22" LCD for Xbox 360 Gaming

Madwacker

n00b
Joined
Oct 2, 2003
Messages
31
So here's the deal... my Dad games on his new 360 with a 19" SD curved tube TV. He can barely see WTF is going on in the games, menus etc. This weekend I was at a Halo 3 LAN and was gaming on a Dell 22" (no idea what model) and it wasn't bad at all and its something he can afford. Here's my budget and things I care about...you guess can suggest the rest =)

Size: 22"
Widescreen: Yes
Budget: $300 or less
Use: Gaming on the 360 w/ VGA
Angles: Direct or just slightly off to the side, but not way off
Height Adjustments: N/A
Color Quality: Best for my price range

I was looking at the Dell 22" E228WFP and read that it doesn't have lag issues (??) for $269 USD. I also looked at the Acer AL2223Wd. Dell seems to be quite popular, as that is what most of the people were using at the LAN.

thanks
 
The Acer will scale the image to proportion.

My 226BW doesn't and I hate it.
 
go 24"

22" is the cheap/value size

I hate replies like that.

In case you missed the original post his budget is $300, you know of a good 24" for $300 or less? I've got an even better idea, you can give him an extra $200 so he can get a 24" as money doesn't seem to be an issue for you.
 
I hate replies like that.

In case you missed the original post his budget is $300, you know of a good 24" for $300 or less? I've got an even better idea, you can give him an extra $200 so he can get a 24" as money doesn't seem to be an issue for you.

Yep...I hate people that can't read what is plain and simple. I thought I took out any doubt about what I was going for, and he proved me wrong. :rolleyes:

Anyone else? plzthx
 
94 views and 1 decent reply? C'mon guys!

I would love to help you but I really don't know enough about monitors, I did just buy a 24" the other day but it came to $430 after shipping besides I wont get it until Wednesday so I couldn't do much of a review even if you were interested.
 
Hey Grifter_66,

I'm in the market for a 24" panel. What did you end up getting? I'm just curious.... $430 is not a bad price especially after shipping...

Thanks in advance,
Wil

I would love to help you but I really don't know enough about monitors, I did just buy a 24" the other day but it came to $430 after shipping besides I wont get it until Wednesday so I couldn't do much of a review even if you were interested.
 
You might want to check for a nice 20" lcd that isnt a cheap panel like the 22" lcds. I like the BENQ panels and LG models for both sizes, check newegg mucho selection there.
 
You might want to check for a nice 20" lcd that isnt a cheap panel like the 22" lcds. I like the BENQ panels and LG models for both sizes, check newegg mucho selection there.

Further explain to me the "cheap panel" thing that I'll get with 22" LCDs but not 20 or 24
 
Hey Grifter_66,

I'm in the market for a 24" panel. What did you end up getting? I'm just curious.... $430 is not a bad price especially after shipping...

Thanks in advance,
Wil

I ended up getting this Westinghouse unfortunately it seems to be going back up in price but it's still a good deal. I got it mainly because I needed a good monitor but also something that could double for a TV with the appropriate inputs so I can hook my 360 up to it. It doesn't have DVI but I just picked up a HDMI to DVI cable from www.Monoprice.com for like $8 shipped. All the reviews for it seem good and the few negative remarks are about things that really don't matter to me. It should be here tomorrow so I will let you know what I think buy the end of the week.
 
Don't bother with a 20" or 22".

The 360 VGA cable doesn't support 1680 x 1050 as a native resolution, which is the native of the 20 and 22.

The best thing would be to get a screen with either 1920 x 1080 resolution or 1366 x 768. But if you don't mind the scaling then 1680 x 1050 should be OK. I prefer it to be a native resolution.

Also a 22" panel is going to a TN which means although it has good response times the colours aren't that good and looking at them from an angle isn't too good either. TN panels are fine for gaming though as you aren't looking at the colours too much.

This is what I'm buying next week.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824112008&CMP=AFC-C8Junction
 
The Acer will scale the image to proportion.

Interesting!

For 360/PS3 gaming, scaling to proportion is perfect. You don't have to worry about the monitor's 16:10 ratio when playing a console's 16:9 supported resolutions.

