The Decade's 25 Biggest Tech Flops

[H]adouken!;1034368593 said:
thats a lot of sony's flops

Maybe so.. but it's nice to see that Sony atleast tries to be innovative. Even if they fail a thousand times, they're attempts should one day pay off (Thomas Edison and the light bulb comes to mind).
 
Well, I guess if one could argue with the Popularity and Support standpoint, I could see Satellite Radio and HDDVD being on this list.

But as actual tech failures? They are not.

I'm not sure about that one.. I would have to say that Satellite Radio is pretty deserving of the status tech failure. In a day where (most) every car has a CD player or a plug in for an iPod.. people can choose the music they want to listen to. And if they want to hear a variety of songs, there is FM radio for free. However to pay for a satellite radio service just always sounded ridiculous to me when CDs are so cheap and I can listen to what I want if I decide that the radio doesn't have anything good on.
 
I can't believe media center is on there. I use media center every day. I record my tv shows while at work, use lifextender to delete all the commercials. Makes for an awesome free dvr unit! I use it to watch my dvds.
 
Maybe so.. but it's nice to see that Sony atleast tries to be innovative. Even if they fail a thousand times, they're attempts should one day pay off (Thomas Edison and the light bulb comes to mind).

The problem is that so many of their innovations are so proprietary. If they would adopt popular standards that work on the devices of many manufacturers, say MiniSD cards instead of Memory Stick, I might have a better opinion of their products. At least they're not the only ones involved with Blu Ray, might be a mess otherwise.
 
Waaa. For better or worse that's how the world works. Blu Ray currently offers equal features and higher capacity, and its always had higher mandatory audio and video bitrates than HD DVD, the extra features like ethernet are pointless, IMO.

I'm just glad the format war is over.

QFT. I loved HD-DVD but now that both have equal capabilities I'm glad that Blu Ray won out. Higher storage capacity is always better because you get higher bitrate video encodings and lossless audio.

Crying about how HD-DVD lost is pointless because its over, and frankly, its been been an inferior technology ever since the Blu Ray 2.0 spec launched almost two years ago. Again, I loved HD-DVD because it was better than BR when it came out, but now its worse because of its lower capacity.

And thankfully its dead and consumers can move forward with buying the best video format out there!
 
What I consider more of a sad loss then the UMD, was its father the Mini Disc. When it was introduced back in 90-91 it was god-awfull expensive (about $1000 for a portable player), but it was incredibly ahead of its time, and there wouldn't be another technology that came close for almost another 10 years. There were two things that left a huge imprint on my life back in the early 90's, Mini Disc and the Acura NSX :cool:

While Mini Disc didnt really improve the physical technology of optical storage it brought forth ATRAC which was Sony's version of MP3 long before MP3 was a household name. It also had as a standard to the format 10 second "shock protection" which was jaw dropping in the early 90's and still a premium feature among opticle portables by the turn of the decade.

However Sony, like with many of their technologies, shot themselves in the foot with thier huge urge to have everything proprietery. They would not allow other manufactures to get in on the market until around 96-97 (although in asia Goldstar did put out a very limited selection of 3rd party models). They also restricted ALL pre-recorded albums to Sony's library, which was fine if you like Alice in Chains, Pink Floyd, or Boston...but the selection was very limited.

I bought my first MD player in 97 for a, then, cheap $200. I followed that up with a recorder that was about $300. As far as I know I was the only person at my high school that had one, and it just completely mystified everyone that saw it.

Although Sony began opening up the format to other manufacturers in the late 90's, a culmination of 3 things in the late 90's ended up destroying what could have been an excellent format. Broadband Internet (other then ISDN) became cheap and accessible to many households. Napster brought of MP3 to forefront of the masses. And the Diamond Rio showed us just how convienent MP3 and computers could make portable music.

And with that the fate of Mini Disc was sealed.
 
