CPU or GPU upgrade for choppy VC-1 Playback?

TurboGLH

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
755
It's been a while since I upgraded, and with the limited upgrade path for my 939/AGP system it'll probably be a while more. But I'm having trouble playing back some media and I might be willing to drop a little $$ even though this system is a dead end to help.

A quick run through:
Opty 144 @ 2.4 (too many systems in one room brings the ambient way up)
1gig pc3200
x850 XT PE


Now, I can play back h264/vc-1 media that's encoded at 1080i with no problems, but I've also got some 1080p material that just seems to choke the shit out of my system. Plays laggy and the audio can't stay sync'd.

I'd rather not dump more money into an AGP card, so the title should really read "Would a dual core cpu help with my choppy playback"
 
You need a dual core CPU which isn't bad since you can get them (even in 939 trim) for a decent price but you might have to look a bit harder for one.
 
I was figuring on a 165 or a 170 with a little bit of water and some ocing thrown at it. I just figured I'd run it by a few people who have some more experience with HD decoding to see if a dual core would be enough to help or if a better video card would be recommended in addition/instead.
 
You need a dual core CPU which isn't bad since you can get them (even in 939 trim) for a decent price but you might have to look a bit harder for one.
He shouldn't need a dual core CPU for VC-1 content.

To the OP, Is your CPU usage at 100% when you're playing VC-1 stuff back?
 
He shouldn't need a dual core CPU for VC-1 content.

To the OP, Is your CPU usage at 100% when you're playing VC-1 stuff back?

100% (97-99%) during playback. It seems that only only thing that I have a real problem with is the vc-1 encoded stuff in 1080p.
 
Without the hardware decoding assist from a GPU, I'd say you'll need at least E6600/X2 6000+, and even then it won't be 100% satisfactory. I'm sorry to say this but I'm afraid that you're out of luck if you were to use the 939/AGP rig for 1080P playback. You really need one of those PCI-E video cards that are built for HD decoding (e.g. 2600XT/8600GT)
 

That thought had crossed my mind, but the 2600pro's aren't supposed to be any faster in gaming than my OC'd x850 xtpe. So the $130 would be spent for the sole purpose of speeding up HD video playback and I can't justify that. At least with a proc upgrade or even if they offered a 2900 or 8800 on AGP it might be worth the $$ dropped to not only allow me to decode the video I want to watch but also give a good bump in game performance.
 
At least with a proc upgrade or even if they offered a 2900 or 8800 on AGP it might be worth the $$ dropped to not only allow me to decode the video I want to watch but also give a good bump in game performance.
The 2900 and 8800 series cards don't do H264/VC-1 decoding in hardware. The only ones that do are the 2400/2600 and 8500/8600 series.

Just pick up a dual core and OC it, you can't really do much more then that with your current system.
 
The 2900 and 8800 series cards don't do H264/VC-1 decoding in hardware. The only ones that do are the 2400/2600 and 8500/8600 series.

Just pick up a dual core and OC it, you can't really do much more then that with your current system.

Well, that's throughly horrrifying. I was under the mistaken impression that at the least the whole 2K series had hardware decoding. At this point in time I'd almost expect it as a feature, especially considering it's available on the low/mid range cards.
 
Go dual core.. it helps out a lot when doing high def content. I mean.. if you are upgrading something, why remain single core? There are so many benefits dual cores bring.
 
Well, that's throughly horrrifying. I was under the mistaken impression that at the least the whole 2K series had hardware decoding. At this point in time I'd almost expect it as a feature, especially considering it's available on the low/mid range cards.
Everyone was. NV never marketed their highend cards such but ATI did, plastering "AVIVO HD" stickers all over them and then they turn around and said that the 2900 series didn't have it. It was a big fiasco when they launched them.
 
Back
Top