Small upgrade

GJSNeptune

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
12,372
Been thinking about a cheap ($100 or less) CPU/mobo upgrade that can use my existing hardware and not bottleneck my x800 GTO (AGP).

Since I need an AGP board, I likely have to look in the FS/FT forum, but I figured I'd make sure it's practical. I won't have the money to build a completely new system for awhile. Maybe not even this year.

Which socket offers the best performance and value? I've seen 754 and 939 AGP boards, but none of them seem to have the best reviews. I'm not that concerned about overclocking, so any solid board is fine. Just don't know what board or CPU to look at. Also, I suppose I'd have to get another HSF as well.

Current:
AthlonXP 3000+ Barton
Abit NF7-S v2
1.5GB (3x512) Corsair VS DDR400 (PC3200)
Thermaltake Silent Boost
Antec TrueBlue 480W
WD 1600YS - WD 1200JD - WD 400EB
NEC 3550A
Memorex 52x CD-RW
 
I'm also open to the Intel route (Pentium D, etc.), although it seems they're mostly mATX boards.
 
Okay, some others suggested the same board and 805 Smithfield. It's OEM, so I'd need a good but cheap HSF.

I don't need anything futureproof. It's gonna be a long time before I can put money into a new computer, and I won't be upgrading this any further if I do upgrade now. I've had this setup for almost three years. When the time (and money) come, I'll build a completely new system.
 
Okay, some others suggested the same board and 805 Smithfield. It's OEM, so I'd need a good but cheap HSF.

I don't need anything futureproof. It's gonna be a long time before I can put money into a new computer, and I won't be upgrading this any further if I do upgrade now. I've had this setup for almost three years. When the time (and money) come, I'll build a completely new system.

Scrounge up a cheap stock HSF from the forums or ebay for a couple bucks.

Also, this is a good upgrade path as you might not upgrade now, but you may have to replace hardware... in which case the newer hardware will be cheaper than the older hardware.
 
Heh, I was about to suggest the same things. If you have a fry's near you, they sometimes have the Pent. D 805 w/ AGP mobo for $90. For the cooler, here's a decent one:

$15 - Arctic Cooling Alpine 7 92mm CPU Cooler - Retail
 
I don't. No Fry's in Ohio. I'm also having Athlon 64 recommendations. A 3200+ Venice is $36 shipped on Newegg.


$92.69 for:

ARCTIC COOLING ALPINE 7 92mm CPU Cooler - Retail
BIOSTAR K8NHA Grand Socket 754 NVIDIA nForce3 250Gb ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (Combo)
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice 2.2GHz Socket 754 Processor Model ADA3200AI04BX - OEM (Combo)


Then again, single core seems silly, but a Pentium 805 doesn't have HT, and the ones that do are quite a bit more expensive.
 
I don't. No Fry's in Ohio. I'm also having Athlon 64 recommendations. A 3200+ Venice is $36 shipped on Newegg.


$92.69 for:

ARCTIC COOLING ALPINE 7 92mm CPU Cooler - Retail
BIOSTAR K8NHA Grand Socket 754 NVIDIA nForce3 250Gb ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (Combo)
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice 2.2GHz Socket 754 Processor Model ADA3200AI04BX - OEM (Combo)


Then again, single core seems silly, but a Pentium 805 doesn't have HT, and the ones that do are quite a bit more expensive.

A single core is fine for your purposes. It just wont have much upgradability. The 3200+ system has good value, though, since its rather cheap. The Pentium D 805 doesnt need HT, it has a physical 2nd core on-die (its dual core). :p
 
I know, but why do the higher end Ds have HT enabled then?

I want the best balance of performance and value. As I said, this is the final upgrade for these parts.
 
Just realized that the Biostar only has two RAM slots. I have three sticks of 512. How significant would 1.5GB be over 1GB? I'd like to use all three, since I have them. Hate to have one collecting dust.
 
It really depends on what you use your system for. Just surfing the web and mild gaming on relatively low settings, you should be fine with just 1gig of ram. But, if you really want to get a bit deeper into gaming, like slightly faster load times and the ability to push your system just a bit further, then you might want to have your 3x512 instead. If you multi task a lot, you might want to get that little bit more memory. I know sometimes when I leave my system running with programs in the background while I'm doing something else that it slowly builds up, and I can end up using close to 1.4 gigs of ram. But that could just be my personal experience... Another possibility is you could stick with just one gig until you can afford a 2x1 gb kit. Thats kinda the issue that I was dealing with just a little while ago.

Bottom line is, its all up in the air until you really decide what you use your system for and what you think would be better price vs. performance wise. A good way to check out what you would need is to check your consumption in the task manager often while you do your daily computing. Also, it is kind of frustrating going down in ram, even if the overall system is much faster.

Other than that, good luck :D

edit: added a few things
 
I just picked up a e4300 + ecs motherboard from fry's today for $129 to do a similar upgrade to yours. It wouldn't boot up at first, even after trying various combinations of my existing 3 sticks of DDR1 512mb memory (2 333mhz, 1 400mhz). After I pulled 2 gigs of ddr2 800 from this system and threw them in that ecs motherboard, it booted up just fine. The existing gpu is a x800gto agp and seems to run with vista premium quite nicely. I do notice that it's slower than my sig rig I just built however. I'm sure it has to do with various bottlenecking factors. The hard drive is probably the worst of them. Not a bad upgrade for $130 though.
 
I don't. No Fry's in Ohio. I'm also having Athlon 64 recommendations. A 3200+ Venice is $36 shipped on Newegg.


$92.69 for:

ARCTIC COOLING ALPINE 7 92mm CPU Cooler - Retail
BIOSTAR K8NHA Grand Socket 754 NVIDIA nForce3 250Gb ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (Combo)
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice 2.2GHz Socket 754 Processor Model ADA3200AI04BX - OEM (Combo)


Then again, single core seems silly, but a Pentium 805 doesn't have HT, and the ones that do are quite a bit more expensive.

Single core. Old technology. Old socket. No upgrade path. Minimal performance over your setup.

I know, but why do the higher end Ds have HT enabled then?

I want the best balance of performance and value. As I said, this is the final upgrade for these parts.

Because you pay more. Just like more higher end models have more cache too. AMD doesn't have hyperthreading and it has one less core.


Best performance for money will be this, unless if you can get another dual core for around the same price, or if you can afford an E4300.

Just realized that the Biostar only has two RAM slots. I have three sticks of 512. How significant would 1.5GB be over 1GB? I'd like to use all three, since I have them. Hate to have one collecting dust.

Why would you consider this? Not only you get the downfall of alll the things mentioned above, but now you will take a performance hit on your memory too. Find a different board with a different socket solution. And it would be a significant diff fyi.

If you need to, you can always sell one, use that money and spend a little more on your setup?
 
Normal use and moderate gaming. No AutoCAD or anything, but audio, imaging, and video work. Have never maxed out my RAM. Don't think that would be a problem.
 
Fished around in FS/FT and happened to find some good deals.


Pentium D 820 + retail heatsink for $58 shipped. Retail is about $86 on Newegg.

ASRock 4coredual-VSTA for $50-55 shipped. I'll have a 512MB RAM module left over, but it'll be nice to have if I ever use the old CPU/mobo for another system. I probably will, too.
 
Back
Top