X1800XT vs 7900GT

Status
Not open for further replies.
tim-x said:
and on air a 7900GT CAN do 800mhz.

edit: if arguing about how your video card is so superior on a forum helps you fan boys sleep at night, that's fine with me. i'm done watching you google benchmarks that show negligible differences. If you can't follow the simple instructions to volt modding your 7900GT then you either must be very stupid, or have parkinson's.

You're one to call someone stupid, you call a 40% difference negligible. Also, you're arguably the only fan boy here :rolleyes:
 
I liked that unbiased 7900GT vs x1800xt review hardforum posted up from another site. It was neat, everytime the 7900GT was ahead by 1% margin or less it they made it seem like the 7900GT was spanking the x1800 and made that VERY clear. Everytime the x1800 was ahead, according to the guy in the review, it didn't matter because it wasn't a significant different. What the fuck kind of review was that? At the end when both cards were pretty much tied and it was tossup, the guy didn't mention the fact that they were almost even the whole time and the x1800xt has a few features the 7900GT didn't. He even went as far as to say the x1800xt did much better in a few game with AA/AF. Yet, despite that, the idiot recommended the 7900GT because of hte availibility, which from what i've seen, isn't as availible as the x1800xt. But that's just something i've noticed. I dont' know how much more availible a card has to be when it's in stock, at a bunch of popular sites and is equal to the price or cheaper than it's competitor.

I'm still not sure what card I want. It's pretty much whatever I can find that is cheaper. That x1800xt is looking mighty nice though.
 
sabrewolf732 said:
Can you use a calculator and figure out percent differances too? And I can post around 20 more for the 1800 than you can for the 7900. Read the article, god damn :rolleyes: Shoo !!!!!! shoo. The x1800xt 512MB is simply the better deal atm at $260.

yeah the x1800xt 512 definitely is a better deal at $260. at the same price however it's a toss up to preference. do you really think you'd notice a difference in games playing between either of the two cards? I'm willing to bet you couldn't tell the difference if you played on two comps, one with the x1800xt and one with the 7900gt. that was my point. But keep googling benchmarks if it makes you feel better.
 
sabrewolf732 said:
Actually running a 6600 right now :p

http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/images/bf21024.gif

LOL 1fps more? Im just saying what's better, and at $260 for the 1800xt 512 it's simply the better deal.
Yeah, but look at all the other benchmarks: For most FPS games (+ oblivion), the X1800XT does better.

HL2 LC: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page4.asp
Better at all resolutions.
BF2 : http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page5.asp
Much better at all resolutions.
Fear: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page9.asp
Better at all resoutions.
Call of Duty 2: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page10.asp
Significantly better at all resolutions.
Oblivion: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page12.asp
Decimating at all resoutions.
Far Cry: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page13.asp
That game sucks but the X1800XT is even with the 7900GT.

T-overclocking defense in 3...2...1...
 
ATI Wipes the floor with Nvidia and then some... You can even use Nvidia type toilet Paper if you're an ATI Guy like me. ;-)
 
Tilde said:
Yeah, but look at all the other benchmarks: For most FPS games (+ oblivion), the X1800XT does better.

HL2 LC: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page4.asp
Better at all resolutions.
BF2 : http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page5.asp
Much better at all resolutions.
Fear: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page9.asp
Better at all resoutions.
Call of Duty 2: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page10.asp
Significantly better at all resolutions.
Oblivion: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page12.asp
Decimating at all resoutions.
Far Cry: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page13.asp
That game sucks but the X1800XT is even with the 7900GT.

T-overclocking defense in 3...2...1...

Look at me! I can post benchmarks too!@!
http://images.planetamd64.com/athildja/X1800XT_Images/HL2.png
Looks like the x1800xt 512 is getting annihilated by the 7800GTX (of which the 7900GT is proven slightly better)

Look at me again, googling more benchmarks!
http://images.planetamd64.com/athildja/X1800XT_Images/FEAR.png
Do i see the 7800GTX outperforming it once again?

Once more
http://images.planetamd64.com/athildja/X1800XT_Images/COD2.png
CoD2. ouch... that must hurt...


And here we are at the end
http://www.planetx64.com/index.php?...sk=view&id=39&Itemid=14&limit=1&limitstart=10
looks like the 7800GTX 256 has beaten the x1800xt 512 in more benchmarks.... GOOGLE WINS!@!

Want more? From different sources I might add unlike you.
http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=30680
What's that? the x1800xt 512 getting beaten?

What have I proven? That I can go and google benchmarks that'll show me what i want to see. Now in real life performance.... negligible. You lose.
 
tim-x said:
Look at me! I can post benchmarks too!@!

