What's an acceptable frame rate?

Acceptable frame rate?

  • 100+ FPS

    Votes: 23 4.4%
  • 60+ FPS, no dips below 60 FPS

    Votes: 109 20.7%
  • 60 FPS, occasionally below 60 FPS

    Votes: 122 23.2%
  • 45+ FPS, no dips below 45 FPS

    Votes: 82 15.6%
  • 45 FPS, occasionally below 45 FPS

    Votes: 77 14.6%
  • 30+ FPS, no dips below 30 FPS

    Votes: 113 21.5%

  • Total voters
    526
kpedge said:
In my experience, 72 Hz seems to be the "sweet spot". I know everyone's different, but that seems to do the trick for me as far as eye strain goes.

I have it now at 85Hz still. The pain has gone away. I could set it at 72Hz, but it would force me to recalibrate the screen size, which is a tedious process for me. :D
 
Well , i voted for 60+ with dips below. I find that to be the best and acceptable. I will play at lower in some games (Joint Ops) and not really mind it, but 60 is what i work for.
 
I'm fairly good with refresh rates... gimmie a monitor and I could guess weather its 60hz, 70hz, 75hz, or 85hz... however, I can no longer tell the difference between 85hz and anything above 85hz... e.g. to the average joe, 85hz is the limit of not seeing flicker. If you're going CRT, make sure your monitor can do at least 1280x1024 @ 85hz. 1600x1200 is even better... I recommend the old sony G400. If you uncheck the "do not show modes the monitor does not support" you can safetly run 1600x1200 @85hz... and go all the way up to that 2048x1536 resolution as well, if you ever needed to. I'll tell yah, Q3 @ 2048x1536, and you see no need for AA!
 
What's funny is that there is an actual fps measurement that is physically impossible to achieve. Turns out that time is quantized. Physicists have found that time is organized into frames that are a couple millionths of a second in length. So the universal limit on refresh rate is actually in the millions of frames per second...

This message has been brought to you by the "Give-A-Crap" Foundation, "Because fertilizer should be free."
 
For me, the minimum framerate is just as important, if not more, than the average.

Above about 45-50fps is 'smooth' to me. However, below 30fps is very irritating.

I guess the most important bits of information for me from a benchmark would be:

Average fps
Minimum fps
% of time spent below 45fps
% of time spent below 30fps

[H] fraps output graphs are great, because I can get a good idea of each of these.
 
Optimus said:
What's funny is that there is an actual fps measurement that is physically impossible to achieve. Turns out that time is quantized. Physicists have found that time is organized into frames that are a couple millionths of a second in length. So the universal limit on refresh rate is actually in the millions of frames per second...

yes, time is quantised, but it's size is extremely small (space is also quantised, in the order of 10^-34m ish).

The smallest time that has any physical significance is the length of time it takes for light to travel the distance of a hydrogen atom. The size of quantisation is many powers of 10 smaller than this, so the 'funny' argument has no real point.

Also, note that the time it takes for your processor to do a clock cycle is much smaller than 'a couple millionths of a second'. How would this work if you were right?
 
Look here, Arseface... :D

Hehe... Just had to be punny.... oh, the humanity! :p

I apologize, my know-it-all friend, but I neglected to include the additional scientific notation on the figure which I saw. But for you, I'll look it up... :rolleyes:

Theoretically it is 10^-44 seconds as per this link.
Experimentally this has not been measured yet, as far as I have heard.

Interesting pages found during my search:
http://www.science-frontiers.com/sf103/sf103a05.htm
http://www.draaisma.net/rudi/science_cosmology/quantized_time_eternity.html
One actually suggesting with evidence that time is not quantized:
http://www.astronomy.com/Content/Dynamic/Articles/000/000/001/219fcvov.asp
 
I was able to come up with the 3^10^-44 without reading those links :p how long does it take to go the shortest distance (plank length) at the fastest possible speed (speed of light).. 10^-44s not sure that means a whole lot... the only one to try to test the idea says it doesn't hold.
 
tranCendenZ said:
I hope HardOCP is looking at this poll :)

Out of the 172 people that voted, only 21% agree with HardOCP's review criteria for acceptable framerate.
We picked the number we did as that is what we see as required to play the game in an enjoyable manner. Obviously, from our graphs and data, you will be able to look and see if there is room for you to adjust for your faster framerates, but it will be known that you will do it at some sacrifice to the visual quality we have outlined. Doing it this way allows us to cover about all that would be using them game. I think it is common knowledge that pulling back resolution or AA/AF will give you some performance if that is what you need.

What I have found amazing in the last couple of years is this. (And keep in mind this is coming from a hardcore FPS junkie that used to demand 200+ fps to Quake deathmatch.) Playing a ton of different games with FRAPS on you will find that even down to 15 fps is accpetable in SOME games.
 
I always find it amazing how a thread about framerate turns into a pseudo-scientific argument about the refresh rate fo the universe.

:eek:

So it turns out God is GPU limited, bwahahaha :D

Kyle, I think you should make the minimum framerate 45. I think that would make the reviews perfect. Really, we live in an age of immensely powerful hardware (don't we always? :( ), and when you think about it we should be demanding full quality at more than 35FPS. I know it iritates me when the framerate drops below 50, I can definitely feel it.
 
tranCendenZ said:
I hope HardOCP is looking at this poll :)

Out of the 172 people that voted, only 21% agree with HardOCP's review criteria for acceptable framerate.

I hope they notice too. B/c most "Hard Gamers" need a higher FPS. Those minimum fps in the 20's & 30's just wont cut it. Most want a minimum of 45-60 and an average of 60-100+
 
Back
Top