Maxtor SATA HD - DO NOT BUY!

Status
Not open for further replies.

mokkapoop

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
1,155
I was shopping at my local fry's yesterday when I came upon Maxtor's 160gb SATA II 8MB buffer hard drive. The price was $39 brand new, retail. I could not resist, it would act as a hard drive for my Vista Home Basic (just to get to know the system).

However, after formatting my orginal hard drive, installing XP Professional, I decided to install Vista on the Maxtor drive. It went all the way through the installation, and upon reboot and boot into Vista, it gave me errors saying there were files missing or corrupt. I wiped the drive and reinstalled 3 more times, each time the same thing.

Now, after much frustration and time wasted, I tested it back on my original drive. I formatted it, installing Vista, and BAM, it worked.

I am taking back this POS Maxtor drive and getting my money back.

In my computer now, I have a 200gb Seagate Barracuda SATA drive. I didn't think these were "great drives", but it sures seems better than Maxtor.

With this said, what is the best HD brand out there?

Should I just go to Microcenter and pick up a Raptr 150gb for $169?
 
I'm partial to Western Digital.

You shouldn't say not to buy Maxtor because of your specific problem. It would be more accurate to advise us not to buy them if we plan to install Vista on them.

Not sure if you know, but Seagate owns Maxtor. It doesn't necessarily mean they improved Maxtor drives though. :p
 
So because you found one lemon, they are all bad? Sensationalist garbage. I've seen plenty of bad WD, Seagate, Maxtor drives over the years.

I have 4 WD, and 6 or so Maxtor's in my systems now. There are millions of people with maxtor harddrives without issue.
 
Just so happens the one I pick is a dud......still no reason for it. Hard drives have beeb around for years. They should know exactly how do make these without problems...
 
Anecdotal evidence does not translate into proof that Maxtor sucks. Did you use the same SATA cable that you used for the Seagate? Perhaps the cable is bad?

I'm sorry you probably got a dud, just get a refund/exchange. Of course, if you get a replacement maxtor and it happens again, perhaps you're on to something. :)

Personally, I use hard drives from Hitachi, Seagate, Maxtor, and WD, and in 10 years of computing, none have died on me, yet. The problem is that while they probably come off the assembly line fine, QA doesn't catch all defects, shipping might have been rough, it might have been mishandled by employees (used for kickball?), or a variety of other things.
 
So because you found one lemon, they are all bad? Sensationalist garbage. I've seen plenty of bad WD, Seagate, Maxtor drives over the years.

I have 4 WD, and 6 or so Maxtor's in my systems now. There are millions of people with maxtor harddrives without issue.

Amen. I run 8 or so in my servers and no problem here yet for the past few years of them running *knocks on wood*

Just so happens the one I pick is a dud......still no reason for it. Hard drives have beeb around for years. They should know exactly how do make these without problems...

Yes, all hardware fail, it doesn't matter who makes it. There is a good chance of failure... perhaps you installed it wrong, created static shock? perhaps it got killed during shipping, many many many reasons for a mechanical electrical device to fail.

I had seagates, western digitals, and hitachis arrive at my door doa on the spot. It's not just one brand.
 
You guys are all right.

I am just frustrated. Had the night to relax and do this with my computer, ended up staying up late and am really tired today....was at work at 6am.

I won't take my chances with Maxtor again though.
 
Just so happens the one I pick is a dud......still no reason for it. Hard drives have beeb around for years. They should know exactly how do make these without problems...

Stuff fails or comes in doa. Get over it.
 
Stuff fails or comes in doa. Get over it.

Did you read my last post....dick?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Mod Edit - Personal attacks will get you more attention than you may have intended, and can result in modification to your posting abilities.

Fair warning........B.B.S.
 
Time for a lock.



By the way, he posted only two minutes after your last post, and was only reiterating that all brands have drive failures. Try to relax a little.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top