Windows 8 Release Preview Review

The majority of Windows users haven't even seen Windows 8 or know anything about Metro. Not even 10 million anonymous posts from people how don't like Metro or 20 million videos about the "missing" Start Button comes anywhere near the majority of Windows users.

Sure Microsoft should listen to its customers, it's actually better at that than some people realize. But I don't think that design by a committee that thinks its the majority when it's in reality a pretty small minority is the same as listening to customers.

Since I use Windows daily and have for years across multiple form factors and input devices well duh, I guess I do love it since it's designed to do specially the things that I've been doing for years. And if you think that Start Menu is great you've never used it on a touch device. The touch experience is 100 times worse with the Start Menu then the keyboard and mouse experience is with the Start Screen. If Microsoft produced something that perfectly fit into how you've always done things you'd love it too.

If Microsoft starts listening to this so called majority of its customers, they would still be stuck in Windows XP service pack 10.
 
One thing I don't get is you and a few others facination with digital pens. Now if you are an artist, sure I get it but there are drawing pads are are magnitudes more accurate than touch screens are going to be in the visible future. Pens on a computer of any type just strike me as completely pointless. I can type many times faster than anything I can write with a pen normally, not to mention a digital one that forces me to slow down even more. Now I suppose if you are just looking for something to toss out rough sketches quickly, then sure but how many people honestly need that and how often would you actually use it? Even though I am not a big fan of software keyboards on tablets and would rather link up a small bluetooth, they are still overwhelmingly faster then a pen. I just don't get that at all.

All of my Windows tablets have dual mode digitizers, pen and touch, the screens in most of tablet devices ARE drawing pads. Not top of the line digitizers but good enough for high-level art work for a lot of people.

Pens are just another way to interact with a computer. It's great for note taking, jotting down idea. I often like to proof read documents on my tablet because its more like holding paper, physically closer than a screen, I can do it lying on my side in bed. It's great for document notion, and the written text is searchable in the OS, it's not tied to specific programs.

It seems like people who don't like Metro see the PC as only tool where maximum productivity is the only point and that it can only be achieved with a keyboard and mouse and only with things that are densely packed into the smallest space possible. Its all about the machine and not about the environment, comfort, mood, or experience of the user. Metro opponents seem to say Microsoft is forcing this UI but it also gives people more freedom to use whatever Windows device they want in whatever manner they see fit. But I do understand that if the only why you ever used a PC is with a pointing device and keyboard that using PCs outside of that zone will probably have no value that you could relate to.
 
One thing I don't get is you and a few others facination with digital pens. Now if you are an artist, sure I get it but there are drawing pads are are magnitudes more accurate than touch screens are going to be in the visible future. Pens on a computer of any type just strike me as completely pointless. I can type many times faster than anything I can write with a pen normally, not to mention a digital one that forces me to slow down even more. Now I suppose if you are just looking for something to toss out rough sketches quickly, then sure but how many people honestly need that and how often would you actually use it? Even though I am not a big fan of software keyboards on tablets and would rather link up a small bluetooth, they are still overwhelmingly faster then a pen. I just don't get that at all.

OneNote is such an incredibly awesome tool for students, and digitizer pens make it so much better because of the accuracy of the pen. All throughout college I didn't print out any notes because I would do "screen printouts" into onenote and take notes directly on there. Even in classes without powerpoint notes it was still a blessing, I can still remember my awesome E&M diagrams from freshman year because of the built in graph axis draw tool!
 
All of my Windows tablets have dual mode digitizers, pen and touch, the screens in most of tablet devices ARE drawing pads. Not top of the line digitizers but good enough for high-level art work for a lot of people.

Pens are just another way to interact with a computer. It's great for note taking, jotting down idea. I often like to proof read documents on my tablet because its more like holding paper, physically closer than a screen, I can do it lying on my side in bed. It's great for document notion, and the written text is searchable in the OS, it's not tied to specific programs.

