Steam Hardware & Software Survey: June 2012

So what if it runs a win8 kernel? Best case, it probably will run a dx10 card...and it'll be a year or more after the console hits shelves that people start seriously bothering with dx10.

I'm not quite sure what your basing your assumptions on here, a DX11 capable GPU doesn't have to be a screaming fast 200watt chewing monster so there no reason to drop in anything less. Considering all the rumours (grain... salt) last year suggested some form of AMD APU being used, it would be a fair guess that the GPU will be able to support the full range of features available under DX11.

In any case it will be a proprietary build of a DirectX API much like the 360 and the Xbox before it. It will probably share a lot in common with DX11 much like the 360's DirectX shared a lot with DX9 however it also introduced some of the features built out for DX10 (it also has a few unique features that aren't included in either PC API).
 
My point is that it these technical advances aren't as vital to rendering as you might think. Certain things become possibilities that weren't before, but mostly things just get faster. Even the things you might believe would be hugely beneficial from a performance perspective aren't in many scenarios.

I've said before that I don't think there's a compelling reason to write to D3D9 anymore. With feature levels, you can still hit D3D9 hardware and get the perks of the cleaner, more efficient D3D10/11 API. I'm not going to boycott games just because they're D3D9, though, because that really makes no sense.

I disagree about performance not enabling big things. In BF3, they are able to do dynamic lighting and radiosity because of the efficiency of DX10 and DX11, which makes the scene make sense after large scale destruction. For instance, the shadows/lighting change, instead of a shadow of a building remaining on the ground after the building has been blown to dust, or the inside of a building remaining dark after a hole is blown through the wall exposing sunlight. I think if it was feasible to fall back to DX9 with this, DICE would've, they had to sacrifice a large number of sales when killing XP and DX9. My understanding is that you can fall back from DX11 to DX10, but falling back to DX9 means too many compromises to be worth making the game DX10+ in the first place, or falling back to DX9.

As far as boycotting DX9 games, I stand by that. I don't think a game can effectively use DX10/11 while remaining backwards compatible with DX9, at least I've never seen it done and have heard it's not practical. And for me, DX11 games like BF3 look so much better than DX9 games that I could never go back. I've been really wanting to go back and replay skyrim, but I just can't - it looks too primitive in comparison.
 
Nobody noticed the weirdness in the video card chart?

I get the huge jump in Intel recently - the new HD3000 and HD4000 integrated parts are amazingly powerful.

WTF is "other"? Not AMD, not Intel, not nVidia....

...what? Who else is making video cards that would see such a big jump in the past quarter?
 
Nobody noticed the weirdness in the video card chart?

I get the huge jump in Intel recently - the new HD3000 and HD4000 integrated parts are amazingly powerful.

WTF is "other"? Not AMD, not Intel, not nVidia....

...what? Who else is making video cards that would see such a big jump in the past quarter?

That is weird, perhaps it's some kind of detection issue with BETA drivers?
 
Nobody noticed the weirdness in the video card chart?

I get the huge jump in Intel recently - the new HD3000 and HD4000 integrated parts are amazingly powerful.

WTF is "other"? Not AMD, not Intel, not nVidia....

...what? Who else is making video cards that would see such a big jump in the past quarter?

VIA makes the UniChrome IGP to bundle in chipsets with the CPUs designed by the Centaur team. Maybe there are more wandering around than before?
 
VIA makes the UniChrome IGP to bundle in chipsets with the CPUs designed by the Centaur team. Maybe there are more wandering around than before?

Does the hardware survey run on the Steam mobile client?
 
I disagree about performance not enabling big things. In BF3, they are able to do dynamic lighting and radiosity because of the efficiency of DX10 and DX11, which makes the scene make sense after large scale destruction.
But that isn't the reason why they're able to do real-time global illumination. They can use compute shaders to do global illumination calculations, and that's the route they chose. It's not the only way to do it, however. It may not even be the fastest method in every case. It probably is, but neither you or I are in any position to be able to make that call. Why then would you boycott D3D9 if you don't truly know it's what holds competent developers back?

As far as boycotting DX9 games, I stand by that. And for me, DX11 games like BF3 look so much better than DX9 games that I could never go back.
The issue I take to that is that BF3 looks better than other games because DICE is willing to throw more on your machine to enable that level of visual quality, and they have the technical ability to make that run fast. You can argue that DX11 helps them do that better, and that's a perfectly valid argument to make, but you can't argue that without DX11, they wouldn't be able to deliver better visuals than anyone else. That takes knowledge and it takes a decision to push for that. It doesn't take any particular API.

The API is a tool. It's a way to get at hardware, and better APIs make it easier to get more out of that hardware. It's not the end-all-be-all.
 
But that isn't the reason why they're able to do real-time global illumination. They can use compute shaders to do global illumination calculations, and that's the route they chose. It's not the only way to do it, however. It may not even be the fastest method in every case. It probably is, but neither you or I are in any position to be able to make that call. Why then would you boycott D3D9 if you don't truly know it's what holds competent developers back?


The issue I take to that is that BF3 looks better than other games because DICE is willing to throw more on your machine to enable that level of visual quality, and they have the technical ability to make that run fast. You can argue that DX11 helps them do that better, and that's a perfectly valid argument to make, but you can't argue that without DX11, they wouldn't be able to deliver better visuals than anyone else. That takes knowledge and it takes a decision to push for that. It doesn't take any particular API.

The API is a tool. It's a way to get at hardware, and better APIs make it easier to get more out of that hardware. It's not the end-all-be-all.

I think I can argue that you can't do it with DX9. Because, nobody has done it. And tech presentations that DICE gave before BF3's release state quite explicitly that they felt what they wanted to do was not possible with DX9, until someone proves otherwise I'm going to agree with DICE. An API can make a huge difference in graphics, or at least DICE thinks so and I haven't any reason to doubt them on that. Maybe I, DICE, and many other knowledgeable people I've listened to over years will be proved wrong and someone will make a DX9 game that kills BF3 graphics wise, at that point I will reconsider, until then I think I can generally state that I'm not touching another DX9 game.
 
Back
Top