AMD Opteron or X2?

nandaman

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 16, 2005
Messages
287
Hey quick question(s). I have an older socket 939 motherboard with 2gb of ddr400, and a X1950GT. I was wondering- Should I get an Opteron 165 or is the X2 4200 good enough? I don't know about the different L2 cache levels. I don't play very many games but CS:S and C&C 3. I am looking to buy Crysis when it comes out, but if I want to run everything on high then I have to upgrade everything. I am looking to overclock one of these processors to somewhere around 2.6-2.7. Do you think the X2 is good enough or should I spend the extra 25-30 bucks for the Opteron. Please respond, I need your help. Thanks in advance!
 
The cache makes very little difference in games which is why I bought a 4200+ Toledo S939 chip.
It clocks nicely to 2.8GHz with a cheap tower cooler.
 
Opteron would be a better choice (newer steppings I believe) but would come at a premium, im trying to work in this new oem 4200+ x2 I got from newegg, I still haven't gotten my ultra 90, 2.6 seems easy at almost stock voltage and stock cooling, but I think my OS acting up and giving me problems.

Also, does anyone know if new 4200s can be unlidded, I know 939s could be unlidded, then AM2 came out, some of those could be unlidded, but when they moved from 2001 to 2005 they sodered the cores on.

Mine says "diffused in germany, assembled in malaysia" but it says 2001 on it. I'm wondering if anyone has tried it on a week 714 or later chip?
 
Also, does anyone know if new 4200s can be unlidded, I know 939s could be unlidded, then AM2 came out, some of those could be unlidded, but when they moved from 2001 to 2005 they sodered the cores on.

Hmm interesting, I havent heard of any lid being soldered on before!
I would expect the cores to be attached so they cant be removed though. Perhaps you meant the lids attachment to the core?
 
Hmm interesting, I haven't heard of any lid being soldered on before!
I would expect the cores to be attached so they cant be removed though. Perhaps you meant the lids attachment to the core?

Yes, As I said, I know most (not all) AM2s are have adhesive / sodered the IHS to the core so you can't remove w/o fuckin shit up, I know 939 and AM2 production overlapped, so thats just why im wondering.
 
I'm currently deciding between an Opteron 180 (Denmark) and an X2 4800+ (sk939's).

Both are 2.4Ghz and have 1024 caches. What I'm unsure about is:
--the Opteron lists a 1000MHz HT, but no "system bus speed"
--the X2 lists a 2000Mhz "system bus speed", but no HT spec.

Since HT is the bus to the northbridge, are these two different names for the same thing?
Or do X2's and Opterons run the same HT speed?
 
I think they're architecturally identical, except that the Opteron has been manufactured with far more overhead/redundancy. For overclocking, Opteron every time as it's not on the limit at stock speeds and voltages. If not clocking, then it's your call.

Please correct me if I've made a mistake.
 
I'm currently deciding between an Opteron 180 (Denmark) and an X2 4800+ (sk939's).

Both are 2.4Ghz and have 1024 caches. What I'm unsure about is:
--the Opteron lists a 1000MHz HT, but no "system bus speed"
--the X2 lists a 2000Mhz "system bus speed", but no HT spec.

Since HT is the bus to the northbridge, are these two different names for the same thing?
Or do X2's and Opterons run the same HT speed?


The opteron 180 would be better (if your buying both of them new) since that they stopped making 4800+s before they stopped making 180s (if they have stopped yet), so their steppings are newer, and AMD is usually pretty consistent with making improvements to the core as time goes by (in the sense of overclocking).

The second one is really a misnomer. The processor connects to the northbrige and pciE bus and memory over a series of HTT links, these links are run at 1000Mhz, and are bi directional (so you can double the number). Its mildly confusing, but their is nothing structurally different between cpu's.

I got a 4200+ recently, and ive been able to keep it around 50c at 2800mhz @ 1.34v (pretty low), thats with my stock (4 heatpipe, the good one) heatsink. I'm getting an utlra 90 on monday, so I should see a bit of an improvment in temps, and I really haven't tried to dial down the overclock yet, I just got it game stable, and im sure it can go higher.
Its a week 714 chip so its pretty recent.
 
Clock speed offers more performance than cache size. I'd go with the Opteron if you don't plan on buying an aftermarket cooler. If you do, go with the X2. Also, keep in mind Opterons typically have a higher fault tolerance, since they're server-grade chips.
 
Hey.. instead of just making a new thread ill post in this one.

I have an AMD 64 3500+ on my A8N Deluxe motherboard.

I need to know the differences between the 3500+, Opteron 185 and 165.

185 is a tad expensive, but will the 165 improve my system enough ?

and how does a 185 compare in performance to the X2 6000?
 
Hey.. instead of just making a new thread ill post in this one.

