Best in-case water cooling?

Papaspurs

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
110
Hi all,

I'm an overclocking noob (things appear to have changed a little since I doubled the speed of my 486 DX 33 witha jumper move).

I want a quiet case with watercooling inside as the machine will be going in the living room.

I'm looking at the TT Ta-Chi with LCS, I know I could get better performance from an external module, but the key to my purchase is neat and quiet.

About to buy;

E6600
nForce 680i (EVGA or Striker)
4gb 1066 sli mem
Raptor 150
a 320GB second disk
and a 8900/8950/X2800XTX2 depending on which comes out top.

I've got a million other questions relating to the Tai-Chi if it's the way to go.
 
tai-chi is a pretty good case. but i'd prefer lian li on my opinion.
watercooling is best when u make it urself. u can see the pics at the sticky to look for watercooled rigs.
 
You can do better by building your own loop...

They dont HAVE to be external anymore.

an antec 900, or a CM stacker will EASILY fit a dual radiator up front (and the masstige would too but it's discontinued)...

You'll get a much better setup at about the same cost... if not less.

Apogee CPU block - 40$
Swiftech MCR220 Rad - 40$
EKS 8800 waterblock - 110$ (or whatever you need for your current GPU choice)
MCP655 pump - 50$
Tubing - 10$
Tline - 2$

That's about 250$ plus $100 for a nice case...

Your temperatures will be about 5-10c lower than the Tai Chi, and you'll save a bit of cash.

hell, I don't even know if the TT TC LCS can handle anything over a 7xx0 lvl GPU... Infact, I'm almost positive it won't be able to.

It's sure as hell a beautiful case though :3
 
OK, sounds good. What a great forum - 3 replies quick as that!

Now for the scarey best prices.....I'm in the UK.....

TT Tai-Chi LCS: £217

Stacker 830 £137
TT VA8003BWS Armour £95

DangerDen DD12V £56
DangerDen TDX Processor block £36
DangerDen Dual Bay Res. £22
Tube £2 per metre
Fluid £15
Fill point?? £10

Which puts the price over the Tai-Chi. (I could go a little over)

Now that opens up a whole case debate :eek:\

I want quiet and pretty (I'd like the case that showed the most of the inside if i'm honest, but needs to be quiet)
 
get the Tt khandalf lcs. it has a triple 120mm fan rad. should be enough for gfx cooling too.
 
I don't like the kandalf lcs because the radiator blocks of the whole front. Surely the reduced airdlow would cause a higher ambient temp in the case
 
For reference...

I've got 4 yate loons on my BIP 2.120 radiator running at 6-7v.

From 1 foot (case closed) the noise emitted is 21db, over an ambient noise of 17db.

During full gaming load (my 8800, nb and CPU are all in the loop) I ramp it up to 9v (temps still about 55, they climb to 61 if I leave the fans down) and it pushes out 24db (which is about 2x as loud as 21db).

For reference, speach with someone sitting across from you is anywhere from 50-60db... And quietly whispering to someone ranges 20-25db.

"middle" volume on your iPod is closer to 80db... With maximum volume in the 100s.
 
You can do better by building your own loop...

They dont HAVE to be external anymore.

an antec 900, or a CM stacker will EASILY fit a dual radiator up front (and the masstige would too but it's discontinued)...

You'll get a much better setup at about the same cost... if not less.

Apogee CPU block - 40$
Swiftech MCR220 Rad - 40$
EKS 8800 waterblock - 110$ (or whatever you need for your current GPU choice)
MCP655 pump - 50$
Tubing - 10$
Tline - 2$

That's about 250$ plus $100 for a nice case...

Your temperatures will be about 5-10c lower than the Tai Chi, and you'll save a bit of cash.

hell, I don't even know if the TT TC LCS can handle anything over a 7xx0 lvl GPU... Infact, I'm almost positive it won't be able to.

It's sure as hell a beautiful case though :3

distilled water: $0.50
clamps x11: $8.25
additive: $4.50

:p
 
OK, I'm now leaning towards the Stacker 832 (£150)

So what do I need for watercooling just the processor to begin with? (with a view to watercooling everything eventually - gpu, chipset, h/d?,mem?)

I gather Swiftech Alphacool and DangerDen are good manufacturers?

What do I need in the way of rads/fans?

Who does the quietest pump?

Again sorry for the noob questions :)
 
For reference...
I've got 4 yate loons on my BIP 2.120 radiator running at 6-7v.

What case do you have?

I'm now trying to decide between the Lian Li PC-V2100BplusII (with the clear window option) and the Coolermaster Stacker 832.

I'm figuring the LL would be a fair bit quieter?
 
The stacker is the easiet to mount a rad up front IMO.

The Lian Li needs to be cut.

I've got a (now discontinued) Aerocool Masstige. It's such a nice case, I wish I had bought more.
 
OK, I think I'm decided :).....on everything but the water cooling....