Look at me again, googling more benchmarks!
http://images.planetamd64.com/athildja/X1800XT_Images/FEAR.png
Do i see the 7800GTX outperforming it once again?
Actually, no, you don't see that. You have to compare the Green and Brown bars, and frankly, comparing them across mobos is just a little silly. On the highest-performing ATI mobos, the X1800XT wins.
tim-x said:
I guess it would, were the X1800XT not getting better AVERAGE (not peak) framerates on most of the motherboards.
tim-x said:
And here we are at the end
http://www.planetx64.com/index.php?...sk=view&id=39&Itemid=14&limit=1&limitstart=10
looks like the 7800GTX 256 has beaten the x1800xt 512 in more benchmarks.... GOOGLE WINS!@!
"So I had to rely on stick performance. In this case it would appear that the two cards are tied." -- the article
tim-x said:
Want more? From different sources I might add unlike you.
http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=30680
What's that? the x1800xt 512 getting beaten?

What have I proven? That I can go and google benchmarks that'll show me what i want to see. Now in real life performance.... negligible. You lose.
Now what have I proven? Most people don't understand statistics - It's the average framerate that's most interesting, not the maximum. Real benchmark sites use top-quality reference hardware, allowing the card to really show itself off at its best. That site intentionally used low-quality boards because it was testing the boards - when you use video card tests, not mobo tests, the X1800XT wins. And even in half of the mobo tests you quoted, on top AMD boards, the X1800XT wins. If the best you can come up with is some stats, and half of which say I win, I think that means you lose, dude.
 
Tilde said:
Actually, no, you don't see that. You have to compare the Green and Brown bars, and frankly, comparing them across mobos is just a little silly. On the highest-performing ATI mobos, the X1800XT wins.

I guess it would, were the X1800XT not getting better AVERAGE (not peak) framerates on most of the motherboards.

"So I had to rely on stick performance. In this case it would appear that the two cards are tied." -- the article

Now what have I proven? Most people don't understand statistics - It's the average framerate that's most interesting, not the maximum. Real benchmark sites use top-quality reference hardware, allowing the card to really show itself off at its best. That site intentionally used low-quality boards because it was testing the boards - when you use video card tests, not mobo tests, the X1800XT wins. And even in half of the mobo tests you quoted, on top AMD boards, the X1800XT wins. If the best you can come up with is some stats, and half of which say I win, I think that means you lose, dude.

And the site you used had the 7900GT beating the x1800xt 512 mb in 5 out of the 11 benchmarks. So.... you're a hypocrite? Looks like you haven't come up with anything solid. You sure have showed me that the x1800xt 512 DESTROYS the 7900GT. Wanna try and tell me you could tell the difference if we put two computers with the same specs playing the same game but one with the x1800xt and one with the 7900GT? You're such an ati fan boy and haven't proven anything.
 
wow tim-x getting so worked up, funny to see his mad devotion to nvidia nontheless
 
acidic said:
wow tim-x getting so worked up, funny to see his mad devotion to nvidia nontheless

can you read? if you read my initial post i simply said to the OP that the performance differences were negligible and he'd be happy with either choice.

Edit: Let me clarify - it's my opinion that the x1800xt 512 is a much better buy at $260 as opposed to a more expensive 7900GT. The performance differences between the two are minimal with each beating the other in different googled benchmarks.
 
tim-x said:
And the site you used had the 7900GT beating the x1800xt 512 mb in 5 out of the 11 benchmarks. So.... you're a hypocrite? Looks like you haven't come up with anything solid. You sure have showed me that the x1800xt 512 DESTROYS the 7900GT. Wanna try and tell me you could tell the difference if we put two computers with the same specs playing the same game but one with the x1800xt and one with the 7900GT? You're such an ati fan boy and haven't proven anything.
Alright, let's look at those games:
7900GT Wins:
Quake 4
Lock On: Modern Air Combat
Pacific Fighters


X1800XT Wins:
Half-Life 2
Battlefield 2
F.E.A.R.
Call of Duty 2
Oblivion

Draw:
Far Cry

Btw, I'm going with this one: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page8.asp

I mean, ask yourself, which games do you play?
 
