Why the MMORPG Subscription-Based Model is Broken

The Subscription Based model is Not Broken,

what is broken is the fact that most of the MMORPG's that are being released CANNOT compete with the mmo's that are already out there currently.

for fantasy mmo's you HAVE to compete with World of Warcraft(10+ million world wide). EQ cannot do it (~200k subscribers) EQ2 cannot do it (~200k subscribers), AoC imo will be around 200k subscribers after 6 months on the business, Warhammer online also will not be able to compete with WoW when it releases (will be an AoC style release- ~1 million first month, probably half of that 2nd month(ie paid subscriptions) with that game probably settling around the 2-300 thousand mark.

see: http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart1.html

for a blowup of the lower ones: see that giant cluster around the 50-200k mark, that is where most mmo's end up because they are not special, they are not exceptionally well done, and that is where WoW excelled, it was -by FAR- the most feature complete, bug free, "Finished" mmo to release Ever. Yes it had things that were not finished, were buggy, but in the overall scheme, not one mmo has come Close to what WoW did quality of product wise at release. (for the record i played everquest on the same server with several employees of Blizzard- including rob pardo and jeff kaplan-even grouped with them alot.)

http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart2.html

1 game controls most of the market, 1 game is the game that EVERYONE has to compete against if going for the same Genre,

WoW did A LOT of things Right, it did A LOT of things wrong, but overall, the experience you get playing it is alot of fun (2 accounts here 1 for me, 1 for the wife) and dollar for dollar it is potentially the cheapest paid entertainment you can buy.

I play wow ~20hrs a week- this is typical. so about 80hrs a month playing wow..i pay quarterly so i pay 14 a month, so it costs me ~18 cents an HOUR to play wow- movies are ~5 dollars an hr. cable tv is less than that if you figure 24x7 but lets say 40hrs a week of TV....160 hrs a month ,,, that is still ABOUT 50cents an hr for the typical $80 a month cable tv costs(my cable bill is that- no premium channels, but do have HD)

profit margins for wow..about 35-40%. Approx. 60-65% of the revenue generated by wow is used for expenses- bandwidth, data centers, salaries, etc.
 
Yeah, and I'm sure they are making a nice profit. But guess what? Making a profit isn't greed. They are a business, plain and simple. A publicly traded one at that. They have responsibilities to their employees and their shareholders to make their company as successful as possible.

$15/mo is the industry average. You claimed you would not pay $1 a month. I can only surmise that you are out of touch with the reality of business. Do you expect them to undercut everyone just for the sake of undercutting, and destroy their profits?

$15/mo is ridiculously cheap. People are paying $15 a for dozens of hours of entertainment. What will that $15 get you elsewhere? An 18-pack of beer? Two matinee-priced movie tickets and no snacks? Half a pay-per-view event?

I was thinking the same thing. It's just 15 bucks a month. So what? If you can't afford 15 a month, then I think it's safe to say you can't afford to play video games period!

If you want to take a break from the game, cancel your account. Your toons will still be there if you want to pick up where you left off later.
 
I'd also like to add that if subscription based MMO systems are broken, then why the hell isn't Guild Wars as successful?
 
The Subscription Based model is Not Broken,

what is broken is the fact that most of the MMORPG's that are being released CANNOT compete with the mmo's that are already out there currently.

I don't think it's necessarily competition. Even among fantasy MMOs, each one is going to appeal to a different player. EQ2 has a solid playerbase, even though it is relatively small in subscribers compared to WoW. Yet, even with such a small playerbase EQ2 had more content at launch than WoW, and WAY more expansion content. The game itself has a ton more depth, too. Overall it's a "better" MMO, yet it has less subscribers. So it's less about competition and more about choosing who you want to attract.

I think WoW, more than anything, is a fluke. It's more like Myspace or Facebook than it is an MMO. Blizzard made a good MMO that targeted a wide variety of players. After a while, it reached that critical point where new MMO purchasers _had_ to choose WoW because thats where their friends were at, and it just exploded from there. EQ2 on the other hand chose to try and grab EQ1 players who were tired of that game and wanted something fresh, and other traditional MMO players. WoW decided to sacrifice a lot of game depth in order to appeal to a broader audience.

As an aside, I think it's interesting that despite WoW's content being relatively shallow and easy to create compared to EQ2, that the game hasn't had more content additions. You'd think with all the money they are rolling in that they could push out content faster. I'm guessing Vivendi isn't letting them have much, money-wise, for new content. After all, content is content. Whether 10 million people are going to be playing it, or 100,000, all that differs is the number of servers you have to bring online, the creation of the content should be the same. So more money should equal more content. But we haven't seen that.
 
