)
Videocard - 2 x MSI 8800GT OC ($235 x 2)
Soundcard - Creative 70SB046A00000 7.1 Channels 24-bit 192KHz PCI Interface Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series ($145)
Case - Antec P182 Gun Metal Black 0.8mm cold rolled steel ATX Mid Tower ($140)
Case Fans - 3 x 120mm Scythe something, not sure which, also do I need a Scythe for my Ultra 120 extreme, plz help? ($45)
Power Supply - PC Power & Cooling Silencer 750 Quad (Black) EPS12V 750W ($200)
Hard Drive Gaming - 1 x 150gb Raptor 10k RPM 16mb Cache SATA 1.5 ($180)
Hard Drive Storage - 2 x 750gb Hitachi 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA 3.0 ($200 x 2)
Arctic Cooling Paste - Not sure what's good these days, plz help (estimated $10)

Total - $2295


Thanks for taking the time to read my post and critique. I still could use advice on the case fans and arctic cooling stuff as people take them so for granted there is not much discussion on them that I've found. These specs make me drool just looking at them, zomg I can't wait!~ :cool:

~Cooltown
 
I really can't say much, it looks solid. One thing though, you might want to drop the X-FI card it's not really needed unless you're kind of audiofile and then still it's games. Instead get at 2x2GB RAM kit (G.Skill has one on newegg that's approx. $170).

About the fan question; you will need a fan for the HFS also, the S-Flex fan is an excellent choice in that regard.

How concerned are you about noise? IIRC you still get 3 Tri-Cool fans with the case, while not the quietest fans in the world they will do on set on "low".
 
I haven't upgraded since my Athlon 2700+ which I'm now typing to you on. I'm a hardcore gamer and I somehow skipped an entire generation (the dual cores) and am going all out for my quad core system. I want high end parts but not bleeding edge or stupid extras just to waste money. So that being said for example I'm going with the smart buy of the 8800GT w/ SLI instead of 8800Ultra SLI. I've never overclocked before but considering I've played competitive FPS for a decade and am a game developer myself I feel embarassed that I've not become a part of the hardware side of the hardcore community ;) I'm hoping to achieve 3.4ghz on my OC, but would still be thrilled with 3.2 (newbs can't get greedy right?). There are sooooooo many new chipsets to choose from right now, and so many coming out around the corner. I thought the X38 was my sure choice until I found it out had no SLI :*( Anyways I'd love to hear any comments and thank you for your time! Cya in Crysis, UT3 and TF2 :D

My target budget is $2000-2300 for my PC, not including the monitor.

*Some notes on my needs for my system*
-I will definitely overclock
-Noise is a definite issue as this PC will sit in my bedroom, 6 feet from my bed. I already have my old machine there and I'm used to a soft hum perhaps, but I don't want an airplane in my house 24/7. If I picked any parts that you think are like this, please let me know!
-I will definitely use SLI 8800GT
-I will likely be using raid one day and upgrading to a Penryn sometime down the road
-I really don't know the difference between the vast variety of motherboards out there. I basically picked the one that was rated well on newegg after reading tons of peoples reviews for it on there. Also the one I picked has cool colours LOL. :p Really I want the best mobo for OC'ing so that it will make it easiest on me to OC to my goal of 3.4.
-I'm not sure whether I should be getting a 4gb kit or 2 2gb kits, if it is 4gb kit then do I get 2 x 2gb or 4 x 1gb?
-I need a mid tower case no taller than 21 inches, anything else goes.


So here's what I've come up with so far:

CPU - Intel Q6600 G0 stepping ($280)
Motherboard - EVGA 122-CK-NF68-T1 nForce 680i SLI Motherboard ($200)
Heatsink - Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme ($65)
Ram - 2 x G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 ($80 x 2)
Videocard - 2 x MSI 8800GT OC ($235 x 2)
Soundcard - Creative 70SB046A00000 7.1 Channels 24-bit 192KHz PCI Interface Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series ($145)
Case - Antec P182 Gun Metal Black 0.8mm cold rolled steel ATX Mid Tower ($140)
Case Fans - 3 x 120mm Scythe something, not sure which, also do I need a Scythe for my Ultra 120 extreme, plz help? ($45)
Power Supply - PC Power & Cooling Silencer 750 Quad (Black) EPS12V 750W ($200)
Hard Drive Gaming - 1 x 150gb Raptor 10k RPM 16mb Cache SATA 1.5 ($180)
Hard Drive Storage - 2 x 750gb Hitachi 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA 3.0 ($200 x 2)
Arctic Cooling Paste - Not sure what's good these days, plz help (estimated $10)