I have an AMD 64 3500+ on my A8N Deluxe motherboard.

I need to know the differences between the 3500+, Opteron 185 and 165.

185 is a tad expensive, but will the 165 improve my system enough ?

and how does a 185 compare in performance to the X2 6000?

O about 400mhz of difference.
 
lol. If you want to OC, get the X2 4200+ OEM and push it to 2.8Ghz or higher for only <$70. The Opteron's aren't really worth their price premium now, especially since the 939 platform is dead. If you need a good cooler to OC, get the Arctic Cooling Freezer 64 Pro for only $20.

http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu_2007.html
 
If I was to get a Opty 170 for $80 would that be recommended over the 4200?

Heh, thats a tossup to me. The Opteron is a server class chip that requires less voltage, runs cooler, and can probably OC higher... and it has a 2x1MB cache; Oh, and it has a great stock HSF (4-heatpipes!). The X2 had a higher multiplier so its easier to OC. Well, it looks like the Opteron is the winner. Go for it, since its only $10 more. Make sure you get the stock HSF with it (retail box).
 
FWIW i went from a 4400+ to an opty 185 and the difference was night and day, really.

if you can get ahold of a 185, go for it:)
 
For everyone who's been asking this question, here are some hard numbers for ya.

Test date: 29-OCT-2007

My test set-up was as follows:
Soltek K8TPRO-939
AMD stock heatsink
1 Gb Ultra DDR400 ( 2 x 512 running dual-channel mode )
ATI FireGL X3-256 AGP
Windows Vista Ultimate

All CPU's were run at stock speed, stock voltages, no o'c, and no C&Q.

Athlon 64 3000+ (1.8GHz, 512Kb L2)
Passmark = 378.4
Super_Pi = 48.312s @ 100% cpu load

Athlon 64 3700+ (2.2GHz, 1Mb L2)
Passmark = 465.7
Super_Pi = 39.062s @ 100% cpu load

Athlon X2 4800+ (2.4GHz, dual 1Mb L2)
Passmark = 538.8
Super_Pi = 36.578s @ ~60% cpu load

Opteron 185 (2.6GHz, dual 1Mb L2)
Passmark = 564.2
Super_Pi = 33.360s @ ~55% cpu load

Keep in mind that these numbers don't account for dual-core advantages toward multi-tasking. Also, these results would be more revealing if I had an X2 with the 512Mb L2's.
But, for me, this still kinda put the performance increases into perspective.
 
For everyone who's been asking this question, here are some hard numbers for ya.

Opteron 185
Passmark = 564.2
Super_Pi = 33.360s @ ~55% cpu load

I'm guessing these CPUs are at stock speed? Because my Opteron 165 @ 2.6Ghz gets 33s for Super Pi 1M. I'll see what time I get with it cranked up to 3Ghz when I get time to swap in a better cooler (3Ghz gets too hot with the stock cooler :( ).
 
For everyone who's been asking this question, here are some hard numbers for ya.

Test date: 29-OCT-2007

My test set-up was as follows:
Soltek K8TPRO-939
AMD stock heatsink
1 Gb Ultra DDR400 ( 2 x 512 running dual-channel mode )
ATI FireGL X3-256 AGP
Windows Vista Ultimate

All CPU's were run at stock speed, stock voltages, no o'c, and no C&Q.

Athlon 64 3000+
Passmark = 378.4
Super_Pi = 48.312s @ 100% cpu load

Athlon 64 3700+
Passmark = 465.7
Super_Pi = 39.062s @ 100% cpu load

Athlon X2 4800+
Passmark = 538.8
Super_Pi = 36.578s @ ~60% cpu load

Opteron 185
Passmark = 564.2
Super_Pi = 33.360s @ ~55% cpu load

Also, keep in mind that these numbers don't account for dual-core advantages toward multi-tasking. But, for me, this kinda put the performance increases into perspective.

Nice! Thanks, it's a 185 for me!
 
Nice! Thanks, it's a 185 for me!

Used or new? If new, I wouldn't pay that much for a s939 CPU, especially since it can only reach around 3Ghz -- same as an X2 4200+ Toledo OEM, for much less money. Despite the larger cache, the 4200+ will still perform similarly for less money. If you're getting it used, keep the price of the OEM 4200+ in mind. Clock speed matters more than cache size with these chips.
 
Used or new? If new, I wouldn't pay that much for a s939 CPU, especially since it can only reach around 3Ghz -- same as an X2 4200+ Toledo OEM, for much less money. Despite the larger cache, the 4200+ will still perform similarly for less money. If you're getting it used, keep the price of the OEM 4200+ in mind. Clock speed matters more than cache size with these chips.

Thanks for the info.


Mike
 
Back
Top