X800XT to 8800GTS, power difference?

chiablo

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 6, 2005
Messages
387
I am currently running a Dell machine (P4 3.6 with X800XT)

Because of the recent drop in price of the 8800GTS, I am very interested in doing an upgrade and could probably convince the wife to give me the go ahead.

However, I am concerned with the power requirement difference between the x800 and the 8800. If I need to do a PSU upgrade for the new card, I'd also need a larger case to hold it... suddenly my $300 purchase becomes a $500 purchase and that would not fly so well with the woman in charge.

I don't know what the PSU is in the system at the moment (I'm not at home right now) but it's safe to assume it's around 350w. Is the 8800 going to overtax my PSU?
 
I am currently running a Dell machine (P4 3.6 with X800XT)

Because of the recent drop in price of the 8800GTS, I am very interested in doing an upgrade and could probably convince the wife to give me the go ahead.

However, I am concerned with the power requirement difference between the x800 and the 8800. If I need to do a PSU upgrade for the new card, I'd also need a larger case to hold it... suddenly my $300 purchase becomes a $500 purchase and that would not fly so well with the woman in charge.

I don't know what the PSU is in the system at the moment (I'm not at home right now) but it's safe to assume it's around 350w. Is the 8800 going to overtax my PSU?

350w? yes :)

A better PSU does not mean a bigger case... they are of standard size. Get yourself a 8800gts 320mb for lower resolution gaming or 640mb for higher resolution and also a solid, low price PSU. Don't worry about getting a new case.

Here's a good one on newegg: xclio 500w for $50

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817189005
 
its a Dell that means he needs a DELL psu or a PCP&C one for a dell

what model dell does the OP and he will need to go look to see if PCP&C makes one that works be for he goes out and buys one and then kills his PC becouse the pin-outs on the dell mobo are different
 
its a Dell that means he needs a DELL psu or a PCP&C one for a dell

what model dell does the OP and he will need to go look to see if PCP&C makes one that works be for he goes out and buys one and then kills his PC becouse the pin-outs on the dell mobo are different

oops, good catch. I completely missed the "dell" in that thread. From what I understand from my buddy with lots of dell machines, the new xps's are pretty customizable in that you can do psu swaps without worrying among other things. op's system might not be in that category.
 
It is a Dell Dimension (stop laughing!) not an XPS. I didn't think that Dell used proprietary PSU pin-outs on anything newer than a P3. I'll double check to make sure. The case is pretty crammed as it is, I have to keep the clam-shell open about an inch or it unplugs my SATA drives.


I was considering getting one of these so that it will survive a few upgrade cycles...
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139001
 
what model number is it
yea id bet youll need to get some thing from PCP&C for that though
 
Finally home... it's a Dimension 8400.

The PSU is a 24 pin 250w

Here's the specs (as per the text on the PSU itself):

18 amps on the +12v rails
17 amps on the +3.3v
22 amps on the +5.5
 
Ooh :eek:.

I'm surprised the X800XT runs in it. Must be a really nice PSU.

Get something new... Doesn't have to be an amazing PSU, but it should be a good brand with at least 500w.

Corsair, OCZ, PCPnC, the newer Ultra Xfinities, etc.
 
Watts aren't as important as amps, here. You want amps on the 12v rail, more specifically, or if there is a dedicated PCI-E rail, that's the one you need to look at. Single rails are less hassle, though.
 
Kind of pointless buying such a fast videocard with a old system, I had a P4 @ 3.2 and it bottlenecked with a X850 XT PE. Buy a new PC, cheap mobo, E4300, 500w PSU, etc.
 
fwiw, I don't think Dell has used proprietary PSUs since the P3 era, they're now standard ATX, I powered my Dimension 4550 machine with a 350w Antec, can't remember if I had to do anything weird to mount it, but electrically it worked great.
 
Well, I don't want to build a whole new system just yet with the quad cores plummeting in price this summer.

I'll see if I can convince the master and commander to let me get a PSU and 8800GTS.

Thanks for all of your input.
 
After doing a few searches on the Dell forums, apparently dell understates the capacity of their PSUs, there are several members who are running the 640mb version of the 8800GTS on a 305watt Dell PSU without problems.

http://www.dellcommunity.com/suppor...ghw&message.id=101373&query.id=222984#M101373

Apparently the big problem with the dell machine is that there just isn't room enough in there for the larger card. I can see how this could be the case (pun :p ).

My main goal is to be able to run Oblivion and some of the newer MMOs (LOTRO is awesome) at 1080p on my Westy. I know where the game's limitations are in regards to the CPU, but the higher rez is what I'm aiming for.
 
After doing a few searches on the Dell forums, apparently dell understates the capacity of their PSUs, there are several members who are running the 640mb version of the 8800GTS on a 305watt Dell PSU without problems.

It's not the Dell specs that are UNDERstated, it's the requirements from Nvidia that are OVERstated. Nvidia suggests 26A on the 12v line because they have no fucking clue what's in your system, or how good your powersupply is. Dell users have simply assumed that their powersupplies are underrated because they don't know any better.

The reality is, the 8800 GTS peaks at around 110w (about 10A on the 12v line). The remaining 16A in Nvidia's assumed "requirement" of 26A is just a bogus number to cover their asses. (in the linked thread above, the 350w powersupply requirement for the 6-series cards was yet another bogus case of Nvidia covering their asses with an outrageous "requirement").

That's not hard to believe that people get the 8800 GTS working on a 305w powersupply. This leaves (my guess) somewhere between 120-150w on the 12v line free for the rest of the system, which is plenty if the rest of the system is close to stock (and not overclocked).

Your system, however, uses a 250w powersuply with only 18A on the 12v line, which would not be enough to supply the rest of the system reliably (10A goes to the video card, that's 8A for the rest of the system). You need a beefier powersupply for this card.

For reference, the x800 XT uses around 60w, which is roughly half the power of the 8800 GTS. This is why you were able to run it stable on a 250w powersupply.
 
Great info there default.

It's a 350w PSU though. ;)

And taking a closer look at the label on the PSU, there are two 18 amp +12v rails. So I have a total of 36A system power. I should think this would be enough to power it.

But since I am going to do a full system update by year end, I think I'll get the beefier PSU while I'm at it.
 
2x18a 12v rails, but what combined power? There's no way it adds up to 36a (36*12=432w, and you said 350w no?) - it's more like 24-26a combined at most probably. May be enough, may not. Personally I wouldn't risk it, but you're kinda screwed if the PSU really does have proprietary pinouts (I'd definately put a bit more cash into the current upgrade in prep for a new system now if you could convince the other half to go along). Being single ain't so bad - no WAF to worry about :D .

[edit] Oh, and yes - FOR SURE get the Corsair if the wife approves. 5 yr warranty and proven to be able to run GTS/640s in SLI.
 
Great info there default.

It's a 350w PSU though. ;)

Thanks for the clarification. Your post above says 250w.

You can probably run the 8800 GTS with the 350w supply, although as had been noted, there's no way you can get 36A combined on a 350w supply. The good thing is, you only need about 20-22A to be sure of a stable system, and that's almost assured for the powersupplies Dell uses (they're not bad).
 
Back
Top