Tests Show Wireless Network Could Harm GPS Systems

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A new report says that the proposed nationwide wireless broadband network could actually interfere with GPS systems. Thanks to Bill Ward for the link!

They say that sensitive satellite receivers _ designed to pick up relatively weak signals coming from space _ could be overwhelmed when LightSquared starts sending high-powered signals from as many as 40,000 transmitters on the ground. GPS signals, they say, will suffer the way a radio station can get drowned out by a stronger broadcast in a nearby channel.
 
Last edited:
broadbandreports.com has been reporting on this for a while, this is not the first test and this happened before.
 
Time to change the spectrum again?

Isn't this the only job the FCC really needs to be doing?
 
I'm ALL for keeping the GPS going, and not launching the nationwide wireless signals.......Especially after that news post on the [H] about wireless routers, and such, harming trees.
 
All I can tell you is that if GPS systems get screwed up, it will become a serious safety issue considering how many asian women I see who can't live without these things. There will be hell to pay if my own built in GPS system gets screwed up because someone thinks our country needs a nationwide wireless network. I still want to know how much it would cost and who would end up footing the bill. I know the answer to the 2nd part of the question.

I tend to be biased as i'm not a fan of wireless at all.
 
Wow, that sounds so racist...

anyway, on topic... while I do like GPS, I rarely ever use it... sometime it confuses me as well.
 
Make all GPS device use LightSquared chip in addition to standalone GPS. Make all GPS signal feed into 40k LightSquared towers to act as assisted GPS in LightSquared region, and normal GPS outside of said region.

Problem solved.

Or get a GPS antenna tall enough to reach airline GPS altitude. It's only like 35,000 feet, right?
 
I think it was on ars where I read more details of the proposed LightSquared fixes. It really is sounding like a problem with the GPS makers assuming that were would be no interference on (then) unused spectrum, and so it didn't filter out non-GPS bands very well. But what can you really do with possibly millions of existing devices that may experience interference? It's not like LightSquared is using frequencies outside it's spectrum. At the same time, the GPS makers won't do a recall since it would be too expensive.
 
Although the FCC in January gave LightSquared approval to build the system, the agency said it would not let the company turn on the network until GPS interference problems are resolved.

FCC is good at this, they'll get it resolved.

I hope they find a way to allow both technologies to coexist, though. A nationwide wireless network sounds pretty awesome.
 
So, is it a real problem or just companies that don't 'want' it to happen over money.
 
Make all GPS device use LightSquared chip in addition to standalone GPS. Make all GPS signal feed into 40k LightSquared towers to act as assisted GPS in LightSquared region, and normal GPS outside of said region.

Problem solved.

Or get a GPS antenna tall enough to reach airline GPS altitude. It's only like 35,000 feet, right?

And just who is going to shell out the $400+ for a new gps when this LightSquared thing goes live?
 
And just who is going to shell out the $400+ for a new gps when this LightSquared thing goes live?

I was being sarcastic ;-)

Seriously though, I'm not sure if this is true but doesn't a Nook have "free" services when you buy books online? My sister says so and I've never bothered to look it up myself. I've wondered if she meant Wi-fi or 3G.
 
New test results
Who conducted this testing?
based on extensive equipment tests conducted in Las Vegas
By whom?
increase pressure on the Federal Communications Commission to block a Virginia company called LightSquared from launching the network, which is designed to compete with super-fast systems being rolled out by AT&T and Verizon Wireless.
Oh, I see where the "tests" are coming from now...
 
I think it was on ars where I read more details of the proposed LightSquared fixes. It really is sounding like a problem with the GPS makers assuming that were would be no interference on (then) unused spectrum, and so it didn't filter out non-GPS bands very well.
It's more that GPS manufacturers assumed that the particular part of the spectrum would remain for satellite broadcast only, with comparably weak signals that would be relatively easy to filter out. Lightsquared's waiver to allow it to able to use so many terrestrial stations is unprecedented.

It's not like LightSquared is using frequencies outside it's spectrum. At the same time, the GPS makers won't do a recall since it would be too expensive.
The relative difference between the Lightsquared signal strength and GPS signal strength is in the order of billions of time so there is an impact outside of its frequencies. And while it may be possible to reduce the impact on low-end products, the Lightsquared signal would essentially wipe out precision GPS and thirty years of advancement and ironically result in the USA being the worst place in the world for GPS positioning.
 
