Students Take File Swapping Quiz Before Using P2P

i used to get cheap cd's from colombia house. with the way everything is now i haven't spent a dime in years. i refuse to fund riaa/mpaa (i may see 1 or 2 movies a year in theaters but that is it)
 
Why would one feel guilty at all? It's there to download, thus they have a choice. If you abide by some set of morals that says that it's 'stealing' then maybe you shouldn't do it. That's for the person doing it to decide, not anyone else. The laws may state that it's illegal to do it, but the chances of getting busted for it are slim to none. Have you ever run a red light? Same thing.

Sorry, but the average citizen cannot decide what is right and wrong. What if I decide that murder is okay and go out and kill someone? Do you believe I should not face life in prison because what I did was morally acceptable in my own mind.

Also, "the laws" exist because the people writing them actually understand how to run a successful economy. Please see my argument below for more information.

Downloading music is no different than what I did before the Internet became popular. Where was the RIAA back when me and my friends made copies of CDs, cassettes, and 45s/LPs? It was the same thing, yet now it's considered stealing and breaking the law? Where was the MPAA when I made copies of movies I rented on VHS?

Digital technology has simply made piracy easy enough that it is actually making a dent in music industry profits. No, I am not saying they don't make enough as it is, but in the days of cassettes and CDs, not enough people copied music for it to generate the attention that it does today.

No one would deny that piracy is rampant on p2p and torrents, but file sharing could be anything. Blame the cable and DSL companies, not file sharers. With their 15Mbps or higher packages, they are encouraging it. Who else needs those kinds of download speeds?

The cable and DSL companies are providing high speeds and torrents users are misusing that service. High speeds, however, have many more legal uses than illegal uses (videos, online conferencing, online backups, interactive websites, software downloads).

With users wasting bandwidth on torrents, cable and DSL companies are forced to cap bandwidth to continue to provide reasonable service to other customers. Of course, they have to equally cap all customers to avoid violating this "net neutrality" thing. I do not appreciate my bandwidth being limited to provide for other users' illegal activities.

I call it 'sharing' or 'borrowing'. If a friend or relative brings over a CD or DVD, am I stealing the product because I watched or listened to it? Getting it off p2p, torrent, etc. is no different. In both cases, I didn't pay for it. In both cases, someone else already payed for it. I don't recall a single case where someone got fined for 'borrowing' a DVD or CD. The way I get the content doesn't matter because the end result is same. I never paid for it but someone else did. This is not illegal because nothing was stolen. I can borrow a friend's car, their computer, etc. I can borrow their friend's car or computer, etc. And I can go on and on.

By your logic, everyone in the world could have a song if just one person buys it. That person's friends could copy ("borrow") it from him, then those people's friends could copy it from them, and so on until everyone who wanted to song had it. The artist and music studio would make a gross profit of $1 on their song. Sorry, but the consumer goods economy that has served us so well and encouraged such amazing progress cannot function that way.

Digital media does change things because it's easier to make copies and distribute. The RIAA and MPAA can change the way the distribute their content but refuse to do it. I guess it's easier to raise prices and use scare tactics than do something that would solve the problem for good. They're fighting a losing battle.

I 100% agree with you here. Music companies are definitely handling the piracy problem the wrong way and are still holding on to high-profit CDs. Pirating more music, however, is not the best way for you to help solve this problem. That will only increase the statistics and increase public support for the RIAA's actions. Instead, you should buy DRM-free tracks when they are available and pay for reasonably-priced songs online. Then, the music studios will look at their sales numbers, think "hey, the customers seem to like this", and continue to move towards cheap, unrestricted digital distribution.

Music studios and the RIAA are currently trying to stay away from DRM-free digital distribution because they are afraid of losing money to piracy. If everyone stopped pirating music, that fear would disappear.

When you can clone computer parts, cars, food, or clothing at little to no cost, I will consider the analogies even remotely applicable. You also make a fallacy yourself, namely that because something has "always" been done a certain way, that makes it right and proper and that it should never be changed. If we were to live by that credo, we would still be hunters and gatherers.

When we can clone said objects, are you saying that people should be allowed to do so and never have to pay for anything at all? I'm sorry, but as I explained above, the world cannot function under those conditions. I'm not saying things should stay the way they are because that's the way they've always been; I'm saying things should stay the way they are because they work extremely well the way they are. The consumer goods economy is the best system ever created by humankind; your ability to read this message on your computer screen is proof of that. It is the consumer goods economy that has allowed the human race to make so much progress in the past century, going from horses to cars to airplanes to telephones to computers to the Internet in less than 100 years. Let's not ruin this beautiful system now because we want free music.

I think that the whole notion that a person or corporation can own ideas (patents) or even a specific application of an idea (copyrights) ludicrous. Nevertheless, I do believe that artists/musicians/programmers should be paid too, just not with the extremist system today that will soon try to charge us for singing in the shower. Perhaps the old patronage system was better though, or some new model that doesn't just enrich the lawyers and the incumbents, but actually encourages new works, not just extracting money for old works ad infinitum.

