Ubisoft Dev: Xbox 720 Specs Will Be Aligned With PS4

At least with identical specifications, there will be no reason to argue about which console is better so all the various console owners can live on the Internet in a happy, specs aligned utopia, holding each others' hands and singing while they roast marshmallows around a campfire.

Next, the PC gamer types will look in at the Xbox people hugging the Playstation people hugging the Wii people and think, "Hey, I want in on this hugging sweet hugging action too. Maybe I should get a specs aligned PC so I can have a hug."

Except for that one grumpy person that'll sit all alone by the lake pouting about how its not right for everyone to hug without first going through a proper courtship and marriage that includes a reasonable dowry and somehow involves making two families that dislike one another get so upset that everyone drinks hemlock and dies.

That grumpy person probably bought a Wii U or an OUYA.
 
Why do you keep saying the 720 (Durango) will be easier to develop for? I don't remember seeing PCs having embedded ram to supplement slow DDR3.

The PS4 is basically a monster APU (relatively speaking) sitting on 8GB of DDR5 and the OS. There is no special chip to be learned, no fancy buffers, no work around, etc.
 
Why do you keep saying the 720 (Durango) will be easier to develop for? I don't remember seeing PCs having embedded ram to supplement slow DDR3.

The PS4 is basically a monster APU (relatively speaking) sitting on 8GB of DDR5 and the OS. There is no special chip to be learned, no fancy buffers, no work around, etc.

did some digging PS4 only has 4GB of GDDR5 to the 720s 8GB of DDR3

the thing we dont know is the size of the memory bus for the 720 IF its 256bit bus ie 4 channel then the bandwith issue even less then if its only 128bit
we also dont know the speed of the DDR3 as high speed DDR3 with low latency is almost as fast
the 720 setup is also better for all around use like a PC


as to why i think its going to be easier?
MS has historically had better dev kits and support
the 720 dev kit is closer to the same tools already in use for PC games and DX11 is just easier to deal then Sonys API because people already know how to code for DX11
 
oh another thought

i expect that most cross platform games WONT make use off 8GB of ram on the 720

this might give 720 only titles nice boost as they can make use of all 8GB so expect some WOW from the 720 exclusives like the next Forza
 
imo i think both will be great consoles as far as consoles go
performance will be very very close and make the Wii U look dated

it will really come down to how well the devs work with the APIs


as to which console is better? meh its a wash pick the eco system you like better

I pretty much bought my Wii U for some very specific franchises. It does have some advantages over the Xbox 360 (2 gigs of ram versus 512 megs, for example), and it'll get a much improved version of Deus Ex Human Revolution, but I sincerly doubt it'll be the only console I'll have this generation.
 
did some digging PS4 only has 4GB of GDDR5 to the 720s 8GB of DDR3

the thing we dont know is the size of the memory bus for the 720 IF its 256bit bus ie 4 channel then the bandwith issue even less then if its only 128bit
we also dont know the speed of the DDR3 as high speed DDR3 with low latency is almost as fast
the 720 setup is also better for all around use like a PC


as to why i think its going to be easier?
MS has historically had better dev kits and support
the 720 dev kit is closer to the same tools already in use for PC games and DX11 is just easier to deal then Sonys API because people already know how to code for DX11

I've said it before and I'll say it again: The next generation is going to be the equivalent of devs developing for Linux and Windows.

One will use OpenGL, or a variant of it called libgcm or similar, and the other is DirectX. Both consoles are compatible with the latest OpenGL and DirectX API-- 4.1 and 11 respectively.

The difference is going to be the development tools and SDKs. However, I believe that the PS4 will be much easier to develop for than the PS3 itself. That and Sony, unlike Microsoft, is giving developers baremetal access to the hardware. Microsoft, supposedly, will not allow that and programming a game or app will be closer to developing for a Windows PC and the Windows Store. I would assume VS 2012 is going to be the bare minimum IDE required to use for the Xbox 720 as that's the only one Microsoft allows to use for developing apps for the Windows Store. It's already a given since Microsoft intends to unify Xbox Live across different platforms-- mobile, desktop PC, and smartphone, and supposedly set top box (rumored).

It's going to be interesting how this all plays out. One console is going to look like it'll be more open to developers while the other will be a little more closed off.

It's going to be up to developers and game companies that want to spend their money and resources on in developing games for. I expect Microsoft to pay up for exclusive titles, and I will not be surprised developers lazily, half-ass ports to the PS4 like they did with the PS3.

