Video Game Bill Passes

Fortunately consoles already have such a device, it's called a power switch.
 
Many parents dont know to password protect the console and for those that do, kids are damn resourceful. Many will find a way to get hold of the password.
This leaves the machine wide open.
Restricting what kids can buy and rent will help.

Except that this law doesn't do that, it simply mandates that consoles must have a way to voluntarily restrict violent content, which is something they can already do. The fact that it was approved 61 to 1 implies to me that this law was written without any research having been done. This law has done nothing except waste taxpayer money since all of the consoles are already in compliance.

The ESRB ratings are voluntarily applied so there are cases where they are not used.
Improving this will allow parents/shopkeepers to trust the ratings system as a reliable guide to what the kids are buying/using and restrict accordingly.

Interestingly, the law does not mandate that video game manufacturers have to rate their video games in any shape way or form, probably in an attempt to avoid a lawsuit.

My feelings are that if any fight is necessary, its to make sure that the controls that are used are agreeable and not draconian.

Parental control is not an easy task for many parents.
The easier it is and the more trustworthy it is, the better.

Personally, I'm of the opinion that if you tie a leash around a dog's neck and set something out of reach that it wants, it will just go and get it once you release the leash, no matter how long you leave it tied up. Children are the same way.

You need to set the rules and let them learn to control themselves lest they lose privileges. This is how I raise my children, and it works incredibly well. I don't have to set parental controls because they know what they are and are not allowed to do, and if they break the rules, they are disciplined. Discipline is about teaching the child good and bad decisions, which makes parental controls useless because they don't teach the child anything; they just prevent them from getting to it. And just like the dog, once they no longer have that description, they will run to it, only without the benefit of the parent's guidance. Parental controls are short-term delays, not a long-term solution.
 
The vast majority of games are rated by the ESRB. In this case I don't see why the government feels the need to step in 'regulate' an industry that's already self-regulating by trying to create their own 'advisory council' that'll most likely make the same exact recommendations that the ESRB already does.

In fact, it could make things worse by implying that the ESRB cannot be trusted; thus necessitating the need for the 'advisory council' to sink taxpayer money into advising parents about every single game that's already been voluntarily rated.

Besides, I don't know about you but I'd much rather trust the ESRB than have the government judge the decency and appropriateness of a game.
 
Just in the nick of time. Parents everywhere almost had to pay attention to their children for a second there.
 
Wow...my jaw was dropped by the end of that article. The absurdness of this whole affair disgusts me. I really don't know what else to say other than...WTF PEOPLE
 
After working at Comcast for almost 2 years I had learned one important lesson in life...


When kids are young, between the ages of like 1 - 7ish the TV is their automatic baby sitter and when cable doesn't work and the kids could not get their daily dosage of Sprouts I had seen so many stay at home parents make the transformation from "Normal and somewhat rational human berings" to the vocal equivelant of a Forum Troll with Mace in their eyes....

Parents in this age grew up with the TV being a center of entertainment for them at most points of their lives... They have no idea how to fill the void that is created by one day of no cable TV service, primarily due to their kids wanting "Unusual Amounts of Attentions from their Parents"... Go figure!

And I'm assuming at later ages their automatic baby sitter is the video games consoles... Which means the parents have no time to be bothered to look at something for even a minute otherwise their investment into the robotic automatic baby sitting device is not working as intended....
 
A video game bill that wanted, among other things, to create an advisory council on interactive media and youth violence has passed the NY state assembly. The bill requires video game consoles to be equipped with a device or control to permit owners to prevent the display of violent or indecent video games.

That's excellent news. Parents don't always have time to fully investigate the video games their children play, so a switch that blocks mature rated content would be a great asset to parents.

Also, this is NOT censorship. Please don't abuse that word, because when the government truly censors us, we don't want a 'boy who cried wolf' syndrome leading to apathy. The government is requiring a system to allow parents to censor their childrens' gaming habits, and nothing more than that.

If anything, this will actually FIGHT censorship: companies will be able to publish 'R-rated' games with nudity, hardcore sex, and violence and all that stuff and still have a strong argument against the Anti-Gamer/Anti-R-Rated Content crowd; if every system has a way to prevent minors from accessing R rated content with the equivalent of flipping a switch, then Anti-Mature Gaming organizations won't have a case and will cease to fight Adult Gaming.

Again, please recognize that censorship is when the government outlaws the production or sale of mature games to legal adults, but outlawing the sale of mature games directly to minors is simply common sense and a positive action of the government.
 
