Wtf [H] ?!?!!??

orkan

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 9, 2002
Messages
1,488
Ok... first the MSI K8N Neo4, now the DFI nForce4 board... and no review?

What gives?
 
I would settle for a DFI SLI-DR bord of my own and i would write a review although i never have before so it woulnt be all that great!
 
I may end up buying the SLI just for the 4 extra SATA connectors on the SI controller.
 
orkan said:
bah... you can have the sli... i want the ultra-d

Their pretty much the same exact board except the SLI-DR has more features like 8 SATA ports. They both have two x16 PCI-E slots. I was dissapointed that the Ultra-D only featured 4 SATA ports when the MSI Neo4 Platinum has 8.
 
Does it matter? Every board and video card that is reviewed gets high marks. No site says hardware is crappy anymore. Look at all the hard reviews. Every product is a work of art.
 
almostinsane1 said:
Does it matter? Every board and video card that is reviewed gets high marks. No site says hardware is crappy anymore. Look at all the hard reviews. Every product is a work of art.

Quite true.
 
almostinsane1 said:
Does it matter? Every board and video card that is reviewed gets high marks. No site says hardware is crappy anymore. Look at all the hard reviews. Every product is a work of art.
yup. unless the reviewer doesnt get free samples and pays for everything he/she reviews
 
burningrave101 said:
Their pretty much the same exact board except the SLI-DR has more features like 8 SATA ports. They both have two x16 PCI-E slots. I was dissapointed that the Ultra-D only featured 4 SATA ports when the MSI Neo4 Platinum has 8.

4 ports seems like a sensible number, but 8 seems a little redundant. The Ultra-D is fine for me. ;)
 
dIsRuPtIvE said:
4 ports seems like a sensible number, but 8 seems a little redundant. The Ultra-D is fine for me. ;)
Wouldn't that be the point? (Being redundant)
 
almostinsane1 said:
Does it matter? Every board and video card that is reviewed gets high marks. No site says hardware is crappy anymore. Look at all the hard reviews. Every product is a work of art.

See [H]ard's review of the Corsair liquid cooling system. Not only did it get low marks, but [H] refused to recommend it.

Unless I'm in the process of upgrading, (Like I am now) I rarely read reviews for hardware. This is one of a few bad reviews I've seen lately.

I tend to look more at the negatives than how many stars or numbers out of 10 the products recieve.
 
MrSlacker said:
yup. unless the reviewer doesnt get free samples and pays for everything he/she reviews
i know for a fact kyle dishes out tons of cash at newegg for stuff he reviews

think about this guys, its not like reviewers are gonna review a PC-Chips board, especially [H]. we're concerned with the high end of the PC market and typically, anything that is tuned for the enthusiast is going to be a good buy because the companies' rep is riding on that board/cpu/gfx card

and there are still instances of reviewers giving crappy reviews cuase the hardware is crappy. has everyone forgotten the FX series already?
 
Wesley at AT had said "AnandTech had an exclusive on this board which is why this is the first review posted of the DFI."

The reason for theirs being the first.
 
lithium726 said:
i know for a fact kyle dishes out tons of cash at newegg for stuff he reviews

think about this guys, its not like reviewers are gonna review a PC-Chips board, especially [H]. we're concerned with the high end of the PC market and typically, anything that is tuned for the enthusiast is going to be a good buy because the companies' rep is riding on that board/cpu/gfx card

and there are still instances of reviewers giving crappy reviews cuase the hardware is crappy. has everyone forgotten the FX series already?

The point is comparing high end stuff to high end stuff. And these days [H] and every other site gives every high end product a glowing review.

IS NOTHING CRAPPY ANYMORE????

This doesn't help the consumers buying decisions.
 
Just to prove my point, look at all the recent [H] reviews. Do they just not review shitty boards?


DFI 855GME-MGF:
DFI has a new weapon in its arsenal sure to capture the hearts and minds of enthusiasts everywhere.

ABIT Fatal1ty AA8XE:
The Fatal1ty AA8XE was designed to be a competitor, with attention to detail evident throughout the board.


DFI LanParty 875P-T:
The design of the LanParty series often satisfies even the most discerning enthusiast.


ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe
The A8N-SLI is a masterpiece, with very few problems encountered overall.


