Tesla Test Drive on Tape

keep in mind the worse mpg occurs in stop and go city driving, and during acceleration. generators running at one speed charging batteries are much more efficient than gas motors only.
 
$32 for an electric car that goes 240 miles?

Gee, how long is it going to take you until you see the savings at the pump???

10 years?

laff, I'd rather buy a used "new bettle" for $5,000 and get 22-30 mpg.

electric cars FTL
 
$32 for an electric car that goes 240 miles?

Gee, how long is it going to take you until you see the savings at the pump???

10 years?

laff, I'd rather buy a used "new bettle" for $5,000 and get 22-30 mpg.

electric cars FTL

id rather buy a motorcycle. 40-50mpg, brand new, warranty
used "bettles" FTL
 
keep in mind the worse mpg occurs in stop and go city driving, and during acceleration. generators running at one speed charging batteries are much more efficient than gas motors only.

Exactly. People seem to forget that the reason the Volt is better than all these other hybrids is that it has a generator, not a drive motor. Running a gasoline engine at the exact RPM for peak efficiency is going to get you awesome mileage, even if there was no battery to charge. Series hybrids FTW.
 
I'm having trouble believing that you can plug the Tesla into a standard 120V outlet and give it a full charge in four or even eight hours.

Let's assume that the Tesla can go 240 miles, since it makes the numbers easy. So you drive at 60mph, and it takes you four hours. If the car recharges in four hours, that means you're getting as much power out of that outlet as you use as you drive down the highway. A typical wall outlet can give you 15A, so that's 1.8kW, or 2.5HP. Even considering the 30% efficiency of gasoline engines, that's only 8.5HP of engine. Do you really think you're engine is only putting out 8.5HP at highway speeds?
 
Exactly. People seem to forget that the reason the Volt is better than all these other hybrids is that it has a generator, not a drive motor. Running a gasoline engine at the exact RPM for peak efficiency is going to get you awesome mileage, even if there was no battery to charge. Series hybrids FTW.

They don't forget, they just dont know because they've never bothered to do the research, but yet feel empowered to spread their wrong opinions everywhere they go.
 
Really? It seems many of you are bent at the knees in front of GM. 10,000 (the Volt's premier run) units produced is not a lot of cars... that's a fraction of a percent of the cars that GM will manufacture. That's if they even meet that number (it's not looking swell for them at this point).

I am a little familiar with the workings of a car. A radiator system while perhaps not "dozens of moving parts" is a failure rich system. Its presence is indicative of the power you're pouring into thin air with an ICE.

I never professed that the ICE of the Volt was particularly inefficient, but that the system of the car in total cannot be as efficient as the Tesla.

Also... moving parts.
 
$32 for an electric car that goes 240 miles?

Gee, how long is it going to take you until you see the savings at the pump???

10 years?

laff, I'd rather buy a used "new bettle" for $5,000 and get 22-30 mpg.

electric cars FTL

Assuming you are talking about the Volt, that would be $32K for a car that goes about 500 miles on a tank of gas. The break even point in terms of money saved on gas is a moving target that is dependent on the cost of gas and how much you drive. For me, I commute 20 miles per day, well within the 40 mile battery range. I'd likely only need the gas engine a couple times per year. Assuming I could drive about 6,000 miles per year on roughly 16 gallons of gas (figure 5200 commute miles all on battery and 800 extra errand and trip miles on generator), I'd be saving about $500/year compared to my Honda Accord. I've owned my Accord for nearly 10 years. Assuming I did the same with the Volt, (and assuming gas prices stay at $2/gal) I could save $5000 over the life of the vehicle. The savings is great an all, but what I really like is that is $5000 less going to Middle Eastern governments that hate us.
 
Bent at the knees? Because I am challenging you to substantiate your claims of garbage? I dont think so. You have made it obvious you have little understanding of the actual technology involved, making your opinions little more than random noise.

No one is arguing efficiency here, im sure the Tesla is more efficient than the volt or any other hybrid.
But to say cooling systems have dozens of parts is WRONG.
To say that modern gasoline engines are unreliable is WRONG.
To say the volt is GARBAGE requires some substantial facts to back it up, otherwise its just some random e-rage.
 
What I don't understand about Tesla, is why they didn't put a secondary power source in the car like the Chevy Volt has planned. When this thing is out of power, it had better be somewhere near a 120V plug, otherwise you are SOL. I think the design of the Volt is far superior because it includes a small genset to allow the vehicle to charge itself when needed. I hope GM survives long enough to actually sell the Volt.

Meh it's like saying "why don't gas powered cars have secondary means of power in case you run out of gas"

Just keep an eye on your fuel (or volt) gauge like you normally do and you won't have a problem.
 
Enjoy your trips to Pep Boys.

