Best $-performance video card right now?

Booker

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 11, 2005
Messages
196
I´m planning on upgrading my very very very old pc.
i´m still not sure what to do.. if i should get a GT8800 video card with DX10.
Or go to the best DX9.0 video card and save extra money to spend it on other places.

What i should do? what VC are the best performance = $ out in the market?

Right now these choices

SAPPHIRE ATI Radeon X1950Pro 256MB = 300usd
Asus EN8800GTS =429usd
MSI GeForce NX7900GS HD 256MB =U$S 315

(price differ because i´m in other country).
 
I´m planning on upgrading my very very very old pc.
i´m still not sure what to do.. if i should get a GT8800 video card with DX10.
Or go to the best DX9.0 video card and save extra money to spend it on other places.

What i should do? what VC are the best performance = $ out in the market?

Right now these choices

SAPPHIRE ATI Radeon X1950Pro 256MB = 300usd
Asus EN8800GTS =429usd
MSI GeForce NX7900GS HD 256MB =U$S 315

(price differ because i´m in other country).

You are asking which card is the best bang for your buck and that is definitely the 8800 GTS 320, followed closely by the 8800 GTS 640.
 
best dx9 is the x1950xt @ newegg for 169 after rebate

best dx10 is the leadtek @ 320MB GTS for 259 AR @ newegg.
 
The EVGA 8800GTS 320 Superclock outperforms the 640 on lower resolutions for $300ish.

Also gets you a life time warranty and the ability to do pretty much anything without voiding the warranty.
 
thanks guys for the replys.

Basically i`m upgrading my very old system and i want to know some advice of what Videcard i should get.
I have those 3 or 4 in mind.. (i´m open to recommendations, though).

What i should do? go for a very fast and cheap DX9 videocard (as X1950pro)
Or i should go for the most expensive (of those 3 options) option but have DX10.

Some will say getting a Dx9 will be a throwing the money away. I have like 130usd difference between a Dx10 card and Dx9 card. It is worth it right now?

Others will say getting a DX10 is paying too much for a videocard since there is no DX10 games out yet and when they get out and become a standard you will get cheaper and better performance videocards.

Also, the DX9 is the same performance on 8800 and the latest DX9 cards.

So my question is.. what do you guys think?

(remember price differ because i´m in other country).
 
I think OP has an AGP card..

I'd say just wait until you upgrade your whole system before getting a new videocard (PCIe instead of AGP).

Plus your 1.8ghz Athlon XP is a huge limiting factor.
 
Doh... sorry my bad.
i´m actually upgrading my whole system.
This is what i have in mind, i can´t go a lot higher, because in my country the prices are alot higher than 1st world coutries :(

Intel Core 2 duo E6400 300usd
1Gb RAM 800 or 667 (i may go for 2GB but honestly, i´m sataying with XP and i´m stil uncertain if is really needed) 150usd (more or less)
Mobo (not decided yet, but around 130usd-160usd) (advice will be appreciated).

And video card.. between these 3... leanning towards the X1950pro right now.. but still not sure. Need more advice. (already post the prices)
 
thanks guys for the replys.

Basically i`m upgrading my very old system and i want to know some advice of what Videcard i should get.
I have those 3 or 4 in mind.. (i´m open to recommendations, though).

What i should do? go for a very fast and cheap DX9 videocard (as X1950pro)
Or i should go for the most expensive (of those 3 options) option but have DX10.

Some will say getting a Dx9 will be a throwing the money away. I have like 130usd difference between a Dx10 card and Dx9 card. It is worth it right now?

Others will say getting a DX10 is paying too much for a videocard since there is no DX10 games out yet and when they get out and become a standard you will get cheaper and better performance videocards.

Also, the DX9 is the same performance on 8800 and the latest DX9 cards.

So my question is.. what do you guys think?

(remember price differ because i´m in other country).

If price is important and you want the best bang for your buck (excellent performance at low or reasonable price), get the 8800 GTS 320.
 
I disagree.
Plus as you just said you dont care for Vista. Well keep in mind DX10 only works on vista and not only are you spending 100 dollers more the those dx10 cards but you have to add an additional 300 for vista.
Really I would go for the 1950pro. To me thats best bang for buck hands down.
All the next gen games coming out the end of year can be played on both dx10 and dx9.
So i dont see the point in spending that extra money when its not needed yet.

This forum is full of VERY knowledeagble people but i find them all to hardcore on parts.

Im planning on getting a new computer in fall and Im still interested in the 1950pro.

Spend the extra money on the cpu. I find the cpu goes a much longer ways if you buy high end. Then at 2 years upgrade video card if you want. I think thats what im gonna do. But im not spending more then 300cdn on cpu. If that quad core 6600? goes down to that 300 in fall then thats what im getting.
 