Unfortunately, most people don't care how much money artists make. They wouldn't give them a dime if they didn't have to in order to get the music. A patronage system simply would not work because the general public does not understand technology, the arts, and the economy like we do. They would simply jump on the opportunity to get free stuff.

But here's the thing, I don't believe morally that anyone has all these hyper-restrictive copyrights that law currently grants. I believe that moral fair dealing rights are grossly under-represented by the law (and I live in a country which comparatively represents them well!). I simply do not believe anyone has a right to tell me I cannot make a mix tape for a friend. This is a different concept than someone licensing a work under the creative commons and "letting" me make a mix tape; it's that I had the right to begin with, regardless of what the author feels.

You're saying that an artist does not have a right to control what he creates? Wow. I'm sorry, but if I spend days working on something and then say that you can't distribute it, you do not have a "right" to distribute it. Did you spend any time working on it? Did you work for hours trying to get it exactly right? Then you do not have any right to do anything with someone else's work.

As I mentioned earlier, I do earn my living by spending "many hours on digital material" and I feel that current copyright law is ridiculously oppressive. Attempting to appeal to my sympathy for the IP creator isn't going to be particularly effective, since I am one myself.

As I said above, if you believe others should be able to do as they please with your work, you are free to grant them the right to do so. Others artists, however, may have different opinions. Ultimately, it is their decision who gets to do what with their work.

Also, copyright is at most 400 years old in western civilization. It's hardly been around since the "beginning of intelligent life" as you put it. People could freely copy anything they wanted before then. Copyright is not a moral right; it's a right that the government grants to help the progress of art and science.

The use of money to buy things has existed for many thousands of years. Also, the consumer goods economy, which I talk about in more detail above, has only been around for about 100 years, but in those 100 years humans have acheived more, IMO, than in the rest of their existence. After millions of years, we've finally got it right. Let's not ruin that because we want free music.

i used to get cheap cd's from colombia house. with the way everything is now i haven't spent a dime in years. i refuse to fund riaa/mpaa (i may see 1 or 2 movies a year in theaters but that is it)

As I said earlier, by continuing to pirate music you're only encouraging the RIAA to continue and providing that statistical data that convinces the public to support them.
 
Sorry, but the average citizen cannot decide what is right and wrong. What if I decide that murder is okay and go out and kill someone? Do you believe I should not face life in prison because what I did was morally acceptable in my own mind.

Also, "the laws" exist because the people writing them actually understand how to run a successful economy.
People make bad decisions everyday. Murder happens everyday. It's not a question of whether it is right or wrong. It just is. You can't force a person to do good their entire life because humans are not perfect.

Several laws are really stupid because the people writing them are being paid off by some lobbyist group. If that isn't corruption I don't know what is.

Digital technology has simply made piracy easy enough that it is actually making a dent in music industry profits. No, I am not saying they don't make enough as it is, but in the days of cassettes and CDs, not enough people copied music for it to generate the attention that it does today.
Casual copying back then is no different than what is going on today. Profits are down because of a number factors. The economy sucks, people prefer to buy just a song or two, etc.

The cable and DSL companies are providing high speeds and torrents users are misusing that service. High speeds, however, have many more legal uses than illegal uses (videos, online conferencing, online backups, interactive websites, software downloads).
But they market the 15Mbps and higher packages at HEAVY downloaders. It doewn't matter what the use is for. Bandwidth is bandwidth.

By your logic, everyone in the world could have a song if just one person buys it. That person's friends could copy ("borrow") it from him, then those people's friends could copy it from them, and so on until everyone who wanted to song had it. The artist and music studio would make a gross profit of $1 on their song. Sorry, but the consumer goods economy that has served us so well and encouraged such amazing progress cannot function that way.
The point of borrowing something is so that you don't have to waste your own money on something that's only going to get used once or twice. I never mentioned anything about copying since that would be impossible to do with a car, a lawn mower, etc. With CDs,
you and the RIAA assumes everyone is making copies. Where is the data to back this up? There is no data because you can't prove everyone does it.

The act of borrowing things been going on forever, yet the economy in recent years has been doing fine. Piracy has been going for years and the economy hasn't been hurt because of it. What music artist, studio, producers have had to call it quits because of piracy? CDs and DVDs still sell rather well. No one is starving.
 
You're saying that an artist does not have a right to control what he creates?

The artist certainly doesn't have complete control over the work he creates as you're suggesting. Copyrights are a limited set of rights which allow the artist to control certain elements of how the work is distributed. This is strictly to promote the progress of art and science; there is no moral right here. Check the constitution if you don't believe me.

Fair dealing/use rights are in place because it benefits society when everyone is able to freely share copyright works; culture is spread, lives are enriched, etc. etc. This is why copyright is for limited time only. This is also why the law protects these rights.

You almost certainly make use of the fact that copyright is not absolute. If you have ever sung "happy birthday", read Shakespeare, Dickens, the bible, sung karaoke, or listened to Beethoven, you've made use of the fact that copyright isn't absolute.

