Name any non-mouse handheld controller that isn't awful for FPS... ever. They all are, and that's the limitation of leaning back on your couch without wanting to use a Logitech Anywhere MX mouse, trackball, or similar.I get this vibe that the controller is moving away from a novel concept to basically a near carbon copy of the xbox controller. And I don't think that's a good thing because the xbox controller is awful for PC games and awful for FPSs.
The only good option would be a wii like actual gun you could hold and aim, but most lack the accuracy to be competative and are more just a novelty.
Couch FPSs are going to have autoaim help, that's just the way it is.