Alchemy for Audigy, Vista

well, I am sure you are aware of the issues invovled and will agree it is not exactly a hot-fix only from XP to Vista. I am not sure whether I like the $$$ idea, either. Then again, we all buy upgrades for all sorts of stuff like Nero, Photoshop, etc, etc.. only to have our perfectly valid XP software running on Vista, for example - and I don't hear much complaining about that, either. Maybe it is because people view it more natural / as a given that hardware is simply suppoded to "just work". I think 10 $ is better spent on that driver than 50-70 on a new cheapo card without EAX.
 
They can get fvcked if they think I'm paying for what is essentially a goddamn driver. It's up on torrent so I shall be obtaining it from there.

And a big FVCK YOU to Creative Labs. :rolleyes:
 
I can see where they are comming from when they charge for the drivers, I dont like it but i understand. I'm pretty sure it does not say "compatible with all upcomming versions of windows" on the box.
 
I'm sorry, that is total bulls*** on the part of CL's.

- They still promote/sell the Audigy 4 on their website
- They state the Audigy 4 is compatible with Vista
- They charge the customer for a currently shipping product (Audigy 4) the Alchemy "upgrade"

It amazes me how some people try to defend CL. "It works on my system, so it must be a user problem, not CL's". Total BS. If a product works on only half the systems out there, it is a the company's problem. Just peruse the Vista forum over at CL's. If it wasn't so tragic, it would almost be funny.

Slightly changing the subject, what I do not understand is why the X-Meridian is being discontinued. From what I read here, it is just about the nicest soundcard (w/o EAX) that you can get. Auzen has not "discontinued" the X-Plosion. I think Auzen is shooting themselves in the foot, if they really think the Prelude is going to sell like hotcakes, given CL's reputation for drivers, now and in the past.
 
What functionality (besides lack of EAX in DirectSound games) are the drivers lacking?
 
I have an Audigy 2 ZS gathering dust, not the 4. I mentioned the 4, simply because it is on the CL website as a currently shipping product. Both cards use the same drivers from mid-March.

Anyway, my Audigy gave me 2-channel "tinny"sound, VERY basic drivers, and NOTHING to tweak the sound card settings.

My Realtek on-board sounds better in Vista than the 2 ZS, has fully functional drivers, and "tweaking" utilities, etc.

Quite frankly, I really do not miss EAX. It would be nice to have back, but I would simply rather have a card that I can use with my 5.1 speakers.

In the end, the problem with CL is proprietary HW and features. Most computer companies have learned that proprietary offerings are no longer welcomed by the consumer. Dell, for example. Companies compete on features and value in this age.

CL still tries to compete with proprietary HW. MS has been moving consistently away from allowing components to bypass the operating system. In DOS, everything bypassed the OS. Finally, in Vista (like it or not), not much of anything bypasses the OS. IOW, CL needed to "wake up and smell the roses" ALONG time ago.
 
The current state of the drivers have none of the issues you described (outside of the lack EAX in DirectSound games, obviously that can't be fixed at a driver level).

I don't get your problem. They have fully functional drivers for Vista (maybe not by your standards, but by Microsoft's standards). They developed an add on program that enhances the user's experience with Vista. They charge some users for that program, just like Nvidia charges for the PureVideo codecs. ALchemy is extra; Creative can sell it any way they want.
 
The current state of the drivers have none of the issues you described (outside of the lack EAX in DirectSound games, obviously that can't be fixed at a driver level).

I don't get your problem. They have fully functional drivers for Vista (maybe not by your standards, but by Microsoft's standards). They developed an add on program that enhances the user's experience with Vista. They charge some users for that program, just like Nvidia charges for the PureVideo codecs. ALchemy is extra; Creative can sell it any way they want.

I assume you are using a X-fi? I *believe* the driver situation has improved. But that is just plain BS if you say "current state of the drivers have none of the issues you described" regarding Audigy. Unless you take the X-fi drivers and force them to install on an Audigy card, which you can do. Which just goes to show that CL is holding back. They have made a very concious decision to provide minimal "offcial" support of the Audigy.

