A guide to understanding wide gamut displays

Rembrandt

Gawd
Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Messages
596
Folks, understanding wide gamut displays is fairly simple.

Wide gamut monitors have nothing to do with Adobe or its spectrum. Adobe has their own limited spectrum of color in the full color spectrum.

The sRGB color spectrum is a smaller spectrum than the color spectrum than what Adobe is capable of and sRGB is the industry standard spectrum used in program development and web programs. It is a minimum world wide standard. If you did not know, “s” stands for standard.

Wide gamut monitor manufactures refer to the Adobe gamut, as a comparison, to what the monitor will show in the color spectrum. The panel in the monitor has no idea what an Adobe aRGB is and it does not conform to the boundaries of the aRGB color spectrum.

By using a new tube system in the back of a LCD panel, the panel is now capable of seeing more colors that was already there in the panel but could not be seen. These are natural colors being rendered from the computer that were never seen before because of the way the backlight was manufactured in the past. The extended colors seen have nothing to do with the electronics on a circuit board or setting Adobe standards to the monitor.

It was not a ploy to try to match the Adobe spectrum but a way of comparing how much more natural colors can be seen than with a conventional LCD panel with a conventional backlight system. Saying it has a 92% of the Adobe spectrum compared to 72% of the conventional monitor really has nothing to do with conforming to the Adobe gamut. It is just a comparison and reference point for marketing purposes. I could also say that it covers 60% of the RGB spectrum but that does not sound as nice as 92%. Why would I want to buy something that is only 60%?

An 8 bit panel can produce and has been producing a much larger spectrum of colors than sRGB. It is only because of the limits of how LCD panels have been manufactured that the color spectrum we see is so limited. The LED backlight models will have a spectrum of 110% or more of the Adobe color spectrum.

Some of us can remember…way back… when color picture tubes first came out. They looked like crap but they had color and everyone was happy. They developed over time to be very sharp and show a much larger color spectrum. The top of the line monitors for color work are still tube type monitors because LCD’s can not show the wide spectrum of colors that they can.

A wide gamut panel is a better color panel.
 
Maybe it would also help to define what is color critical work?

I edit photos....as a hobby. I wouldn't consider it color critical, but I also wouldn't mind having a wider gamut. One problem with wider gamut displays is that they are but one component in a chain of components required to get beautiful, accurate colors. This is particularly a problem if you're using the wider gamut to create something that other people are going to view, like web pages or online photos or even photographic prints.

But if all you're going to do is edit photos for viewing on your monitor, or playing games, or watching movies, then having a wider gamut allows more vibrant colors and you don't necessarily have to worry about it being calibrated or how it fits into the color chain.

I finally calibrated my NEC LCD2490 last night (sRGB space), editted some photos, and am astounded at how nice it looks. But I'm naturally curious as to how much nicer it would look if I had a 2690 (92% NTSC space) :D. Human nature I guess, but the blues in the Grand Teton Sky finally looks like I remember it.
 
I will tell you a little about my self and about color critical. Many moons ago I went to a photographic school to study studio work. Most there were interested in stetting up their own portrait studio or were interested in magazine and brochure layout. In the portrait work, color critical was not as important because the photographer wanted license to adjust the color to please his or her taste. A customer may have a better side than another and the better side may show facial imperfections that may need to be hidden. Using a Rembrandt effect (guess how a got my name years ago) of lowering the light on the face and shine light from slightly from the rear to show a patch of light on the front cheek is a real work of art. Color accuracy in print is very important in portrait work.

On the other side is the magazine and brochure studio work. Color critical is absolute at the school and having a printed picture with the identical color as the product in real life was essential. The phtographer almost never uses a flash fill light. The lighting on the set does not change. It is adjusted to the brightness, shadow and angle that are desired. Jus as essential to the work is the use of a devise that looks like a Swiss army knife of colors. This color pallet tool fans out to give you the colors of the color spectrum. Some of you may be familiar with some like this in looking a paint and home decorations. The difference is that these color swabs are color critical and cost a lot of money because they are absolute correct. The photographer then hands off the picture and the color match settings to the person that sits behind the monitor to make the picture conform to what is to be printed or sent to press. They may alter the background or the foreground. It may be cropped or included with other products for the same page but the color must be correct enough for the client.

This is just a basic view of professional color critical work. I do not make the majority of my income in photography so I do not fall into either category.
 
