R600 doesn't do AF in DX10?

Its not being thin skinned. Its the ignorance of someone that thinks the 2900XT cant do AF in any DX10 game, because of a post from nvnews. Hes obviously partial towards one company.

Going the extent of calling ATi cheating for this, is laughable. Yeah, they left out AF on purpose! Please, use some common sense. The issue has been fixed, but the poster couldnt be bothered to do some research about that.

It's not just because of a post genius. I know for a fact that it can't do it in any game in any driver up to 7.7. What would you think if NVIDIA decided to disable AF in their code for a few driver versions? You'd think it was a lame attempt to inflate their benchmarks.

How would you feel if a part of the featureset was QUIETLY not working, even when turned on for any card that just came out. Obviously they knew a lot of reviews would be done on it, and they inform reviewers prior to most reviews what to look for. They never mentioned this fact, and let reviewers post reviews basically showing them getting 16x AF for free. They only fix it after most reviews of the product are done. I'd call that a scam.
 
It's not just because of a post genius.

Then dont say it as if its all DX10 games. "R600 doesn't do AF in DX10?" sure makes it sound like its all DX10 games. Either you're ignorant, or just trying to make it sound like its something its not, and have an agenda.

I know for a fact that it can't do it in any game in any driver up to 7.7.

Then why not say that? Dont act as if ATi did this on purpose to inflate benchmarks. I also know for a fact it works fine on XP, which all reviews that I have seen used, and most people still use.

What would you think if NVIDIA decided to disable AF in their code for a few driver versions? You'd think it was a lame attempt to inflate their benchmarks.

First off, ATi didnt "decide to disable AF". Its called a bug. And no I wouldnt think NV tried to inflate their numbers, just like I dont think NV would disable AF. Its silly to think so.

How would you feel if a part of the featureset was QUIETLY not working, even when turned on for any card that just came out. Obviously they knew a lot of reviews would be done on it, and they inform reviewers prior to most reviews what to look for. They never mentioned this fact, and let reviewers post reviews basically showing them getting 16x AF for free. They only fix it after most reviews of the product are done. I'd call that a scam.

Your problem is you think ATi did this to gain numbers in a game. Again, thats silly. There is no timedemo, and if reviewers missed it, its on them. Most reviews were done in XP anyways, not Vista. So AF was working for them. Its not some scam ATi pulled, but your bias wont let you see that. In fact, a quick search shows [H], FS and Anand all used XP. Making your claim of ATi "scamming" look pretty silly. Go ahead and find all the reviews that used Vista only, and not XP to benchmark when the 2900XT came out. Then find out how many used XP only. Then come back and talk about how many people got "scammed".

There were plenty of problems for the 8800's and Vista. Lots and lots of huge problems. You could call their lack of working drivers, yet their claim of support for Vista a scam. Among other problems. By your logic, that seems fair. I dont see it that way, but it fits your way of thinking.
 
Except most reviewers were saying that the 2900 performs better in Vista than XP, when apparently there was a bug preventing AF from working. Like it or not, it DID inflate scores in favor of the 2900XT.

[H] noticed it in the latest review of Lost Planet:

There is one problem that we experience with the ATI Radeon HD 2900 XT you need to be aware of. With Catalyst 7.7 we found that the Radeon HD 2900 XT in Lost Planet was not rendering Anisotropic filtering at all. For the life of us we could not get it working, whether forced from the game or the control panel, it did not work in DX9 or DX10 mode at all. The fix was to use the yet-to-be released Catalyst 7.8 drivers provided to us by ATI. This new driver to be released in August will fix the broken AF in Lost Planet.
 
Except most reviewers were saying that the 2900 performs better in Vista than XP, when apparently there was a bug preventing AF from working. Like it or not, it DID inflate scores in favor of the 2900XT.

[H] noticed it in the latest review of Lost Planet:

AF works in Oblivion, if the HD2900XT was going to get completely destroyed under Vista by the 8800GTS that would be the game.

I have played alot of games on the 2900 and LP and CoJ have been the only ones that I have found that I could not force AF in the CCC with. Not that with out a microscope you could see that LP isnt appling AF anyways. The way AMDati fixed bugs are by priortity and I am guessing not alot of people submitted tickets over the issue.

The constant look to find AMD doing something shady or underhanded has become nothing more then embarrassing for someone that has visited the forum for a long time. It has gotten so bad I wouldnt even recommend anyone to come visit the [H] if they were looking for help with a AMD system. Not really sure what AMD did to piss off everyone around here, as it almost feels like I am in one of Microsofts Viral Marketing Sites for Halo 3.
 
Except most reviewers were saying that the 2900 performs better in Vista than XP, when apparently there was a bug preventing AF from working. Like it or not, it DID inflate scores in favor of the 2900XT.

[H] noticed it in the latest review of Lost Planet:

Except most reviewers used XP for their reviews. Vista faster than XP? Hardly. If anything, XP faster than Vista. [H] has had articles showing just this. Like it or not, reviews done in XP (aka most if not all) didnt inflate anything, because AF was working fine.

And as mentioned, its fixed in a beta driver. So its moot now anyway. You want it fixed? DL the beta driver. Wait... you dont have a 2900XT.
 
Come on Sr7, take a chill pill. I can see the veins popping out your forehead.
 