It seems like people who don't like Metro see the PC as only tool where maximum productivity is the only point and that it can only be achieved with a keyboard and mouse and only with things that are densely packed into the smallest space possible. Its all about the machine and not about the environment, comfort, mood, or experience of the user. Metro opponents seem to say Microsoft is forcing this UI but it also gives people more freedom to use whatever Windows device they want in whatever manner they see fit. But I do understand that if the only why you ever used a PC is with a pointing device and keyboard that using PCs outside of that zone will probably have no value that you could relate to.

I suppose, though if I need to use a tablet like a piece of paper I find a "Swipe" style keyboard with prediction to still be far faster. I can see it as a notation device, but I don't see a large percentage of users benefiting from that. I do quite a bit of photo shop work as a hobby so I use a drawing tablet, I have never found a touch screen to be even remotely as accurate.

Again, I see the value of metro on a touch device. You are correct in that it is a far superior layout on a non mouse and keyboard driven device (earlier post from you) to a start menu. However, I just don't see why desktop users are being forced into an inferior experience to cater to a minority of the market. No need to argue it further, I know everything you are going to say. I still maintain the stance that there is no logical valid reason for doing it. The desktop user just doesn't benefit from it.

I guess the problem is I just can't completely relate to your method of operation. I have a tablet as a consumption device. It is great for quickly checking out technical documents, responding to email or pulling up information from the web and not making me squint like my phone. Even if it had office on it, I wouldn't use it to produce documentation because a software keyboard is too slow, the attachable keyboard while awesome for a quick email is just too small for anything lengthy. I am either going to break out my laptop or my desktop for full blown productivity as there is just no possible way for the tablet to keep up. The desktop is likewise my graphics workstation and gaming rig. Obviously the Laptop and tablet both just aren't powerful enough to even be considered for this.

So I use a tablet for consumption. Win8/RT as opposed to android offers me choice but nothing I can't already do.

Laptop I use for mobile productivity - Win 8 offers better battery life but nothing really beyond that for me. I already get 5+ hours and am never away from an outlet that long anyhow.

Desktop - Main office productivity, gaming, Media creation and streaming. However bear in mind I am extremely OCD about crap on my desktop. There isn't a single icon on it and it is purely for art that I enjoy seeing. I have my main programs pinned to taskbar and everything else is nearly instantly accessible though start search. Metro adds completely unnecessary clutter for me. Even without bitching about the horrible aesthetics it just doesn't do much.

Another thing to note is I don't do news feeds, I don't do social media and in general don't benefit from any of the extra crap that metro adds in. I am a minimalist when it comes to what is on my screen. I use app markets heavily on my phone and tablet, however there is literally nothing on any app store that I would want on my laptop/desktop. Even if there was, I can find it through a web browser quite easily and don't require a ui change to support it since "Apps once launched run normally" anyhow. Not sure why metro supporters keep bringing app integration up like it actually does anything that can't be done without it. For the record, I am no longer debating it with you. I am simply giving you some perspective on how I utilize technology so you better understand my perspective.

I look forward to more competition in the current non x86 tablet market, but given the lack of traction gained by Windows phone 7, I am skeptical if MS has a chance. Android and iOS are extremely entrenched at this point and MS has a Huge perception problem to battle. When people think windows, they certainly don't think of something light and fast on a handheld device. Now if MS can get the hardware support to make x86 a serious competitor to that market, then I think they have something. However the initial signs aren't promising. We saw a preview of a device from Dell that is coming down the pipe a few days ago and the hardware specs were far from encouraging. The Processing power and ram left much to be desired and the major flaw of the x86 platform will be the SSD and the cost they add. I am super skeptical of these machines having the capacity to handle major productivity storage needs while remaining competitive. Couple that with all feedback that I have gotten from "Average" users being extremely negative on a laptop/desktop and I have reservations. This is why I am so adamantly opposed to metro being foisted on to traditional platform users. I feel that particular demographic is going to be far from accepting and we are going to end up with another Vista downgrade to XP fiasco. I don't believe MS can afford another PR blow like that without losing significant market share to Apple and possibly chrome OS if Google steps up.
 