Developing for something that uses the equivalent of OpenGL should be no different nor difficult than using DirectX, so there's no reason to have half-ass ports especially when both consoles are now using an x86-based platform. Again, it's the equivalent of Linux versus Windows PC gaming.

Also, take note, that indie game developers pretty much shunned Microsoft at the recent GDC. They're wholly opposed to the Windows Store, and I would not be surprised they feel the same way about Xbox Live Arcade or its app store. Marketshare and number of apps in Windows Store and its smartphone equivalent is a good indication of what'll happen to the indie game market on the Xbox 720.
 
I thought Sony themselves said that the PS4 would have 8 GB of GDDR5 RAM, or so I thought. Where are you hearing that it won't?

That was already confirmed by Sony themselves in their press kit. So, I doubt they'd say otherwise.

Also, I don't think they'd want to change specs before the 720's announcement and reduce the maximum amount of RAM.
 
That was already confirmed by Sony themselves in their press kit. So, I doubt they'd say otherwise.

Also, I don't think they'd want to change specs before the 720's announcement and reduce the maximum amount of RAM.

This.

I don't know why he is saying what he is saying calling it fact, then saying the MS console will be easier to develop for. All of the developers currently are saying otherwise and as mentioned it looks to be much more open than the MS platform.

I'm interested in both, especially the possible DVR rumors of 720 as I'm a huge HTPC fan. Throw that bad boy in the bedroom and watch the ball game playing the next Halo during commercials.
 
This.

I don't know why he is saying what he is saying calling it fact, then saying the MS console will be easier to develop for. All of the developers currently are saying otherwise and as mentioned it looks to be much more open than the MS platform.

I'm interested in both, especially the possible DVR rumors of 720 as I'm a huge HTPC fan. Throw that bad boy in the bedroom and watch the ball game playing the next Halo during commercials.

Forgot to edit: Wife pulls my man card so I get kicked off the living room TV :(
 
the leaked dev kit stuff shows 4GB for release hardware

wile 'baremetal' is more open and powerful in theory it is harder to work with
 
the leaked dev kit stuff shows 4GB for release hardware

wile 'baremetal' is more open and powerful in theory it is harder to work with

So leaked info trumps official Sony statements?
 
did some digging PS4 only has 4GB of GDDR5 to the 720s 8GB of DDR3

the thing we dont know is the size of the memory bus for the 720 IF its 256bit bus ie 4 channel then the bandwith issue even less then if its only 128bit
we also dont know the speed of the DDR3 as high speed DDR3 with low latency is almost as fast
the 720 setup is also better for all around use like a PC


as to why i think its going to be easier?
MS has historically had better dev kits and support
the 720 dev kit is closer to the same tools already in use for PC games and DX11 is just easier to deal then Sonys API because people already know how to code for DX11

You know you try to make yourself sound pretty smart with all the tech jargin you're spewing. But when you ramble on about how you did some "digging" and the PS4 has 4GB of Ram AFTER it was officially announced to have 8... it just makes you look a fool.

Guessing all your posts, like this one, are full of it.
 
You know you try to make yourself sound pretty smart with all the tech jargin you're spewing. But when you ramble on about how you did some "digging" and the PS4 has 4GB of Ram AFTER it was officially announced to have 8... it just makes you look a fool.

Guessing all your posts, like this one, are full of it.

just going on what i find

if thats wrong its wrong

but ether way it matters little how much it has
both systems will be dead even in power
pick one which the eco system you like better
 
just going on what i find

if thats wrong its wrong

but ether way it matters little how much it has
both systems will be dead even in power
pick one which the eco system you like better

... Are you thinking that half of the 8 gigs will be dedicated to the OS? From what I recall, the PS3 OS was also really memory hungry.
 
... Are you thinking that half of the 8 gigs will be dedicated to the OS? From what I recall, the PS3 OS was also really memory hungry.

i was digging for better details on PS4 hardware what i found was dev kit info showing that consumer hardware would have 4GB where the dev kits would have 8GB
soo no idea i may be that Sony changed there minds on it last min which with some thing like ram is an easy change
 
i was digging for better details on PS4 hardware what i found was dev kit info showing that consumer hardware would have 4GB where the dev kits would have 8GB
soo no idea i may be that Sony changed there minds on it last min which with some thing like ram is an easy change

Chances are, if there is any truth to that at all, Sony released their dev kits really early before the RAM was completely nailed down to get development started, or they were waiting for RAM prices to drop. Sony isn't exactly made out of money anymore...

So first gen PS4 games probably won't use all the available system RAM if there's any truth to that.
 
Correction: It's eSRAM (embedded SRAM).

