Why ATX and not uATX

Teancum

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 12, 2003
Messages
275
For a while I've been watching what people use when they build their rigs, and I've had one question that keeps bothering me:

Why does everybody always use a full-ATX motherboard instead of a uATX board?

The most obvious reason I can see to get an ATX MB is the fact that you get more PCI slots and DIMM slots. But most people, even on this forum, rarely have more than 3 expansion cards in their machine anyway. The only other reason I can think of is that a select few features can only be found on full-ATX motherboards--things like SLI and flexible overclocking controls. However, (again, even here) few people have SLI setups, and all the overclocking features *could* be included on a uATX board easily--it's just a few things in the chipset and BIOS.

uATX is a smaller form factor that can be fit into more things (including ATX cases), and it seems like it would be cheaper to manufacture. I personally am a fan of uATX cases, but I want to know the other perspective. Is there something I'm missing here?
 
A lot of the uATX boards are not OC'ers ... at least they are not designed to be. They were used to be designed as an entry level boards for low-cost PCs ... hopefully this will change ...
 
Classic case of supply and demand: most mainboards are ATX and few people seem to have fundamental issues with this formfactor. Ergo, uATX mainboards are only produced for a small minority (mostly people who want to have a small/budget PC). Only if demand for uATX rises will more uATX mainboards be supplied.
 
Teancum said:
For a while I've been watching what people use when they build their rigs, and I've had one question that keeps bothering me:

Why does everybody always use a full-ATX motherboard instead of a uATX board?

The most obvious reason I can see to get an ATX MB is the fact that you get more PCI slots and DIMM slots. But most people, even on this forum, rarely have more than 3 expansion cards in their machine anyway. The only other reason I can think of is that a select few features can only be found on full-ATX motherboards--things like SLI and flexible overclocking controls. However, (again, even here) few people have SLI setups, and all the overclocking features *could* be included on a uATX board easily--it's just a few things in the chipset and BIOS.

uATX is a smaller form factor that can be fit into more things (including ATX cases), and it seems like it would be cheaper to manufacture. I personally am a fan of uATX cases, but I want to know the other perspective. Is there something I'm missing here?

Although I'm aircooling right now, I did want a case that's large enough to probably accept watercooling parts in case I go that route, so that was a factor personally. Ignoring that, I'm using a Socket 939 AMD 64 CPU. Even ignoring the new PCI-E/SLI boards, how many Socket 939 boards in micro ATX are there out there? I can think of maybe one or two at most, and couldn't tell you their model numbers off hand. But not like I hate the form factor, if I was building an entertainment system PC to sit in my living room for instance it would be one I'd look at.
 
I buy whatever has the features and performance I need. For my systems, it doesn't happen on uatx, although I have built a few using those mobos for other people without any problems.

EATX all the way!
 
Another thought--the 'really nice' chipsets all seem to be available only on ATX motherboards. And for a MB manufacturer, putting an nForce2 is a lot more expensive than a plain vanilla VIA or SiS chipset.

But what keeps MB manufacturers from producing a uATX motherboard with a nice chipset? It would be cheaper to produce than a full ATX motherboard and would fulfill the needs of 90% of even the enthusiast crowd.

I guess the question comes down to a chicken-and-the-egg sort of question: Do MB manufacturers avoid putting lots of features on uATX motherboards because of lack of demand, or is there little demand because there are far fewer features? Is this a vicious circle?
 
Back
Top