OneNote is such an incredibly awesome tool for students, and digitizer pens make it so much better because of the accuracy of the pen. All throughout college I didn't print out any notes because I would do "screen printouts" into onenote and take notes directly on there. Even in classes without powerpoint notes it was still a blessing, I can still remember my awesome E&M diagrams from freshman year because of the built in graph axis draw tool!

I use one note and have for years. It is one of the best inclusions in office MS has ever put in. The pen is still too slow, I can type far faster as well as add notations, bullets, lists etc. Also not having to go back and forth between two devices allows me to drag images into one note and quickly resize them in addition to dropping emails in and quickly moving things around. If you think a digital pen is good in one note, you haven't even begun to tap into how incredibly powerful it is.
 
OneNote is such an incredibly awesome tool for students, and digitizer pens make it so much better because of the accuracy of the pen. All throughout college I didn't print out any notes because I would do "screen printouts" into onenote and take notes directly on there. Even in classes without powerpoint notes it was still a blessing, I can still remember my awesome E&M diagrams from freshman year because of the built in graph axis draw tool!

I really hope that Microsoft has some interesting things in store for the next version of OneNote with Windows 8's focus on tablets it has enormous potential in the educational sector to really take it the iPad in this market especially considering the big interest in note taking on the iPad rather large market for pens for a device that's woefully suited for digital ink. Good Atom and Windows RT devices with pens at the right price can do very well in education.
 
I suppose, though if I need to use a tablet like a piece of paper I find a "Swipe" style keyboard with prediction to still be far faster. I can see it as a notation device, but I don't see a large percentage of users benefiting from that. I do quite a bit of photo shop work as a hobby so I use a drawing tablet, I have never found a touch screen to be even remotely as accurate.

I don't know why you keep calling a Wacom digitizer a touch screen. Digital artists are probably the most loyal Tablet PC customer base their is. Photoshop has had special support for Wacom digitizers even before Windows XP Tablet PC edition. At any rate, good devices with Wacom digitizers are extremely accurate.

So I use a tablet for consumption. Win8/RT as opposed to android offers me choice but nothing I can't already do.

And I use a tablet for both consumption and production depending on the task as many are these days. Productivity isn't always about a high rate of input and I think that the market sees it that way with more and more tablets being used for productive purposes.

Laptop I use for mobile productivity - Win 8 offers better battery life but nothing really beyond that for me. I already get 5+ hours and am never away from an outlet that long anyhow.

5 hours is consider not that great, even for laptops these days. Heck my Samsung Series 7 Slate, an x86 SB based machine with the same computer hardware as the current baseline MacBook Air 11 can get 5 to 6 hours running Office and web browsing with minimal video.

Metro adds completely unnecessary clutter for me. Even without bitching about the horrible aesthetics it just doesn't do much.

There's nothing cluttered about Metro, not a single thing has to be on the Start Screen, it's a blank slate and completely customizable as to what's on it. One can argue but the full screen aspect or size or white space or mouse travel but cluttered is simply false.

[/QUOTE]
I look forward to more competition in the current non x86 tablet market, but given the lack of traction gained by Windows phone 7, I am skeptical if MS has a chance. Android and iOS are extremely entrenched at this point and MS has a Huge perception problem to battle. When people think windows, they certainly don't think of something light and fast on a handheld device. Now if MS can get the hardware support to make x86 a serious competitor to that market, then I think they have something. However the initial signs aren't promising. We saw a preview of a device from Dell that is coming down the pipe a few days ago and the hardware specs were far from encouraging. The Processing power and ram left much to be desired and the major flaw of the x86 platform will be the SSD and the cost they add. I am super skeptical of these machines having the capacity to handle major productivity storage needs while remaining competitive. Couple that with all feedback that I have gotten from "Average" users being extremely negative on a laptop/desktop and I have reservations. This is why I am so adamantly opposed to metro being foisted on to traditional platform users. I feel that particular demographic is going to be far from accepting and we are going to end up with another Vista downgrade to XP fiasco. I don't believe MS can afford another PR blow like that without losing significant market share to Apple and possibly chrome OS if Google steps up.[/QUOTE]