I Drive a 1999 Honda Accord. It has nearly 100K miles on it. I take it in for it's schedule maintenance. Beyond that I've bought a new battery for it, new tires, and new spark plugs. I've never been stranded, it's never broken down, and besides filling up the gas tank every three weeks, I don't even think about it. New cars have been made for a decade now with 100,000 mile powertrain warranties. Where is your preoccupation with unreliable engines coming from?
 
Are you really that stupid? Seriously, grow up and read a book or two.

YOU. Shit breaks on cars... There's a billion dollar industry setup to remedy this. The most batshit insane thing an auto manufacturer could do would be to engineer a car to last.
 
Meh it's like saying "why don't gas powered cars have secondary means of power in case you run out of gas"

Just keep an eye on your fuel (or volt) gauge like you normally do and you won't have a problem.

It's not the same. The range is 1/3 less than most cars, and "refueling" it takes hours instead of minutes.
 
I Drive a 1999 Honda Accord. It has nearly 100K miles on it. I take it in for it's schedule maintenance. Beyond that I've bought a new battery for it, new tires, and new spark plugs. I've never been stranded, it's never broken down, and besides filling up the gas tank every three weeks, I don't even think about it. New cars have been made for a decade now with 100,000 mile powertrain warranties. Where is your preoccupation with unreliable engines coming from?

He's probably only considering domestic reliability (and not including imports).
 
I Drive a 1999 Honda Accord. It has nearly 100K miles on it. I take it in for it's schedule maintenance. Beyond that I've bought a new battery for it, new tires, and new spark plugs. I've never been stranded, it's never broken down, and besides filling up the gas tank every three weeks, I don't even think about it. New cars have been made for a decade now with 100,000 mile powertrain warranties. Where is your preoccupation with unreliable engines coming from?

Having spent too much time replacing things.

I too have a foreign '99 with 100k+ miles on it. My car hasn't left me stranded, nor broken down, but I've had to replace a fair number of parts on it and every other that I've owned.
 
I have a 2003 Grand Am (as in, not foreign). It's got the little 2.2 Ecotec engine in it, and about 100,000 k. Only 2 times has it given me trouble. Once the battery died. Recently the ignition went out. And I don't mean the starter or anything having to do with a gasoline engine, but the electrical link that verifies that the car is allowed to start.

I'm going to go out on a limb and say electric AND hybrid cars will have those problems as well. And I'm still all for them, but the reliability of even modern domestic cars is just fine with regular oil changes and the odd alignment (also an issue with electric and hybrids).

I'm all for electrics, but hybrids (good ones, series kind) will do us quite nicely until full-electrics are more accessible.
 
YOU. Shit breaks on cars... There's a billion dollar industry setup to remedy this. The most batshit insane thing an auto manufacturer could do would be to engineer a car to last.

yes, and electric cars will be INVINCIBLE and never need any work ever.

Idiot.
 
Having spent too much time replacing things.

I too have a foreign '99 with 100k+ miles on it. My car hasn't left me stranded, nor broken down, but I've had to replace a fair number of parts on it and every other that I've owned.

Just out of curiosity, how many of those parts had directly to do with the gasoline engine? I've had several cars break on me various times, and at least half were electrical, suspension, brakes, and other problems that an electric car might also have.
 
What I don't understand about Tesla, is why they didn't put a secondary power source in the car like the Chevy Volt has planned. When this thing is out of power, it had better be somewhere near a 120V plug, otherwise you are SOL. I think the design of the Volt is far superior because it includes a small genset to allow the vehicle to charge itself when needed. I hope GM survives long enough to actually sell the Volt.

AFAIK, the Volt CANT use the generator while driving the way they designed it, you have to pull off to the side and let it recharge. I really hope I'm wrong, or they changed the way everything is powered (basically as it is you can't recharge and discharge batteries at the same time which is the volt's biggest problem), because otherwise it's going to be another steaming pile of dogshit.

Seriously, look into third market applications for existing hybrid cars, they're a cheaper route than the volt, and they're here today.
 
AFAIK, the Volt CANT use the generator while driving the way they designed it, you have to pull off to the side and let it recharge. I really hope I'm wrong, or they changed the way everything is powered (basically as it is you can't recharge and discharge batteries at the same time which is the volt's biggest problem), because otherwise it's going to be another steaming pile of dogshit.

Seriously, look into third market applications for existing hybrid cars, they're a cheaper route than the volt, and they're here today.

The generator is powerful enough to keep the car going during a trip. You dont have to pull over. Assuming wiki and the few articles ive seen are accurate.
 
I'M RIGHT ABOUT EVERYTHING ALWAYS, STUPID!

That's the third direct insult; you're an intolerant child.

Moving systems introduce inefficiencies. Why, when developing a system for a more efficient car, would you needlessly engineer in inefficiencies for the odd scenario in which somebody wants to drive his car across the continent?
 
That's the third direct insult; you're an intolerant child.

Moving systems introduce inefficiencies. Why, when developing a system for a more efficient car, would you needlessly engineer in inefficiencies for the odd scenario in which somebody wants to drive his car across the continent?

