Small Dev Steals Assets From Other Games

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This has to be the worst case of video game asset theft I have ever seen. Sure there have been incidents in the past where someone used a texture from someone else’s game but I’ve never seen anything like this. It is almost comical how they thought no one would notice. Head on over to Shacknews for a bunch of comparison photos and the list of games “borrowed” from.

Along with Oblivion and Thief: Deadly Shadows, it seems the three-man Majestic team stole assets from People Can Fly's Painkiller (PC) for use in Limbo. Allegations are flying across several forums, including NeoGAF, that the 2D point and click adventure further "borrows" from a truly staggering amount of other titles.
 
I hope this isnt like last time, where they had actually purchased the art/textures/models whatever from a third party, in which case there is absolutely nothing wrong.
 
lol This dev stole from several different games. Too bad for the publisher if they paid those crooks.
 
The site trying to make the comparisons absolutely suck at doing so... the navigation of their picture gallery suck.
 
Ok i didnt realise it was a 2D game, so it looks just like they printscreen'd and definetely didnt purchase any textures/etc etc etc
 
They used the Wintermute Engine (an engine for 2.5d games) and just used lots screenshots from games like Painkiller, UT (2k3/4), Oblivion, Morrowind, possibly Silent Hill (I have seen the same thing attributed to both UT and Silent Hill), Diablo, and a couple of others. Not only that, but the trailers use footage from the film Spawn and Pirates of the Caribbean.

Supposedly the game was being worked on as early as '95, and then got put on hold until (if I remember correctly) ~'03. Honestly though, is anyone surprised that a three-man bedroom team, who look older than Palpatine himself, with a marketing-speak name (Tri-Synergy?! Come on!) thought they could get away with this?
 
LOL @ http://www.quandaryland.com/jsp/dispArticle.jsp?index=795

Gordon: So have any more recent games influenced your current project?

Steve: The project is more influenced by film and literature rather than other games, we want the experience to be as original as possible and as such we have made a calculated effort to keep away from other games in the genre. Limbo of the Lost is an experience first and foremost, secondly wrapped up in a game media and genre.
 
Wow lol. A Diablo II shield graphic is used many times in the backgrounds. I think it was a Unique quality shield called Wall of the Eyeless. As someone pointed out in the shacknews comments, even the top border was taken from the border of a WoW wallpaper.

I really wanna hear the devs disclosing all the games they stole the goods from.
 
Wow lol. A Diablo II shield graphic is used many times in the backgrounds. I think it was a Unique quality shield called Wall of the Eyeless. As someone pointed out in the shacknews comments, even the top border was taken from the border of a WoW wallpaper.

I really wanna hear the devs disclosing all the games they stole the goods from.

I remember the Wall of the Eyeless. :D
 
Combine a lot of good games to make one MASSIVE UBER AWESOMEST game ever! Playdoe approach!

I like it!
:D
 
ya know, given that this is a 2.5 - D adventure game, it IS like using samples as a DJ. Fine if you are spinning (freeware) but no good for retail launches. Stupid on their part to think that nobody would notice, though. They could've possibly licensed the art (from at least a few of the companies) and been fine.

Given how much time and TALENT is involved in high res art creation these days I think we'll see a lot more licensing in the future. Maybe even art crews forming independently from publishing/dev teams. . .
 
Update: Limbo of the Lost publisher Tri Synergy has issued a statement regarding the comparisons between the adventure title and Oblivion, specifying that it will immediately discontinue sales of Limbo in both retail and online outlets.

AHAHAHA QWNAGEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
 
argh!!!

"At no point during our dealings with Majestic Studios...did we have any knowledge of these similarities," the company wrote. "We have contacted the developer, Majestic, and are anxiously awaiting their response. As soon as we know more on this matter we will issue another statement."

what have they been living a cave?
 
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Perhaps the makers of Limbo should be paid by the other companies for the free advertisement. ;)
 
Well, the person who said they were just using samples has a point when you think about it. Why is it ok for rap music to sample other peoples music and then call it their own but someone can't sample images and make them into a new game What's the big difference? Both are lame IMO.
 
Well, the person who said they were just using samples has a point when you think about it. Why is it ok for rap music to sample other peoples music and then call it their own but someone can't sample images and make them into a new game What's the big difference? Both are lame IMO.

It's not ok to sample unless you get permission or pay for it. Should be the same case here.
 
Back
Top