UCLA Professor Lets Students Cheat To Learn

Continually or when it is new content to you? Do you not ever reference concepts that are new to you?

In that reference you'd have a point, but we are talking about people PAYING to be taught how to do something to attain a degree that supports their discipline and show credibility to potential employers who will pay top dollar for those skill sets. And not to sound pompous, when your at my level of experience (25 years+), there are very few things that are "new", mostly newer tech and methods of doing similar methods. I do a lot of digital and analog designs, so a lot reuse happens...but the rules of how it all works are constant and not only have to be memorized but also properly applied....and sometimes creatively expanded on......that isn't something that open book or socializing can achieve.

I was also a college professor for 8 years, and I would have to ask, what are you gonna do if your all alone and stuck somewhere and no one was around to help you fix a circuit? You'd have to KNOW how to diagnose and fix the problem.

How bout this, you work for a company that mass produces stuff......and when it has to be released it costs the company millions of dollars in bad product.....because you weren't smart enough to think of all the angles in which something could have gone wrong.......think cheating and networking will save your bacon from being fired if it happened 1/2/3.....times?

I'm not saying it applies to all fields, but there seems to be a broad paint brush being used that this is an "ok" way to do things.......I flat out say that it is wrong.
 
Memorization is not learning. All a test will do is test your capacity to memorize facts.

I disagree......learning something that is being taught is like learning another language.....people speak their primary language because it is LEARNED because of memorization......how else can you "speak" and communicate if you didn't learn how the nouns, verbs, punctuation all worked?...Same for foreign languages.....how else can you yo speak Italian, French.....etc......unless you memorize the whole thing?.....same is true for any school taught degreed material......it has to be MEMORIZED and then used to be learned how it all works.......and that is for all disciplines.....anyone who thinks otherwise or defends cheating as ok....has something else wrong to justify the action IMO.
 
reminds me of Asimov's Foundation and Earth where Pelorat and Trevise deduced that the Galactic Empire ultimately failed because nobody knew the "why" anymore They just took everything for granted.
 
I disagree......learning something that is being taught is like learning another language.....people speak their primary language because it is LEARNED because of memorization......how else can you "speak" and communicate if you didn't learn how the nouns, verbs, punctuation all worked?...Same for foreign languages.....how else can you yo speak Italian, French.....etc......unless you memorize the whole thing?.....same is true for any school taught degreed material......it has to be MEMORIZED and then used to be learned how it all works.......and that is for all disciplines.....anyone who thinks otherwise or defends cheating as ok....has something else wrong to justify the action IMO.
You have this backwards: people learn to speak and write languages long before they memorize grammar.

Also, if you read the article it's less about allowing students to do whatever they want during the test and more about what happened in the week leading up to it and the application of Game Theory to the testing environment.
 
Memorization is not learning. All a test will do is test your capacity to memorize facts.
No, it doesn't. I agree it will sway toward people who can memorise facts, but a well written test is typically just as easy to answer with on the fly knowledge as it is to answer with memorised facts.

I personally have a terrible memory, but I got pretty high grades through my studies because I could understand concepts and apply them during a test rather than just memorising shit.
My math and physics classes encouraged cheat sheets. But if you didnt understand it beforehand you werent going to teach yourself in the time you took the test anyway.
My physics professors did the same thing; their reasoning was that if students didn't use cheat sheets, we'd program the formulas in our calculators and cheat sheets weren't going to teach us the conceptual part of physics.
I don't care about cheat sheets in a non-competitive world, in a competitive world, I really dislike them. More than once I've had tests which allowed cheat sheets and there was a question that required specific knowledge of something that you wouldn't know unless you copied a particular part of a particular example in to your cheat sheet. Everyone who had copied that in to their cheat sheet got it right, everyone who didn't got at best 50% for that question.

Good professors should include a formula sheet of all information you need to do the test assuming you understand the concepts and ideally the sheet should be available for students before the test itself for students to study where things are located on it.

That's what a good test should be, understand concepts, not being lucky enough to have recorded the exact specific example you need to do a question.
we'd program the formulas in our calculators and cheat sheets weren't going to teach us the conceptual part of physics.
That's why my University banned programmable calculators in exams for engineering students. The only time it was ever a problem was when, from memory, a professor asked a question in an exam that required inverting a rather large matrix which only calculators with a memory can do and was too time consuming to do by hand... but assuming your professors aren't retards they can ask questions that test your knowledge rather than your ability to perform menial mathematical tasks.
Like open book tests. If you know where to find the answer, that's good enough.
It depends on what you are trying to test. In many cases, no, knowing where to find it is not what you're trying to test. You're often trying to test the understanding of a concept. In real life you often aren't asked a question "What is the blah of blah" and given a text book, rather YOU have to have the understanding that you should be asking yourself that question.

There's a world of difference between understanding a concept and understanding where to look if asked a particular question, I want my students to have the former rather than the latter.
 
Awesome. This is how it SHOULD be. In the real world you are not locked in a room alone to try to solve a problem, you normally work with a team, and have access to the internet, books, company resources, etc.

Open book testing is an old thing. Crutching on someone else in the work world has three outcomes

1) You burn your bridge by over using it and you're fired
2) The person helping you ends up neglecting their work and he's fired followed by you being fired when your crutch is no longer there
3) You become a rising star in management.
 
Yeah. I remember taking tests in my programming classes and thinking "When am I ever going to be in a job situation where I'm not allowed to ask questions or look something up?" After almost 20 years in the business, I can honestly say "Never."

When you go for an interview and are tested. :eek:
 
483492_10151669243873465_844197008_n.jpg

I was the guy at the far right. :p Like show up the last day, heyyyy what's going on here guys!
 
Memorization is not learning. All a test will do is test your capacity to memorize facts.

What is learning then? Because most people I know of just memorize everything, even if its the memorization of how to find the answer, but only and incredibly small percent of the population actually solve novel problems. Certainly not enough of them to even fill a single US university.
 
Back
Top