Tilde said:
Alright, let's look at those games:
7900GT Wins:
Quake 4
Lock On: Modern Air Combat
Pacific Fighters


X1800XT Wins:
Half-Life 2
Battlefield 2
F.E.A.R.
Call of Duty 2
Oblivion

Draw:
Far Cry

Btw, I'm going with this one: http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/powercolor_radeon_x1800_gto/page8.asp

I mean, ask yourself, which games do you play?

try and get more than 1 source of info buddy

edit: i've come up with 2 that say the 7900GT is better. If the x1800xt was marginally superior you'd think that all the reviews would go the same?
 
tim-x said:
and on air a 7900GT CAN do 800mhz.

edit: if arguing about how your video card is so superior on a forum helps you fan boys sleep at night, that's fine with me. i'm done watching you google benchmarks that show negligible differences. If you can't follow the simple instructions to volt modding your 7900GT then you either must be very stupid, or have parkinson's.


on stock cooler my X1800XT hit 800mhz core :/ so what? can you actually run a game with ur stock heatsink @ 800mhz and voltmod? or just run 3dmark with artifacts?
i
ts obvious which choice is more "logical" or convenient, both cards have an annoying whine, the X1800XT has a more annoying noise during gaming, but the 7900gt has a more audible idle noise one card gives you newer features, better support for PS3.0, and more ram doesn't require hardware modification to stay competitive,

who cares if EVGA BFG and XFX offer lifetime warranties when ur going to "vmod" it
some people like to actually buy something and have it work without moddifying it :)

are you seriously quoting THE INQUIRERs guestimation on the 7900GT as a source of INFO?
 
omg.. this dude was just wondering about a 7900gt and a X1800xt, and it has turned into Nvidia VS ati. how bout before you say anything stupid. you just leave. your argueing with people your never probibly going to meet in your life. so is it really worth pressing the issue?

the 7900gt and X1800xt are both excellent cards, and about the same, can we leave it at that?

both on a 90nm process, both score almost identical in 3dmark, both get great FPS in almost any game at 1600X1200, so they both kick ass.

edit: i love how some of you are refering 3-4 fps as "beating" the other card. i like that. becasue hmmmmm.... perhalps... when they tested it they were near water? where perhalps it was shader intensive and a little more suited to X1800XT? or the opposite? maybe it was in the desert and a little more Texture intensive... better suited for the 7900GT?

i have been struck by an idea, why dont we all stop beeing retarded?
 
how about this guys.

when benchmarking the 7900gt and the x1800xt512mb, both cards trade the top spot depending on the game.

OVERALL, when averaged, the performance differences between the two are negligeble. if you had to pick a winner, unbiased, it would probably be the x1800xt512mb, but even still, it doesn't usually win by a lot. really, they are pretty close.

so now, we look at features, both cards have basically the same features. but, the x1800xt does have 512mb of vram vs. the 256mb on the 7900gt. while nobody knows for sure, certain current games like COD 2, Quake 4, and FEAR that are either really shader intensive, or have really high res textures, or both, can and will benefit from having 512mb of ram. some times in the case of FEAR the benefit isn't huge, but its undeniably there, and sometimes in the case of COD 2 and Quake 4, its quite significant, and can be seen in an 512mb card from ATI or Nvidia. so, in the end here, the ATI x1800xt wins the features round slightly, because it can be plausibly assumed that in future games, it just might be able to edge out the 7900gt more significantly.

and last, we look at price. which ATI wins here hands down. right this second, you can get an x1800xt for $209 - $50 instantly. vs. the commonly seen $299-$219 price of $7900gt's.

without this special deal. you can get an x1800xt for $299. which is the same price as some of the $7900gt, but I'm gonna say that the x1800xt will be easier to get a hold of, because 7900gt's stock in small batches that sell out fast. even if they were easily available though, the x1800xt still wins in the features department, and therefore by a small margin can be declared the winner here.

also take into account the x1800xt 256mb, which sells everyday for about $270, only performs differently in aforementioned games that take advantage of the 512mb, and you've really got a clear winner on your hands.

still though, both cards are close enough, that its situational, based on preference and money. either card is gonna be just damn fine, so choose which one you want, not what other people say.

if you are unbiased though, the x1800xt 512mb is your card. if you need to save a few bucks, get the 256mb, but that's only after the special deal ends.
 
i see everyone yelling "ati fan boy" all the time... i guess this will fit then: NVIDIA FAN BOYS. suck it :cool:

just look on any review with highest settings (AA, AF, HDR etc etc) that ATI has better image quality without huge fps drops. theres one around with pics from HL2 where you are on the train tracks with brick wall on the left with white lines. NV cards just blur out after a while but ATI card just brilliantly keeps the line going all over the wall :eek:
 
Holy cow timx is ignorant to the facts. Name calling? Good job there. Oh well, just buring your head in the sand a little more and it will be ok.

All you need to do, is look at a real review such as FS, and its pretty obvious the XT is much faster. Its too bad more reputable sites didnt compare the XT and GT. You can find plent though that compare the XT and 7800GTX.
 
Plain and simple the OP's question was answered and he made his decision. We don't need this pointless bickering to continue, so you guys can go back to your respective corners.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top