Copyright is a very important aspect to our society, just as fair dealing rights are. I personally believe that I am within my moral rights to make copies of certain works in certain circumstances. The law agrees with me in some circumstances, but not all, and the legal code is certainly not the same thing as a moral code.
 
I call it 'sharing' or 'borrowing'. If a friend or relative brings over a CD or DVD, am I stealing the product because I watched or listened to it? Getting it off p2p, torrent, etc. is no different. In both cases, I didn't pay for it. In both cases, someone else already payed for it. I don't recall a single case where someone got fined for 'borrowing' a DVD or CD. The way I get the content doesn't matter because the end result is same. I never paid for it but someone else did. This is not illegal because nothing was stolen. I can borrow a friend's car, their computer, etc. I can borrow their friend's car or computer, etc. And I can go on and on.

Actually, getting something off p2p is completely different than borrowing it from a friend. When you borrow a CD or DVD, only one person has access to it. That is why it is not a problem. When you can just copy a CD or DVD from p2p, a potentially infinite number of people could get access to it. I could be missing your point, but it seems like you believe only one person should ever have to pay for digital media, and then the rest of the world has the right to get it for free from them. It costs a lot of money to make a record (most records anyway), so I am not sure where they would get the money to do so.

Digital media does change things because it's easier to make copies and distribute. The RIAA and MPAA can change the way the distribute their content but refuse to do it. I guess it's easier to raise prices and use scare tactics than do something that would solve the problem for good. They're fighting a losing battle.

I completely agree with you there. I think the RIAA is going about solving the problem the wrong way. The scare tactics are a little annoying.
 
Actually, getting something off p2p is completely different than borrowing it from a friend. When you borrow a CD or DVD, only one person has access to it. That is why it is not a problem. When you can just copy a CD or DVD from p2p, a potentially infinite number of people could get access to it. I could be missing your point, but it seems like you believe only one person should ever have to pay for digital media, and then the rest of the world has the right to get it for free from them. It costs a lot of money to make a record (most records anyway), so I am not sure where they would get the money to do so.
The very fact that it's in a digital format should give you a clue. It's not that I believe everyone should get music, movies and games for free. The technology that they store the media on has made it possible. The Internet has made it possible for the masses. It's a lose-lose situation for the entertainment industry.

Let's just assume for a moment that everyone has a friend or relative that borrows CDs, DVDs and games. That's millions of people not paying for said products. P2P only grants easier or maybe quicker access to those products. The same logic applies because the person who downloads or borrows doesn't pay for the product. They're both considered lost sales, yet one is considered illegal while the other isn't. How it was obtained shouldn't matter since the end result is the same.

With the economy being in such bad shape, people that never pirate are going to be looking at ways of getting their music, movies and games for free.
 
The very fact that it's in a digital format should give you a clue. It's not that I believe everyone should get music, movies and games for free. The technology that they store the media on has made it possible. The Internet has made it possible for the masses. It's a lose-lose situation for the entertainment industry.

Let's just assume for a moment that everyone has a friend or relative that borrows CDs, DVDs and games. That's millions of people not paying for said products. P2P only grants easier or maybe quicker access to those products. The same logic applies because the person who downloads or borrows doesn't pay for the product. They're both considered lost sales, yet one is considered illegal while the other isn't. How it was obtained shouldn't matter since the end result is the same.

With the economy being in such bad shape, people that never pirate are going to be looking at ways of getting their music, movies and games for free.

Fair enough. I do believe it is also illegal to copy a CD or DVD from a friend though. Like I said before, borrowing it is different because only one person has access to it. Copying it is still illegal, you just won't get caught doing it.

I agree that it is time to get with the times though. I just worry it will end in some copy protection that screws up computers.
 
Fair enough. I do believe it is also illegal to copy a CD or DVD from a friend though. Like I said before, borrowing it is different because only one person has access to it. Copying it is still illegal, you just won't get caught doing it.

I agree that it is time to get with the times though. I just worry it will end in some copy protection that screws up computers.

I don't know if borrowing is necessarily different. If I borrow a DVD from a friend or even watch it with them and never buy it is that a lost sale? Did I infact "steal" that movie by watching it without paying for it? The way they have it set up for music it seems like that would be their stance which im sure seems ridiculous to most people.

If I listen to an internet radio stream, or listen to a song on myspace it's legal, but as soon as I record the 0 and 1's that are already entering my computer i'm breaking the law? These are the types of things to think about.

In another thread there was a discussion if pirating or used games result in more lost sales. If you think about when you buy a used game your basically increasing the amount of consumers for the product while not giving anything back to the original artist. That is also a potential sales lose so is this also going to become illegal?

The system they are using and their methodology for doing it just doesn't make sense if you put it in different situations and look at the grand scheme of things.
 
Eventually games and movies will all come with "For your eyes only" secret service label and explode if someone else tries to use them ;)
 
Back
Top