Water Powered Car

Anyone who thinks ethanol is a good solution hasn't taken a large look at the facts. The biggest, and most obvious reason ethanol is a bad choice - is that it is currently produced from corn. Corn is used in most of the food products we buy. It doesn't take a genius to understand that if we start using ethanol on a large scale, the price of food goes up considerably. This has already happened a little, and we're using it on a small scale.

I'm not sure where you're from, but outside of the midwest, where I'm from, ethanol stations are also few and far between. Not to mention that their "Green" claims are "dubious" at best.. obviously requiring fossil fuels to be produced in the first place, and only offering 2/3 of the energy that's in a gallon of gasoline.

But the reality is -- if we'd ever use it on a mass scale we'd be killing ourselves in food cost increases.

I'm not fan for ethanol myself, but you completely sidestepped the part of his argument about using waste and useless land to grow the plants for production of ethanol so that corn doesn't have to be used. Plus, the Government pays farmers to NOT grow crops to keep the market artificially inflated.
 
You haven't been paying attention. Ethanol production for fuel has been on the rise for quite some time. Current crop choices (esp. corn) compete with food demand, decreasing supply and increasing the price of food, and increasing greenhouse gases due to fertilizer production and harvesting requirements.

Don't you dare fucking say corn supply is limited. Government subsidies are the only reason corn supply isn't so high it overflows into the streets. Farmers are paid to NOT grow corn on large parts of their land and just let it sit idle. Corn demand is way to high now for these ridiculous subsidies to exist anymore for a crop that has multiple major volume uses.

The fact that YOU are within easy driving distance of an E85 station (there's only about 2000 total in the country), is NOT proof that the market isn't limited.

Also, I didn't say anything about E85 not being "pure enough".

I said that if you think you're going to replace the entire automotive fuel economy of the US with E85 or E100, you're nuts. The only reason it's as inexpensive as it is now is because of corn subsidies. You gain any sort of real market traction though and those subsidies go away.

I won't even dignify your accusations of ignorance with a reply.

SUBSIDIES KEEP THE PRICES HIGH DUE TO STUNTED PRODUCTION. Talk about fucking ignorance!
 
Can't remember the manufacturer of the concept car that worked but Top gear had test driven it back in 03 I think, I think that ran on sea water as well.

I personally think Hydrogen powered cars are teh way to go myself, it's infinite unlike sea water which will eventually run out if 16 billion people are burning it up.
 
Anyone who thinks ethanol is a good solution hasn't taken a large look at the facts. The biggest, and most obvious reason ethanol is a bad choice - is that it is currently produced from corn. Corn is used in most of the food products we buy. It doesn't take a genius to understand that if we start using ethanol on a large scale, the price of food goes up considerably. This has already happened a little, and we're using it on a small scale.

I'm not sure where you're from, but outside of the midwest, where I'm from, ethanol stations are also few and far between. Not to mention that their "Green" claims are "dubious" at best.. obviously requiring fossil fuels to be produced in the first place, and only offering 2/3 of the energy that's in a gallon of gasoline.

But the reality is -- if we'd ever use it on a mass scale we'd be killing ourselves in food cost increases.

If the government didn't pay off farmers to reduce their supply, market demand would be more than satiated by the true production capabilities of corn farmers.
 
Can't remember the manufacturer of the concept car that worked but Top gear had test driven it back in 03 I think, I think that ran on sea water as well.

I personally think Hydrogen powered cars are teh way to go myself, it's infinite unlike sea water which will eventually run out if 16 billion people are burning it up.

Do a little more research before you side with the failure that is Hydrogen.
 
Fact is, it doesn't have to be made from corn. In fact corn is one of the poorest choices. It was simply a way to keep corn producers in cash flow. Corn does work in one way though. As I have already stated in an earlier post above, corn used to create ethanol, is now a better feed for cattle(estimated %25 more food value(fattening)) You do realize that huge amounts of corn produced are used as livestock feed? Now this same feed has given us virtually free fuel and better cattle feed. Corn or any grain is not in short supply. Hence the broke American farmer!!! Your believing big oil fud!
 
I personally think Hydrogen powered cars are teh way to go myself, it's infinite unlike sea water which will eventually run out if 16 billion people are burning it up.

What the hell? First of all, the most widespread source of hydrogen is IN WATER. You know, H2O? Hint, the H stands for HYDROGEN. And hydrogen is *NOT* infinite, where the hell did you get that idea?

