Thieves Made Millions On eBay

Nono, that was the mothership for another attempt.


The pirates currently holding the 1000'+ super tanker full of oil is threatining that if their demands aren't met, they will sink the tanker.

Why not just napalm the entire coast? From the news reports, sounds like every last man woman and child thinks the piracy is awesome on the coast of Somalia.
 
Why not just napalm the entire coast? From the news reports, sounds like every last man woman and child thinks the piracy is awesome on the coast of Somalia.

yeah why not just vietnam another country?

i think the indians are taking care of it anyway... i have a feeling in the next couple months youll start seeing many more 'motherships' destroyed....
 
thats why best buy has insurance. IT pays for these loses. they dint get the stuff back.


All that means, in most jurisdictions, is that the recovery rights are transfered to the insurance company. If they want to recover they can.

I had a car stolen, insurance paid for it. The police recovered the vehicle 6 months later. The insurance company got the car. I imagine they auctioned it off to recover as much of what they had to pay me as they could.
 
yeah why not just vietnam another country?

i think the indians are taking care of it anyway... i have a feeling in the next couple months youll start seeing many more 'motherships' destroyed....

No one said anything about ground troops. Just take all those ships patrolling the Gulf/Coast and start incendiary shelling for a few weeks. Gives countries like India some good live fire target practice for their Navy.

I guarantee they won't be sending out anymore "pirate-ships" any time soon.
 
All that means, in most jurisdictions, is that the recovery rights are transfered to the insurance company. If they want to recover they can.

I had a car stolen, insurance paid for it. The police recovered the vehicle 6 months later. The insurance company got the car. I imagine they auctioned it off to recover as much of what they had to pay me as they could.

why should it be like that? insurance companies get paid for a service, and yet they would get to recover assets?
 
why should it be like that? insurance companies get paid for a service, and yet they would get to recover assets?

They do if you sign the papers and take the check. I am not saying how it should or should not be, just how it is in most places in the US.
 
Yes, theft by receiving. If it is without prior knowledge then I'm sure the cops will not charge you with theft by receiving. I guess it really depends on the agency though.

I hope these bastards go down though. I've been ripped off on ebay before, it is not fun.

Reread what you put here... they will not charge you BECAUSE IT IS NOT A CRIME WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE

Way to be a douche. A simple hey man that's not correct would be been better. Apparently you did not read my entire post. I said it depends on the agency. If that person did not know it was stolen or there is no evidence of that person receiving stolen property, how can they charge someone with theft by receiving?

Why is the no evidence line even necessary? You are being vague with your 'it depends on the agency' phrase. You could either mean the law enforcement agency or something odd like the mode of receiving the stolen goods? Either way, that does not matter.

Nebraska law defines theft by receiving stolen property as follows:
A person commits theft if he receives, retains, or disposes of stolen
movable property of another knowing that it has been stolen, or
believing
that it has been stolen, unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner.

Nebraska law was taken from the model penal code and this is simply one state out of many cases from different states I found. 'Theft by receiving' in all states I found requies knowledge the goods are stolen, belief it may be stolen or in some states a reckless disregard for thinking about if it was stolen. Please don't call someone a douche when you refuse to admit you are wrong. You don't define agency yet it does not matter. From every state's case law I could find you are wrong. You can go research Louisiana if you want to, as their area of law is really fucked up so you may find a small victory there. Stick to the knowledge you know or at least man up and admit when you are wrong.
 
Reread what you put here... they will not charge you BECAUSE IT IS NOT A CRIME WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE



Why is the no evidence line even necessary? You are being vague with your 'it depends on the agency' phrase. You could either mean the law enforcement agency or something odd like the mode of receiving the stolen goods? Either way, that does not matter.

Nebraska law defines theft by receiving stolen property as follows:
A person commits theft if he receives, retains, or disposes of stolen
movable property of another knowing that it has been stolen, or
believing
that it has been stolen, unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner.

Nebraska law was taken from the model penal code and this is simply one state out of many cases from different states I found. 'Theft by receiving' in all states I found requies knowledge the goods are stolen, belief it may be stolen or in some states a reckless disregard for thinking about if it was stolen. Please don't call someone a douche when you refuse to admit you are wrong. You don't define agency yet it does not matter. From every state's case law I could find you are wrong. You can go research Louisiana if you want to, as their area of law is really fucked up so you may find a small victory there. Stick to the knowledge you know or at least man up and admit when you are wrong.

Right... We are talking about people all over the United States (not just in Nebraska) that received stolen property that they did not know was stolen. So the person who bought something from this guy is out X amount of dollars because they did not know they were buying stolen property. What becomes of the money involved? Does it go back to the buyer? What if the seller does not have it anymore? You're the expert here apparently. We already know what happens to the bad guys.

