The Subscription Based model is Not Broken,
what is broken is the fact that most of the MMORPG's that are being released CANNOT compete with the mmo's that are already out there currently.
for fantasy mmo's you HAVE to compete with World of Warcraft(10+ million world wide). EQ cannot do it (~200k subscribers) EQ2 cannot do it (~200k subscribers), AoC imo will be around 200k subscribers after 6 months on the business, Warhammer online also will not be able to compete with WoW when it releases (will be an AoC style release- ~1 million first month, probably half of that 2nd month(ie paid subscriptions) with that game probably settling around the 2-300 thousand mark.
see: http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart1.html
for a blowup of the lower ones: see that giant cluster around the 50-200k mark, that is where most mmo's end up because they are not special, they are not exceptionally well done, and that is where WoW excelled, it was -by FAR- the most feature complete, bug free, "Finished" mmo to release Ever. Yes it had things that were not finished, were buggy, but in the overall scheme, not one mmo has come Close to what WoW did quality of product wise at release. (for the record i played everquest on the same server with several employees of Blizzard- including rob pardo and jeff kaplan-even grouped with them alot.)
http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart2.html
1 game controls most of the market, 1 game is the game that EVERYONE has to compete against if going for the same Genre,
WoW did A LOT of things Right, it did A LOT of things wrong, but overall, the experience you get playing it is alot of fun (2 accounts here 1 for me, 1 for the wife) and dollar for dollar it is potentially the cheapest paid entertainment you can buy.
I play wow ~20hrs a week- this is typical. so about 80hrs a month playing wow..i pay quarterly so i pay 14 a month, so it costs me ~18 cents an HOUR to play wow- movies are ~5 dollars an hr. cable tv is less than that if you figure 24x7 but lets say 40hrs a week of TV....160 hrs a month ,,, that is still ABOUT 50cents an hr for the typical $80 a month cable tv costs(my cable bill is that- no premium channels, but do have HD)
profit margins for wow..about 35-40%. Approx. 60-65% of the revenue generated by wow is used for expenses- bandwidth, data centers, salaries, etc.
what is broken is the fact that most of the MMORPG's that are being released CANNOT compete with the mmo's that are already out there currently.
for fantasy mmo's you HAVE to compete with World of Warcraft(10+ million world wide). EQ cannot do it (~200k subscribers) EQ2 cannot do it (~200k subscribers), AoC imo will be around 200k subscribers after 6 months on the business, Warhammer online also will not be able to compete with WoW when it releases (will be an AoC style release- ~1 million first month, probably half of that 2nd month(ie paid subscriptions) with that game probably settling around the 2-300 thousand mark.
see: http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart1.html
for a blowup of the lower ones: see that giant cluster around the 50-200k mark, that is where most mmo's end up because they are not special, they are not exceptionally well done, and that is where WoW excelled, it was -by FAR- the most feature complete, bug free, "Finished" mmo to release Ever. Yes it had things that were not finished, were buggy, but in the overall scheme, not one mmo has come Close to what WoW did quality of product wise at release. (for the record i played everquest on the same server with several employees of Blizzard- including rob pardo and jeff kaplan-even grouped with them alot.)
http://www.mmogchart.com/Chart2.html
1 game controls most of the market, 1 game is the game that EVERYONE has to compete against if going for the same Genre,
WoW did A LOT of things Right, it did A LOT of things wrong, but overall, the experience you get playing it is alot of fun (2 accounts here 1 for me, 1 for the wife) and dollar for dollar it is potentially the cheapest paid entertainment you can buy.
I play wow ~20hrs a week- this is typical. so about 80hrs a month playing wow..i pay quarterly so i pay 14 a month, so it costs me ~18 cents an HOUR to play wow- movies are ~5 dollars an hr. cable tv is less than that if you figure 24x7 but lets say 40hrs a week of TV....160 hrs a month ,,, that is still ABOUT 50cents an hr for the typical $80 a month cable tv costs(my cable bill is that- no premium channels, but do have HD)
profit margins for wow..about 35-40%. Approx. 60-65% of the revenue generated by wow is used for expenses- bandwidth, data centers, salaries, etc.