Banning Social Networks From Schools

Status
Not open for further replies.

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While it seems pretty obvious that you should be working on school stuff when you are at school, do we actually need laws banning MySpace from school?

Creates the Social Networking Web site Prohibition Act. Provides that each public library must prohibit access to social networking Web sites on all computers made available to the public in the library. Provides that each p
 
Wouldn't that in fact, violate first amendment rights? I'm sick and tired of our government trying to censor what we can do. It's pinko-commie bullshit if you ask me.
 
No, this does not break the first amendment.

On the other hand it is very silly. The schools do not want anything but a controlled environment. They don't want incorrect ideas being introduced to their students. They want to control those little skulls full of mush, and make them into good productive little liberals.
 
Shouldn't this be just some common sense? Same with workplaces.
 
It shouldn't be law. it should be school policy. and by now, it should be common sense.

[H]ardForum? Always allowed. that should have been slipped in the bill somewhere.
 
First off, when did Internet access become a “right”? Just because I live in the United States, it doesn’t give me a right to have Internet Access. Thus, it can be restricted or denied at will. At any time, if the government passed a bill, you’re Internet “rights” could be taken away just as easily as your driver license can be suspended. Bad analogies aside, if the government chooses to pass a bill making it illegal to surf certain Internet sites in public places, so be it. It’s a public place; they can do whatever they want. Living in the US and having “freedom” doesn’t mean you can do whatever the hell you want, when you want…

Personally, I think “social networks” SHOULD be blocked in public places. Computers are put into public libraries and schools for the convenience of learning, not entertainment. If you want partake in “social networks”, buy yourself a computer and pay for Internet access like the rest of us. If you can’t afford it, live without it.

On a side note, it’s fairly easy and inexpensive to successfully block and restrict Internet access on computers. I’m not sure why public places aren’t already doing this…
 
It SHOULDN'T be law because I agree it breaks the first amendment HOWEVER it should be a school policy which are two very different things. Any sort of behavior that does not contribute to a schools atmosphere should be banned because these children, especially in high school, are very fragile and the decisions they make here will haunt them for the rest of their lives. Some of them who end up on the lowest end of the social chain never recover and really, Myspace helps that along somehow.


Ban that shit.
 
I really wish people would take the time to understand what freedom of expression means, instead of screaming ""ZOMG THEY ARE STEALIN MY RIGHTZ !!11!!ONE WTFBBQLOLERSKATZ"". You really do a diservice to your those who actually have their rights violated, when like chicken little, you claim the sky is falling.

:rolleyes:
 
Shouldn't this be just some common sense? Same with workplaces.

I agree, I really don't get the whole "we need a law for this" thing. Why not give the schools the authority to decide such issues for themselves? I am wondering if there are no other problems left to solve in this problem when representatives are wasting time on this type of legislation.
 
Wouldn't that in fact, violate first amendment rights? I'm sick and tired of our government trying to censor what we can do. It's pinko-commie bullshit if you ask me.

First amendment right to free speech is not first amendment right to use property you don't own for a purpose that is not sanctioned by the owner.


You can shout from the rooftops all that you like. but if you don't own the building from which you are shouting, you can be arrested for trespassing.

You can also be arrested for creating a public disturbance if you decide to tell your story in the middle of a busy intersection.


The computers provided by schools to students are designed so that the students can DO WORK on them.

I am (at my age....) back in college. at least HALF of the screens on the computers in my illustrator class that i am taking see sites like meebo, myspace, facebook EVERY TIME I LOOK AROUND.


How the hell are these kids going to LEARN something when they are myspace-ing

?

I personally AGREE with banning ALL these sites on SCHOOL OWNED PROPERTY.


Additionally, as a parent, i'd want to know that my $800 a class is actually being used so that little johnnie can get a fucking job.

The reason these kids do all this stuff is because they AREN'T PAYING FOR IT, so they don't care!
 
Just thought of another thing.

Public library / school. What if some punk is sitting their chatting / myspacing while some other student is actually trying to do WORK?

By your logic, isn't the punk infringing on the rights of the working student?
Like another poster said, do that stuff on your own time. Computers are cheap. Get one. Myspace on it all you like.


My complaint is that the penalty will be upon the owners who don't enforce it!
I think it should be a punishment for the actual violators (but, then again... if the schools/libraries block it, then it won't be an issue)

I stand by this law.