Do all Acers scale? Do you have a link so I can read up on this?
 
i'm also in the market for a new monitor for a cheap alternative for hdtv for my 360,and it would be great to get this whole thing done while its off for repair.I have already bought the microsoft vga attachment for it from newegg and am in the market for a 22" i wouldn't really want to spend any more than 260 with tax and exc included on a 22".and no more than 220 on anything less.I would really like to use it as a pc monitor also,and don't have very much money as i am 16 and just built my computer and saving up for car.I am interested in the acer's especially this one http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Acer...72432/catOid/-12965/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do

would that do the automatic scaling,
 
Don't bother with a 20" or 22".

The 360 VGA cable doesn't support 1680 x 1050 as a native resolution, which is the native of the 20 and 22.

The best thing would be to get a screen with either 1920 x 1080 resolution or 1366 x 768. But if you don't mind the scaling then 1680 x 1050 should be OK. I prefer it to be a native resolution.

Also a 22" panel is going to a TN which means although it has good response times the colours aren't that good and looking at them from an angle isn't too good either. TN panels are fine for gaming though as you aren't looking at the colours too much.

This is what I'm buying next week.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824112008&CMP=AFC-C8Junction

Why do LCD makers put speakers on their products? Ugh. So after doing more research...every-freakin-monitor out there it seems is using 16x10 resolution, unless you go 24" and get 19x12. I played on a 20" and it didn't bother me any, and for a low cost solution for right now it'll have to do.

A guy at work here has a Samsung 206BW (16x10) which I really like, as well as the 245BW
 
My monitor was discussed at length months ago, so you can do a little research on it from this forum, but the Samsung 226BW I would have to say is fantastic. Very very crisp image and the size is perfect.

Here's a quick good news bad news:

Downsides:
-VGA cable for Xbox 360 does not support the native resolution
-Xbox also only runs at 16:9, not the monitor's 16:10, so the image is slightly stretched
That being said, both of these technical issues don't seem to bother my vision or keep me from thinking that the image looks great.
-Bad menu system
-Terrible Stand - would even recommend replacing it

Upsides:
-Often on sale at Circuit City or other hardware retailers (If you're lucky, you can find it under $300)
-Both DVI and VGA inputs allow you to have both the PC and Xbox connected at the same time
-Great picture, one of the best out of the 22" selection
-Least amount of light-bleed I've seen/heard about from 22" panels
-2ms Response time is outstanding for gaming - no ghosting

Oh and don't get the Samsung 216BW, its a cheap knock-off model, the quality is far inferior, there's a reason the price-tag is so much cheaper. Again, I'd recommend looking up the thread on this monitor before considering it.
 
well my limit is 250 before tax and shipping,and i also would like the minimal bleeding i can get since i play my 360 mostly at night.

these are some i have picked

acer: 22" http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824009094
acer: 22" http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824009102
samsung: 22" http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824001236
Lg: 20" http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824005096
KDS: 22" http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824155053
 
I browse this site, but never took initiative to register, but for this topic I decided to get an account.

I have the Acer AL2223W 22 inch that I got for 220 (CDN) at my local best buy. It was the cheapest 22 inch screen that they had, and I just bought it because my money flow wasn't going to well.

So far I love it, Sure the 360 doesn't output exactly what the screen resolution it, but I don't notice any weird things when playing, everything looks fine to me. Unless you are a hardcore that looks for things like that, I would recommend this screen. I have the sound going to the monitor too (which really sucks, but it does the job I guess)

Only thing I don't like about this monitor is that there is a little backlight bleeding at the bottom, and also to switch between inputs you have to press like 4 buttons to do it , but that's not THAT big of a deal.

My brother has the Samsung 226bw for his computer, and I hooked up the 360 to it so see what it would be like, and it looks better then it does on the acer, but for the price I like my acer
hope that helps
 
any other responses on those would be appreciated,i am debating that exaxt acer pretty hard i am about to go to the circuit city by me and check out that monitor and the 216bw samsung beside each other.I also want to see if there's a big difference between a 22inch and 20 inch wide cus i really like that lg
 
i had a look at the monitor i was looking at today,and when i saw the acer it looked alright just kinda washed out maybe not enough contrast idk,but i was digging the 216bw 21.6 inch.I think i can raise my budget cus i feel like waiting a bit longer to buy a bigger size i think i wanna spend 450-500.I want you guys to list the best 22" and 24" in that price range.I saw the deal on that westy 24 inch it looked pretty nice i don't think the color changing with my changing my position will really matter though cus it will be used mostly for gaming which the color change won't be to negative.
 
Back
Top