Intel 945gm > geforce go 7400?

MichaelJB

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
272
Hi i recently purchased a new laptop (hp pavilion dv6000), dual core 1.6Ghz, 2gig ram, and geforce go 7400 256mb.

i benched marked it against an older machine (toshiba satelite), single core 1.8Ghz, 512mb ram, and mobile intel 945GM Express Chipset 64mb.

the newer machine outperformed the older machine in all areas except graphics, in which the intel was almost twice as fast as the nvidia card.

benchmarking software used: passmark
also tested real life performance, intel plays bf2142, cs:s and eve-online all better than the nvidia.

My question is: is this suppost to be like this? is this intel card better than my new nvidia card? or is there something wrong?

i did noticed the nvidia came underclocked from HP (400 core, 700 mem) compared to the standard 400 core, 900 mem on the nvidia website. But should this really make the geforce just half as good as the intel?

i also tried changing the drivers, but i had no luck, i tried both the geforce drivers and geforce go drivers on the nvidia website but neither worked.

any suggestions?
 
I have a feeling that the old one has dedicated graphics memory and the new one doesn't. The new one must be using the same memory as the rest of the system which is generally about as slow as a mole compared to a rabbit compared to normal graphics card dedicated memory.

Take it back!
 
I have a feeling that the old one has dedicated graphics memory and the new one doesn't. The new one must be using the same memory as the rest of the system which is generally about as slow as a mole compared to a rabbit compared to normal graphics card dedicated memory.

Take it back!

quite the opposite infact, the nvidia card has the dedicated memory and the intel ciphons off my ram, this is why im so confused, all common sense seems to lead me to believe the nvidia card should perform better, but thats simply not the case.

any other ideas? anyone else used the card before?
 
Tried a clean install using the driver uninstall and reinstall walkthrough found here: http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=965852'

?
 
Tried a clean install using the driver uninstall and reinstall walkthrough found here: http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=965852'

?

yes, but when it cam around to installing the drivers again none of the ones from nvidia website would work, they just say failed to find compatible hardware then the installation stops, so each time i have to revert back to original drivers that came with the comp.

Mabey you know another place i can try drivers from? ill let u know if iv already tried any that are posted
 
My cousing has a Go 7400 in his Sony laptop and I've seen it in action. Nice card, orders of magnitude more powerful than the pathetic 945GM
 
A friend of mine has a Laptop with both a geForce 7400 Go and a Intel GMA945 it allows you switch between the two for better battery life. Is it possible you have this feature and are stuck in 945 mode?
 
Mabey you know another place i can try drivers from? ill let u know if iv already tried any that are posted

Do you have a cd that has the original mfg's drivers on them? You could try reinstalling the original in the same fashion as if you were whiping and then installing a new driver.

~Adam
 
A friend of mine has a Laptop with both a geForce 7400 Go and a Intel GMA945 it allows you switch between the two for better battery life. Is it possible you have this feature and are stuck in 945 mode?

just checked my model on manufacturer website, it doesnt look likely that iv got 2 grpahics chipsets, think i just have the go 7400. Desktop properties only shows the go 7400.

Do you have a cd that has the original mfg's drivers on them? You could try reinstalling the original in the same fashion as if you were whiping and then installing a new driver.

~Adam

already tried this.

Mabey theres something else affecting it? the only thing installed on the new laptop that isnt on the old one is norton internet security, i couldn't possibly see how this could make a difference, but ill disable it when im next at the lappy and report back.

Thx for all the replies so far :)
 
why not try something else to benchmark? maybe the geforce just doesn't like that benchmark you're using

you could always do what the [H] do for graphics reviews...load up the same game on each (something more recent to give them a workout) and then push the settings to just playable. see who wins. might be easier than keeping track of framerates after all....
 
why not try something else to benchmark? maybe the geforce just doesn't like that benchmark you're using

you could always do what the [H] do for graphics reviews...load up the same game on each (something more recent to give them a workout) and then push the settings to just playable. see who wins. might be easier than keeping track of framerates after all....

He said that BF2142 and CS:S run worse on it than the intel also. Something simple and obvious but worth a try...did you check the power saving settings? Don't know about all laptops but on my friends dell it has some menu to go betwee most performance, in between, and most battery life.
 
did you make sure you're downloading nvidia GO driviers?

yes, but they still said i dont have compatible hardware, also the nvidia site says the the go drivers are for 7800 and 7900, they dont mention 7400, but i tried anyway.

He said that BF2142 and CS:S run worse on it than the intel also. Something simple and obvious but worth a try...did you check the power saving settings? Don't know about all laptops but on my friends dell it has some menu to go betwee most performance, in between, and most battery life.

tell me more about these, i was plugged in all along if that makes a difference?

also the benchmarking software i was using was passmark. Ill post the result files if you like.
 