Case: Black Stacker 830 Evo (I like the fact you can see the insides when it's on only, over a Lia Lin wth a window)
CPU: E6600
M/B: eVGA 680i Sli
Mem: OCZ 4 x 1GB PC2-8500 1066MHz SLI-Ready Edition Dual Channel DDR2
H/D: Raptor 150GB
H/D2: 300GB SATA 2 (prob Hitachi Deskstar)
PSU: Thermaltake 1200w PSU W0133 - Modular
Graphics: 2 x 8950 (eventually)

I'd hope to get the processor over 3Ghz and the memory to 1200Mhz. Quietly.

What do I need for watercooling just the processor to begin with? (with a view to watercooling everything eventually - gpu, chipset, h/d?,mem?)

I gather Swiftech, Alphacool and DangerDen are good manufacturers?

One of these kits? http://www.specialtech.co.uk/spshop/customer/home.php?cat=606

or...

1. What do I need (how many) in the way of rads/fans?
2. Who does the quietest pump?
3. What additional fans should I get for the Stacker?
4. What CPU block should I get?
5. How big a reservoir and 7/16 pipe?

Again sorry for the noob questions :)
 
First, I'd save some cash and get some good OCZ titanium 800mhz RAM... You'll notice no difference between RAM at 800mhz and 1200mhz.

Dtek Fusion CPU block - 70$
Swiftech MCR220 Rad - 40$
YOU"LL NEED A TRIPLE RAD if you want 2 of those GPU's in SLI. OR, get a double THERMOCHILL PA.120
EKS 8800 waterblock - 110$ (or whatever you need for the 8950s)
MCP655 pump - 50$
Masterkleer 7/16" Tubing - 10$
Tline - 2$ / Swiftech micro-res - 30$

Fans... I'd get a few of the 3.25$ Yate Loon fans from Jab-tech. I run 2 of them on each side of my double rad at 7v, they're totally silent (22-24dba if that means anything to you).
 
1) 120.3 radiator - with 100cfm fans if you intend to cool everything later down the line. Once you have CPU, GPUs, Chipset all watercooled and clocked up to "usual" levels, you'll be pushing 650w of heatload at full load if not more - 8950 likely shove out more heat than 8800 so could be approaching 750w of heat to remove... (see http://www.thermochill.com/PATesting for dissipation figures for our rads)

2) Laing DDC

3) *shrug*

4) D-Tek FuZion or Apogee GT

5) Entirely up to you on reservoir - size makes no difference to performance. 7/16 pipe is fine.

In kit form - http://store.over-clock.com/O_CuK_Hand_Spec_d_Kits.html#a659

get a double PRIMOCHILL PA.120
A what???!
 
A what???!

What you talkin bout Marci? :p

(leave me alone, I spent the last 18 hours finishing my psychology thesis ;) )

The 8800GTX's shove out less than 200w of heat, since the 8950s (or whatever) will be die shrunk, I'd imagine they'd put out about the same... I doubt many conroes approach 200w heat output.

Would your Thermochill 2.120's handle 600w? If so I'm going to go buy one right now.
 
Bit more detail on the heatload of the system in question...

E6600 Core2Duo oc'd to 3.8Ghz at 1.5v = 148w
Topend mobo chipset (680i, 650, BadAxe975) = around 50w max(?)
2x 8800GTX @ stock (altho assume they'll get clocked up) with full coverage cards = 300w (oc'd - add another 100w?)
Pump - usually DDC Ultra with this crowd, sooo = 18w

Gives us a total of 516w with GPUs at stock, 616w with GPUs OC'd...

PA1203HeatdissVSFlowrateLPM.jpg

Legend:
Pf H = Panaflo FBA12G12-H1A - 105cfm, 6.8mmH2O, 41.5dBA
1212M = Delta WFB1212M - 72.4cfm, 3.4mmH2O, 34dBA
Nexus = Nexus D12SL-12 - 36.8cfm, 22.8dBA

So, typical flowrate is 6lpm. Look at the top orange line and top dark blue line - that's the airflow required to shift that amount of heat... which requires Panaflo -H fans (103cfm each) to cool with a little headroom for OCing GPUs or Delta1212M fans (72cfm each) to cool with GPUs at stock... any lower airflow than that will result in temps exceeding 50 deg C under load.
 
I assume "Heat dissipated" is in watts? That's impressive, 1.5k btu/hr @ 40dba.

You need to set up a manufacturing setup in the US, I'm sick of reselling swiftech stuff and putting up with their BS supply problems. :p
 
I assume "Heat dissipated" is in watts?

Yep

Would your Thermochill 2.120's handle 600w? If so I'm going to go buy one right now.

Heh - yes, depending how you look at it.

PA1202HeatdissVSFlowrateLPM.jpg


Not according to the above, but that's assuming a 10 deg air to coolant differential.
IE: Water temp will be 10 deg Hotter than inlet air temp. (Room of 20 deg = Water at 30 deg under load... so c/w calculations should be [heatload] x [c/w of waterblock] + [water temp] = approx load temp of that item)

If you increase heatload beyond listed there for the fan you're using (eg: You're using Delta 1212M fans at 12v, and have 6lpm flow, but dumping more than 350w of heat into the system) then the differential increases, and thus so do your temps... so coolant would be room temp + more than 10deg, figure increasing the more heatload you stick in.