Having a wide gamut monitor is not a problem in creating something that other people are going to view, like web pages or online photos or even photographic prints. If Photoshop is set for sRGB, it is only going to allow you to use that limited color spectrum to alter or create something. The monitor does not set the colors in Photoshop it only displays what Photoshop gives to the monitor. The monitor does not create anything. It can only display what was created and does not interfere with the color creation. The exception is if the color is out of the monitors color spectrum and then it has to use the closest colors to display. That is why sRGB is the default color spectrum in Photoshop because 95% + of all the monitors out there will be able to display the full sRGB color spectrum. There are many web pages out there that are created outside of that spectrum but you do not notice the difference because you do not have a wide gamut monitor side by side with a normal monitor. You just accept the colors shown as normal, good and acceptable.

There are several references in the threads here about the monitors that have wide gamut, that the colors pop out or that they notice a difference in the intensity of a particular color on a web page, that they visit often, that was not there with their old monitor. These colors are now in the monitor’s spectrum and can be seen.

Again, a monitor can not alter any color that is thrown to it unless it is OUT of its color spectrum. A monitor does not create color it only displays the colors given to it.
 
Thanks, very helpful info. This is a subject I was curious about. How does bit-depth relate to wide gamut displays? It think it gets confusing when manufacturers claim 92% Adobe gamut on both 6-bit and 8-bit LCD's. And where do CRT's fit in the Adobe gamut range?
 
Most CRTs have a lower gamut - usually below 80%. Wide gamut CRTs are available but rare (pro market, usually.)

Technically there is not a direct relationship between bit depth and color gamut. Bit depth determines the stepping in between colors - i.e. how fine a difference there can be between two adjacent colors in a color ramp (without dithering) whereas color gamut determines the extents of the mapping of reproduced colors to an established standard.

If that last part didn't make sense, consider this: when two monitors are asked to reproduce the color R:255, G:0, B:0 (fully saturated red) they may not produce an equally saturated red. It will look slightly less saturated a red on a 80% gamut reproducing monitor than on a 92% or 102% monitor when you compare it to a standard color chart (physical printed object.) In the latter case (102% gamut) the red on the monitor will be slightly more saturated than it should be if you compare it to a standards body compliant printed color chart (CIE or SRGB). Human color perception exceeds sRGB and CIE standards, but the colors outside these defined gamuts do not often occur naturally as much and you aren't really missing that much in terms of what you as a creator can expect an end user to be able to see (IMHO.) Film captures more than the NTSC CIE standards so an expanded gamut - such as the new gamuts introduced with HDMI 1.3 (xvYCC). xvYCC not only expands bit depth (more defined shades in between colors) it also expands the color space / extents of the color gamut compared to commonly used color spaces in computer / video content creation.

Hope that helps.
 
most CRT's only do 80%???? thats something i didn't know. i figured that the benchmark was CRT's and they would all be therefore 100%. great info. it explains why colour range on my new lcd doesn't seem as bad as i expected. THANK YOU SETHK!!
 
Folks, understanding wide gamut displays is fairly simple.

Wide gamut monitors have nothing to do with Adobe or its spectrum. Adobe has their own limited spectrum of color in the full color spectrum.

The sRGB color spectrum is a smaller spectrum than the color spectrum than what Adobe is capable of and sRGB is the industry standard spectrum used in program development and web programs. It is a minimum world wide standard. If you did not know, “s” stands for standard.

Wide gamut monitor manufactures refer to the Adobe gamut, as a comparison, to what the monitor will show in the color spectrum. The panel in the monitor has no idea what an Adobe aRGB is and it does not conform to the boundaries of the aRGB color spectrum.

By using a new tube system in the back of a LCD panel, the panel is now capable of seeing more colors that was already there in the panel but could not be seen. These are natural colors being rendered from the computer that were never seen before because of the way the backlight was manufactured in the past. The extended colors seen have nothing to do with the electronics on a circuit board or setting Adobe standards to the monitor.

It was not a ploy to try to match the Adobe spectrum but a way of comparing how much more natural colors can be seen than with a conventional LCD panel with a conventional backlight system. Saying it has a 92% of the Adobe spectrum compared to 72% of the conventional monitor really has nothing to do with conforming to the Adobe gamut. It is just a comparison and reference point for marketing purposes. I could also say that it covers 60% of the RGB spectrum but that does not sound as nice as 92%. Why would I want to buy something that is only 60%?