Your 945GM runs CSS?

Mine runs it... DX7, all minimum, 2-3fps. :confused:

im definatly able to play cs:s with playable framerates (25 - 60) on dx8 med settings, would you mind using the benchmarking software i mentioned above and test your 945GM so i can see what your scores are compared to mine.

mabey iv been looking at this from the wrong angle, mabey my 7400 doesnt have a problem, but rarther the 945GM is somehow different? mine uses 64mb from my ram i think, how about yours?

also anyone else with a 7400 if you could post some benchmarks, or just average fps in cs:s with settings and system specs, that would be most useful.
 
PassMark(TM) PerformanceTest 6.1 (http://www.passmark.com)
Results generated on: Friday, January 26, 2007


Benchmark Results

Test Name: This Computer
CPU - Integer Math: 123.6
CPU - Floating Point Math: 389.1
CPU - Find Prime Numbers: 417.3
CPU - SSE/3DNow!: 3267.5
CPU - Compression: 3276.4
CPU - Encryption: 21.4
CPU - Image Rotation: 534.0
CPU - String Sorting: 1713.0
Graphics 2D - Lines: 78.5
Graphics 2D - Rectangles: 50.2
Graphics 2D - Shapes: 24.2
Graphics 2D - Fonts and Text: 85.0
Graphics 2D - GUI: 333.6
Graphics 3D - Simple: 299.6
Graphics 3D - Medium: 50.0
Graphics 3D - Complex: 7.3
Memory - Allocate Small Block: 1226.0
Memory - Read Cached: 1176.5
Memory - Read Uncached: 1155.6
Memory - Write: 757.4
Memory - Large RAM: 211.8
Disk - Sequential Read: 45.3
Disk - Sequential Write: 45.2
Disk - Random Seek + RW: 2.7
CPU Mark: 867.2
2D Graphics Mark: 324.6
Memory Mark: 334.7
Disk Mark: 337.2
3D Graphics Mark: 114.2
PassMark Rating: 421.0

System information: This Computer
CPU Manufacturer: GenuineIntel
Number of CPU: 1
(2 Core(s)/CPU, 1 Logical(s)/Core)
CPU Type: Genuine Intel(R) CPU L2400 @ 1.66GHz
CPU Speed: 1660.4 MHz
Cache size: 2048KB
O/S: Windows XP (WIN32)
Total RAM: 1270.4 MB.
Available RAM: 584.5 MB.
Video settings: 1280x1024x32
Video driver:
DESCRIPTION: Mobile Intel(R) 945GM Express Chipset Family
MANUFACTURER: Mobile Intel(R) 945GM Express Chipset Family
BIOS: Hardware Version 0.0
DATE: 11/16/20
Drive Letter: C
Total Disk Space: 83.4 GBytes
Cluster Size: 4.0 KBytes
File system: NTFS


________________________________________________________
Driver Device Information (Under the Information Button in the Intel Graphics Media driver program

Intel(R) Graphics Media Accelerator Driver for Mobile Report


Report Date: 01/26/2007
Report Time[hr:mm:ss]: 22:54:48
Driver Version: 6.14.10.4693
Operating System: Windows XP* Professional, Service Pack 2 (5.1.2600)
Default Language: English
DirectX* Version: 9.0
Physical Memory: 1270 MB
Minimum Graphics Memory: 8 MB
Maximum Graphics Memory: 224 MB
Graphics Memory in Use: 11 MB
Processor: x86 family 6 Model 14 Stepping 8
Processor Speed: 1662 MHZ
Vendor ID: 8086
Device ID: 27A2
Device Revision: 03


* Accelerator Information *

Accelerator in Use: Mobile Intel(R) 945GM Express Chipset Family
Video BIOS: 1313
Current Graphics Mode: 1280 by 1024 True Color (85 Hz)
 
I have played half life 2 on an onboard intel grpahics card before, it runs... barely playable at 640x480 but it's still "terrible" compared to any lowend dx8 card such as a 4200, a 9600, etc.

Perhaps you should check your cpu/gpu temps if you can? Find out how well the cpu performs in benchies compared to other cpus of the same type... I'm kinda out of ideas at this point. Ahhh, wait, perhaps your DirectX is messed up. Try going to start>run and typing in "dxdiag" and using the DirectX built-in software to see if DX is running correctly and if it says it is I'd reinstall the latest version just in case.

