• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

Which CPU would be better in this situation

smdion

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 30, 2003
Messages
447
I am building a 3D animation machine. Would an AMD or INTEL based system perform better?
 
I'm inclined to say a dual athlon/opteron would be best, but I don't know that for sure.
 
if you have the cash, a dual opteron or intel Xeon will be good

what is the program used for 3d modeling?

my brother is a 3d modeler and got an intel pentium 4 3.4 ghz

he has used cinema 4d and one can see the program supporting hyperthreading
when he renders, the render is divided into two sections
 
To be totally honest here, altough i favor the AMD processors, if you want good render times etc, you would want a P4 w/ Hyper Threading, 3d software loves hyper threading. If you have the cash a Dual Xeon w/ Hyper Threading would be better most 3d software uses both procs and the Hyper Threading. Alos remeber 3d animation also relies alot on the RAM/Vid Card. Get at leas 1 gig of ram, and if you have a crap load of money, get a nVidia Quadro FX or ATI FireGL, the FireGL is just as good and alot cheaper. Good Luck!
 
pistola said:
To be totally honest here, altough i favor the AMD processors, if you want good render times etc, you would want a P4 w/ Hyper Threading, 3d software loves hyper threading. If you have the cash a Dual Xeon w/ Hyper Threading would be better most 3d software uses both procs and the Hyper Threading. Alos remeber 3d animation also relies alot on the RAM/Vid Card. Get at leas 1 gig of ram, and if you have a crap load of money, get a nVidia Quadro FX or ATI FireGL, the FireGL is just as good and alot cheaper. Good Luck!

would an ATI Radeon 9800 XT work...? or go for the Fire?
 
Aztlan said:
if you have the cash, a dual opteron or intel Xeon will be good

what is the program used for 3d modeling?

my brother is a 3d modeler and got an intel pentium 4 3.4 ghz

he has used cinema 4d and one can see the program supporting hyperthreading
when he renders, the render is divided into two sections

what mobo would you recommend?
 
theblabbingfool said:
would an ATI Radeon 9800 XT work...? or go for the Fire?

Sure thats what I use. And 3ds Max would love a Intel with hyper threading. 2 would be utter joy for Max.
 
Gotta let the people know your budget. Are you going for absolute performance top of the line, or what the best is for a specific price range.

-K
 
pistola said:
To be totally honest here, altough i favor the AMD processors, if you want good render times etc, you would want a P4 w/ Hyper Threading, 3d software loves hyper threading. If you have the cash a Dual Xeon w/ Hyper Threading would be better most 3d software uses both procs and the Hyper Threading. Alos remeber 3d animation also relies alot on the RAM/Vid Card. Get at leas 1 gig of ram, and if you have a crap load of money, get a nVidia Quadro FX or ATI FireGL, the FireGL is just as good and alot cheaper. Good Luck!

I agree with most here, but my vote would be for the ATI Radeon 9800XT for the Rendering. It has the fast core processor, not to mention the DDR memory behind it. IIRC, don't the FireGLs have a slower processor?

Oh yes, the processors. I would definitely go the INtel dual Xeon. At least a P4 3.0 GHz. Raptor HD and at least 1 GB of RAM, maybe 2GB if that can be swung.
 
If you're going with dual xeons, I'd go for the ASUS PC-DL Deluxe. I can't wait to get mine up and running (2 2.66GHz Xeons are out of my price range, at the moment)
 
JSClark said:
I agree with most here, but my vote would be for the ATI Radeon 9800XT for the Rendering. It has the fast core processor, not to mention the DDR memory behind it. IIRC, don't the FireGLs have a slower processor?

Oh yes, the processors. I would definitely go the INtel dual Xeon. At least a P4 3.0 GHz. Raptor HD and at least 1 GB of RAM, maybe 2GB if that can be swung.

Acutally its exactly the same as the 9800XT in terms of the core and ram, well the FireGL X2-256t. But the major differances is its tweaked for realtime rendering like working in a 3d enviorment, and it has OpenGL shader langauges which is important in 3d anaimation video card. The 9800XT will do just fine, but if you can get the FireGL.
 
Back
Top