ATI x850XT vs. 8600GT

not1germ

n00b
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
49
I have an ATI x850XT 512, I am thinking about a nVidia 8600GT.

I found these on Newegg:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130091
EVGA

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814150238
Fatal1ty

Both are about the same price, the Fatal1ty seems to have a higher factory overclock and faster memory.

I really like the heatpipe cooler on the Fatal1ty 8600GT, and I have 3 other Fatal1ty products which are great (mouse quality could be a little more robust), so that is my preference for the cards.

How much faster are these 8600GT over my ATI x850XT?

Any opinion on these 2 cards?

Any OC's on the Fatal1ty 8600GT with the Heatpipe - how much of an overclock can it take?
 
A LOT SLOWER compared to your x850xt 512mb card. A LOT SLOWER
 
The 8600GT's performance wise are roughly close to a 7600GT, but a little better i believe.
 
Save your money for atleast an 8800gts. Why are you going from the king of one generation of cards to the retard nephew of this generation? :confused:
 
ROFLCOPTERS

No.


You guys are terribly misinformed =P

I wouldn't say "terribly" misinformed. In most applications, the 8600GT definitely will be slower (although I wouldn't say MUCH slower). It has MUCH lower memory bandwidth, substantially lower pixel fillrate, and roughly equal texture fillrate. The only thing the 8600GT pulls ahead on is shader operations - which, to be fair, it does dominate - but name me one game that is genuinely shader-limited today.
 
ROFLCOPTERS

No.


You guys are terribly misinformed =P

LOL yeah I was misinformed, read the anandtech review and it showed it being a tad bit slower here and there compared to the 7600gt.. and faster in some games. But not worth the "upgrade" from a X850XT for the op... go 8600GTS at least but preferably 8800gts.
 
The 8600 GT is not slower, and certainly not much slower than the X850 XT. Analyses based on memory bandwidth and fillrate do not give meaningful predictions of game performance anymore. In any case, an 8600 GT would not be a "Wow" upgrade, and I doubt you'd feel it was money well spent unless you were only expecting a moderate increase.
 
The 8600 GT is not slower, and certainly not much slower than the X850 XT. Analyses based on memory bandwidth and fillrate do not give meaningful predictions of game performance anymore. In any case, an 8600 GT would not be a "Wow" upgrade, and I doubt you'd feel it was money well spent unless you were only expecting a moderate increase.


Truth. I've owned a x850, a 7600gt and an 8600gt. The 8600gt is deffinately faster than both. However the 8800gt blows them all away by a considerable margin (quite close though at the stock 540MHz, but I'd give the nod to the 8600 especially in recent games) . I wouldn't go to a 8600gt from a x850 though.

LOL yeah I was misinformed, read the anandtech review and it showed it being a tad bit slower here and there compared to the 7600gt.. and faster in some games. But not worth the "upgrade" from a X850XT for the op... go 8600GTS at least but preferably 8800gts.
Reply With Quote

what it was clocked at what? 540MHz stock? Mine does 740 (albeit on water but still, I've seen 800 voltmodded on air). The 8600gt is by far one of the best overclocking cards I've owned, how high they overclock is what makes them worth owning IMO.
 
8600 series cards are severely crippled when compared with 8800 series, even the 8800 GTS, and even moreso compared with the 8800 GTX. If you intend to game I would not recommend one. Save up for an 8800 GTS, as others have recommended.
 
When the 8600 GTS debuted, it was priced at around $220 with the 8800 GTS 320 more like $270. This made the 8800 a no-brainer. But now it's a little different, with 8600 GTS's available for about $160 and GT's as low as $110, while the 8800 GTS 320 is still at the same price it was before. These are very different price segments, and now it's not such a no-brainer anymore. Of course a better card is always a better experience, but not everyone is willing or able to blow an extra $100+, especially if they can save even more because the rest of their system doesn't have to be up to the level of an 8800 GTS. The 8600 GT and GTS are maligned viciously and frequently around here, but while they're not the card the 7600 and 6600 GT's were, they're still not half bad for the price.
 
When the 8600 GTS debuted, it was priced at around $220 with the 8800 GTS 320 more like $270. This made the 8800 a no-brainer. But now it's a little different, with 8600 GTS's available for about $160 and GT's as low as $110, while the 8800 GTS 320 is still at the same price it was before. These are very different price segments, and now it's not such a no-brainer anymore. Of course a better card is always a better experience, but not everyone is willing or able to blow an extra $100+, especially if they can save even more because the rest of their system doesn't have to be up to the level of an 8800 GTS. The 8600 GT and GTS are maligned viciously and frequently around here, but while they're not the card the 7600 and 6600 GT's were, they're still not half bad for the price.

hmm, $160 makes the GTS a pretty nice card, and 110 for a GT is damn nice as well, considering most will clock pretty close to GTS clocks.

If only prices in holland would come down as well, they cost 185/140 for the cheapest ones i can find, 110 puts you square in the 8500GT range over here.

Still, i wouldnt consider one, as my 8800GTS is damn nice, but a 8600GT makes a nice card for a secondary machine (or perhaps a secondary card for CUDA devellopment)
 
Wow, lots of food for thought here.

I am thinking that I will get the Fatal1ty 8600GT and use it to build a silent light gaming system for my sister.

For my own machine, I will wait some more to see what ATI comes out with in the few months.
 
Truth. I've owned a x850, a 7600gt and an 8600gt. The 8600gt is deffinately faster than both. However the 8800gt blows them all away by a considerable margin (quite close though at the stock 540MHz, but I'd give the nod to the 8600 especially in recent games) . I wouldn't go to a 8600gt from a x850 though.



what it was clocked at what? 540MHz stock? Mine does 740 (albeit on water but still, I've seen 800 voltmodded on air). The 8600gt is by far one of the best overclocking cards I've owned, how high they overclock is what makes them worth owning IMO.


VRZone had their Inno3D over 900mhz, and a Palit over 1ghz...both on air. (1020/955 actually)

My leadtek maxes out (not stable), without volt mods, at 737/919. im hoping to be able to get it at least to this after a few pencil strokes (if only i could find someone who has voltmodded a card with the same PCB as mine), but given the clocks obtained in that review and elsewhere, im hoping to push the core at least into the 800's.That'd still put the core a good 200mhz slower than they were able to obtain on the Palit, but hey, what do you want from aircooling and at that price.
 
VRZone had their Inno3D over 900mhz, and a Palit over 1ghz...both on air. (1020/955 actually)

My leadtek maxes out (not stable), without volt mods, at 737/919. im hoping to be able to get it at least to this after a few pencil strokes (if only i could find someone who has voltmodded a card with the same PCB as mine), but given the clocks obtained in that review and elsewhere, im hoping to push the core at least into the 800's.That'd still put the core a good 200mhz slower than they were able to obtain on the Palit, but hey, what do you want from aircooling and at that price.

Exactly. I'm willing to bet you could get into the 900's ;) Mine also does around 740 stable, but only if its at less than 40c, otherwise it's around 730MHz.
 
One thing that the 8600GT will smoke the 7XXX series and the 850 in is HD decoding.

The 850XT was designed as a hardcore gaming card, while the 8600GT is meant to be for casual gaming, 1080p content, and Vista use.
 
Back
Top