K now I'm outa ideas.
 
intel 945GM

Graphics 2D - Lines: 87.5
Graphics 2D - Rectangles: 49.8
Graphics 2D - Shapes: 27.1
Graphics 2D - Fonts and Text: 105.8
Graphics 2D - GUI: 132.3
Graphics 3D - Simple: 270.1
Graphics 3D - Medium: 54.0
Graphics 3D - Complex: 7.7

Geforce go 7400

Graphics 2D - Lines: 109.5
Graphics 2D - Rectangles: 117.5
Graphics 2D - Shapes: 26.1
Graphics 2D - Fonts and Text: 96.5
Graphics 2D - GUI: 138.3
Graphics 3D - Simple: 187.3
Graphics 3D - Medium: 35.6
Graphics 3D - Complex: 23.6

Although these result dont entirely show twice the performance (a little exageration in my first post :eek: ). The real world performance, ie games, show the intel always matching or besting my 7400, which is a disappointment as from what people have pointed out my 7400 should really be leaveing the 945gm in its dust.

What also is surprising is that your result are similar to my 945gm results, yet you cant play cs, this is very strange, i notice on your spec is says graphics memory is currently using 11mb, mabey a problem with that?
 
also here is the full spec of the toshiba satelite. mabey someone notices something that might help graphics performance?

Processor type : Intel® Core™ Solo Processor T1350
clock speed : 1.86 GHz
Front Side Bus : 533 MHz
2nd level cache : 2 MB
Operating system Genuine Windows® XP Home Edition
System memory standard : 512 MB
maximum expandability : 4,096 MB
technology : DDR2 RAM (533 MHz)
Hard disk capacity : 60 GB
certification : S.M.A.R.T.
CD-RW/DVD-ROM drive maximum speed : Read: 24x CD-ROM, 8x DVD-ROM/ Write: 24x CD-R, 4x CD-RW, 10x HS CD-RW, 24x US CD-RW
Display size : 15.4 "
type : WXGA TFT display
internal resolution : 1,280 x 800
Graphics adaptor manufacturer : Intel®
type : 945GM Express chipset
memory : up to 128 MB
memory type : DDR2 RAM (UMA)
Internal video modes resolution : 1,280 x 800
maximum number of colours : 16.7 Million
Max External Video Modes Max Resolution : 2,048 x 1,536
Max Colours : 16.7 Million
Max Refresh Rate : 100 Hz
Non-interlaced resolution with max refresh rate : 1,600 x 1,200
Interfaces 1 x DC-in
1 x external monitor
1 x RJ-11
1 x RJ-45
1 x external microphone
1 x headphone (stereo)
3 x USB 2.0
1 x SD™ card slot (supports SD™ memory card, SD™ IO card)
Expansion 2 x memory slots (1 to configure)
type : PC Card slot for 1x Type II card
Wireless communication Compliancy : Wi-Fi®
Network Support : 802.11b/g integrated
Wireless Technology : Wireless LAN
Wired communication topology : international V.92 modem
speed : 56 Kbps data (V.92) and 14.4 Kbps fax (V.17)
topology : Gigabit Ethernet LAN
speed : 10BASE-T/100BASE-TX/1000BASE-T
Sound system supported audio format : 24-bit stereo
supported sound standards : MIDI support
speakers : built-in stereo speakers
Keyboard keys : 87
Windows keys : 2
Hot Keys : 1
special features : spill-resistant keyboard
Pointing device type : Touch Pad
interface : PS/2
Battery technology : lithium-ion
maximum life : up to 4:00 (Mobile Mark™) hours
AC adaptor input voltage : autosensing AC adapter (100/240 V) for worldwide usage
Physical dimensions W x D x H : 368 x 268 x 29.8/36.9 mm
weight : 2.80 kg
Warranty 1-year international warranty. Upgrade your standard warranty with Toshiba warranty extension, uplift and all-risks insurance packs.
Bundled hardware AC adaptor
Bundled software Toshiba Management Console
ConfigFree™
Microsoft® Office OneNote ™ 2003
Sonic¿ Record Now!
InterVideo® WinDVD Creator (2Platinum)
Toshiba Summit
InterVideo® WinDVD™
on-line user's and modem manual
Toshiba utilities and drivers
Connectivity Doctor
Toshiba EasyGuard Wireless LAN Switch
Toshiba Anti-theft Protection Timer
Norton Internet Security 2005 Antivirus Software (90 Day Trial)
Toshiba Summit
Diversity Antenna
Toshiba ConfigFree™
slot for Kensington Cable Lock
PC Diagnostics
Spill-resistant Keyboard
HDD Protection (3D Sensor to protect data)
Shock Protection Design
Durable Design
Data Backup
Easy Fix Components
Toshiba Device Access Control
Password Utility
Security features system password security
keyboard lock
main memory (by screw)
BIOS password
HDD password on request
main battery pack (by sliding latch)
main hard disk (by screw)
user password
supervisor password
Special features SM BIOS compliant
Toshiba Enhanced SpeedStep
Toshiba Zooming utility
Toshiba Power Saver utility
Certification The manufacturer declares that this product complies with the following directives and regulations for the CE-marking. Responsible for CE marking is Toshiba Europe GmbH, Hammfelddam 8, 41460 Neuss, Germany.
 
www.laptopvideo2go.com

should be good drivers there.