I can even give them a list of sites they probably don't know about (seeing as how politicians are so behind the times.. )
 
Some one give me a good reason why the 11 year olds (from as young as 3 to 13 is whats in my district) should be allowed to chat, socialize, virtually hang out with EVERYONE on the internet?

Most people here are probably think about seniors in high school, College students and the like. College students, I think it should be up to the university. However anything else why? Why are fighting it? This is an institution of education, not a baby sitter for the day, not an excuse for learning, even before we begin on what dangers could and aren't out there there is no value of these sites in a school!

The second reason would have to be because of all the scares of what has happened to people, brought to attention by myspace, but they aren't first or the only ones, there have been many before them and many cases of what has happened there before those. Schools should also not let children into an uncontrolled email system either, we block all webmail but the districts here (which the students do not use). I've actually seen kids in chat rooms in a "meet up" area when our (old) filter failed I can not see how this is useful.

There is some level of protection that is placed upon us while taking care and education children from the community and no way you can swing it these sites have a higher level of threat and zero worth.


This is also not new news, I've known about it since last year and in fact our filter includes a 'social networking' section of blocking. I don't agree with libraries forced to do this, I don't agree with colleges but 12th grade and lower I have no problems with.
 
This does not violate freedom of speech. You own your mouth, not your school's computers.
 
Yes, they should block them.

The labs get filled very quickly in the afternoon and there is nothing more annoying while standing in line to use a computer to see some jerkoff dicking around on myspace or facebook. Checking to see if the man or woman added you? Who gives a fuck....we have things to do that matter, i.e. work. Even more annoying are the people who decide to watch TV shows, i.e. web broadcast of Lost. I'm sorry, but we have areas with televisions or you can wait until you get home to catch up on your TV shows.
 
Yes, they should block them.

The labs get filled very quickly in the afternoon and there is nothing more annoying while standing in line to use a computer to see some jerkoff dicking around on myspace or facebook. Checking to see if the man or woman added you? Who gives a fuck....we have things to do that matter, i.e. work. Even more annoying are the people who decide to watch TV shows, i.e. web broadcast of Lost. I'm sorry, but we have areas with televisions or you can wait until you get home to catch up on your TV shows.

QFT. When I was in college there was nothing more annoying then trying to get something printed or edit an assignment in a full computer lab when half the lab consists of a bunch of smack-tards using myspace, or youtube.
 
Yes, they should block them.

The labs get filled very quickly in the afternoon and there is nothing more annoying while standing in line to use a computer to see some jerkoff dicking around on myspace or facebook. Checking to see if the man or woman added you? Who gives a fuck....we have things to do that matter, i.e. work. Even more annoying are the people who decide to watch TV shows, i.e. web broadcast of Lost. I'm sorry, but we have areas with televisions or you can wait until you get home to catch up on your TV shows.
hahah so funny
 
Somewhere along the internet boom came the idea of social networking. And the kids that grew up with this online networking are usually the quickest to defend it.

I was already out of my undergraduate program by the time xanga and friendster came around, which I believe was one of the first of its kind. While attending graduate school, however, nowhere did I feel it was my god given right to use the school's internet access to find out which one of my old friends had recently added me. Anything that detracts from a students' ability to focus on their education should be removed from an educational environment, especially if it includes the possibility of promoting ignoble behaviors in which a good amount of the myspace crowd seems to excel in.

Students at my high school (I teach) all typically have a myspace account. Many of them would cry out in unison, like some of you have, if told them about this law. Others, and I'm sure the numbers would not be few, would completely understand the logic of this.
 
This is just more political abuse of the "It's for our children" line so a politician can get their personal wants and needs.
 
Perhaps a law is a bit strong, but most schools should make it policy. Our labs already frobid playing games and viewing porn. Social networking should be added to the list.
 
Solution: the instant a kid in school is caught loading up Myspace or Facebook, taht kid has to use the ENCYCLOPEDIAS to finish his/her paper.

The shame should curb the behavior.
 
There are completley legitimate purposes for banning social networking sites from schools and libraries. However, THIS law shouldn't be how it is done.

Schools have a budget, and bandwidth isn't free. Same goes for libraries. The government's dime is being spent on it, and that comes out of our pockets. It should be used for the puposes intended, and not whatever you damn well please. Especially when using it for your time wasting means the school or library cannot carry out it's intended purpose without having to spend extra money.