And I am sorry, but since when did you know what Microsoft's standards are? Got a link for that statement? WHQL has nothing to do with standards of quality. Ever hear of ISO 9000? The standard is not a quality standard. You can make the same crappy product, as long as you can document how you do it.:rolleyes:

To a corporation, the only measure of success they have is sales and associated profits. I no longer plan to ever purchase a CL product. From that perspective, and of many others, CL's measure of success will have to become lower. I guess they do not care. Go figure.

So in the end, I think we should agree to disagree, and leave it at that.:)
 
I assume you are using a X-fi? I *believe* the driver situation has improved. But that is just plain BS if you say "current state of the drivers have none of the issues you described" regarding Audigy. Unless you take the X-fi drivers and force them to install on an Audigy card, which you can do. Which just goes to show that CL is holding back. They have made a very concious decision to provide minimal "offcial" support of the Audigy.

And I am sorry, but since when did you know what Microsoft's standards are? Got a link for that statement? WHQL has nothing to do with standards of quality. Ever hear of ISO 9000? The standard is not a quality standard. You can make the same crappy product, as long as you can document how you do it.

To a corporation, the only measure of success they have is sales and associated profits. I no longer plan to ever purchase a CL product. From that perspective, and of many others, CL's measure of success will have to become lower. I guess they do not care. Go figure.

So in the end, I think we should agree to disagree, and leave it at that.

Please describe to me how they offer "minimal" support? They've released several drivers for the Audigy this year. M-Audio sound cards don't even have any drivers for Vista x64. Clearly you and I have different opinions on what minimal means.

Microsoft makes the O/S, they set the standards in which an audio device must meet to function properly. The Audigy drivers meet this requirement. If you don't like the standards Microsoft sets (see removal of the HAL for DirectSound), then direct your anger against them.
 
I am hardly "angry", as you imply. Just very dissapointed in a company that does seem to want to support their products (my opinion).

If I remember correctly, their only released (as in not BETA) Audigy drivers were released on March 9th and repackaged again (same drivers) on March 16th. This hardly qualifies as "several drivers this year". Maybe you refer to all the "hacked" versions that supposedly work better than the "real" ones.

It is obvious to me that we also disagree on Microsoft's role in this. Perhaps you are angry at MS?:p

Anyway, like I said before: "So in the end, I think we should agree to disagree, and leave it at that.:)".

OK? End of thread as far as I am concerned.
 
I am hardly "angry", as you imply. Just very dissapointed in a company that does seem to want to support their products (my opinion).

Fine, replace angry with disappointed in my previous post.

If I remember correctly, their only released (as in not BETA) Audigy drivers were released on March 9th and repackaged again (same drivers) on March 16th. This hardly qualifies as "several drivers this year". Maybe you refer to all the "hacked" versions that supposedly work better than the "real" ones.

You don't remember correctly. There was at least a beta in January, one in March, and the latest one from two weeks ago.


It is obvious to me that we also disagree on Microsoft's role in this.

How can one argue the role Microsoft plays? They're the ones who removed the HAL from DirectSound and changed around the audio stack in Vista.

Perhaps you are angry at MS?:p

Nope. I don't have a problem with what Microsoft did, for it does not effect me as a Vista user.
 
Supported Games In This Build:

· Baldur's Gate 2
· Battle for Middle Earth 2
· Battlefield Vietnam
· C&C Generals
· Call of Duty
· Call of Duty 2
· Chronicles of Riddick
· Diablo 2
· Dungeon Siege
· Everquest 2
· F.E.A.R.
· Far Cry
· Full Spectrum Warrior*
· Full Spectrum Warrior: Ten Hammers*
· Grand Theft Auto 3
· Grand Theft Auto Vice City
· GTA San Andreas
· Guild Wars
· Hitman 2 Silent Assassin
· Hitman Blood Money
· Knights of the Old Republic 2
· Max Payne 2
· MDK2
· Medieval II: Total War
· Neverwinter Nights
· Neverwinter Nights 2
· No One Lives Forever 2 A Spy in H.A.R.M.'s Way
· Oblivion
· Rome: Total War
· Serious Sam 2
· Serious Sam First Encounter
· Serious Sam Second Encounter
· Star Wars Empire at War
· Thief: Deadly Shadows
· Titan Quest
· Tomb Raider: Angel Of Darkness
· TRON 2.0
· Warcraft III
· World of Warcraft
 
Back
Top