Who conducted this testing?
By whom?
Oh, I see where the "tests" are coming from now...
Mainly by government agencies related to aviation, precise positioning timing, Motorola, QualComm and OnStar.

You'll find the biggest opposition coming from GPS related companies like Trimble and John Deere, then by aviation companies and Lockheed Martin.
 
It's more that GPS manufacturers assumed that the particular part of the spectrum would remain for satellite broadcast only, with comparably weak signals that would be relatively easy to filter out. Lightsquared's waiver to allow it to able to use so many terrestrial stations is unprecedented.
Which turned out to be a poor assumption. ;) And the waiver was not unprecedented simply because of the number of stations*. The spacing of Lightsquared's transmissions from GPS @ 1.57542GHz is fairly normal, even by terrestrial vs broadcast standards. If GPS units properly filtered out non-GPS frequencies there wouldn't be these problems (see the Ars story below for LightSquared's side of things).

The issue is that of practicality. There are many millions of GPS units out there and the GPS makers can't/won't fix the problems with how they fail to filter out non-GPS frequencies. Garmin seems to be leading the astroturf anti-LightSquared crusade.

Lightsquared signal would essentially wipe out precision GPS and thirty years of advancement and ironically result in the USA being the worst place in the world for GPS positioning.
That would have to be a magical signal to interfere @ > 500MHz lower frequency used by "precision GPS". :p

* the waiver has been called unprecedented because LightSquared's model is unusual. the number of stations was only a small part of the decision (read it in full in the link I posted).
However, if you read the actual waiver (PDF) it becomes clear what the FCC's reasoning was in this case. The waiver states that there are five main facts which were weighed: LightSquared will provide substantial MSS (satellite) service; the company will make investments to rationalize the fragmented MSS L-band of spectrum (via a $337.5 million deal with Inmarsat) to provide improved MSS and MSS/ATC (satellite/terrestrial) use; it will invest in the creation of a dual-mode service offering; it has unique terrestrial buildout requirements; and it has made specific commitments to achieve the FCC's MSS and MSS/ATC goals.

Read a little further down, and things become clearer still. A key section of the waiver talks about how LightSquared's planned service will make terrestrial mobile wireless broadband available to a wider variety of users, including in rural areas. Additionally, the waiver said that the public safety and homeland security communities will benefit from having a broadband service when they are operating in or transitioning between urban, suburban or rural areas.

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/...red-4g-network-would-defy-laws-of-physics.ars

The company also says that GPS vendors have shown no willingness to find a fix and says that "the GPS industry could have avoided [this problem] by equipping their devices over the last several years with filters that cost as little as five cents each." Lightsquared has developed its own "three-part solution" to the problem that will now be vetted by FCC engineers.

LightSquared's testing shows that the fix "resolves interference for approximately 99.5 percent of all commercial GPS devices—including 100 percent of the 300 million GPS-enabled cell phones" and says that it can't believe such a terrific national benefit as a new national wireless network could be held up over "a problem posed by approximately 200,000 GPS devices."
There are an estimated 500 million GPS devices in the USA. The evaluation of the proposed fixes is up to the FCC thankfully and not the astroturf assn.
 
Don't worry about it, GPS will no be harmed. Whatever needs to be done to keep it working, will be done. Some people think GPS is just kinda a neat consumer toy, and don't know that many people who use it so they think "Well maybe it'll get ignored." Not hardly. The massive amounts of money spent on GPS was not done for consumers.

GPS is THE navigation system for the world now. All planes, ships, etc use it as their primary navigation system, falling back to others only if it doesn't work. If you see a commercial vessel, it is navigated by GPS. However that isn't the biggest thing. GPS was created by, and is still the property of, the US military. The reason the system exists, the reason the massive amount of R&D and deployment costs were spent was because the military wanted to be able to accurately locate its craft, weapons, and soldiers. They use it extensively. They will also not permit anything to fuck with it.

So if this ends up being a real problem, GPS will win out, don't worry. If this is a minor issue that only affects some small subset of devices, no problem. If this is a major problem that would interfere with the entire GPS system, then it'll go away.

GPS is a commercial necessity today, but more than that it is a strategic asset of the US military. It is going nowhere.
 
Back
Top