Second, when you burn something, it doesn't disappear. In basic terms, when you burn something you are just adding oxygen (O2). When you combust (burn) hydrogen, you get water (more specifically, water vapor), hence why you can't use water as a fuel (it is already "used"). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combustion

Pretty much all of the hydrogen on Earth is already "used" - hence why it can't be used as a fuel, it can only be used as a battery.
 
If the government didn't pay off farmers to reduce their supply, market demand would be more than satiated by the true production capabilities of corn farmers.

The reason the government started subsidizing crops is because farming markets tend to follow a vicious cycle..

1) Population increases and thus demand increases...
3) farmers buy more equipment and land to grow more crops to meet demand.
4) market prices don't cover the cost of new equipment
5) farmers grow more crops to cover their losses
6) market becomes flooded with crops, prices fall
7) farmer grow more crops to try and cover losses again.
8) market goes through the floor.
9) banks repossess farm equipment and land, supply drops, demand increases, market prices go through the roof and no one can afford to buy food.
 
People have too many conspiracy theories on "big oil" as if they are some Pseudo Captain Planet villian who rubs their hands together every time a million barrels of oil is burned..."mwahah pollution, oil!!!"

It's all about money and why shouldn't it be, when's the last time you got or did something for free other than for a loved one? Nature of the world people.

I guarantee if the oil companies knew of a technology that was confirmed to work, they would either patent it or devote all their resources into manufacturing it.

And yes, we all read Physics of the Impossible. You're not that clever I'm afraid...
 
Oil companies have killed every good inventor that has gotten in their way. This isn't just a company like microsoft or something like that, these big main head leader corporations of oil are in the middle east where its basically lawless. They'll kill anyone that gets in their way. They've bought out people with large sums of money and also bought out companies which produce alternatives energies. They destroy these companies like the electric car and right now i think the idea of water is being suppressed also. People think its impossible. I think the water car is possible. I saw many videos on it before already. I just think these big oil corporations are making people think oil is the only thing they need by spreading lies about all the technologies are not going to work. If the car is running in a video and you can obviously see the person driving it then its real unless its edited but more than likely its real.
 
If the government didn't pay off farmers to reduce their supply, market demand would be more than satiated by the true production capabilities of corn farmers.

Actually the last few years they have been paid to grow more corn to subsidize ethanol.. That was a Bush policy BTW. And now environmental groups are recognizing that corn based ethanol is bad. Cellulosic ethanol might change the picture.

http://gas2.org/2008/12/19/environmental-groups-oppose-ethanol-bailout-stimulus-pa/
http://redgreenandblue.org/2009/02/03/study-finds-corn-ethanol-just-as-bad-as-gasoline/
http://greenchemistry.wordpress.com/2007/12/16/why-corn-ethanol-is-bad/
http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2007/10/ethanol-effect-when-alternative-fuels-go-bad
http://www.autobloggreen.com/2007/09/14/why-corn-ethanol-is-especially-bad-for-california/
http://www.alternet.org/environment/118436/ethanol_is_a_disaster,_but_what_about_other_biofuels/
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=18784732
http://minneapolis.metblogs.com/2009/04/15/why-do-ethanol-supporters-hate-the-environment/

Now I suppose you could argue that all those are somehow subverted by the oil conspiracy.. lol, but you might as well start wearing tinfoil hats and worrying about aliens too.

It's simple. Energy in to making ethanol from corn = over 60% (by the most generous estimates) of the energy you get out, and you divert corn from the food supply, and use land that would be a carbon sink if left in it's natural state. What you are left with, is a bad idea.
 
Oil companies have killed every good inventor that has gotten in their way. This isn't just a company like microsoft or something like that, these big main head leader corporations of oil are in the middle east where its basically lawless. They'll kill anyone that gets in their way. They've bought out people with large sums of money and also bought out companies which produce alternatives energies. They destroy these companies like the electric car and right now i think the idea of water is being suppressed also. People think its impossible. I think the water car is possible. I saw many videos on it before already. I just think these big oil corporations are making people think oil is the only thing they need by spreading lies about all the technologies are not going to work. If the car is running in a video and you can obviously see the person driving it then its real unless its edited but more than likely its real.

That's quite a bold claim. Prove it.