I did not define an agency, so that makes me wrong? Okay, the local police dept of that persons town. There, agency defined. I never refused to admit I was wrong. In fact, I still believe I'm right because according to NEBRASKA (I will use your state as an example) law, that person still cannot be charged to theft by receiving unless they intend to return the stolen property. My statement was incomplete making it wrong, sorry. You're the lawyer here. :rolleyes:

Like I said before, a simple that is not correct instead of being a complete ass about it would have sufficed.

:)
 
Right... We are talking about people all over the United States (not just in Nebraska) that received stolen property that they did not know was stolen. So the person who bought something from this guy is out X amount of dollars because they did not know they were buying stolen property. What becomes of the money involved? Does it go back to the buyer? What if the seller does not have it anymore?

Not trying to get in the way of your discussion with Jared, but the buyer of the stolen property, even though they had no clue it was stolen, is generally shit out of luck in most jurisdictions. They can sue the criminal. They can attempt charge backs on their credit cards if used. If money is seized from the criminals by police it might eventually be released to the recompense the victims after the court cases have ended, providing convictions were handed down of course. (big if and when on that, I mean huge if and when. Once the police and courts have seized money, they will do almost anything to keep it, but that is another topic unto itself.) However, the legitimate owner of the property gets their stuff back. It sucks for the people that bought the stolen goods, to be sure.
 
Right... We are talking about people all over the United States (not just in Nebraska) that received stolen property that they did not know was stolen. So the person who bought something from this guy is out X amount of dollars because they did not know they were buying stolen property. What becomes of the money involved? Does it go back to the buyer? What if the seller does not have it anymore? You're the expert here apparently. We already know what happens to the bad guys.

I did not define an agency, so that makes me wrong? Okay, the local police dept of that persons town. There, agency defined. I never refused to admit I was wrong. In fact, I still believe I'm right because according to NEBRASKA (I will use your state as an example) law, that person still cannot be charged to theft by receiving unless they intend to return the stolen property. My statement was incomplete making it wrong, sorry. You're the lawyer here. :rolleyes:

Like I said before, a simple that is not correct instead of being a complete ass about it would have sufficed.

:)

We aren't even arguing over the same point now. You said you don't think the police WOULD charge you with the crime if you did not know it was stolen. What I am saying is that they will not because they CANNOT do it. Your statement means that they still could charge someone. The quote from a case I showed you proves that in this jurisdiction, as well as the other jurisdictions I looked at but did not quote, someone cannot be convicted of this charge without meeting meeting all the elements. I'll paste that part again for you.

Nebraska law defines theft by receiving stolen property as follows:
A person commits theft if he receives, retains, or disposes of stolen
movable property of another knowing that it has been stolen, or
believing that it has been stolen
, unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner.

The last part after the comma, "unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner." only refers to someone who recieves, retains or disposes of stolen property which he KNOWS or BELIEVES is stolen. Without the knowledge or belief the last line never comes into play. Therefore, you cannot be convicted with receiving stolen property unless you knew or believed it was stolen and did NOT intend to restore it to its owner.

You'd normally need to sue the individual to get the money back if you were the buyer in this situation. How you do that if he is in jail I'm not sure. If the thief doesn't have money the buyer is SOL which sucks.
 
Negative.

"State of mind" - If the parts were sold at a large reduction in cost, like 50% under retail or similar - then legal action would be possible against the purchaser... But, considering these were sold just shy of retail price, it would be reasonable to assume they were actually overstock.

Prosecutors have to have evidence that you *knew* the item was stolen.

knew or should have known. Important distinction.
 
We aren't even arguing over the same point now. You said you don't think the police WOULD charge you with the crime if you did not know it was stolen. What I am saying is that they will not because they CANNOT do it. Your statement means that they still could charge someone. The quote from a case I showed you proves that in this jurisdiction, as well as the other jurisdictions I looked at but did not quote, someone cannot be convicted of this charge without meeting meeting all the elements. I'll paste that part again for you.

Nebraska law defines theft by receiving stolen property as follows:
A person commits theft if he receives, retains, or disposes of stolen
movable property of another knowing that it has been stolen, or
believing that it has been stolen
, unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner.

The last part after the comma, "unless the property is received,
retained, or disposed with intention to restore it to the owner." only refers to someone who recieves, retains or disposes of stolen property which he KNOWS or BELIEVES is stolen. Without the knowledge or belief the last line never comes into play. Therefore, you cannot be convicted with receiving stolen property unless you knew or believed it was stolen and did NOT intend to restore it to its owner.