Heck even universities with MUCH larger IT budgets than your average school have to curtail use of huge wastes of badnwidth like myspace, facebook, etc.or turn off the network connection altogether.

You deal with this problem with policy, punishment, and if it comes to it lawsuits for theft of services. If need be reform that last one there, but don't go claiming it is for the children.

As for free speech, I wish idiots owuld get it thorugh their heads that YOUR freedom to say what you want doesn't require ME to have to listen to you, or ANYONE to provide you with a venue where you can say it.

You don't flip out because NBC doesn't give you and hour of primetime to say what you want. It's no different when your local school doesn't give you free internet access and web hosting to blog.
 
Heck even universities with MUCH larger IT budgets than your average school have to curtail use of huge wastes of badnwidth like myspace, facebook, etc.or turn off the network connection altogether.
I don't really so how it's a waste. Some people go online for myspace, others go online for other stuff.
You don't flip out because NBC doesn't give you and hour of primetime to say what you want. It's no different when your local school doesn't give you free internet access and web hosting to blog.
please read
 
No, this does not break the first amendment.

On the other hand it is very silly. The schools do not want anything but a controlled environment. They don't want incorrect ideas being introduced to their students. They want to control those little skulls full of mush, and make them into good productive little liberals.
This comment is so full of it, I don't even know where to begin.

In my state alone, in the past two years, we've had several Amber alerts that started by a teen being lured into a dangerous situation by someone who lied about their identity through MySpace. We've had one situation where a teen videotaped two others (underage) in an intimate encounter and posted it on a social networking site; the female subject of the taping attempted suicide, and the student who made the tape and posted it got brought up on child pornography charges.

This has nothing to do with politics, and everything to do with a) liability (i.e., what if a school is sued by a parent because a situation like the above results from MySpace being available at school?), and b)non-academic content. Schools are paid to teach, and social networking is not a necessary academic exercise. Public schools are also required by federal law (CIPA, look it up) to filter their Internet traffic if they wish to receive federal funding. Without federal funding school districts (already many of whom are in dire financial need) aren't going to be able to provide, resulting in families moving to another school district, resulting in less state funding (since funding is determined on a dollars-per-student basis), creating a vicious circle that can drive a school district into the ground.

Sounds like you've never been in public school administration, or in an IT department. Maybe when you have, you'll know what issues are involved.
 
You think just getting MySpace banned is bad? Try this:

My workstation:

-500MB of Keyloggers from the TDSB (Freezes all the time)
-Video splice (Board can see what I'm doing)
-No forums (I nearly got banned for visiting this site during school)
-No social networking
-No MSN/ Yahoo IM
-No Games
-No Porn (Horrible incident last year in the library forced the board to actually strictly implement this)

If we break one of the rules, the board sends out reps (Everybody calls them the "Men in Black") to talk with us and to indefinitely ban the account. There's an auto fail in my class if you get banned.

Man I wished that I had the level everybody's whining about.
 
You think just getting MySpace banned is bad? Try this:

My workstation:

-500MB of Keyloggers from the TDSB (Freezes all the time)
-Video splice (Board can see what I'm doing)
-No forums (I nearly got banned for visiting this site during school)
-No social networking
-No MSN/ Yahoo IM
-No Games
-No Porn (Horrible incident last year in the library forced the board to actually strictly implement this)

If we break one of the rules, the board sends out reps (Everybody calls them the "Men in Black") to talk with us and to indefinitely ban the account. There's an auto fail in my class if you get banned.

Man I wished that I had the level everybody's whining about.

That's almost inhumane. Where the hell do you go?
 
I don't really so how it's a waste. Some people go online for myspace, others go online for other stuff.

Because if you push 100megabits over your network to conduct school business. i.e. research, payroll, purchase orders, class mailing lists, campus security, etc. ANd you have 100megabits of network, then the 20megabits of myspace, the 30 megabits of youtube, the 95 megabits of whatever flavor of p2p happens to be this month means the school can't go about being a school because of non-school BS on the network.

That's how.
 
I get around all that, They cant block everything unless there that dumb.

They way i do it, easy, https://hidebehind.net/ all you need to do is put a link (ex youtube.com) and it will load it up for you. They cant track you (from the computer anyway...) but for does of you that think that you can do bit torrent on a school computer. good luck...