With the unification of Windows across desktops, tablets and even phones, Windows RT is supposed to be the kernel in Windows Phone 8, it may take time but Microsoft will always be there and the support will be there. Heck Windows Phone with it's current small market share reached 100,000 app submissions faster even than Android and only a few months behind iOS. The iPhone is expensive to carriers who look like they are more than ever willing to embrace Windows Phone, even Verizon who has dragged its feet forever with Windows Phone want's a third ecosystem. And Android has its share of problems, like only Samsung making any money on the devices and of Google will be fighting legal battles for years.

And I wouldn't look at Dell for much on the Windows 8 front. The stuff from Acer, Asus and Samsung looked very good. There's going to be good hardware it looks for Windows 8, but yeah, I doubt it will come from Dell. HP I actually think may be able to do something. They actually have made Windows tablets for a long time and have made some decent ones. We'll see.
 
I wouldn't call Metro cluttered, and I wouldn't say that I dislike the aesthetic or the way it works, but that doesn't mean I think Microsoft is doing the right thing with its implementation. It's easy enough for apologists to write the negative feedback off as 'change jitters', and for the most part, that's the angle being played. There's some validity to that, but the issue goes deeper.

The dissonance Metro introduces in terms of the interface is problematic. Its design language is workable and appropriate for many devices, and there's good value to be had in aesthetic simplification, but it's being implemented atop a paradigm with its own design language and its own manner of interaction, and the two are being designed to exist side-by-side. The result is that Windows now exists in two different dimensions in terms of user interaction, and that's an absurd concept for an operating system: something which should be about unifying the operation and aesthetic of the applications that run on it. An operating system exists not for the convenience of itself but for the convenience of applications and for its users, and it's not clear to me how the current implementation of Metro gets us closer to satisfying either of those goals. It's a novel concept in itself, but it doesn't function properly in the context of the rest of the OS.

I can see this both from the perspective of a designer and as an engineer, and I don't real value here from either perspective. It's easy to say "well, features!" to justify it, but that's a fairly shallow viewpoint considering the nature of the product we're talking about here.
 
For every supposed Microsoft apologist there's 100 people that have obviously never used for any period of time a Windows tablet with any version of Windows, let alone Windows 8. You're calling people apologists and not even looking at what's in plain sight. Practically every device shown running Windows 8 at Computex had a touch screen. And even Windows devices that don't have touch screens will have much improved track pads.

If you've never used Windows with anything more than a mouse and keyboard then it stands to reason you won't like or get Metro. But really, the apologist nonsense is just that. I'm not saying Metro is perfect but when you think about PCs beyond keyboards and mice it's better than the current UI by far and it's not nearly as bad with keyboards and mice as many make it out to be. If were that bad then I just don't understand how it is that I can do the same things on Windows 8 as 7 as quickly and easily for the vast bulk of things. If Metro were as cumbersome and disruptive as you're saying then it just seems to me that things should be more difficult to do with mice and keyboards. That everything would just take much more time, that I'd always be confused, that nothing would work.

Ultimately you can over think it and analyze it to death, people will either figure it out or they won't. I thinking that most will and that some might even like it, even with mice and keyboards. It really ain't that hard.
 
I probably should of thrown specs out with my laptop battery life. The battery life for the type of laptop I run is great, obviously not compared against an ultra book, but I can't run one of those.

Quad core Intel i5
16gb of Ram
Dual 7200 rpm hard drives in a Mirror running encryption
Built in Verizon 3g
17" high resolution display

This is a job requirement type of laptop not something the average user would need by any stretch.

So yes, on this type of machine 5 hours is great. :)

Btw I am not calling a Wacom a touch screen, it isn't. I was referring to standard tablets trying to operate without one. There isn't a tablet on the market that I am aware of that has a touch screen that is anywhere close to accurate. This is why I kept not understanding people's fascination with digital pens to interact with a tablet for productivity software like one note. Obviously for a wacom it is superior for a mouse. But again, win 8 doesn't bring anything to the table here as the wacom has its own software and isn't affected by win 8.
 