I'd also like to add that if subscription based MMO systems are broken, then why the hell isn't Guild Wars as successful?

Exactly. I believe a subscription model is the only thing that works for big, relatively traditional MMOs. Guild Wars is smaller and does things a bit differently. As I said in my above post, all that money rolling in and WoW still doesn't push out as much content as SOE does for the much smaller EQ2. Even EQ1 is still getting more content. They dropped from 6-month xpac cycle to 12-month now for EQ1, but even then thats xpac's about twice as big as WoW's, twice as often.

If a big MMO like WoW went subscription-free, it could never stay solvent, even with in-game advertisements, and microtransactions or whatever else they chose to rape people with.
 
MMO are an addiction for some, enough to make it pay out in the end (Evercrack, Evercrack 2 and WoW), heck Ultima is still running . Most of you missed the people factor, the fact that there is a dedicated following to some of these franchises that keeps them alive, Star Wars Galaxies and Matrix online are prime examples and I'm sure that Stargay Worlds and Star Trekies World are going to be some minor success (Trek MAJOR, especially with the new movie).

Nobodies mentioned Lord of the Rings Online, total WoW rip, but just stunningly beautiful world rich in detail. To me its not really an MMO, but google street view of Middle Earth. Loads of content updates with a major one coming up in fall. The only reason that this game is doing so much better then say Matrix online and any of the other major franchise games was because the franchise isn't controlled by a major movie studio.
 
I happily paid Square-Enix a monthly rate for two and a half years while I played FFXI. I tried WoW for about 3 months as well to see what all the hype was about but I was already sickening of the MMO stage at that point. After awhile you get sick of the drama over fake gear and hearing about this nerf or that nerf.

StarGate and Star Trek have good solid fanbases and are poised to possibly be great games. How they're executed though will be what makes or breaks them. Dunno if I'd ever play the Star Trek one but I could see myself maybe giving StarGate a shot after seeing its launch and what people say about it.

Blizzard had a brilliant launch with WoW and they gave us a quality game that runs on just about any hardware which makes it appealing to just about anybody. They have a nice in game system that easy to learn. They allow addons which make life easier in game. They don't require huge parties like FFXI to level up. Making money in WoW isn't a horrid time consuming chore like in FFXI either. Plus they created a MMO that was built off the WarCraft franchise which was already one of the most well known game franchises ever.

Because of all that Blizzard is making money hand over fist with WoW but I don't think they're being greedy. Their expansions sell millions of copies for $30-50 a pop. Well it takes thousands of man hours to get that expansion out the door. Not to mention possibly having to add in more bandwidth and new hardware to keep up with added zones and influx of new people you get with the release of the new expansion. That cost has to come from somewhere else thus why you purchase the new expansions. The monthly fee maintains what your currently playing, not what you want to play in the future.

So now why is the MMO subscription-based model broken? If anything WoW is a perfect model of how well it works...
 
I just want to clarify one thing. WoW is not huge because WoW is an exceptional game. It is really no better of an MMORPG than any of the other top 10 MMORPG's. WoW is huge because of an unusual situation that nobody else in the industry can replicate....

The first part of the situation is the nature of MMORPG's. Specifically the fact that a good MMORPG is highly addictive, and a persons first MMORPG, if it is a good one, is insanely addictive. The second part of the situation was the fact that this was a Warcraft game made by Blizzard. Before WoW came out there were one million people in this world that would buy ANY Blizzard game automatically and another one million that would buy any Warcraft game automatically. There were also a couple hundred thousand people that would try an MMORPG automatically. So WoW pretty much had an automatic install base of well over 2 million people without hardly trying. These people of course became addicted, and introduced the game to friends and relatives. Other gamers who never played MMORPGs also saw the huge numbers and so decided it must be good and broke down and bought their first pay-to-play game. These numbers were so huge that a kind of critical mass was hit in which people are starting to play the game faster than other players are quitting, and so the game just keeps growing.

It of course didn't hurt that the games graphics were not quite as cutting edge so more PC's could play the game, but over all it was the inherent Blizzard/Warcraft install base that made this game so freaking huge. There was also a unique timing benefit in that MMORPG's were really just hitting the mainstream around the time WoW was released so people were a lot more accepting of the concept than they had been for, say, Star Wars Online, which has similar base popularity as the Warcraft series, but didn't have as good of timing.
 
Don't kid yourself, the profits are HUGE. If they charged 5 bucks a month, they'd make money. Guild Wars shows that you can make money without charging anything.

10 million customers say that $15.00 is probably a good price. If they thought that lowering the price to 10.00 would double the user base, they'd probably drop the price to 10 bucks.