I'd go with the X1950 Pro - as noted, you are not doing 'Vista', so all the DX10 stuff on the GeForce 8-series is wasted silicon. Also, it should be cheaper, which will let you bump the ram to 2gb.

That's REALLY helpful, as many, MANY games basically require 2gb any more. You'd be surprised how much that improves things even in general usage of XP.
 
Ignore the DX10 and DX9 issues. The DX10 cards run DX9 better then the DX9 cards
 
my preference, in ascending order of price, and conveniently also ascending in performance:

x1950pro
8800gts 320
8800gts 640
8800gtx
 
What resolution do you play at?

The CPU can be o/c'd, so no real need to pay more money for it.
 
My native resoltuion is 1680x1050. But i guess most of my gaming will be at 1280x768.
 
I read an article about the 2900XT last night ... too lazy to find it though, it got the most FPS per dollar, so that pretty much answers your question.
 
My native resoltuion is 1680x1050. But i guess most of my gaming will be at 1280x768.

Then the GTS 320 is more than enough. For around $250-270, it's really the best bang for your buck, in the price/performance ratio.
 
I would agree, get the 8800GTS 320mb so you can play at full resolution with some AA/AF.
 
What about the Saphire 1950xt? It has 256 ram. It's about the same price as the 1950 pro with 512 ram.

Should he consider that? What about if he's running in a lower resolution? 1280x1000?
 
What about the Saphire 1950xt? It has 256 ram. It's about the same price as the 1950 pro with 512 ram.

Should he consider that? What about if he's running in a lower resolution? 1280x1000?

Why would he really want to run at a lower resolution? If the videocard is powerful enough, one should always run at native resolution.
 
Well it depends on the monitor. The one I have at home is old...so max settings is 1200x1000 (approx). This being the case it'd be a waste to go higher ram on the vid card, right? Just taking that into account since I'm personally looking at a similar scenerio.
 
If you don't mind me asking what country are you in? All these newegg prices don't mean squat unless you're in the US (or maybe canada).
 
Yeah..i´ll play at 1680x1050 if my system is powerfull enough.. but if is not i guess i´ll play at 1280x768 i don´t see myself playing lower than that.

So i guess most of the people go with the 8800GTS.
even if it cost 429usd?... remember this one cost 429usd, while the x1950pro cost 300usd.

Also how the 8800gts perform on Direct3d ? compare to the latest DX9 video cards?
 
If you don't mind me asking what country are you in? All these newegg prices don't mean squat unless you're in the US (or maybe canada).

I already state i´m not in use neither canada.. Not even in Europe :(

I´m in Argentina, so prices are really different from you guys.
This is why i posted my prices in here. Also i don´t have that many options.

The cheaper 8800GTS is Asus one... if i want to buy a MSI or other brand , it cost me like 50usd more.
 
Yeah..i´ll play at 1680x1050 if my system is powerfull enough.. but if is not i guess i´ll play at 1280x768 i don´t see myself playing lower than that.

So i guess most of the people go with the 8800GTS.
even if it cost 429usd?... remember this one cost 429usd, while the x1950pro cost 300usd.

Also how the 8800gts perform on Direct3d ? compare to the latest DX9 video cards?

The only GTS that can cost 429 USD, is the GTS 640, not what we are suggesting, which is the GTS 320. Also, the GTS 640 (the standard model) can be found for less than 400 USD. Or when you mean 429 USD, you mean the actual price in your country, converted to dollars ?

Even so, the GTS 320 is far, far more powerful than a X1950 Pro, but I guess it's up to you to decide what you want.

Do you want to run your games with in-game settings maxed, at your monitor's native resolution, with very good framerates ? If yes, then get the GTS 320.

If you don't mind lowering the in-game settings a bit (namely AA) and probably lowering the resolution, then the X1950 Pro is more than enough for you.

You decide.
 
Silus,
Of course i´ll choose the 1st option but i have to think about Money. If i go with the GTS 8800 i will have to stick to 1 GB only.. i can´t afford the GTS8800 and 2GB.

And when i say 429usd, i mean 429usd.

Unfrotunately we have to import these items from other countrys, Taxes, and stuff are HUGE here.. so videocards that cost 200usd in US, here is like 2x more.

ASUS 8800 cost 429usd
X1950pro cost 300usd.

1)Is the 8800 worth the 129usd extra us.. i´ll get it.. so my question is.. it is worth it?
2)or i should get the X1950pro and 2GB ?
3)or get the 8800 pro and 1 GB and upgrade memory later ?
 
Ignore the DX10 and DX9 issues. The DX10 cards run DX9 better then the DX9 cards

that is correct. The 8800 series blows away pretty much everything. The dx10 capability is just icing on the cake. Buy an 8800 and don't look back.
 