An 8 bit panel can produce and has been producing a much larger spectrum of colors than sRGB. It is only because of the limits of how LCD panels have been manufactured that the color spectrum we see is so limited. The LED backlight models will have a spectrum of 110% or more of the Adobe color spectrum.

Some of us can remember…way back… when color picture tubes first came out. They looked like crap but they had color and everyone was happy. They developed over time to be very sharp and show a much larger color spectrum. The top of the line monitors for color work are still tube type monitors because LCD’s can not show the wide spectrum of colors that they can.

A wide gamut panel is a better color panel.

Help me Rembrandt. I was following the earlier thread titled "92% Gamut Hype?" in which you were a strong contributor. My conclusion after reading all the posts was that wide gamut can produce better color (whatever that means) but that since the vast majority of monitor users/program publishers will remain w/sRGB standards in the near future that a wide gamut monitor served little purpose for the average user. The exception would be for the serious graphics designer/photographer types.
Do I have that right or does wide gamut offer increased value for the average monitor user?
Not trying to be a wiseguy, just want to understand this better.
Thanks,
 
Help me Rembrandt. I was following the earlier thread titled "92% Gamut Hype?" in which you were a strong contributor. My conclusion after reading all the posts was that wide gamut can produce better color (whatever that means) but that since the vast majority of monitor users/program publishers will remain w/sRGB standards in the near future that a wide gamut monitor served little purpose for the average user. The exception would be for the serious graphics designer/photographer types.
Do I have that right or does wide gamut offer increased value for the average monitor user?
Not trying to be a wiseguy, just want to understand this better.
Thanks,

if you are
designer(print base)-aRGB
designer(web base)-sRGB
photographer (have aRGB DC)-aRGB
photographer (only sRGB/aRGB DC,but will post many photo over internet)-sRGB

normal user(games,movie,web surfing)-sRGB

so,when we need a higher color gamut display for all kind of user??
may be the movie/video made with xvYCC standard,many photo take with aRGB (+internet brower support ICC profile),OS support over 10bit color.....etc
 
Hi j.shafto,

You are right in saying that the vast majority of web material is made in non-wide gamut. But that is changing. It does not make any color in the standard color spectrum look any better. Better color has to do with the panel quality and electronics. Wide spectrum does make colors more vivid and real in the areas outside of the standard color spectrum. Please remember that what we call sRGB is the minimum world wide standard that all hardware manufactures and software manufactures use. It is no necessarily what they use. They can use a higher standard if they want to. In the US we are going to have a mandatory changeover to HD material for broadcast signals and a mandatory change to a higher minimum color spectrum used in that material. We have web pages that are cropping up using the outer realm of the color spectrum. We have HD video that is increasingly using the higher spectrum. Look at the newest LCD TV’s that are coming out. They will display the wider spectrum. Why? Because the wider spectrum will be the normal spectrum in a few years from now.

How long are you going to keep your monitor? One or two years? If it is longer you really need to think of having a wide spectrum monitor. Are you happy with the colors you see on the monitor you have now? Buy on price and don’t worry about it because you are like a lot of people.

I grew up in the St Louis area many moons ago. My father purchased a color TV before there was any color TV broadcast towers set up in town. When Corky the Clown broadcast the first color program in St Louis, it was a thrill for everyone that had color. Then Disney came out, then there was the news, then there was….. it happened very rapidly over about a year. Color photography exploded, 8mm color movie projectors exploded in sales. Everybody had to have it. Years latter, dad bought a solid state color TV…WOW how did we ever watch TV on that milky colored picture tube. Years latter he purchased a Sony…WOW how did we ever do without that sharpness and color. I purchase a Sony 42” HD TV (it has an expanded color spectrum) and go WOW this is great. Five years from now I will have a TV panel technology that is not even out yet and I will go WOW.

Not everyone is interested in the quality and color of what they see. Most are not enthusiasts or in a line of work that involves color. They are looking for what size they can get for the buck. Anything will do, I just need one. We are here because we have a higher standard that most in what we are looking for. I have never purchased a game in my life but that is the main reason this forum is here. We are all enthusiasts in one way or another here and in varying degrees. There are very few absolutes in what you should purchase for a monitor. It is how much of an enthusiast are you to true color and how much you are willing to or can spend to receive what will satisfy you.
 
Back
Top