Total - $2295


Thanks for taking the time to read my post and critique. I still could use advice on the case fans and arctic cooling stuff as people take them so for granted there is not much discussion on them that I've found. These specs make me drool just looking at them, zomg I can't wait!~ :cool:

~Cooltown

Get the 680i a1 version of the board. It is generally considered the best of the 680i boards and it has a lifetime warranty and I don't think the other one does. I also would not consider sli unless I was using at least 640 mb cards and looking at the price of your cards you may have chosen 320 mb cards. I would rethink that. You could get an 8800 gtx and a good p35 board for about the same price if those are 320 mb cards.
 
Get the 680i a1 version of the board. It is generally considered the best of the 680i boards and it has a lifetime warranty and I don't think the other one does. I also would not consider sli unless I was using at least 640 mb cards and looking at the price of your cards you may have chosen 320 mb cards. I would rethink that. You could get an 8800 gtx and a good p35 board for about the same price if those are 320 mb cards.

It's not the 8800GTS@320, it's the new 65nm 8800GT@512, quite the performer the 8800GT makes the 8800GTS cards more or less obsolete...
 
Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series ($145)
I would just get a music or the std x-fi save a hundred right there.
I have a 180 case and hate it. I want an antec 1200 :)
noise is a little loud on the 180...I even bought all 120's the super quiet low fans new design greatest there is and expensive, BUT I WANTED Q U I E T. NOPE still noisy
case temps went up 5C and cpu went up 3C..hell they suck, no they blow. either way its a dud

but when you put 5 in a case yep they get that way.

paste 5 or ceramic they are about the same. I read reviews on the best being
the new conductive liquid stuff...no damn way I am going to put that stuff on my computer
the reviews said the same thing..well you know they hinted at it as well.

read the few reviews of the 8800GT sli setups....it was double a single in almost all cases and resolutions....MAN YOU LUCKY DOG LOL

what monitor? I want a 24+ but all the people say they are not fast enough for games.
 
I want a 24+ but all the people say they are not fast enough for games.

I have two Dell 2407's and they are plenty fast for games as well as having HDCP..etc. They are great monitors for the price.
 
Couple of points to consider:

With 680i boards, it's generally recommended that you buy 4 gigs of RAM in a 2x2 configuration, as some DIMMS have issues with the 680i memory controller when installed in a 4x1 configuration. That's not to say you won't have success with 4x1 (I do,) but if the cost difference is only $30 or less, it's helpful to stay on the safe side. Besides, going 2x2 now means you can upgrade to 8 gigs more easily if in a few years you think it's necessary. Btw, the A1 and T1 are the same board. The difference is that the A1 is the full retail model, while the T1 is the OEM version. The T1 ships with a two year warranty (versus lifetime on the A1) and less cables. I'd advise you get the A1 for the warranty alone.

As for SLI, most people's standard response (including mine) was to not consider it unless you're prepared to buy two of the fastest cards on the market and can game at a resolution of 1920x1200. The 8800 GT is a very interesting card, and is the first to really qualify this advice in a long time. 8800 GT SLI is an attractive proposition because it gives you substantially more performance than a single 8800 Ultra (under most circumstances) for substantially less money. The cost of SLI remains the same however with the 8800 GT. You'll have a more complex (and potentially warmer running) system and you'll be limited to motherboards supporting SLI technology. The 680i is a great chipset (especially after a mid-life revision which fixed some significant bugs,) but Intel P35 boards are generally known to OC better and can be easier to work with.

8800 GTS SLI is really never worth it, btw, as you're paying more for two GTS cards for a sometimes very slight performance edge over a GTX or Ultra card. SLI should only be considered with GT, GTX, or Ultra cards.

As for getting 4 gigs of RAM, be sure to run a 64-bit OS in order to see it all. Otherwise you'll loose an entire gig of it (if not more) due to the amount of component memory you'll have installed. Remember that 32-bit OSes can see and utilize 4 gigs MINUS the sum of all component memory in your PC. For a 64-bit OS, you're only consideration should be Vista, as XP-64 has significant hardware and software compatibility issues, and very limited (and continuously waning) 3rd party support. XP-64 is useful in limited computing environments, but it's always been more of a tech demo than a full fledged sibling of XP-32.

