Your Smart-Home Network Will Be A Mess

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This is just one of the many reasons I'm fine not owning a smart-home. If everything used a universal standard, that would be different. But, as it is, I'll pass on owning smart-home for now.

Light bulbs, refrigerators, sprinklers and door locks soon will be a lot smarter. Too bad they'll have trouble talking to each other. Welcome to the chaotic underside of the smart-home vision, once all those humble devices start trying to communicate over a hodgepodge of wireless network standards.
 
I work in the home automation industry and I can honestly say that this article is spot on.

The sheer amount of shit that needs to talk to each other over wireless (Z-Wave, Bluetooth, Wifi (b/g/n/a/AC/AD), wireless HDMI, etc) is nuts. In order to support all of these protocols we have to build in a mountain of extra parts just to make sure we cover the basics. With the advent of voice recognition (Amazon Echo, Siri, Google Now, Cortana) every other API needs to be covered so we can understand what you are saying while shoving a burrito laced with feathers into your mouth and make it happen.

We get so many phone calls from clueless installers who have no idea how any of this works that we've created a small network kit for them to plugin to the network and run a myriad of diagnostics that spits back a remote connection to our systems where we can tunnel in if needbe.

Every kid from 6th grade on up needs a basic course in networking in order to survive the coming onslaught of Internet of Things.
 
I've been playing with home automation for about a year. It is kind of messy.
I have a Wink hub that controls some lights, door locks, garage door, etc. I also have a few Belkin WeMo products to control plugs (one is a smart outlet so I can reset my Wink Hub when it jams up).
I have two apps on my phone - can kind of do a little integration with IFTT.

I recently set up the web app Home Assistant. Its goal is to integrate with the various devices and provide a single interface. I have it working with my Wink, but it hasn't discovered my WeMo devices yet (need to troubleshoot it). It's under heavy development - nice solution, but it shows the demand for a single interface.

I want to add an Amazon Echo to my house soon - these are nice (but yet another interface).
 
I love the idea of it all but every device running in isolation is no smart home at all
 
Smart homes and smart cars are not yet such a smart idea. IMO we need solid standards and security first.
 
My home automation has been in the works for about 8 years now. It came to fruition in 2007 after many nights of work. At first it took a lot of programming to get it to do the most basic task, there was a lot of baby sitting involved to make sure it didn't go berserk.

I'm at the point where its almost fully voice control, but sometimes it takes a stern kick in the rear to get it to do what I want it to do.

How it works:

Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: What?
Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: Now?
Me: Yes.
Daughter: ok


Me: Turn on the lights
Daughter: Why can't you do it?
Me: Now.
Daughter: No. You're not the boss of me.
Me: Now!
Daughter: OK! I hate you! You're so bossy.
 
My home automation has been in the works for about 8 years now. It came to fruition in 2007 after many nights of work. At first it took a lot of programming to get it to do the most basic task, there was a lot of baby sitting involved to make sure it didn't go berserk.

I'm at the point where its almost fully voice control, but sometimes it takes a stern kick in the rear to get it to do what I want it to do.

How it works:

Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: What?
Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: Now?
Me: Yes.
Daughter: ok

Looks like you installed the same home automation system that I did :)

Biggest problem is the on-going costs and the poor response time, especially after 18 years.
Also usually doesn't work in the middle of the night.
 
I can see the appeal of automating lights, thermostat adjustment, audio/video, cameras, etc. But I draw the line at door locks and wiping my A*S! I prefer that my door locks stay unplugged thank you.
 
My home automation has been in the works for about 8 years now. It came to fruition in 2007 after many nights of work. At first it took a lot of programming to get it to do the most basic task, there was a lot of baby sitting involved to make sure it didn't go berserk.

I'm at the point where its almost fully voice control, but sometimes it takes a stern kick in the rear to get it to do what I want it to do.

How it works:

Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: What?
Me: Go get daddy a bottle of water
Daughter: Now?
Me: Yes.
Daughter: ok


Me: Turn on the lights
Daughter: Why can't you do it?
Me: Now.
Daughter: No. You're not the boss of me.
Me: Now!
Daughter: OK! I hate you! You're so bossy.

My automation system is only 4 years old, hopefully it'll work as good as your soon. Usually it just says no, starts screaming, and then cries and sits there :p I should have bought a bunch more of the x10 firecracker kits when they were cheap in 1999.
 
I'm an electrician and automation programmer, looking forward to build my own home automation in a few years when I build my own house. A lot easier to tie everything from the lights to the thermostat into each other when you build the system yourself :p
 
I'm an electrician and automation programmer, looking forward to build my own home automation in a few years when I build my own house. A lot easier to tie everything from the lights to the thermostat into each other when you build the system yourself :p

Not only that you are likely going to hardwire everything in your self so it actually works. The part about all of the automation hardware you see in stores is they are all really poor products. What I see are dumbed down because it has to be easy for an average person to install. Case in point, a smart bulb that you control from your phone. What's the point of that? You can no longer use your wall switch or the lamp switch because if you cut power to it, it's not going to turn on any more. Are you going to fire up your phone each time you want to turn the light on and off? When it dies you can't replace a $6 bulb, you need to replace a $70 bulb.

You can put real systems in place like UPB which replace the physical switches with soft ones. They will not only allow you to have creative light controls, but can be tied to other systems so you have physical controls of other things, or you can integrate their controls into voice automation, touch screens, or even just link them to some thing else entirely. Open the garage door, that can trigger the system to automatically turn on adjacent lights so you don't have to fiddle in the dark to find them. Set the alarm on your way out the door, you can have the system setup to send a command to turn off all lights in the house, in case you forgot about some. Rather than buying an expensive garage door opener system and having to have a separate app just to control the door, you can integrate that as well. (Just about any garage system could be added for like $10 in parts)
 
The only thing that I want for automation is a smart thermostat. If I want a light on, I will turn it on and then it is off when I am done needing it. I also don't nee a smart fridge as I always know exactly what, and how much, is in it. I live alone so this is simple. Also if you plan before you go to the store to buy food and take inventory before hand, you have no need for a smart fridge.
 
Back
Top