Now, as far as water being used as a fuel, it IS impossible. It doesn't burn on it's own like hydrocarbon based fuels do. Water is and always will be only capable of carrying energy, and the vast majority of cases it's better to just use the energy source (i.e. chemical or electricity) to directly power a car.

The whole seawater burning thing is a sham. It is simply the same science classroom experiment that was taught to high-school kids 50 years ago, electrolysis. It just does it by induction rather than directly.
 
I'm not fan for ethanol myself, but you completely sidestepped the part of his argument about using waste and useless land to grow the plants for production of ethanol so that corn doesn't have to be used. Plus, the Government pays farmers to NOT grow crops to keep the market artificially inflated.

I sidestepped lots of things because there's no reason this needs to even be a debate.. such as..

According to the Cornell study, to create one gallon of ethanol, it
takes 21.6 pounds of corn, and one acre of land can yield a total of
7,100 pounds of corn. Corn is also grown on a yearly basis, so that
equals out to about 328 gallons of corn for every acre grown per year.
According to the Department of Energy, the United States currently
demands around 9.2 million barrels of oil per day (just for gasoline),
and a barrel holds about 42 gallons each, which means that the U.S.
demands close to 378 million gallons of gasoline per day. If all cars
ran on ethanol, which is not as efficient as gasoline, the U.S. would
need around 567 million gallons of ethanol per day. Doing the math,
the U.S. would have to grow close to 1.7 million acres of corn per
day, or over 630 million acres of corn per year, just to produce
enough ethanol to feed the yearly U.S consumption rate. For further
comparison, one acre of land is equal to 4.04 km , so the U.S. would
need to grow around 2.5 billion km of corn per year to fuel its
thirst. To put this in perspective, the Earth's surface area
(including oceans) is only 510 million km , so it would take the land
surface of five Earths to feed the U.S. demand for ethanol for one
year."

Radford University: E85 Ethanol Grows in Popularity, but it's not the Answer
http://www.radford.edu/~whim/tech/articles/ethanol.html
 
Actually, after reading into it, it would appear his math is.. wrong. But the amount of land you'd have to farm to get the entire US powered by Ethanol is still greater than the amount of land we have to farm.

Facts:
One gallon of ethanol = 21.6 lbs of corn
The yield of one acre of corn = 7100 lbs of corn
Amount of gasoline that U.S. consumes in one day = 9,200,000 barrels
One barrel can hold 42 gallons
One gallon of gasoline = 1.5 gallons of ethanol
One acre of land = .004 km2
The surface land area of the U.S. = 9,161,923 km2
Arable land in the U.S. 18.01%

Math
One acre of corn production in gallons: 21.6 pounds / 7100 pounds = 328 gallons
U.S. daily consumption in gallons: 9,200,000 barrels / 42 gallons = 378,000,000 gallons
U.S. daily consumption need in ethanol: 378,000,000 gallons of gasoline * 1.5 = 567,000,000 gallons
U.S. corn acreage daily need to produce enough ethanol: 567,000,000 gallons / 328 gallons = 1,700,000 acres
U.S. corn acreage yearly need to produce enough ethanol: 1,700,000 acres * 365 days = 630,000,000 acres
Surface area required to meet the U.S. yearly need of corn to make ethanol: 630,000,000 acres * .004 km2 = 2,520,000 km2
Arable land divided by total land surface in U.S.: 18.01% * 9,161,923 = 1,650,062.33 km2
 
My point was that he was arguing that we use something more efficient at creating ethanol than corn and you're still arguing that corn-based ethanol isn't sustainable.
 
My point was that he was arguing that we use something more efficient at creating ethanol than corn and you're still arguing that corn-based ethanol isn't sustainable.

Ok, if we can get off of corn and on to something else.. maybe. But even Brazil growing sugarcane can only provide less than 17% of their needs (50% of their cars and none of their large trucks run on E25, or 75% gasoline). And we can't grow sugarcane in most of the US.

The only possible future solutions are cellulose based ethanol or perhaps algae based fuel, neither of which are commercially viable yet.
 
The reason the government started subsidizing crops is because farming markets tend to follow a vicious cycle..

1) Population increases and thus demand increases...
3) farmers buy more equipment and land to grow more crops to meet demand.
4) market prices don't cover the cost of new equipment
5) farmers grow more crops to cover their losses
6) market becomes flooded with crops, prices fall
7) farmer grow more crops to try and cover losses again.
8) market goes through the floor.
9) banks repossess farm equipment and land, supply drops, demand increases, market prices go through the roof and no one can afford to buy food.