Consider that if you go Vista, you'll likely have an issue with your Creative X-Fi card, especially since you're planning on 4 gigs. Creative Vista drivers are terrible. The latest driver release (the first in over four months) blue screens on more computers than it fixes issues on others. This is not to say you can't get an X-Fi to work properly with Vista on a high end machine, but it takes work. My solution was to use an older, slightly modified driver that came with a Vista Creative application suite released by a 3rd party (for some reason, Creative still hasn't made these programs available for download.)

The alternative to the Creative card is the Auzentech prelude. It's a complete X-Fi compatible card with much better driver support. It's a bit pricey, but it's worked very well in situations where the X-Fi causes nothing but frustration.

Lastly, it's my opinion that Raptors are loud, overpriced, and very much not worth it. Large platter drives are (of course) larger, cheaper, and nearly as fast. To me it's not as much the cost of the Raptors as it is the huge space sacrifice (and the noise.) Instead of buying Raptors, consider one or two Seagate 750 gigs instead.

Everything else looks good to go. Good luck on your rig!

Mark.
 
Arctic Silver 5 is still fine for a paste, although do remember it takes time to settle in. Artice MX-2 is an option, it susposedly has close or better performance without that burn in period. The power supply is good, though be aware that it is not all that "silent" despite the name. If you want to explore any alternatives, a PSU most people recommend is the corsair 620HX, which is a solid psu, and given the specs of the GT's power use can probably still power out the SLI, and you can find it probably a bit cheaper than the silencer 750w.

The scythe fans are also good if you want to go all out with them replacing all the case fans on the case. They push good air and are rather quiet, you probably want either the SFF21E or SFF21F version. And yes, you will need a fan for the heatsink itself, most thermalrights including the Ultra 120 Extreme do not come with one.

The T1 version of the motherboard has only a 2 year warranty, no paper manual and less cables. It's also generally the best overclocking 680i board. Some people have complained that there is too much thermal paste on the northbridge/southbridge heatsinks, so you may want to redo those if they hold back your overclock.

If you want to shave a little money, you can consider getting the regular p180/p180b version instead of the p182, unless you really like the gunmetal color. The new versions which is what ships out mostly now has the same internal modifications for cable management that the p182 does, at usually a little lower price.

I assume you are gonna carry over a DVD Burner, unless you just forgot. Almost any 30-35 dollar burner that goes 18-20x will do though, Samsung and Lite-On are good brands. Rig looks good overall.
 
extreme just did a review of Tuniq TX-2 High Performance Thermal Compound
might be a little better than AC5...check it out.
 
extreme just did a review of Tuniq TX-2 High Performance Thermal Compound
might be a little better than AC5...check it out.

MX-2 and TX-2 not only sound similar, but they look similar, too! I wonder if they are indeed the same paste, lol. And when I say "look similar," I mean the tubing and actual paste.
 
Thanks all for the awesome feedback.

I will definitely be switching to the A1 version of the motherboard as well as the 2 x 2gb G Skill ram kit.

I definitely love the gun metal colour of the P182, that's why I chose it over the other P180's, you sure read my mind on that one Anchen. :)

Someone asked where I found the 8800GT..it was on froogle.com that I searched for it. Not only was it a GT but one of the factory OC'd ones. Granted these don't really matter to guys like us who were going to OC anyways, perhaps these factory OC cards are the best of the bunch already so it could help to achieve even higher speeds. Here is the link:

http://www.techonweb.com/products/productdetail.aspx?id=A0044K&src=FG

Markyip1, I will be going Vista 64bit just like you recommend. I want the Raptor for much faster loading in games. Hopefully it's not crazy or noticeably loud. I'm not sure how 2 x 750gb 7200rpm drives in raid compare to the speed of a raptor, probably pretty close?

For those wondering, I still have my old LG Flatron F900P CRT monitor and I love it. I won't be changing that for awhile until they make an LCD with absolutely zero ghosting for high speed FPS games like UT3. I can't stand ghosting as a competitive FPS gamer. ;)
 
Two Seagate 750GB drives in RAID 0 will definitely outperform a Raptor. Though I wouldn't try it since that's a lot of storage that can be lost if your mobo or one of the drives decide to die. I recommend going with two Seagate barracude 7200.10 320GB drives in RAID 0 instead. It's cheaper and less storage to lose but is still faster than a single Raptor.
 