Because people don't want to be stranded when they go more than 200 miles? Seems like a pretty basic requirement to me. But hey, continue with your 200 miles = a continent type of arguments, its great for laughs.
 
AFAIK, the Volt CANT use the generator while driving the way they designed it, you have to pull off to the side and let it recharge. I really hope I'm wrong, or they changed the way everything is powered (basically as it is you can't recharge and discharge batteries at the same time which is the volt's biggest problem), because otherwise it's going to be another steaming pile of dogshit.

Seriously, look into third market applications for existing hybrid cars, they're a cheaper route than the volt, and they're here today.

Not correct. The on-board generator is designed to be used while driving. GM is being extremely cautious with the battery, as Lithium Ion batteries are not designed for deep cycle discharge. To prolong battery life, they consider 80% charge (16 kW) to be "fully charged". The 40 miles of battery travel you get is from 80% to 50% at which point the generator kicks in (53 Kw) to charge the battery back up to 80%. If you are still driving when it gets back to 80% the generator shuts off and you continue on battery for another 40 miles until you hit 50% again. Wash, rinse, repeat. Keeping the battery between 50% and 80% is how they will get 10 years (or 150,000 miles) of useful life out of it. This is what I meant in my initial comments about the generator helping to extend the useful life of the car.
 
Geeeze dont get me started on electric cars again.

It is NOT MORE EFFICIENT. Its purpose is to avoid burning fossil fuel... itself.

In a pure energy conversion equation, it's really hard to beat a state of the art internal combustion engine. With Turbo+Super charging, intercooling, computer controlled valves, etc, etc, you can achieve huge HP/cc displacement, and huge HP/mpg.

None of the car companies uses all the tricks available to maximize the internal combustion engine efficiency. Oh well.

Meantime, a TOTALLY DIFFERENT issue is getting off gasoline/diesel.

T Boone Picken's and his jerkoff minions crack me up, yapping about how electric can do cars, but not trucks, because those are so heavy, etc. At no point does anyone drop reality on thier heads to mention, the most powerful cargo transport we use all the time is... ELECTRIC. It's called a TRAIN. Diesel engines powering a generator that drives electric motors on the wheels. They went that way a long time ago because the electric drive was the most compact and effective DESIGN to achieve the goal.

Hooking the diesels up to driveshafts, transmissions, etc might get higher efficiency but the engine would be too big and heavy at the horsepower levels required to fit on the tracks. Lots of issues go into a design besides just the % energy conversion efficiency.

Cost for the car companies being numero uno.... and we live with the results of thier compromises every day.

Ultimately the plug in electric car will be the way it is, and so will the diesel/electric truck once the car drives the costs down and tech up on the motors and control electronics through mass production and efficiencies of scale. A truck that has motor/generators on every wheel will have much better overall efficiency... by recouping most of its momentum in braking. Not to mention the increase in safety with total wheel traction control and ABS braking, anti jackknife-ing, etc, etc. Faster acceleration/braking, better bad weather traction and handling, etc, etc.

Ditto for the electric car. All wheel motor/generator, high % braking energy recouped. All wheel traction control and ABS, increased handling thanks to all this tech and control systems. Not to mention 0-60 in 3 secs potential... or 2 or 1 :cool:

The fight is to get the oil and auto companies to stop working intently on preventing the inevitable. If they can't stop themselves, then they just have to die.... literally if required. :D

But the Tesla is a joke, and way overpriced for what it provides. That's why they haven't dared to put one in the hands of the car magazines.... I double dog dare them. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
WHAT pisses me off about the volt is here we are FINALLY TWO THOUSAND FUCKIN NINE and we will have a series-hybrid car. we've had this technology forever and its been practical since the 80's when batteries and magnets became oh-so awesome. but even with lead-acid batteries and oversized magnet motors it still would have been more efficient to make these- EVER SINCE GAS ENGINES EXISTED. it just pisses me off that we had to go a century of just blowin our oil up in smoke when we could have been using so much less of it. now its almost gone, and we finally say 'hey look at this new technology! its a series hybrid, OOO AAAAHHHH!!'
 
xx_jack_Carver_xx

when i say efficiency i do mean whatever it takes to use less oil. its the same with hydrogen- yeah it would take lots of nuke plants and work to get the hydrogen out of the water or whatever, but the end result would save the oil we have left for whatever we might need.

and the tesla is a pricing joke. its a little kit car with a good battery pack running a series hybrid motor. yippe. you can only imagine how sophisticated the suspension system is...
 
...it just pisses me off that we had to go a century of just blowin our oil up in smoke when we could have been using so much less of it. now its almost gone...

Really? OPEC is pumping just as much oil per day now as they were 35 years ago. How much was there to begin with, and how much is left? Without answering those questions, your assertion is pretty absurd.
 
Back
Top