Don't even dare compare WoW to Guildwars in the same post. While still both be "fruit" they are totally different.
 
The Subscription Based model is Not Broken,
what is broken is the fact that most of the MMORPG's that are being released CANNOT compete with the mmo's that are already out there currently.

They don't have to compete. 200k x 13.00 (let's assume most people don't go month to month), is 2.6 million dollars/month.

If 60% of WOW's money was going to fixed costs, I'd be completely and utterly shocked.
They're pulling in roughly 130-150 million/month. The idea that their fixed costs for WOW along are are over 60 million doesn't sound reasonable. It may cost that in funny money (you know, where an employee that has a salary of 50k and benefits worth 10k somehow costs the company 120k or more...or moving an employee from one cube to another 30 feet away costs 1000.00), but actual fixed costs can't be close to that.

The point is you don't have to be WOW to make money. WOWs numbers allow them to take more time between releases, but as the number of users goes up, those fixed costs go down. Sure more servers cost more money, but if a server supports a million customers (arbitrary number), then the only way said server costs the company more is if it has a low subscriber base. IME, new servers are added when the old ones are very full and they generally offer free transfers (at least SOE did) to that server for a period of time. Likewise, when populations fall, as happened with EQ, servers are merged.


Like you, I think it's a good value, but your numbers just don't sound realistic. If they were, every other MMORPG is losing money, and clearly EQ and EQ2 aren't losing money. I'm not even sure that LOTRO is losing money, given that they're releasing an expansion.
 
Don't even dare compare WoW to Guildwars in the same post. While still both be "fruit" they are totally different.

It's an MMORPG. the guy said he left because they all had the same model and so on. Clearly that's not the case at the company he just left.
 
I'm perfectly fine spending $15/month on a game that I find enjoyable.

I can also absorb that $15 many times over so spending the money that provides me with countless enjoyment 24/7 is OK with me.
 
If 60% of WOW's money was going to fixed costs, I'd be completely and utterly shocked.

first off, ~5 million do not pay a subscription fee or box sales- they pay by the hr (asian servers)

secondly, are you even aware of how many servers wow HAS running currently and how much bandwidth they use?

US/EU combined has approx 450 servers combined.

asia has about that same amount if not more (another 450ish)

so 900 world servers & associated bandwidth/housing for server costs..

plus CS Plus Devs Plus IT etc= about 60% of revenue going for expenses monthly. that is about what EQ and EQ2 made..

as to EQ2 being the better mmo, personal opinion- i Know Gallenite(old eq2 main dev), met him, like him, really nice guy and he made eq2 into the game it is now, at release, EQ2 was NOT a good mmo-it ran like crap on good setups, the zoning was out of control, combat was a mess, etc- he and his team fixed the problems and it is a good mmo NOW..back then no.

and unfortunately you get ONE shot at being a huge success, 99% of the mmo success can be calculated within 2 months of release. Retention Rate- the rate of which people who bought the game, continue to pay for it.

EQ2 had about 400 thousand box sales at release if i remember correctly, retained about half

vanguard had ~300 thousand or so,,,retained about 25%

AOC had 1 million in sales- no update on subscription numbers but from ancedotal evidence, the retention rate is around 30-40%.

etc

EVE and WOW are the two mmo's that really has broken the mold for general mmo assumptions...

wow, with just its MASSIVE number of subscribers, and Eve, with it's ever growing (slowly) userbase.

back when wow was in closed beta i said it was going to be larger than lineage/lineage 2 within a year, the Game was that good, that polished- hell people were begging for the game to release in closed beta saying they'd buy it even as incomplete as it was. (i've been playing wow since alpha testing)
 
When I played WoW for two years, it was pretty much the only game I plaid. In that aspect $15/month probably came out even to paying $50 for a new game every couple months. I think its fair especially if the game holds your attention.

That said, I think its rediculous to claim that it costs $15M a month to keep WoW up.
 
You can really tell who does their homework on a topic before deciding to try and "inform" someone else about it. I am very much out of the loop with MMOs, but I can tell you that many people cannot understand the costs involved. A great many people mistake revenues for profits. Yet these same people abide monopolies on a daily basis without understanding truly why.

I think the model is not broken, because I think the model is exactly the same as any other business. MMOs are hard to get right. Blizzard dominated by understanding not just the business model, but how to make a game. They have proven that that is the most important part of this, as they have evidently proven before.

All that said, I will most assuredly buy Diablo 3 whenever the hell it comes out. I can't believe how many people feel the need to tell Blizzard how to run their amazingly successful venture. Personally, I will closely watch everything they do so I know how to manage my own ventures.
 
Back
Top