I do a lot of disk intensive activity, such as media encoding and archiving, so fast sequential reads/writes is what I need. Therefore, a RAID0 array is better for my situation than a Raptor. However, I do have both, but still prefer a RAID0 array over a Raptor. With or without a RAID array, make sure you have a good backup solution.

Avg Transfer Rate, Access Time: HDD info, Price
78MB/s, 08.2ms: WD Raptor WD1500ADFD 150GB, $160AR
65MB/s, 13.7ms: Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3320620AS 320GB, $80
65MB/s, 13.2ms: Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3300620AS 300GB, $60
52MB/s, 14.0ms: WD Caviar SE16 WD2500KS 250GB, $70
112MB/s, 13.2ms: RAID0 'cuda's, 600GB total, $120 (ICH9R on P35-DS3R)

As you can see, the 'cuda is twice the size and half the cost, for nearly the same transfer speed. Stick them in RAID0, and you've got an even more cost effective solution. Though, the seek time of the Raptor can't be beat. If you have cash to burn, do so on a Raptor if you really want it. Otherwise, there are better cost effective solutions.
 
Does access time not count for anything in game loading? 2 320gb Cuda's is cheaper than a Raptor, supposedly faster from what you posted, and over twice the size. In fact I could afford 3 Cuda's for the price of the Raptor and then use that type of raid where it doubles the speed but also backs up your data one that 3rd drive, correct?

3 Cuda's seems like a powerful solution in raid, along with 2 x 750gb more basic storage drives though, I'm adding up to 5 hard drives. Will that not run quite noisy and hot? I'd like my box to run as cool as possible so I can OC it a decent amount and noise is an issue as the box is in my bedroom and stays on 24/7.

I was also considering using 2 DVD burners instead of one this time around if I had space. With 5 SATA HDs I believe that would only leave me room for 1 DVD burner (I thought the motherboard allowed 6 total SATA connections to it).

Thanks for the speed & stats info on the HDs enginurd and Danny.
 
Ohh by the way, 2 of you guys said that the A1 version of the motherboard comes with a lifetime warranty. I have checked newegg and it indeed says a 1 year warranty on the A1 version. Tigerdirect says lifetime, other sites like buy.com say 1 year warranty. Who knows? lol. I'll still go with the A1 though, comes with a ton of extra cables that I need which that T1 doesn't.
 
this maybe an alternative for soundcard but i would look possibly an audigy 2 zs platinum. not as refined as the x-fi in quality but its performance in vista is considerably better from my experience. and besides you can get the live drive with it also,

i downgraded myself to an audigy for vista&linux suppost since my x-fi isnt very liked by ubuntu and vista. just my 2 cents.
 
Ohh by the way, 2 of you guys said that the A1 version of the motherboard comes with a lifetime warranty. I have checked newegg and it indeed says a 1 year warranty on the A1 version. Tigerdirect says lifetime, other sites like buy.com say 1 year warranty. Who knows? lol. I'll still go with the A1 though, comes with a ton of extra cables that I need which that T1 doesn't.

If you're looking for info on the manufacturer's warranty, why not check the manufacturer's site? While I like Newegg's summary/product info/etc listed for the parts they carry, its often incomplete and/or inaccurate. For this purpose, they have a link to the manufacturer's website for you to click on.

http://www.evga.com/support/lifetime/
# All EVGA Products purchased ON or AFTER November 1, 2006 MUST be registered within 30 days from ORIGINAL DATE OF PURCHASE to receive limited lifetime warranty. (All products not registered within 30 days will ONLY receive a 1 year limited warranty.)

# Limited Lifetime Warranty is for all retail Graphics Card and Mainboard products ending in the part numbers A1, AR, AX, BR*, BX*, DR, DX, FR, FX, SG, SL, or S2.

So, if you forget to register within 30 days, you only get 1yr warranty with an A1 board. If you register within the timeframe, you've got lifetime warranty.
 
Hrm, I did look on the main site for the mobo at the evga site and they didn't even mention anything about warranty there. I did of course find that odd. I figured they just changed their policy from lifetime to 2 years recently and you guys may not have known. Anyways thanks for the info engine!
 
Back
Top