I am really interested to know what laptop you have please. :confused: Last time I looked into it, the i5 was not available as a quad in a laptop, only the i7 was. (As far as intel goes, anyways.)

Laptop i5's were dual cores with hyperthreading well desktop i5's were quads.
 
I am really interested to know what laptop you have please. :confused: Last time I looked into it, the i5 was not available as a quad in a laptop, only the i7 was. (As far as intel goes, anyways.)

Laptop i5's were dual cores with hyperthreading well desktop i5's were quads.

HP Elitebook 8560p

coreo.png
 
Nevermind, I am having an idiot Durr moment. It is a dual core. Forgot intel shows hyperthreading as individual cores.

Anyhow Dual core and the rest remains the same. The hdd setup is the battery eater.
 
If Metro were as cumbersome and disruptive as you're saying then it just seems to me that things should be more difficult to do with mice and keyboards.
Having two different interfaces with two different paradigms within the same operating system makes interaction more complex for all input modes. The level of difficulty and complexity hasn't increased exponentially, but it has increased: that cannot be rationally argued against. It's fundamentally nonsensical to argue that an increase in complexity does not yield a corresponding increase in difficulty for users.

It's ironic, considering the core of Metro's design language is about simplification. Like I said, though, the implementation atop the existing UI structure only increases complexity.
 
Having two different interfaces with two different paradigms within the same operating system makes interaction more complex for all input modes.

Whatever level of complexity Metro adds, Windows 8 is FAR superior to Windows 7 with touch, even the desktop shell works better in 8 than 7 with touch.


The level of difficulty and complexity hasn't increased exponentially, but it has increased: that cannot be rationally argued against. It's fundamentally nonsensical to argue that an increase in complexity does not yield a corresponding increase in difficulty for users.

It's ironic, considering the core of Metro's design language is about simplification. Like I said, though, the implementation atop the existing UI structure only increases complexity.

The complexity is mostly rooted in differences. Again, my point is that if Metro makes everything harder I simply cannot feel the difference in day to day operation now that I'm used to it. Assuming that a person can adapt there's no inherent reason why they can't use the OS as easily as they have Windows historically with keyboards and mice for the vast majority of tasks.

If Metro opponents know that hundreds of millions of Windows users will perceive Metro then you way too smart to be posting here. I have no clue how it will be perceived overall especially since most people are going to get Windows 8 on some type of device that either has a touch screen or much better track pad than current Windows devices and that's something that most Metro opponents are not factoring into all of this.

I can only speak for myself and when I look at Metro overall, it's just not as bad as many are making it out to be but I also understand that Metro is particularly well suited for how I use Windows personally.
 
A person can adapt, without tremendous difficulty, to a window's close button jumping from corner to corner every three seconds. That isn't justification for making the close button jump from corner to corner every three seconds, however. That's no kind of argument.
 
I probably should of thrown specs out with my laptop battery life. The battery life for the type of laptop I run is great, obviously not compared against an ultra book, but I can't run one of those.

Quad core Intel i5
16gb of Ram
Dual 7200 rpm hard drives in a Mirror running encryption
Built in Verizon 3g
17" high resolution display

This is a job requirement type of laptop not something the average user would need by any stretch.

So yes, on this type of machine 5 hours is great. :)

Nice machine, it's my work device as well just with 8GB and a 128GB. Not particularly mobile.

Btw I am not calling a Wacom a touch screen, it isn't. I was referring to standard tablets trying to operate without one. There isn't a tablet on the market that I am aware of that has a touch screen that is anywhere close to accurate. This is why I kept not understanding people's fascination with digital pens to interact with a tablet for productivity software like one note. Obviously for a wacom it is superior for a mouse. But again, win 8 doesn't bring anything to the table here as the wacom has its own software and isn't affected by win 8.

