Gaming on Mac: Native or Bootcamp?

Molingrad

Gawd
Joined
Aug 28, 2004
Messages
706
I just bought a macbook pro and was wondering if the best thing to do for gaming is to buy a Mac version of the game or to just run it on XP in bootcamp. Does either entail a performance hit?
 
I just bought a macbook pro and was wondering if the best thing to do for gaming is to buy a Mac version of the game or to just run it on XP in bootcamp. Does either entail a performance hit?

The games I've tested (Civ IV, Prey) run about the same under each OS on my MBP. In Windows, you have the ability to overclock the GPU which can add some extra performance, but it's certainly more convenient (at least for me) to run any games that I can under Mac OS since it's where I spend the bulk of my time.
 
Mac side if the game has been written for it, no reason to use bootcamp unless the game has only been written for XP and you really really want to play it.

What game(s) you wanting to play?
 
If a game runs in OS X; I play it there, otherwise I pretty much have all of those games on my Desktop too; and in most cases the only difference between the Windows and OS X version is the app that accesses all the content.

My friend with a new Core 2 Duo 2.33ghz MBP prefers to play WoW and WC3 and any game that plays in OS X; in OS X.

In XP however you can use custom drivers and you can over clock your graphics card. So I'd probably just play them all in BootCamp if I didn't have a desktop.
 
I just bought a macbook pro and was wondering if the best thing to do for gaming is to buy a Mac version of the game or to just run it on XP in bootcamp. Does either entail a performance hit?

Vootcamp it, trust me, it will run just as well as a real windoze machione with the same specs, I am running Windows Vista on my MBP and games are super fast.
 
im looking to play Civ 4, as a great time killing game i would like it to run natively but dont want to buy a game for full price that I already own, especially when its still $50 for macs.

No one happens to have a Civ 4 Mac Ver they want to sell?
 
I've found that games that have a Mac port run really well in OSX. At least as well as they would in Windows. WoW runs better in OSX than it does in Windows. CS:S and a few other Windows only games run well in XP...
 
I just bought a macbook pro and was wondering if the best thing to do for gaming is to buy a Mac version of the game or to just run it on XP in bootcamp. Does either entail a performance hit?

Bootcamp it, trust me, it will run just as well as a real windoze machione with the same specs, I am running Windows Vista on my MBP and games are super fast. I use OSX for everything else or for games, like Civ 4 in OSX
 
Boot Camp does not actually have anything to do with running Windows on a Mac, as such. Boot Camp does the following:

*Lets you repartition the hard drive.
*Patches the firmware to allow BIOS emulation.
*Makes it easy to burn a disk with drivers for the hardware.


Once that is done, you have what is essentially a normal PC, running Windows, just as normal. A horrible waste, if you ask me, but the Macbook Pro is one sweet piece of hardware anyway.

Also, most games run about the same in Windows and Mac OS X, provided that they have been properly ported.
 
im looking to play Civ 4, as a great time killing game i would like it to run natively but dont want to buy a game for full price that I already own, especially when its still $50 for macs.
Verses (legally) paying for another copy of Windows?
 
Verses (legally) paying for another copy of Windows?

Or you can get a copy of windows from the msdnaa or a number of other resources that offer heavily discounted if not free copies... I have 4 or 5 unused keys for winxp that were completely free to me from school and the msdn etc..

:rolleyes: Not everyone is a pirate.
 
Or you can get a copy of windows from the msdnaa or a number of other resources that offer heavily discounted if not free copies... I have 4 or 5 unused keys for winxp that were completely free to me from school and the msdn etc..

:rolleyes: Not everyone is a pirate.

Vista keys can be had for free too. I just got a Vista Business Edition from a guy at work who was handed a stack of MSOffice 2007 demo sleeve that includes a full version of Vista while at a class for SQL.Net. I think the key is for 64-bit or 32, but the media is sadly only 32-bit. I'm ok with 32bit though as my macbook is only Core Duo and not Core 2 Duo and my Macbook is the only place I'm even considering running it. At any rate, I had no interest in buying Vista, but with a free key I'll give it a go.
 
I tend toward gaming in OSX myself, but that's just because I don't like having to reboot.

But it is pretty.
 
With everything tweaked I get a better framerate in the Windows versions versus the OS X counterpart. Not by a huge margin mind you , but with the Intel Graphics on the MacBook ill take every last frame I can get!
 
With everything tweaked I get a better framerate in the Windows versions versus the OS X counterpart. Not by a huge margin mind you , but with the Intel Graphics on the MacBook ill take every last frame I can get!

That's a MacBook, he's talking about a MacBook Pro.
 
That's a MacBook, he's talking about a MacBook Pro.

Which is still kinda the same deal because you can overclock in windows and use hacked/enhanced drivers that you can't use in os x.
 
Back
Top