Intel D925XECV2 :
Once again, Intel proves their mettle as a motherboard manufacturer with the introduction of the D925XECV2. The board’s design and layout is nothing short of commendable, with only a few tight areas to take note of.


ASUS P5AD2-E Premium :
There’s a reason why ASUS is revered among enthusiasts, and this board clearly demonstrates that reason.

Shuttle SB77G5 :
Shuttle seems to have another winner on their hands with the SB77G5.



Does Hardocp ever review anything bad? I think if you just send them something they will give you stellar reviews. But I'm not faulting [H], every site is like this. They should be reviewing high end stuff against high end stuff. In every other market some come out on top and others are on the bottom. When you read hw reviews everthing is the best you can buy. WTF? As a consumer I expect these sites to give me non biased reviews with the best of their abilities. When the give everything a glowing review it makes me want to find a new site and not give them any of my traffic.


Just because it is written on the Internet doesn't mean it's true!!!!!!!
 
Yeah selective reading can net you whatever end result you wish

The Bottom Line:

When it comes right down to it though, with the experiences we witnessed in gaming with the Gigabyte 3D1 6600 GT SLI versus a GeForce 6800 GT single, we had a more consistent and better experience with the single GeForce 6800 GT. In the times in FarCry when the SFR SLI wasn’t working too well, the GeForce 6800 GT was faster. In Need for Speed Underground 2 and other games where SLI isn’t enabled, a single GeForce 6800 GT is faster. When you look closely at the pricing, you’ll find that a single GeForce 6800 GT with a motherboard is around the same price as the Gigabyte bundle. Again, what we would really like to see is two GeForce 6800 GTs in SLI on one board. Now that would be interesting…

Oh and I can paste selective text from one of the same reviews you did, too! :p

Looking back over the entire hype and pimping of this board for months now, one question still pops to mind. If you are going to build a “gamer’s motherboard,” why the hell are you doing leading off with an Intel system? It is no big secret that AMD Athlon 64 systems are king of the hill when it comes to gaming these days, and very few folks are going to throw down the big dollars it takes to get into a new Pentium 4 system if they are in fact a hardcore gamer. We do know that the AMD Fatal1ty line is coming, and we are surely waiting to see those products. I do have to admit, it takes some cojones to put your name on a statement as bold as the one quoted above, when it simply is not the truth. It seems as though Jonathan has gotten taken in a bit by the multi-million dollar marketing machine around him or he does not know what makes a gaming rig the “fastest.” Call me cynical, but I am going to bet it is the former.
 
I just hope the [H] crew test the DFI with the big Zalman and Thermalright 120 coolers with some "tall" memory like the Crucial 3200XL.

The CPU socket is too close to the mem banks to my taste.

:eek:






I may be wrong btw :D
 
Erc said:
I just hope the [H] crew test the DFI with the big Zalman and Thermalright 120 coolers with some "tall" memory like the Crucial 3200XL.

The CPU socket is too close to the mem banks to my taste.

This board is for watercoolers and phasers only plz. :)
 
orkan said:
This board is for watercoolers and phasers only plz. :)
confused.gif
what in the world are you talking about? not everyone can afford watercooling, myself included.
 
lithium726 said:
confused.gif
what in the world are you talking about? not everyone can afford watercooling, myself included.

Dont cry... breathe slowly through your nose. It was not meant to be taken seriously. Forgive me. Let me know if I can buy your next prescription meds for you.
 
dIsRuPtIvE said:
4 ports seems like a sensible number, but 8 seems a little redundant. The Ultra-D is fine for me. ;)

Yeah, but also consider that SATA optical drives are just now coming out, someone with four hard drives, something really not that bizarre these days with a lot of people running either a RAID 0 or a RAID 1 array (or even one of each), having more then four SATA ports starts to make some sense.
 
orkan said:
This board is for watercoolers and phasers only plz. :)

Phasers?

You know, if I wanted to sound like a real geek, I could pretend to be confused and start some inane Star Trek vrs Star Wars off topic conversation and ask about Light Sabers instead.


But I won't and just mention that I've seen high FSB overclocks in the reviews of both the MSI & DFI board even on air cooling. ;)
 
Back
Top