The constant look to find AMD doing something shady or underhanded has become nothing more then embarrassing for someone that has visited the forum for a long time. It has gotten so bad I wouldnt even recommend anyone to come visit the [H] if they were looking for help with a AMD system. Not really sure what AMD did to piss off everyone around here, as it almost feels like I am in one of Microsofts Viral Marketing Sites for Halo 3.

People just call it as they see it. If nvidia cards have problems threads are made as well.

Except most reviewers used XP for their reviews. Vista faster than XP? Hardly. If anything, XP faster than Vista. [H] has had articles showing just this. Like it or not, reviews done in XP (aka most if not all) didnt inflate anything, because AF was working fine.

I guess you missed the whole part in this thread where we were talking about VISTA and DX10 games where the bug was occurring...

Look at the CoJ DX10 reviews, notice how the 2900 was apparently doing better?
 
I guess you missed the whole part in this thread where we were talking about VISTA and DX10 games where the bug was occurring...

Look at the CoJ DX10 reviews, notice how the 2900 was apparently doing better?

Its CoJ who cares, what all of 10 people bought the game in the US, besides nobody has mentioned CoJ anywhere for a very long time. And if a reviewer was unable to see the differnce between no AF and 16AF on the ground textures in CoJ, then why are you reading their review anyways.

Most reviewers have just used the DX10 benchmark instead of actual ingame performance.

The bug effected 3 games, big woppty doo. Even though people want those three to decided the fate of DX10 for both card companies.
 
Then dont say it as if its all DX10 games. "R600 doesn't do AF in DX10?" sure makes it sound like its all DX10 games. Either you're ignorant, or just trying to make it sound like its something its not, and have an agenda.



Then why not say that? Dont act as if ATi did this on purpose to inflate benchmarks. I also know for a fact it works fine on XP, which all reviews that I have seen used, and most people still use.



First off, ATi didnt "decide to disable AF". Its called a bug. And no I wouldnt think NV tried to inflate their numbers, just like I dont think NV would disable AF. Its silly to think so.



Your problem is you think ATi did this to gain numbers in a game. Again, thats silly. There is no timedemo, and if reviewers missed it, its on them. Most reviews were done in XP anyways, not Vista. So AF was working for them. Its not some scam ATi pulled, but your bias wont let you see that. In fact, a quick search shows [H], FS and Anand all used XP. Making your claim of ATi "scamming" look pretty silly. Go ahead and find all the reviews that used Vista only, and not XP to benchmark when the 2900XT came out. Then find out how many used XP only. Then come back and talk about how many people got "scammed".

There were plenty of problems for the 8800's and Vista. Lots and lots of huge problems. You could call their lack of working drivers, yet their claim of support for Vista a scam. Among other problems. By your logic, that seems fair. I dont see it that way, but it fits your way of thinking.

IT IS in ALL DX10 GAMES MORON.

I was saying that I'm not just saying it because of 1 lone post.. it's because it's FACT that it hasn't done AF in DX10 in any of the DX10 games. Learn to read guy.

Way to equivocate two totally different issues. Frank reads on the internet, and thinks OH GEE John has a problem with his 8800... better steer clear. Simultaneously, Joe sees OH GEE R600 scores well in reviews (partially due to AF not working, while 8800 is taking the performance hit).. better go buy one!

One issue artificially assists the brand make sales. The other only takes away from the likelihood of the product selling. Can you tell them apart guy?

It is ATI's responsibility to inform reviewers what they need to know to accurately bench their product. Even if it WAS a bug... did they lie? No. They misled by what they DIDN'T tell reviewers. So if you guys would understand this, the point is even if ATI was not being malicious with this by doing it intentionally, they had plenty of chances to clear it up prior to it being "found out" by a third party.
 
AF works in Oblivion, if the HD2900XT was going to get completely destroyed under Vista by the 8800GTS that would be the game.

I have played alot of games on the 2900 and LP and CoJ have been the only ones that I have found that I could not force AF in the CCC with. Not that with out a microscope you could see that LP isnt appling AF anyways. The way AMDati fixed bugs are by priortity and I am guessing not alot of people submitted tickets over the issue.

The constant look to find AMD doing something shady or underhanded has become nothing more then embarrassing for someone that has visited the forum for a long time. It has gotten so bad I wouldnt even recommend anyone to come visit the [H] if they were looking for help with a AMD system. Not really sure what AMD did to piss off everyone around here, as it almost feels like I am in one of Microsofts Viral Marketing Sites for Halo 3.

Way to read the thread... this isa a DX10 only issue. Oblivion, my friend, is not DX10.

And if you can't tell AF apart from no AF, you must be blind.
 
Way to read the thread... this isa a DX10 only issue. Oblivion, my friend, is not DX10.

And if you can't tell AF apart from no AF, you must be blind.

As I see you cant read either, I already posted that I knew about it when CoJ first came out.

And I was responding the this generalized statement
Except most reviewers were saying that the 2900 performs better in Vista than XP, when apparently there was a bug preventing AF from working. Like it or not, it DID inflate scores in favor of the 2900XT.
 
Dang, I just get back after missing this thread for a day and ya'll are still beating that poor dead horse! The nag is glue already, guys.
 
Back
Top