I'm not sure about that one.. I would have to say that Satellite Radio is pretty deserving of the status tech failure. In a day where (most) every car has a CD player or a plug in for an iPod.. people can choose the music they want to listen to. And if they want to hear a variety of songs, there is FM radio for free. However to pay for a satellite radio service just always sounded ridiculous to me when CDs are so cheap and I can listen to what I want if I decide that the radio doesn't have anything good on.

I don't necessarily disagree with you, but satellite radio deff. has a place in the market. They're not regulated by the FCC (or not supposed to be) since it's a paid for service. For music it's not really all that great, but for comedy and talk radio it's the perfect venue and offers content that you cannot get anywhere else :)

if it had flopped, it would of deserved a place on the list, but it's not really doing bad. In 2007, XM had 8.5 million subscribers while sirius had approx 7.5 million subs.

however, if they keep raising rates, the management will eventually run it into the ground

http://www.orbitcast.com/archives/satellite-radio-subscribers-running-the-numbers.html
 
Well, I guess if one could argue with the Popularity and Support standpoint, I could see Satellite Radio and HDDVD being on this list.

But as actual tech failures? They are not.

These are flops, not failures. A flop is a product that never makes back its original R&D investment; i.e. loses money.
 
These are flops, not failures. A flop is a product that never makes back its original R&D investment; i.e. loses money.

So then why isn't the PS3 on there? Might as well add another Sony product to the list.


I'd almost say Apple, but many of their failed products over the past decades really haven't had a huge outpouring of R&D anyway, at least not in the magnitude that Sony has with the PS3.
 
The problem is that so many of their innovations are so proprietary. If they would adopt popular standards that work on the devices of many manufacturers, say MiniSD cards instead of Memory Stick, I might have a better opinion of their products. At least they're not the only ones involved with Blu Ray, might be a mess otherwise.

I'm not going to disagree with that.. if Sony wasn't so proprietary, and was more open to industry standards then I'm sure that most of the stuff they have on this list would have done a lot better. I'm still glad to see that they try to innovate though, if you look at the list.. some of the other items on there can be directly attributed to a Sony success: HD-DVD, Sega Dreamcast (while the Sega Saturn was the first console I can recall to have games on CDs, the Playstation was the one that really brought it to the forefront and the Playstation pretty much killed all hopes of the Dreamcast surviving).
 
So then why isn't the PS3 on there? Might as well add another Sony product to the list.


I'd almost say Apple, but many of their failed products over the past decades really haven't had a huge outpouring of R&D anyway, at least not in the magnitude that Sony has with the PS3.

I'd imagine the PS3 isn't on there because it hasn't been a terrible flop since they finally got it out. If they would have delivered it on time instead of giving the X-Box 360 a year long head start.. I believe it would have sold a lot more units and would have had a lot better backing from the developers. They shot themselves in the foot by taking so long to release it, continually rolling it back.. however Microsoft (who ALWAYS pushes back the release dates of their products) actually rushed out the 360 while it wasn't ready for production (that first 6 months all I remember hearing was recalls and repairs for RROD and overheated units) and garnered a lot of the market for the next gen consoles. The Wii is just a gimmick and, while enjoyable, is not a true competitor to the PS3 or 360 (most I know own a Wii in conjunction to a PS3 or 360). Also, because they released it so late, when the PS3 came out the price tag looked swollen because the 360 had a year of price cuts behind it and was much cheaper.

Furthermore we don't know the final outcome of the PS3 yet. It's still selling units and may pick up steam (especially if they have another price cut). I remember the PS2 was well ahead of the original X-Box, but the X-Box was new and had some intrigue, as well as being more powerful than the PS2 so it picked up a lot of steam late in the PS2's lifespan. The PS3 doesn't have the appeal of a new company jumping into the console gaming industry, but it is more powerful than the 360, and if they ever get to a comparable price I think the PS3 could start gaining some ground (especially now that Blu-Ray won the format war, which was another thing that held the PS3 back at first cause no one knew if Blu-Ray was going to survive).