This is the article: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/df-hardware-spec-analysis-durango-vs-orbis

Scroll about halfway down.

8GB of DDR3 RAM (68GB/s bandwidth)
32MB of fast embedded SRAM (ESRAM) (102GB/s)

Not sure how they're squeezing 68GB/s out of DDR3, but under the section "RAM: capacity vs. bandwidth" shows what Microsoft is going to try to get around the limited bandwidth.

Thanks for the correction.
Well, in order to get 68GB/s, it might actually be GDDR3, which would be great for the CPU, but not so much for the GPU.

It certainly does sound like standard DDR3 with the aid of the 32MB SRAM cache:
There's just one problem. Cramming 8GB of the fastest memory into a console box simply isn't logistically possible. A key Xbox 360 advantage over PS3 was a unified pool of 512MB of fast GDDR3 memory. GDDR5 is the latest equivalent, used principally in PC graphics cards, but the problem here is that the modules only come in certain capacities - the largest and most difficult to produce being 512MB. Daisy-chaining 16 of those onto a console motherboard just wouldn't work. Sony has opted for a tighter system - fewer memory modules, but all of them very, very fast. It retains GDDR5 as the single memory pool with all the raw bandwidth advantages that entails, but it is limited to 4GB (there are rumours of 6GB/8GB upgrades but this is highly unlikely to happen).

Microsoft's technique for accommodating 8GB is to fall back on cheaper DDR3 modules - the same type found in current PCs and indeed Wii U. This presents a problem - namely, bandwidth. Think of data as water flowing through a pipe - the wider the pipe, the more water can flow through it at any given point. DDR3 can only process around one third the amount of data as the wider GDDR5, because the "pipe" is that much thinner. Microsoft's solution? To equip Durango with 32MB of fast memory (ESRAM) attached directly to the graphics core, but capable of being accessed from the CPU too. This little cache of memory can run in parallel with the DDR3, and combined bandwidth then rises back up to around 170GB/s - a number close to the throughput of the GDDR5 in Orbis.
 
see there is that 4GB number i kept seeing around in a few places
 
Thanks for the correction.
Well, in order to get 68GB/s, it might actually be GDDR3, which would be great for the CPU, but not so much for the GPU.

It certainly does sound like standard DDR3 with the aid of the 32MB SRAM cache:

The only company able to produce the necessary 8GB of GDDR5 (at this time) is Samsung: 4096Gbit GDDR5 chip (512MB)
http://www.samsung.com/global/busin...t/graphic-dram/detail?productId=7824&iaId=759

Production started around September 2012 according to this PDF.

In another post, I stated that the PS4 will need 16 of these chips in another forum thread on [H]. The PS4 would need a complex 512-bit bus though to cram all 16 chips in there. Someone else replied they could do this without doubling the bus by switching between different chips, or multi-plexing.

So either A) Sony went with a 512-bit bus or B) they went with multi-plexing. And, unless Sony official states it and retracts their press release PDF, there is still going to be 8GB GDDR5.
 
At least with identical specifications, there will be no reason to argue about which console is better so all the various console owners can live on the Internet in a happy, specs aligned utopia, holding each others' hands and singing while they roast marshmallows around a campfire.

Next, the PC gamer types will look in at the Xbox people hugging the Playstation people hugging the Wii people and think, "Hey, I want in on this hugging sweet hugging action too. Maybe I should get a specs aligned PC so I can have a hug."

Except for that one grumpy person that'll sit all alone by the lake pouting about how its not right for everyone to hug without first going through a proper courtship and marriage that includes a reasonable dowry and somehow involves making two families that dislike one another get so upset that everyone drinks hemlock and dies.

LOl! well said unc:D
 
just going on what i find

if thats wrong its wrong

but ether way it matters little how much it has
both systems will be dead even in power

pick one which the eco system you like better

You sure about that? I've read multiple times of the 1.6ghz CPU for 720 and 2ghz CPU for PS4 not to mention the PS4 is suppose to have a better GPU (slightly faster 7850 for PS4 vs. 7790 for 720).

While the difference in RAM architecture may make up for bandwidth vs. the other the CPU and GPU seem to be more than just a tad faster in the PS4.
 
From the article:



Seems Sony has changed and the old man is just set in his ways of thinking.

yeah i saw that. But i have read other articles that had the same tone as Bushnells about sony. Who knows. I think developers will get what they want from both platforms this time around. hopefully PC gamers will too. I just hope we dont have to buy a WinBlue/AMDXX machine to do it :)
 
Back
Top