This is the country that spews "FREE MARKET" shit all the time, yet when ol farmer john's market gets overcrowded, socialism is suddenly the answer instead of the invisible hand?

Fuck that nonsense. You shouldn't get subsidies when your product suddenly has multiple high volume demanding uses.

Actually the last few years they have been paid to grow more corn to subsidize ethanol.. That was a Bush policy BTW. And now environmental groups are recognizing that corn based ethanol is bad. Cellulosic ethanol might change the picture.

http://gas2.org/2008/12/19/environmental-groups-oppose-ethanol-bailout-stimulus-pa/
http://redgreenandblue.org/2009/02/03/study-finds-corn-ethanol-just-as-bad-as-gasoline/
http://greenchemistry.wordpress.com/2007/12/16/why-corn-ethanol-is-bad/
http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2007/10/ethanol-effect-when-alternative-fuels-go-bad
http://www.autobloggreen.com/2007/09/14/why-corn-ethanol-is-especially-bad-for-california/
http://www.alternet.org/environment/118436/ethanol_is_a_disaster,_but_what_about_other_biofuels/
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=18784732
http://minneapolis.metblogs.com/2009/04/15/why-do-ethanol-supporters-hate-the-environment/

Now I suppose you could argue that all those are somehow subverted by the oil conspiracy.. lol, but you might as well start wearing tinfoil hats and worrying about aliens too.

It's simple. Energy in to making ethanol from corn = over 60% (by the most generous estimates) of the energy you get out, and you divert corn from the food supply, and use land that would be a carbon sink if left in it's natural state. What you are left with, is a bad idea.

From one of your own links
"But environmental groups say that the ethanol industry already receives more federal support than any other renewable energy program."

A new subsidy does not make the existing subsidies nonexistent. Its just MORE subsidies for an undeserving industry with shit tons of lobbyists. There is no demand shortage now, and even back then, there was only a supply overage until socialism stepped in to save the day in a failed "free market".
 
we just need highly advanced batteries, that's all. battery technology will explode at some point, it has to. until then, i think hydrogen serves as a great medium for storing and using energy for our vehicles.
 
we just need highly advanced batteries, that's all. battery technology will explode at some point, it has to. until then, i think hydrogen serves as a great medium for storing and using energy for our vehicles.

Flaming laptops are proof it already has :D:D:D
 
This is the country that spews "FREE MARKET" shit all the time, yet when ol farmer john's market gets overcrowded, socialism is suddenly the answer instead of the invisible hand?

Fuck that nonsense. You shouldn't get subsidies when your product suddenly has multiple high volume demanding uses.



From one of your own links

A new subsidy does not make the existing subsidies nonexistent. Its just MORE subsidies for an undeserving industry with shit tons of lobbyists. There is no demand shortage now, and even back then, there was only a supply overage until socialism stepped in to save the day in a failed "free market".

Wait what are we debating? Ethanol and corn subsidies need to stop, they are bad ideas.
 
Ok, if we can get off of corn and on to something else.. maybe. But even Brazil growing sugarcane can only provide less than 17% of their needs (50% of their cars and none of their large trucks run on E25, or 75% gasoline). And we can't grow sugarcane in most of the US.

The only possible future solutions are cellulose based ethanol or perhaps algae based fuel, neither of which are commercially viable yet.

Agreed [to Ryan]-- if farms could grow sugar for ethanol and reap more profits in corn -- don't you think they'd be doing it?
And while it is definitely better than corn - we still wouldn't be self-sufficient if we had that ability to grow sugar cane/beets.
 
we just need highly advanced batteries, that's all. battery technology will explode at some point, it has to. until then, i think hydrogen serves as a great medium for storing and using energy for our vehicles.

I agree with this, but the environmental costs and the actual costs are very high, especially given the lifespan of batteries in their current stage.

With proper batteries we could get electricity from whatever was the most efficient and best way of deriving it in the US.
 
Wait what are we debating? Ethanol and corn subsidies need to stop, they are bad ideas.

Agreed. I thought you were implying that they weren't paid to stop growing because a new subsidy paid them also to grow. My misunderstanding.
 
Back
Top