Even if the PS3 doesn't pick up steam it's following behind the Playstation and the PS2, which were two of the most successful systems to be launched (I still love my PS2 haha).. I'm sure that Sony will have learned from their mistakes with the PS3 and in 3-4yrs or so when it's time for the new "next gen" console, they will be a lot more competitive on initial release day with the PS4 (or whatever name they so choose to give it if they deviate from the Playstation moniker).
 
I don't necessarily disagree with you, but satellite radio deff. has a place in the market. They're not regulated by the FCC (or not supposed to be) since it's a paid for service. For music it's not really all that great, but for comedy and talk radio it's the perfect venue and offers content that you cannot get anywhere else :)

if it had flopped, it would of deserved a place on the list, but it's not really doing bad. In 2007, XM had 8.5 million subscribers while sirius had approx 7.5 million subs.

however, if they keep raising rates, the management will eventually run it into the ground

http://www.orbitcast.com/archives/satellite-radio-subscribers-running-the-numbers.html

I guess it does have it's market.. for me personally, I can't stand listening to talk radio; So the idea of paying for radio service when music is so freely or cheaply available, never made an iota of sense for my purposes.
 
I'd imagine the PS3 isn't on there because it hasn't been a terrible flop since they finally got it out.
Doesn't matter. I was responding to the statement that a flop is a product which never recoups the R&D money. The PS3 fills that statement very nicely, Sony loses more money on each PS3 than they probably make back on games (/on_limb).


Explain it away all you want, but based on the statement above, the PS3 deserves to be there.


Unless there's another definition of "flop" we can use.

Flat out to me, looks like this article didn't follow ANY definition or requirements at all.
 
Doesn't matter. I was responding to the statement that a flop is a product which never recoups the R&D money. The PS3 fills that statement very nicely, Sony loses more money on each PS3 than they probably make back on games (/on_limb).


Explain it away all you want, but based on the statement above, the PS3 deserves to be there.


Unless there's another definition of "flop" we can use.

Flat out to me, looks like this article didn't follow ANY definition or requirements at all.

I'd agree with that last statement that this article didn't follow any definition or requirements.. however the issue with your belief about the PS3 is that it's still on the market. It may not have made back the R&D as of this moment.. but for all we know it picks up a full head of steam and storms the gates to every household in America over the next year and a half. Can't make statements of fact based on uncertain events. If you were to say the PS3 will likely be a flop.. or looks to be a flop, that's all fine and dandy because you're making a prediction based on the current data.. however when you say that the PS3 IS a flop, and make it out to be as if it's set and stone and already a fact, that's where your argument doesn't hold up.
 
Yeah, agreed.

I went through 10 of them and it was such a bitch I just closed it.

lol @ DC being #1 though, along with those silly sony robot dogs. I'll get a real dog, thanks.

Yeah, but a robot dog won't poop on the rug.
 
I'd agree with that last statement that this article didn't follow any definition or requirements.. however the issue with your belief about the PS3 is that it's still on the market.

I'd call BS on that one, too. There were other products still being manufactured on that list, too.
 
I would've thought Windows ME and Windows Vista would be bigger flops than Windows Media Center.

Wouldn't Blu-ray also be considered a flop? Granted, it beat HD-DVD, but it hasn't beaten DVD.

Speaking of media formats, DivX, that "disposable DVD" format that one of the big-box stores was pushing, was a big failure.

Of all those things on the list, I own one of them: a couple DVD-A discs. :eek:
 
I would've thought Windows ME and Windows Vista would be bigger flops than Windows Media Center.

Wouldn't Blu-ray also be considered a flop? Granted, it beat HD-DVD, but it hasn't beaten DVD.

Speaking of media formats, DivX, that "disposable DVD" format that one of the big-box stores was pushing, was a big failure.

Of all those things on the list, I own one of them: a couple DVD-A discs. :eek:

I own a Dreamcast.. it's really not that bad of a console.
 
Back
Top