7200 vs 10000 - Raptor Vs Regular

mokkapoop

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
1,155
Ok.

Currently in my system I have a 160gb SATA Segate 7200 rpm hard drive.

Microcenter has the 150gb SATA Raptor 10k rpm for $169.

If I was NOT running raid, just 1 of these drives alone, would it be better for system performance (Loading Windows, Games, Ripping dvd's, writing dvd's, etc)?

Please let me know your opinion.
 
Yes it will be better performance with a Raptor. Multi-tasking hard drive intensive apps will be much better too.

This has been covered ad nausuem in the Storage forum if you'd like to look up more opinions.
 
I would think you will see more of a benefit from getting more ram, if you just have 1gig make it 2. It will be faster with that drive but i don't think you will see as much of a difference if you had more ram. If you already have 2 gigs save the money for something else.
 
I would think you will see more of a benefit from getting more ram

Hard drives are frequently the limiter of a system; RAM is rarely the reoccurring cause of a bottleneck (unless you're running 256MB PC133 or something). If OP is doing anything HDD intensive (as he stated he was), then he will most definitely see a benefit from faster HDD read/writes.
 
The difference was very noticeable for me.

Even folders will load quicker (for example, My Pictures comes up almost instantly with the thumbnails now for me :) )
 
Hard drives are the biggest bottleneck of a system. It makes a difference man. Youll have faster transfer rates, access times, games will load faster, bootup speeds...etc. Ill never go back to 7200 for my boot drive. 10K RPM 4 life!
 
whats the avg transfer rate on your seagate drive? dl hd tune and run the test.

here are my results. all drives tested in my main rig (see sig).
Average Transfer Rate
78MB/s - WD Raptor, 150gb, WD1500ADFD, SATA150, retail: $200AR
65MB/s - Seagate 'cuda 7200.10, 320gb, ST3320620AS, SATA300, retail: $90
52MB/s - WD Caviar SE16, 250GB, WD2500KS, SATA300, retail: $80
52MB/s - WD Caviar SE, 160GB, WD1600JS, SATA300, retail: $53
50MB/s - Maxtor DiamondMax, 200GB, 6L200M0, SATA150, retail: $40
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
37MB/s - WD Caviar SE, 80GB, WD800JB, ATA100
44MB/s - WD Caviar SE, 160GB, WD1600JB, ATA100
 
HDTach

WD Raptor 150GB SATA - 77.9 MB/s avg
Maxtor MaxLine 500GB SATA2 - 61.3 MB/s avg

ICH8R, intel sata2 controllers.
 
Back
Top