I'm quoting this post because I didn't see whether or not you tried these drivers yet, and there's a link to 100.40 drivers right on the front page, with a c/p of the INF file saying that it supports three different versions of the GeForce Go 7400.
 
I have played half life 2 on an onboard intel grpahics card before, it runs... barely playable at 640x480 but it's still "terrible" compared to any lowend dx8 card such as a 4200, a 9600, etc.

Perhaps you should check your cpu/gpu temps if you can? Find out how well the cpu performs in benchies compared to other cpus of the same type... I'm kinda out of ideas at this point. Ahhh, wait, perhaps your DirectX is messed up. Try going to start>run and typing in "dxdiag" and using the DirectX built-in software to see if DX is running correctly and if it says it is I'd reinstall the latest version just in case.

K now I'm outa ideas.

i have a geofrce fx5200 on my desktop, which is capable of playing cs at 15 - 25 fps on low settings, this is comparable to what the 7400 achieves, yet its running at twice the speed :eek:

of all 3 computers, my desky is the slowest. ill post the passmark results for it later, it probably wont help, but it definatly cant hurt ;)
 
I'm quoting this post because I didn't see whether or not you tried these drivers yet, and there's a link to 100.40 drivers right on the front page, with a c/p of the INF file saying that it supports three different versions of the GeForce Go 7400.

i totally missed this post, thx for pointing it out, im downloading them now. Althought the 100.40 drivers are for vista, there are some newer xp drivers that i can get instead :D
 
If this message appears twice im sorry, iv posted it once but it seems the forum didnt get it.

I unistalled and cleaned (twice) my drivers, i tried the latest driver for xp from the site mentioned above, and i got the same (no compatible hardware found, setup will now terminate) error. I then tried the vista drive, but they gave me a "vista not found" style of error (go figure, as im on xp :rolleyes: ).

The site mentions hacked inf files, i briefly read about these but am still a little confused, mabey i need one of these? i would of just assumed they were included in the driver download, but mabey there not. Any way if someone could clear up if i need one of these to get the drivers to install id be most greatful.

Thx for sticking with this guys, hopefully ill have the problem resolved soon.
 
Bump for myself, as im currently sitting without drivers. Anyone know how to modify inf files so i can get the drivers to install on my laptop?
 
ok, i managed to get the information i was looking for on the laptopvideo2go forums, installed 3 different sets of newer drivers but results are only marginally different. so after all that im back to square 1, drivers dont seem to be the issue, any other suggestions?
 
Everything seems fine, I ran dxdiag, reinstalled intel's drivers, performance hasn't changed. No biggie, it works in everything else (warcraft III) so I will try a reinstall at some point of CSS.
 
Maybe the lower performance is because you're running in DX9 instead of the 945GM's DX8?

In CS:S, try using the command 'mat_dxlevel 81' in the console. See if that helps.
 
DirectX reported no errors, im not sure how to reinstall, i have the latest version so i cant update, and there is no directx in the add/remove programs window.

could someone with a go 7400 of there own please run the bechmarking software so i can see roughly the result i should be obtaining, just the graphics test will surfice.
 
What level AA and AF are you running? Triple buffering or double?

I suggest no AA and no AF and triple buffering. You can find the settings that override all ingame settings in the nvidia driver software that stays resident in your memory on your taskbar.

~Adam
 
No AA, no AF, all settings lowest possible, dxlevel 70.

:(

Very strange right?
 
I just ran 3dmark06 and got a result of 823, according to link provided above i should be around the 800 mark, so it appears from this point of view theres no problem. mabey i should just update my card. (can that even be done on my laptop?)
 
Dual Core: the 945 drivers are using the 2nd core on a C2D for assistance quite well which is one reason why you're getting better results on the 945 than the 7400.

The other reason is probably quality. Take some screenshots of your benchmarks. I've seen reviews where at supposedly all of the same in game settings, etc.. the integrated graphics are cheating on the quality.
 
Dual Core: the 945 drivers are using the 2nd core on a C2D for assistance quite well which is one reason why you're getting better results on the 945 than the 7400.

The other reason is probably quality. Take some screenshots of your benchmarks. I've seen reviews where at supposedly all of the same in game settings, etc.. the integrated graphics are cheating on the quality.

this guy may have hit it on the head, altho i couldnt tell the difference in quality (but i dont pretend to be any expert). Either way i cant take pics as i'v sold the toshiba on. But thx for all the help in this thread.
 
Back
Top