The shader technology alone on a 8800GTS makes every game look way better with DX9 verse any card out there unless its another GTS lol The money will be well spent and after having a 7950gt and playing on a buddies new x1900xt i grabbed a 8800GTS 320mb for 265.00usd and was never let down...Its a night and day gaming experiance.
 
If you guys want to see what prices are like in Argentina, check out www.mercadolibre.com.ar. It's pretty much their ebay over there.

We're talking about a 50% import tax right off the bat and usually a healthy markup on top of that. Almost double the price for hardware, especially the higher end stuff. Cheapest GTS 320's are about 450 or so over there.\

Used to live there buddy, and let me tell you, anytime any hardware ever went bad it was a nightmare.
 
I have the XFX8800GTS 320. I've seen the same games played on other computers with high end DX9 cards, and mine look way better.
 
Silus,
Of course i´ll choose the 1st option but i have to think about Money. If i go with the GTS 8800 i will have to stick to 1 GB only.. i can´t afford the GTS8800 and 2GB.

And when i say 429usd, i mean 429usd.

Unfrotunately we have to import these items from other countrys, Taxes, and stuff are HUGE here.. so videocards that cost 200usd in US, here is like 2x more.

ASUS 8800 cost 429usd
X1950pro cost 300usd.

1)Is the 8800 worth the 129usd extra us.. i´ll get it.. so my question is.. it is worth it?
2)or i should get the X1950pro and 2GB ?
3)or get the 8800 pro and 1 GB and upgrade memory later ?


Go with the less expensive card and 2 GB of ram...you don't want your hard drive thrashing around while playing pc games.
 
If you don't mind me asking what country are you in? All these newegg prices don't mean squat unless you're in the US (or maybe canada).

i don't know why you guys are even mentionig newegg. as good of a store they are, they only ship to the US unless they've changed their shipping policies recently.
 
Silus,
Of course i´ll choose the 1st option but i have to think about Money. If i go with the GTS 8800 i will have to stick to 1 GB only.. i can´t afford the GTS8800 and 2GB.

And when i say 429usd, i mean 429usd.

Unfrotunately we have to import these items from other countrys, Taxes, and stuff are HUGE here.. so videocards that cost 200usd in US, here is like 2x more.

ASUS 8800 cost 429usd
X1950pro cost 300usd.

1)Is the 8800 worth the 129usd extra us.. i´ll get it.. so my question is.. it is worth it?
2)or i should get the X1950pro and 2GB ?
3)or get the 8800 pro and 1 GB and upgrade memory later ?

I'm not in the US either mind you :)
So I also suffer from some price gouging, and it's not just taxes, but the fact that stores usually make a direct exchange from dollars to euros. For example the $250-260 GTS 320 would cost almost 300 euros, which is 250-260 euros plus taxes.

250 euros is more or less 340 dollars.
300 euros is more or less 400 dollars.

So as you can see, I'm in a similar situation as you, as far as prices go :)

Anyway, back to your situation and answering your question: Yes, the GTS 320 is REALLY worth it, but if your budget doesn't allow it, there's just no question that you should go with the cheapest card. It's a good card too, but the GTS 320 is much better.
 
I am sorry I am late to this, because what I have to say should have come MUCH earlier in this thread.

This question is IMPOSSIBLE to answer properly without first knowing the default resolution of the monitor this videocard will be used with.....

For instance, if you have a 1920x1080 monitor, then you need at least a 512mb videocard, so the 8800GTS 340mb is definitely not the best DX10 price/performance card for you, even though it is for someone who is running 1280x1024.

So if you can let us know what res you will need, then we can give better advice.
 
I am sorry I am late to this, because what I have to say should have come MUCH earlier in this thread.

This question is IMPOSSIBLE to answer properly without first knowing the default resolution of the monitor this videocard will be used with.....

For instance, if you have a 1920x1080 monitor, then you need at least a 512mb videocard, so the 8800GTS 340mb is definitely not the best DX10 price/performance card for you, even though it is for someone who is running 1280x1024.

So if you can let us know what res you will need, then we can give better advice.

We do know, you just didn't read..:rolleyes:

It's 1680x1050 native resolution.
 
We do know, you just didn't read..:rolleyes:

It's 1680x1050 native resolution.

Exaclty... i will play at 1680x1050 if the system can do it, if not, i´ll go to 1280x768. I won´t go lower than that.

AND.. I can´t go higher than the 8800GTS 320mb

Just to clariy. My budget allow me at most the 8800GTS 320mb, there is a HUGE price difference between the 320mb and de 640mb.

So again... if 8800GTS 320mb (ASUS) is worth the 429usd.. i´ll buy it. but can´t go higher than that.

thank again for all the feedback!
 
The 8800GTS is much better then the 1950pro. Definately worth the extra ~40% in cost.
 
Back
Top