You'd normally need to sue the individual to get the money back if you were the buyer in this situation. How you do that if he is in jail I'm not sure. If the thief doesn't have money the buyer is SOL which sucks.

I already read the Nebraska law and it is pretty much the same as GA law. I know what the law means. I never implied that the person behind this scheme was in jail. If they are not in jail then they should be, but that is just opinion.

Sucks for the buyer in this case.
 
If they're going to hold consumers responsible, then I say string up eBay, bleed them for every cent they got, then sell off the pieces...

With the ridiculous excessive fees they charge, they should be far more vigilant about who is selling what on ebay and where it's from.. They can go through my private messages and tell me its against ebay policy to conduct sales outside of ebay, then they can catch people like this...
 
so how much did ebay pocket in all this? well if going by fees from ebay and paypal, if the thieves sold $1,000,000 of goods, ebay/paypal would have pocketed >$50,000

I've been looking at the prices, and that's ridiculous, somebody at ebay should have noticed much sooner, these items are consistently a significant amount below retail.... i mean its not what you'd pay some guy standing at the back of a truck, but still a significant amount below what they could purchase it from suppliers...
 
oh and i bet all these people that have to return their purchases wont see a cent from PayPal.... Buyer protection my ass..
 
Why not just napalm the entire coast? From the news reports, sounds like every last man woman and child thinks the piracy is awesome on the coast of Somalia.

napalm is bad.

i think piracy is kind of cool. I think its essential to have this kind of thing to keep people on their toes. Some giant oil conglomerate gets owned by the people it takes advantage of. then they one of up the pirates then the pirates one up them. When you have an industry that has no competition thats a fitting way to give them compensation.

when you come from a country like somalia thats been used and abused over and over, you would do the same thing.

as for the ebay thing. If some cop said i purchased something stolen and i had to return it. I would refuse and if they have an issue with that they can talk to my lawyer...As simply put the gestapo law enforcement in this country will not remove anything from my property period.
 
also I would like to bring up something.

ya'll mention retail prices...

did you ever see what best buy and other mainstream electronic retailers charge?

they deserve losing money. I'd buy from the back of a guys truck if he was ripping one of these corporations. Seriously, their profit margins are criminal.
 
when you come from a country like somalia thats been used and abused over and over, you would do the same thing.

LOL exactly, somalians may have pirated a few american movies, americans have pirated all their natural resources and labor.... :p :D :p :D :eek: :eek:
 
i dont think there is any natural resources or labor in somolia. unless you want disease laden jungles.
 
napalm is bad.

i think piracy is kind of cool. I think its essential to have this kind of thing to keep people on their toes. Some giant oil conglomerate gets owned by the people it takes advantage of. then they one of up the pirates then the pirates one up them. When you have an industry that has no competition thats a fitting way to give them compensation.

when you come from a country like somalia thats been used and abused over and over, you would do the same thing.

as for the ebay thing. If some cop said i purchased something stolen and i had to return it. I would refuse and if they have an issue with that they can talk to my lawyer...As simply put the gestapo law enforcement in this country will not remove anything from my property period.
That's a slap in the face of the billions of people who are poor and law abiding.
 
That's a slap in the face of the billions of people who are poor and law abiding.

not really, and i would fully support them if they decided to take back from the people who grow rich off their labours.

if the poor in america rose up against the wealthy elite i would support them, same goes for any country. When you are taken advantage of, a little revolution or dissent is the best way to take back some of your dignity and compensation for the abuse.

laws aren't something that designate right and wrong. There are the poor that abide by laws, but if they decided they weren't going to take it anymore, does that make it wrong or simply against a law written to hold them down?

thats my point.
 
i just think its ridiculous that these millionaires write/sing/produce songs about the downtrodden etc etc.. yet the people they're singing about couldn't afford to buy their music. ridiculous. Just like that goddamn Pink song where shes talking about the president doing nothing about the homeless ra ra ra, then her next song she's braggin how she could fit your house in her swimming pool.. dumb bitch, and whats worse she's messed her head up so bad she doesn't even look remotely fuckable..
 
sucks for those Thieves! meh its Ebay, they wouldve got caught eventually anyways

nah ebay wouldn't have ever done anything about it.... as long as they get their fee's their cool with whatever, you can 'shill-bid' till the cows come home and they'll never ban you or even warn you about it... they're wrapped by the idea im guessing.. higher sale-price equals higher fees... but the moment you try to conduct a sale outside of ebay (they read every single private message) alarms go off and they send you nasty messages.
 
Back
Top