* I will not be held repsonsible for your problems using this site *
 
school it admins just need to block it, and anyone caught using methods to go around the block should get a warning and if that doesnt stop htem they shouldnt be allowed on hte internet at all. I grew up without access to computers, finding books etc for information they can do the same.
 
I honestly couldnt give a shi*, First off being that classes in most public schools are 45 mins, at least where i went to school. Students need to make the most out of time for computer class. Alot of people i had with me in class didn't do anything but watch music videos, play games at at games sites, and look at shoes/cars/etc.

By the end of class they hadn't completed no work. I say ban myspace and other social networking sites from all schools during class periods. Maybe there could be a timer that removes the IP ban as soon as school ends, so people browsing after school can go there. Why would you even want to browse myspace during schools, heck, i had like 2000 people in my school, thats enough socializing for me. what could you possibly need myspace for? I mean yes, when you go to university you want to keep in touch with your friends, etc. So for university it is acceptable, then again your own personal PC or laptop is basically required when entering University, so do your myspace on that, not the schools PC.
 
This does not violate freedom of speech. You own your mouth, not your school's computers.

Exactly. If the schools own the computers then they have the authority to block whatever website they feel like it.

So they can block pr0n but not Myspace?

Besides, last time I checked those little punks in high school need to pay attention to their school work and maybe their grades wont suck ass.

Like I tell my 16 year old daughter when she can't talk to someone online cause their not on AIM, try the phone dummy!!
 
Because if you push 100megabits over your network to conduct school business. i.e. research, payroll, purchase orders, class mailing lists, campus security, etc. ANd you have 100megabits of network, then the 20megabits of myspace, the 30 megabits of youtube, the 95 megabits of whatever flavor of p2p happens to be this month means the school can't go about being a school because of non-school BS on the network.

That's how.
The only problem I have with your argument is qualifiing myspace as "BS" and "waste." I'm not a big fan of myspace, but people are free to do what they please with themselves. I don't go around calling myspace names and I don't think you should either. If you don't like myspace, then ignore them.

I'd also like to remind people that government functions for the citizens benefit. I consider letting children access myspace at school a public good, although I dislike some aspects of the system. I think it's more good than bad.
 
Thanks loco laptop, all communications with address 64.72.125.239 (hidebehinde.net) are now restricted from my district, thanks for helping me kill this proxy.

piako: Its easy to classify myspace and all other sites in this bill as rubbish, zero educational value, disruptive behavior, entertainment, and security risk. Students do not <i>need</i> any of these sites. They also do not <i>need</i> to chat, e-mail (until college level), play games, or just generally surf.

Now some of these things in a library may be unwanted but might be ok, however you also have to remember that if anything happens to these kids, if they are exposed to anything, if they are found to be harmed by whatever happens, it is the school that is to blame.
 
The only problem I have with your argument is qualifiing myspace as "BS" and "waste." I'm not a big fan of myspace, but people are free to do what they please with themselves. I don't go around calling myspace names and I don't think you should either. If you don't like myspace, then ignore them.

I'd also like to remind people that government functions for the citizens benefit. I consider letting children access myspace at school a public good, although I dislike some aspects of the system. I think it's more good than bad.

Not to argue with you or anything, but seriously, what positive contribution has myspace done for society vs all the negative things it has delivered?
 
piako: Its easy to classify myspace and all other sites in this bill as rubbish, zero educational value, disruptive behavior, entertainment, and security risk. Students do not <i>need</i> any of these sites. They also do not <i>need</i> to chat, e-mail (until college level), play games, or just generally surf.
I completely disagree. How arrogant you are to describe what someone else needs. What is this communism? People decide for themselves what they need. You do not tell them what they need.
Not to argue with you or anything, but seriously, what positive contribution has myspace done for society vs all the negative things it has delivered?
You proved my point yet again. Responding qualitatively is dangerous. Students should be able to access any page they wish while at school. If the speech of any page they access violates classes of unprotected speech that site should be banned. How does myspace meet the criterial of unprotected speech? It doesn't. This is freaking communism. Makes me so angry.
 
You proved my point yet again. Responding qualitatively is dangerous. Students should be able to access any page they wish while at school. If the speech of any page they access violates classes of unprotected speech that site should be banned. How does myspace meet the criterial of unprotected speech? It doesn't. This is freaking communism. Makes me so angry.

So little johnny can surf !!!!!! and pron while learning about history?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top