The question is, with XXcfm airflow, would a PA120.2 keep hardware at a REASONABLE temp... and that all depends on what you call reasonable.


For data for ALL our PA Series rads, see http://www.thermochill.com/PATesting/
 
Excellent, thanks fo rthe response.

What about one of these?....

Alphacool Xtreme Pro 360mm Kit: http://www.specialtech.co.uk/spshop/customer/product.php?productid=3507&cat=607&page=1

- Black-ICE Xtreme III 360mm radiator,
- CPU Alphacool NexXxoS XP cooler,
- Mountings for AMD XP, AMD 64 and Opteron, Intel 478 and Socket 775
- Laing DDC Pump, incl. water tank (can also be mounted in 3,5" slot)
- Bridging plug for the ATX power pack
- 4 Meter hose PUR 10/8mm transparent,
- 3x Fan 120x120x25 Alphacool
- Watter additive Tec-Protect-Plus 0,5liter,
- 8x connections Plugin with G1/4"-external thread on 10mm (external diameter) hoses,
- Adhesive tape 13cm long and 10cm wide for pump mounting at the case,
- thermal paste
- manual.

Also regarding power, if the 8950GX2 uses 15% more power than the 8900GTX (as in the 7900/7950gx2 jump) then I think power consumption for the graphics could be 700W or over! :eek:

Oh... and how the hell would I mount a 3 fan monster in the 830?
 
That's impressive, 1.5k btu/hr @ 40dba

Need another "@" at end of that for flowrate... 1.5k btu/hr @ 40dba @ X lpm to make it a useful statement...
 
Excellent, thanks fo rthe response.

What about one of these?....

Alphacool Xtreme Pro 360mm Kit: http://www.specialtech.co.uk/spshop/customer/product.php?productid=3507&cat=607&page=1

- Black-ICE Xtreme III 360mm radiator,
- CPU Alphacool NexXxoS XP cooler,
- Mountings for AMD XP, AMD 64 and Opteron, Intel 478 and Socket 775
- Laing DDC Pump, incl. water tank (can also be mounted in 3,5" slot)
- Bridging plug for the ATX power pack
- 4 Meter hose PUR 10/8mm transparent,
- 3x Fan 120x120x25 Alphacool
- Watter additive Tec-Protect-Plus 0,5liter,
- 8x connections Plugin with G1/4"-external thread on 10mm (external diameter) hoses,
- Adhesive tape 13cm long and 10cm wide for pump mounting at the case,
- thermal paste
- manual.

Also regarding power, if the 8950GX2 uses 15% more power than the 8900GTX (as in the 7900/7950gx2 jump) then I think power consumption for the graphics could be 700W or over! :eek:


First off, the 8800GTX's use about 150w of power alone. Overclocking them to 660/2100 increases that load to almost 250w. (heat dump, of course, is lower than that). Two of them in SLI shouldn't use more than 500w of power under a HEAVY overclock. I can assume that power consumption of 2 8900GTX's to be relatively similar.

Now, that radiator. The BIX is NOT the radiator you want to use if you're going for silence. It needs fans of 60CFM+ to be truely effective. Sure, since it's in triple form, slower fans would work, but you'd still see lower noise levels (similar or better temps) with a Black ice PRO and some yate loons.

For reference, I'm running a 160w (CPU) + 200w (GPU) + ~40w (NB) heat load on a BIP Xflow 240 (worse than both the BIP and BIX) which produces very acceptable temperatures (during full load the noise ramps up to about 27dba from 1-2 feet with the case fully closed and radiator fans muffled).

With a BIX 240 (I had that at one point too) my temperatures were much warmer than they are currently (totally different setup, Athlon X2 and a 7800) but the load noise level was closer to 32db.

In short, the BIX was louder than my BIPxflow on a slower, cooler system.

The nexxos isn't a bad block kit though, but it's not exactly "noise conscious"

Need another "@" at end of that for flowrate... 1.5k btu/hr @ 40dba @ X lpm to make it a useful statement...

Too true. I just don't know of very many people that don't use a pump pushing 5-7 lpm... Not on this continent anyways (stares at the AC crowd)
 
As I'll only be buying one graphics car when they come out (and another when they're cheap) could I by the water cooling in modular fashion.

ie buy 1 or 2 fan rad now and add more later?

do three seprate rass work better than one big one?

how would I go about mounting the rad(s) in the 830 and how many free 5.25" bays would I be left with?

Can't seem to find Yate Loons in the UK :(
 
Mine is all internal and very quiet, I'd go for a custom built loop if I were you.


Totally agree. After doing months of research I built my own and it was well worth it. Much better results than any kit could produce. Kits are cheap, but you probably won't get great cooling out of most of them. I guess it depends on your budget and what you're looking to get out of it.
 
Back
Top