Why Oculus Rift Is Bound To Fail

Anybody who says the Rift is "guaranteed" to be anything is speaking with the wrong set of lips.

Failure or success.
 
Now talk to me about its potential applications in medical, aerospace and other fields as a tool and I will agree all day it has a bright future indeed.

So if it fails at entertainment it's bound to fail?

This reasoning boggles me.

It or something like it will have a place with sim geeks (as even now it is seriously undercutting the costs of their previous solutions and providing a better experience), and will likely be very useful in a number of professional settings.

No, it won't be the next smart phone in terms of massive yearly sales numbers, but then most things wont. That doesn't mean they failed.
 
From my perspective, best thing they can do to guarantee success is support my back catalog of games. If I already have dozens of games that support it or it is easy for the community to add support for existing games, I'll buy it as a day one purchase. If it only supports future games, then I'll be waiting until either a lot of games support it or at least a few "gotta-have-it" killer apps.
 
At this point I'm more excited (or nervous) about Gear VR, because it's coming out in the next few months for under 200... supposedly.
 
It doesn't need to appeal to mass markets. This will be widely adopted in the sim community because of it's application there. DCS/Arma and now star citizen. Being able to control your view independently of controls is almost an absolute necessity for these types of games.

It will make TrackIR almost completely obsolete sans for the select few who don't want something attached to their head/motion sickness issues etc.
 
With hydra controllers as standard, the potential is amazing. However packaging that into something cheap and commercially viable... i dunno yet.
 
Been saying this for a while now, the experience just doesn't live up to the hype. The more the supporters hype it, the harder it is going to fall. I've said it more times than I can count and this article just reinforces it. It really is a cool device and as for gaming a really amazing experience...for a a short period of time. That being the real crux of its problem. It is neat but it isn't something people are going to want to spend the kinds of hours they do at a console or PC with. So no, I just don't see it being commercially successful in a manner that revolutionizes anything. It will certainly do well it specific niches, but that is it.

Now talk to me about its potential applications in medical, aerospace and other fields as a tool and I will agree all day it has a bright future indeed.

I accept that it's not ready for prime time, but is that a surprise? It seems like a device has to be out of development before you can judge it's impact. From what I've read, it does as well or better than far more expensive VR goggles did when O.R. first came out.

Is it going to be like TNG's holodeck? Of course not. Are there really people who expect that from Occulus Rift (or any wearable VR projector)? The motion part of it, is not that far out. There's been research tech that does this for at least 10 years (probably longer). From a gaming perspective, I believe there's a company that's already got a prototype; however that seems like a niche product to me.

Ultimately, I expect these goggles to be come very small and light, but I do agree with someone else that said these have to become monitor/TV replacement quality to truly become mainstream.

Clearly FB sees some potential (then again Apple tossed big money for Beatz and you'd think Apple could design headphones that look as good and sound at least as good for the same MSRP, with very little R&D on the audio side.
 
I'm uncertain it will gain mainstream viability but I think it's a step in the right direction. The whole 3d glasses was too early and we didn't have the technology and hardware to support it back in the mid 90's.

http://www.virtualrealityreviewer.com/dactyl-nightmare-90s-virtual-reality-oculus-rift/

It was a fad, but I think people are willing to put up with it a bit more now. I still want a CAST AR kit myself to make some augmented reality circuit designs or instant visualized plans. There's practical applications out there people- it's not going to be just for games for very long.

So NO. It's not going to fail as long as enough of us rally and make it a useful tool and entertainment option.
 
If I can wear this thing for a few hours at a time and not get nauseous that would be awesome. I haven't tried any of the dev rifts, but plan on checking out the commercial version when available. I'm hoping this takes off for virtual presence more so than gaming. If I could skip my commute to work but still be there in meetings, etc. I would be very happy. I would pay as much as a high end car to avoid getting in mine and sitting in traffic for 2hrs/day.

I'm sure something like that to take off would be 5-10yrs out, but I'm still hopeful. They aren't going to fix the roads in Austin.. ever.
 
If I can wear this thing for a few hours at a time and not get nauseous that would be awesome. I haven't tried any of the dev rifts, but plan on checking out the commercial version when available

games where your virtual person is in a static position (sitting in a chair), the nauseous feeling is being reduced greatly from DK1 -> DK2, and to be honest, with DK2 sitting in a car in www.liveforspeed.net is enjoyable for hours without any nausea...

now with even lower latency in CV1 and higher refresh rates, higher resolution and wider positional tracking, it is really an extremely awesome piece of equipment. implementing support for it isn't even that hard, with 2 mainstream engines already providing native support (Unreal, Unity) , so it's guaranteed to be an useful accessory to a cool gaming setup.

Step inside your virtual Ferrari and of you go, the Rift is the actually the cheapest piece of gaming gear, compared to $500+ steering wheels and $500 flight sticks :)
 
Alot of this could be said about the Wii and it was very sucessful. Not that tons of people played Wii games but everyone wanted to own one around the holiday season.
 
It doesn't need to appeal to mass markets. This will be widely adopted in the sim community because of it's application there. DCS/Arma and now star citizen. Being able to control your view independently of controls is almost an absolute necessity for these types of games.

I'm one of those sim-heads, and I even can't see the sim community adopting Oculus Rift en masse. Especially for those hardcore civilian flight simmers that build cockpits and use MFDs and other non-HOTAS controllers.

And there are cheaper DIY ways to do head tracking besides TrackIR.
 
Alot of this could be said about the Wii and it was very sucessful. Not that tons of people played Wii games but everyone wanted to own one around the holiday season.

I can say that Wii is pretty much dead now. I'm not saying the same for Rift but using Wii as an example is not a good one.
 
Back
Top