Ok, not really sure where you're going with the Wacom digitizer discussion. All I'll say is that I've have Windows devices with Wacom digitizers for ten years now and they are extremely fast and accurate overall and that Wacom has

Windows 8 does have some minor improvements to the handwriting recognition speed and accuracy from my experience and the Tablet Input Panel overall has some pretty major improvements. While Windows 8 doesn't specifically add a lot to digital ink, Windows is already by far and away a much digital ink platform compared to iOS and Android.
 
Heartless,

It is called representative statistics sampling. It is done in politics to determine candidates popularity and support, it is done by businesses for marketing purposes, it is done by TV producers to determine viewership. No clearly it is not a perfect system, but it works well enough to be considered fairly accurate. I assume you know what it is, but I will give the simplified explanation to be clear. In short a small number of people are surveyed, people that are what you would consider the "average" demographic and those people are used to create an expected trend of what a much larger group of the same minded people will do.

I came to the conclusions I came too because I have taken the time to put metro in front of hundreds of users who would be the typical PC user to see how they reacted. I have gotten almost no positive feedback from it. Using the same methodology above, one can assume that the results in a larger pool of people will be similar. It might be wrong, obviously it can't guarantee to be 100% accurate but it certainly doesn't paint the picture some of you guys are trying.
 
Nice machine, it's my work device as well just with 8GB and a 128GB. Not particularly mobile.



Ok, not really sure where you're going with the Wacom digitizer discussion. All I'll say is that I've have Windows devices with Wacom digitizers for ten years now and they are extremely fast and accurate overall and that Wacom has

Windows 8 does have some minor improvements to the handwriting recognition speed and accuracy from my experience and the Tablet Input Panel overall has some pretty major improvements. While Windows 8 doesn't specifically add a lot to digital ink, Windows is already by far and away a much digital ink platform compared to iOS and Android.

No, it isn't particularly mobile heh. It resides in a rolling tool bag with a bunch of hand tools anyhow. So Size and weight are sort of a non issue for this. This is also why I have the Asus Transformer Prime as my mobile email and service manual device.

I think you and I are on two different conversations concerning Wacom's..lets just move on. ;)
 
A person can adapt, without tremendous difficulty, to a window's close button jumping from corner to corner every three seconds. That isn't justification for making the close button jump from corner to corner every three seconds, however. That's no kind of argument.

But one of the main points that Metro opponents make is that will be just too hard for people to adapt. So yes, the ability for people to adapt is important and again the devices that Windows 8 comes on will make touch front and center to the experience. not a jumping close button.

People that haven't used Windows 8 with touch hardware are missing a lot of the story. If all you want to do is run desktop apps and be tied to only a mouse and keyboard I get it, it's not how you use Windows today. Microsoft is designing Windows 8 under the assumption that most people will use it with touch capable hardware. That's an adaptation as well.
 
I came to the conclusions I came too because I have taken the time to put metro in front of hundreds of users who would be the typical PC user to see how they reacted. I have gotten almost no positive feedback from it. Using the same methodology above, one can assume that the results in a larger pool of people will be similar. It might be wrong, obviously it can't guarantee to be 100% accurate but it certainly doesn't paint the picture some of you guys are trying.

As though Microsoft didn't do the same thing. And how many of those devices had touch capability? I'm not saying you aren't right but I heard these same arguments, these same supposed types of scientific studies when the ribbon was introduced in Office.

Seriously, why would you expect for someone to look at a very different Windows UI from the one that's been there for the last 20 years and expect them to actually like it in just brief exposure on hardware that doesn't support it's full capabilities? Indeed, it makes more sense that most people WOULDN'T like it under those conditions.

I too have done my self studies, not nearly on the scale that you did but I did it with my x220t tablet. I won't say that people fell in love but they were definitely intrigue buy being able to operate the device with the screen and a couple of people loved playing Angry Birds on it just like their phones, just a bigger touch screen than they'd play it on before.
 
