User Choice and Music Licensing

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
YouTube has come up with a novel way of dealing with video clips that contain unauthorized music, giving the uploader the option of removing the video or allowing the video to stay… with no sound. What do you think of this idea?

Previously, when a music label or other rights owner issued a copyright claim to block audio, the video was automatically taken down. Uploaders had two choices: dispute the claim (in the case of fair use, for example) or use our AudioSwap tool to replace the track with one from our library of pre-cleared music. Now we've added an additional choice. Instead of automatically removing the video from YouTube, we give users the option to modify the video by removing the music subject to the copyright claim and post the new version, and many of them are taking that option.
 
I think it's really stupid for music labels to frown upon this. Users aren't making money from it, and whenever I view a video that uses a song I've never heard but really dig, I look into the artist and sometimes even buy the song.

Is the RIAA going to hire college students to go around campuses and shut down people blasting music from their dorm room windows? Frat house parties? All it does is spread awareness and create potential sales.

Or am I wrong?
 
Does anyone know where to find a list of 'pre-cleared' music for Youtube? As a youtube video producer I keep hearing about Youtube's pre-cleared music list but I've never actually seen a list. It would help to know what music is safe and what isn't.
 
snip

I think it's really stupid for music labels to frown upon this. Users aren't making money from it, and whenever I view a video that uses a song I've never heard but really dig, I look into the artist and sometimes even buy the song.

thats what I was thinking
 
Yeah, I ran across one of these last night. The video was pointless wo/ the music to go with it.
 
I think it's really stupid for music labels to frown upon this. Users aren't making money from it, and whenever I view a video that uses a song I've never heard but really dig, I look into the artist and sometimes even buy the song.

"GASP" That just makes too much sense, what were you thinking! You should be ashamed of your logical thoughts!
 
Half the responses to your typical youtube video are "what song is that in the background?". Stupid stupid stupid RIAA.
 
What better way to keep people from stealing your music by preventing them from ever hearing it! lol ZOMG the lost profits incurred from some kids soundtrack to his fanmade jackie chan clips.
 
Half the responses to your typical youtube video are "what song is that in the background?". Stupid stupid stupid RIAA.

Totally agreed.

I've resorted to using obscure classical pieces in most of my videos now because I've already had 2 youtube accounts closed due to 'copyright infringement'.

Funny story:

Recently I had a family christmas video that kept getting flagged because a small portion of 'Dizzy' by Tommy Roe was playing in the background audio from a TV that happened to be turned on. I swear... it was a video of my family opening presents and because of 20 seconds of an oldies tune from a TV on in the background the video isn't allowed on Youtube.

Bah what a crock of shit.
 
What they would rather do is raise the price on songs and make you pay for them to advertise to you instead of "free" from word of mouth. Oh wait, they already charge way over what it actually costs to produce a song... Why do we have music labels again? heh
 
This is ridiculous. If O-Zone made that numa numa guy remove the audio from his video before it became popular then they would be losing out on hundred of thousands of sales. That video made the band so popular that they even had a choir touring with a opera version of their song. This is a huge example of how music companies don't do whats best for their artists. There could be thousands of dollars missing from artists and company pockets because of this. Another example of this is OK Go who made a popular video without the record companies permission.

Do music companies seriously think people are going to rip the audio from all these videos. The people who are tech savvy enough to rip music from youtube videos are most likely knowledgeable enough to find and download the song illegally. Even then so companies should just limit the bitrate so ripping the songs will give you the same quality as say recording off the radio. Removing music from these sites just limits how an artist can be heard in our evolving world.
 
What this just may do is push some unsigned bands into popularity, proving to the world artists no longer need the recording industry.
 
What this just may do is push some unsigned bands into popularity, proving to the world artists no longer need the recording industry.

i've been saying this for a long time. All my bands have recorded the demo's at home... if you are willing to take some time to learn how to do it right you can get everything you need for pretty cheap and never owe a dime to any third party.

the recording industry is one that is in its dying years...all these recent issues are just them trying to cling to their fading relevance
 
I've got stuff flagged but it is just blocked in a few countries (nothing major). On the other hand anything even remotely related to Foks movies, gets deleted quickly . But if there is no reference to it in the description it is left alone. So they don't actually look at videos ,initially. I don't blame Youtube though, they're simply stuck between a rock and hard place, trying to make the best of it.
 
The fact that they take down videos because of songs is dumb in itself. They're removing FREE advertising for that band or musician. What idiots. (RIAA)

I've had two videos pulled for that so far. One was showing Unreal Tournament 3 footage and one had Team Fortress 2 soldier gameplay.

I was advertising those games and the nice songs (from Jimmy Eatworld and Muse). Those videos had tens of thousands of views, so the RIAA basically cost those 2 bands tens of thousands of potential song sales.

See? That's why I love companies like Valve. They let people mod their games and post as many videos and pics from them as they want, and that's how they got so famous and successful. Other companies, full of idiots, try to sue you for advertising their work in a positive way. That's why those companies don't deserve any success.
 
what I don't get is if they keep blocking things like that...then where do we find out about new music from...theoretically anyway, i've moved away from most big label stuff and the few i still follow aren't on any of the "yarr riaa!" labels.

The last time i got stuck listening to the radio i remember it being more sterile than a maternity ward. I think i maybe heard 8 different songs...all not too heavy we don't want to upset grandma.

Do they seriously expect us to just blindly buy music nowadays? honestly thats what i sounds like with all this...Here take a random chance on a band...only 17.99!

eat me, i'll take a random chance on a download...it's free for me to reinstall windows...i paid for one of those keys
 
I posted a custom vid of a few dives I did back in the day and I used a popular metal band as the soundtrack. Sure enough, I received a warning from Universal Media Group; however I just want to go on record for saying that they actually gave me a choice: 1). remove the soundtrack from the video, or 2). they would place advertisements of their choosing within the content. They also mentioned they'd continue to monitor the popularity of the media in question and change their policy if necessary.

I was too lazy to redo the whole track and I had already scrapped the raw unmixed data, so I let them rape my media with their ads (which truth-be-told, is expected considering the "free" nature of YouTube). Anyway, the whole point to this shpeal is that they don't always force folks who use more than 30 secs of commercial music on their vids to remove the offending piece; sometimes (especially if it suits their needs), they'll simply claim the media as their own until you choose to remove it.

- James
 
Back
Top