The current video game rating system simply doesn't work, AoC made that very clear to me. Why doesn't it work? because the vast majority of parents are brain dead and are using video games and TV as a replacement for parenting. As much as I do not like government taking this approach, it is necessary.
 
That's excellent news. Parents don't always have time to fully investigate the video games their children play, so a switch that blocks mature rated content would be a great asset to parents.

Also, this is NOT censorship. Please don't abuse that word, because when the government truly censors us, we don't want a 'boy who cried wolf' syndrome leading to apathy. The government is requiring a system to allow parents to censor their childrens' gaming habits, and nothing more than that.

If anything, this will actually FIGHT censorship: companies will be able to publish 'R-rated' games with nudity, hardcore sex, and violence and all that stuff and still have a strong argument against the Anti-Gamer/Anti-R-Rated Content crowd; if every system has a way to prevent minors from accessing R rated content with the equivalent of flipping a switch, then Anti-Mature Gaming organizations won't have a case and will cease to fight Adult Gaming.

Again, please recognize that censorship is when the government outlaws the production or sale of mature games to legal adults, but outlawing the sale of mature games directly to minors is simply common sense and a positive action of the government.

I agree with your point of view in the fact that this will become a standing ground as far as making a point against those who demand censorship in video games.... But read what I said and tell me that parents are doing their full jobs as that role figure for their child when they don't even take the time to read a summary of what is being fed to their childrens brains.... It's like parents use these devices to seperate themselves from their children and their childrens interests... Otherwise parents would know what their children were playing on the living room TV set...

Now I'm not making this a dig on all parents, but it's quite ugly these days, with how parents view their own individual needs vs. their childrens...

The only thing I fear though, is the fact that these devices aren't simple enough for a parent with low technical abilities to figure out (which is usually the case)... Which then defeats the argument against censorship and gives those who preach censorship another point in their argument... "If you can't make the devices for censorship easy enough for an idiot to use, than you need to tone down and start blocking any violent content or nudity within games."
 
Like others have said, this technology already exists in all consoles. (Actually I'm not sure about the ps3)
 
I had a nice big long post for this, but then I decided it was better for the SoapBox. And even then, I'm not sure it's even SoapBox safe.
 
This is an absolute waste of taxpayer's money. Lawmakers should just spend money on important things like national security. :mad:
 
To be fair, the PS3's parental controls can be circumvented as easily as resetting the console to factory settings (this option does not require a password, presumably so people can use it if they forget the password...lol). I imagine the PSP has the same flaw, but I don't own one to say for sure.
 
I agree with your point of view in the fact that this will become a standing ground as far as making a point against those who demand censorship in video games.... But read what I said and tell me that parents are doing their full jobs as that role figure for their child when they don't even take the time to read a summary of what is being fed to their childrens brains.... It's like parents use these devices to seperate themselves from their children and their childrens interests... Otherwise parents would know what their children were playing on the living room TV set...

Now I'm not making this a dig on all parents, but it's quite ugly these days, with how parents view their own individual needs vs. their childrens...

The only thing I fear though, is the fact that these devices aren't simple enough for a parent with low technical abilities to figure out (which is usually the case)... Which then defeats the argument against censorship and gives those who preach censorship another point in their argument... "If you can't make the devices for censorship easy enough for an idiot to use, than you need to tone down and start blocking any violent content or nudity within games."

I agree with you that parents often do a terrible job rearing their children, either do to time, apathy, or stupidity. I see this law as a tool for parents to more easily control the content their children use for entertainment on a daily basis. Nothing more.

Ideally, children would spend a few hours a week playing video games, and the rest of their time playing sports, studying math and science, reading books, working or volunteering, and socializing with their peers. That's not going to happen. :-(
 
The sad fact is that most people (primarily parents, but retailers too) can't be bothered to show due diligence and restrict violent content getting into the hands of minors.

I actually scolded my mom for buying Bully for my 8yr old nephew. He started to act out parts of the game and was a little shit for a few weeks. I asked her if she looked at the rating and she asked me "What rating?"

My nephew grabbed the case for it and showed it to her. If an 8 year old knows that game isn't for him that's pretty bad a parent won't check the ratings. Of course he didn't say anything when she bought it because he knew he wouldn't get it then. :D

The funny thing is I had to have them buy Half-Life 1 for me when it came out and they sat me down and asked if I was adult enough for the game. That was when I was 12 and had been playing the Doom and Quake series since they came out.
 
Anti-Vilonce switch....
One has been on EVERY game system I've gotten... NES, SNES, PS, PS2, ETC... it's called the power switch....

Got to love the V-Chip for games.
 
Back
Top