As though Microsoft didn't do the same thing. And how many of those devices had touch capability? I'm not saying you aren't right but I heard these same arguments, these same supposed types of scientific studies when the ribbon was introduced in Office.

Seriously, why would you expect for someone to look at a very different Windows UI from the one that's been there for the last 20 years and expect them to actually like it in just brief exposure on hardware that doesn't support it's full capabilities? Indeed, it makes more sense that most people WOULDN'T like it under those conditions.

I too have done my self studies, not nearly on the scale that you did but I did it with my x220t tablet. I won't say that people fell in love but they were definitely intrigue buy being able to operate the device with the screen and a couple of people loved playing Angry Birds on it just like their phones, just a bigger touch screen than they'd play it on before.

No, not touch. But bear in mind I haven't argued against win 8 on a touch device. Do remember, I only object to metro on a non touch device, I think it is great on a touch device. Has microsoft done it? I doubt they have on a non touch device quite frankly. They don't seem particularly interested in anything desktop users have to say. Concerning ribbon, well the argument about ribbon was stupid. Ribbon from the word go was overwhelmingly superior in nearly every respect. I never actually understood why people got up in arms about it. Ribbon, like it or not at least made sense. I don't believe metro makes sense on a desktop there is a pretty big difference in my mind.
 
But one of the main points that Metro opponents make is that will be just too hard for people to adapt.
That is not my argument.

People that haven't used Windows 8 with touch hardware are missing a lot of the story.
One doesn't need to be particularly intelligent to have used Metro with a non-touch-enabled device and understand how its interface translates to touch interaction — people here know how these basic gestures work because, in Metro, they have to do them with a mouse. It's disingenuous then to suggest that these users are simply "missing the story". It simply suits your agenda to portray people who've spoken against Metro as too uninformed or too inexperienced to be able to make any kind of reasonable judgments.
 
No, not touch. But bear in mind I haven't argued against win 8 on a touch device. Do remember, I only object to metro on a non touch device, I think it is great on a touch device. Has microsoft done it? I doubt they have on a non touch device quite frankly. They don't seem particularly interested in anything desktop users have to say. Concerning ribbon, well the argument about ribbon was stupid. Ribbon from the word go was overwhelmingly superior in nearly every respect. I never actually understood why people got up in arms about it. Ribbon, like it or not at least made sense. I don't believe metro makes sense on a desktop there is a pretty big difference in my mind.

Actually there was a good anoint of work done with multi-monitor support. One group of desktop users that might actually like Windows 8 over Windows 7 are multi-monitor users. If you have two or three or more monitors the Start Screen taking up one full screen becomes a non-issue and unlike the Start Menu the Start Screen can display on any monitor.

I may be a Microsoft apologist but I actually have taken the time to learn the product across multiple form factors and input methods. Few people judging the product have.
 
One doesn't need to be particularly intelligent to have used Metro with a non-touch-enabled device and understand how its interface translates to touch interaction — people here know how these basic gestures work because, in Metro, they have to do them with a mouse. It's disingenuous then to suggest that these users are simply "missing the story". It simply suits your agenda to portray people who've spoken against Metro as too uninformed or too inexperienced to be able to make any kind of reasonable judgments.

It's more than translation, it's the experience. People often talk about gorilla arm and what not and while on a desktop that could be an issue on a laptop its quite different. Even while I'm in laptop mode from time to time its just simple and natural to tap the screen rather than repositioning the mouse.

You can't translate that into a keyboard and mouse only experience nor understand that it's just natural and quick sometimes and you don't always do it.
 
Actually there was a good anoint of work done with multi-monitor support. One group of desktop users that might actually like Windows 8 over Windows 7 are multi-monitor users. If you have two or three or more monitors the Start Screen taking up one full screen becomes a non-issue and unlike the Start Menu the Start Screen can display on any monitor.

I may be a Microsoft apologist but I actually have taken the time to learn the product across multiple form factors and input methods. Few people judging the product have.

I have a triple monitor setup and I haven't really noticed anything that eyefinity doesn't already do better.
 
Back
Top